Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.
Ironically, this inane line of thought converges with an element of the lunatic left, who also sees AGW as a phony power grab. For instance:
Alexander Cockburn said:
Anthropogenic Global Warming is a Farce
 
Global Warming denial is really the only woo I ever toyed with.

And I can assure you I was concerned very little with facts and science while I was in that phase. Mostly it was just done out of spite against the environmental activist crowd I knew in college.

You see I went into college very concerned about global warming but when I got labeled a "monster" and "shill" because my solution to the problem involved nuclear power I grew very resentful.

"Travis, you aren't thinking outside of the box. We need to make people understand they don't need their microwaves or their idiot boxes and can be perfectly happy in teepees out in nature."

Yeah, that'll happen. :rolleyes:

And I suppose that was what made me most angry. They had a fundamental misunderstanding of how to deal with the issue. I wanted to find a way to make the massive amount of electricity a technological society needs with less carbon output. They wanted to make it so people wouldn't use electricity anymore.

So in my case it was pretty must just an emotional outburst that lasted several years. I couldn't live like that forever though. The science of the matter is just too solid and fundamental for me to ignore it even on a purely irrational level.

The truth of the matter is that only nuclear power is likely to be a viable replacement for fossil fuels, if we are to maintain anything remotely resembling an industrial civilization, or for that matter, avoid economic chaos.

A major problem that I see, and one that I think is driving a lot of the denialism, is that many of the proposed solutions to AGW, involving massive regulation or taxation to drastically reduce the use of fossil fuels would very likely result in an economic disaster as bad as the climatological disaster they are attempting to avoid. Unfortunately, this economic disaster is exactly what some of the more extreme elements of the environmental movement want.

The debate that we should be having is how best to mitigate global warming without throwing the economy into the tank, and nuclear energy would definitely have to be a major part of any reasonable solution.

Instead, the debate has devolved into "Global warming is real, therefore we need to go back to the horse and buggy era." vs. "It's all fake, so drill, baby drill."
 
I can completely sympathise with this position. There are some groups that really put the "mental" in "environmental" and those groups, the ones with the placards and the drums, misrepresent the science to further a cause. The cause isn't the environment, it's modern day puritanism.

Essentially what they're saying is that their environmentalism makes them better than other people, and what better way to show how much better than lecturing others on how they should behave? In this respect I would say that the sophomoric/sixth form version of tie-dye environmentalism is like a religion.



The past decade hasn't cooled. A few people have claimed this by carefully choosing the start and end dates of their data to coincide with the El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO). That means they take as a start date the peak of El Nino and as their end point the depth of La Nina and claim that this means the temperature is cooling. The trend over the last two centuries or so, coinciding with the Industrial Revolution is one of startling rise in temperatures and the last decade has been warming, and quickly.

There are warming and cooling cycles but the cooling cycles of today are warmer than the cooling cycles of yesteryear. The same goes for the hotter years too.

Claiming that the last decade has been cooling is a lie.



Peter Ferrara, a lawyer who comments on political and economic news, raises a number of red flags in his article. For one thing he declares the Heartland Institute as the "international headquarters" of "climate realists". He proudly bosts that he spoke at an event on climate science on the subject of "The Economic Implications of High Cost Energy" (as if the economic impact of anything makes any difference to reality) and he crows about the reluctance of real scientists "climate alarmists" to publicly debate their findings.

The latter is the most telling. Scientific debate happens in the technical literature. Not behind a podium. Science is a detail sport. Climate science in particular involves collating data from vast numbers of sources, taming it through use of statistical analysis and basing conclusions on it, to be teased apart, challenged and confirmed by other scientists in the field. It's hard.

Public debate is about grand rhetorical flourishes, feel-good statements and dumbing down to your audience. If your audience is unable to understand statistical analysis then they're probably not good candidates to attend a scientific debate. Which is why it takes place in the literature, a venue which is steadfastly avoided by prominent denialists.



They already do that. Ever been to Newcastle? :D



Again I agree with this. But that's why it's important to follow the science. The mistake isn't in heeding scientists, the mistake is in picking a side. In reality we're all on the same side. Just some people don't know it yet.

The historical record of the Climate Change Chicken Littles:
A picture speaks a thousand words:

picture.php
 
The historical record of the Climate Change Chicken Littles:
A picture speaks a thousand words:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=808&pictureid=7092[/qimg]

Have you read the article inside the magazine, or are you LITERALLY expecting people to judge it by a cover?
 
Ah yes and how exactly how many climatologists actually thought we were heading into an ice age?
 
No. Not science, but Junk Science promoted by the purveyors of Marxist "share the wealth" enablers.

Sorry Robert but you already conceded you were wrong about 'Marxists' please pay attention and stop trying to 'fringe reset' everything. I mean at least try to be coherent, okay?
 
Essentially what they're saying is that their environmentalism makes them better than other people, and what better way to show how much better than lecturing others on how they should behave? In this respect I would say that the sophomoric/sixth form version of tie-dye environmentalism is like a religion.

Indeed this is the first of three things that bothers me about the climate debate. Where environmentalism is simply the instrument of social moralism or luddism, it resembles religion. Penn & Teller showed that even patently absurd, nonsensical, or irrational propositions got traction among those groups so long as they were framed propely in moralistic rhetoric. That is where moralistic environmentalism and scientific environmentalism ought to part company; the former I regard as religion.

The second follows from the first. The moralistic spine of the argument gives rise to a ribcage of attendant industries (cottage or otherwise) that propose to resolve the disapprobation by providing equivalent benefits at inflated cost and with greater difficulty. That is, where environmentalist arguments are used to advocate one commercial venture over another according to moralist criteria rather than commercial criteria -- specifically to distract from an unfavorable cost-benefit analysis -- then I believe this pollutes the purity of the environmental argument. One should be wary of people who install a moral code that they are well-poised to accommodate with a product or service.

For example, I tend to view the carbon offset cap-and-trade mechanism as little different than the sale of indulgences. In this system you use the moral stigma of pollution to justify capping some entity's emissions, but then let him purchase the right to continue polluting at the same levels, so long as that right comes from someone else's unused capacity. Such a system, to me, is ripe for misuse, corruption, and fraud. But I believe is also conceptually flawed. How does the changing-hands of money relate to the moral goodness of the action? If it is wrong to pollute, then how does paying someone money alleviate that wrong?

If we agree scientifically that we need to reduce carbon emissions, then reduce carbon emissions. If we apply a moral stigma to compel action toward that end, then don't conflate that moral obligation with the contrived equity of buying and selling. The same goes with any other identifiable cause of climate shift. The moral obligation to act can and should arise from our emotional response to scientific findings. But when the moral imperative evaporates through some non-scientific means, moralistic environmentalism becomes more than just a religion; it becomes environmental televangelism. "Pay me, and I'll stop making you feel guilty," is the worst kind of religion.

The third follows from where you say:

Climate science in particular involves collating data from vast numbers of sources, taming it through use of statistical analysis and basing conclusions on it, to be teased apart, challenged and confirmed by other scientists in the field. It's hard.

In my role as an engineer, my bread and butter depends upon satisfying a customer's specific requirements, even where I don't agree that the requirement has a defensible rationale. Either way I have a two-pronged ethical duty, first to satisfy the requirement in the most responsible way (where "responsible" is a complex judgment), and second to inform the customer honestly of the tradeoff consequences of our collective choice.

As such I am acutely aware that any action taken has unavoidable and sometimes unintended consequences. This includes actions demanded by alarmists. Alarmism defeats responsible engineering and policy-making by compelling us to take rash action and thus endure the tradeoffs before understanding them and before knowing how effective the action is likely to be. Knee-jerk responses are not traditionally effective, but leave you with their consequences anyway.

Moralistic environmentalism wants to substitute emotional pleas for careful deliberation. Any action is justified in the frantic mitigation of the perceived threat, and any fallout from misguided actions is taken as the acceptable price of urgency. Resource policy, especially energy policy, is greatly affected by the climate debate. Policy changes contemplated from premature or tentative findings have consequences that materially affect the global economy. Hence haste itself has consequences.

Scare tactics are fully consist with a religious bent.

And in the spirit of "don't choose sides," advice I agree with, the religious overtones of the moralistic environmentalists give fodder for the denialists to reject environmental advocacy in toto. Where there are alarmists, everyone is seen as alarmist even when their actual claims are reasonable and well-founded. One errs -- sometimes to a religious extent -- by dismissing unpleasant science. And one errs by overreacting to it. Extremism is the error.
 
I have no doubts that AGW is happening and eventually will cause huge disruptions to society and untold death and suffering. We should indeed be acting now (or really should have a decade or more ago). The problem is finding the finding the political will, internationally, to honestly address this problem, and then address it in a rational fashion. I just don't see that happening until the sheet really hits the fan, and then it will be too late. I am pushing the half century mark, and don't have any children, so I guess I find it easier than many to not worry about it too much.
 
So, is our present subject representative of the denialist camp? I have to admit that AGW denialism isn't a topic I've dipped too deeply into, more interesting things to look at. But they're so persistent I thought I'd get a grip on the species.
 
I have no doubts that AGW is happening and eventually will cause huge disruptions to society and untold death and suffering. We should indeed be acting now (or really should have a decade or more ago). The problem is finding the finding the political will, internationally, to honestly address this problem, and then address it in a rational fashion. I just don't see that happening until the sheet really hits the fan, and then it will be too late. I am pushing the half century mark, and don't have any children, so I guess I find it easier than many to not worry about it too much.

The political will exists in some countries. Sweden recently adopted a plan to be CFC-neutral by 2050. There seems to be some questions of exactly how this is to be achieved, but it at least shows will.
 
The 'westernized' nations will adapt the third world will not and will fall into chaos which in turn will disrupt aspects of those who made an effort, ie Europe will probably adapt, places like Pakistan, Mosambique, etc will not
 
Okay, I'm switching over to "religion".

As far as i can tell from what i've seen, in a large number of cases the religion is actually an obsessive free market, anti-government, anti regulation stance - or in the case of some, actual religion like christianity.

AGW denial is the result of scientific findings colliding with these world views.
 
Sorry if there's already a thread on this, merge is fine.

I see all the hallmarks of both conspiracy theorists and religulous folks in GWD. So I'm wondering if it's more one than the other. Thoughts?

Denialism is not a conspiracy theory -though it has elements of it in their daily speech- nor a blind irrational faith. It's just some basic human antagonistic feeling shaped as an advocacy.

It is like sport hostility and fanaticism: having the enemy team defeated slowly becomes the only reason for them to participate. The opponent is stupid and malicious as they became more stupid and malicious every day by adding a new instance of what the zealots detest. It's just plain human hate, aggressiveness and competitive desire of overpowering that needs to be channelled in an appropriate way according to the Zeitgeist or air du temps. I mean, today hating Frenchmen, despising Negroes or abhorring Jews is not only unfashionable but a crime in many jurisdictions. You can't detest and oppose a Muslim for being a Muslim and thinking like a Muslim and acting as the Muslims "typically" act. Buy you can oppose -postpone detesting them just for next week- those who want to contaminate the watershed, those who want to tear down that historical building to lay down a parking lot or those who want to show themselves scantily dressed in the subway. There are no laws against bigotry when there is a rational justification for that and the group detested can't be identified as such when they are sleeping (you can spot a Negro sleeping but you can't spot a nuke panegyrist sleeping unless he's tattooed something in a visible zone -and that's one of the reasons of tattoos, badges and uniforms).

So denialism is just some kind of activism. We have had in this thread a couple of examples in Robert Prey's and StankApe's posts. You can see how quickly the thread topic becomes activism for them when the matter is if they had liked to discuss the fundamentals of it they would have used the Global Warming thread specifically for that. But they hardly debate there as anyone can feel but not anyone can know, the kind of attitude of those mediocre chaps who know that "Christ DOES save and heal" but keep themselves apart from any discussion with Buddhist scholars.

Also this activism has goals and strategies. For instance, this thread is about analysing climate denialism and what's behind, and not at all to analyse climate. But some deniers have managed to gallop their favourite horses and do some proselytism, as it doesn't matter because they can derail the thread all they want and instead of being sanctioned they can have this whole thread flushed into the said Global Warming thread and then forgotten. That kind of strategic thinking is useful in advocacies and in the adversarial system of justice; it's also paramount for effective denialism and contrary to every aspect of science.
 
Last edited:
But I've seen many denialists say that AGW is just a front for profiteers, eco-terrorists, tree huggers, etc., so I'm good with it being a conspiracy theory. This is further reinforced when you consider my belief that the target of a conspiracy theory is the real reason for the CTers' actions, not the event or events in question. They use the event as a means of attacking a party or group, and thus the actuality of the theory is irrelevant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom