Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

It is more a fervent campaign than a conspiracy, however some denier like ufologists, 9/11 truthers, NWO Belivers, Illuminatio Bleivers, cling to their beleifs no matter what evidence to the contrary is suppplied.
 
Last edited:
Global Warming denial is really the only woo I ever toyed with.

And I can assure you I was concerned very little with facts and science while I was in that phase. Mostly it was just done out of spite against the environmental activist crowd I knew in college.

You see I went into college very concerned about global warming but when I got labeled a "monster" and "shill" because my solution to the problem involved nuclear power I grew very resentful.

"Travis, you aren't thinking outside of the box. We need to make people understand they don't need their microwaves or their idiot boxes and can be perfectly happy in teepees out in nature."

Yeah, that'll happen. :rolleyes:

And I suppose that was what made me most angry. They had a fundamental misunderstanding of how to deal with the issue. I wanted to find a way to make the massive amount of electricity a technological society needs with less carbon output. They wanted to make it so people wouldn't use electricity anymore.

So in my case it was pretty must just an emotional outburst that lasted several years. I couldn't live like that forever though. The science of the matter is just too solid and fundamental for me to ignore it even on a purely irrational level.
 
I don't view Climate Change denialism by itself as a conspiracy theory, because so much of it is out in the open. To me at least, "Conspiracy" implies secrecy.

Of course, some Climate Change denialists believe that Climate Change belief is the result if a Conspiracy, but that is not the same thing as saying that the denialist movement is the result of a conspiracy - the perpetrators and advocates are, for the most part, out in the open, shouting from the rooftops and anything but secret.
 
Sorry if there's already a thread on this, merge is fine.

I see all the hallmarks of both conspiracy theorists and religulous folks in GWD. So I'm wondering if it's more one than the other. Thoughts?

Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.
 
Your evidence Mr Prey if you have any that is

I'm skeptical about climate change (the severity, not the existence thereof) as well, so I would like to see your evidence if you'd be so kind.

Oh and Robert? Evidence that anything you claimed has any basis in reality, if you be so kind.
 
Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.

So Robert what is the Marxist leftie position of the Vatican on global warming?
 
I'm skeptical about climate change (the severity, not the existence thereof) as well, so I would like to see your evidence if you'd be so kind.

Oh and Robert? Evidence that anything you claimed has any basis in reality, if you be so kind.


Well, here in Michigan, in the last two years, we haven't had lasting (> 18 hours) snow before December 10. The previous 6, lasting snow would usually come early to mid November. I understand that there is seasonable variability, but coupled with the massive droughts that most of the US has seen, it's fairly safe to assume that it AGW is going to be a problem that needs attention.
 
Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.

This kind of thinking inspired this thread.
 
Well, here in Michigan, in the last two years, we haven't had lasting (> 18 hours) snow before December 10. The previous 6, lasting snow would usually come early to mid November. I understand that there is seasonable variability, but coupled with the massive droughts that most of the US has seen, it's fairly safe to assume that it AGW is going to be a problem that needs attention.

Yeah... I'm sorry, I just don't see the connection. Why can't this be a natural? Where is the correlation?
 
Yeah... I'm sorry, I just don't see the connection. Why can't this be a natural? Where is the correlation?

It's simple physics. CO2 is a greenhouse gas. Scientists can tell by isotope analysis that we are responsible for a lot of the CO2 in the atmosphere. As more is released, more heat gets trapped. As the system warms, well, the system warms, and there is more energy for extreme weather events.

Now I understand that it is incredibly difficult to tie any individual event to global warming, but that is why we have scientists. Personally, if the people who do this stuff for a living say it's a problem, I tend to yield to their expertise.
 
Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.

What is your evidence of the bolded?
 
Global Warming denial is really the only woo I ever toyed with.

And I can assure you I was concerned very little with facts and science while I was in that phase. Mostly it was just done out of spite against the environmental activist crowd I knew in college.

You see I went into college very concerned about global warming but when I got labeled a "monster" and "shill" because my solution to the problem involved nuclear power I grew very resentful.

"Travis, you aren't thinking outside of the box. We need to make people understand they don't need their microwaves or their idiot boxes and can be perfectly happy in teepees out in nature."

Yeah, that'll happen. :rolleyes:

And I suppose that was what made me most angry. They had a fundamental misunderstanding of how to deal with the issue. I wanted to find a way to make the massive amount of electricity a technological society needs with less carbon output. They wanted to make it so people wouldn't use electricity anymore.

So in my case it was pretty must just an emotional outburst that lasted several years. I couldn't live like that forever though. The science of the matter is just too solid and fundamental for me to ignore it even on a purely irrational level.

I'm mostly with you on this. I'm of the opinion that sufficiently advanced technology can make it so we can maintain our standard of living whilst not wrecking the planet. Purely reactionary environmentalists who want us to regress as a society have a valid point in the threat of global warming, but are going about it entirely the wrong way, in my view.
 
Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft.
Evidence please.
But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.
Where's your evidence of a decade of cooling? BTW the name global climate change goes back until at least 1988 and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). As far as U.S. politics, it was early in G.W. Bush's administration that government officials started using GCC instead of GW, per WH marching orders.
 
*puts on flame proof suit*

I am of the opinion that there is evidence for AGW, but also evidence for a normal warm cycle going on as well.

But my beef isn't about the cause of Global Warming. It's with the chicken little sky is falling rhetoric.

Different groups have latched into AGW and used hyperbole involving the possible consequences as a tool to forward their own agenda. ( the "teepee" thing Travis mentioned). Many of the leading lights of the environmental movement have since come forward and stated that perhaps their initial claims about global mayhem were overstated, and the time frame given for mass destruction were wrong.

When you make a grandiose statement, it makes the front page, when you retract it 4 years later, it gets a tiny blurb on page 12....

I think that the lunatic fringe has hijacked AGW and THIS has a lot to do with why so many people are skeptical. It isn't the science proving it's occurring, it's the claims of the consequences that are inconsistent and tend to err on the side of absurdity.
 
Now I understand that it is incredibly difficult to tie any individual event to global warming, but that is why we have scientists. Personally, if the people who do this stuff for a living say it's a problem, I tend to yield to their expertise.

It might help if they came to a consensus to what that problem is.
 
Sorry if there's already a thread on this, merge is fine.

I see all the hallmarks of both conspiracy theorists and religulous folks in GWD. So I'm wondering if it's more one than the other. Thoughts?
I think GW denialism is more like a religion, one that believes that GW concerns are being generated by a conspiracy.
 
*puts on flame proof suit*

I am of the opinion that there is evidence for AGW, but also evidence for a normal warm cycle going on as well.

But my beef isn't about the cause of Global Warming. It's with the chicken little sky is falling rhetoric.

Different groups have latched into AGW and used hyperbole involving the possible consequences as a tool to forward their own agenda. ( the "teepee" thing Travis mentioned). Many of the leading lights of the environmental movement have since come forward and stated that perhaps their initial claims about global mayhem were overstated, and the time frame given for mass destruction were wrong.

When you make a grandiose statement, it makes the front page, when you retract it 4 years later, it gets a tiny blurb on page 12....

I think that the lunatic fringe has hijacked AGW and THIS has a lot to do with why so many people are skeptical. It isn't the science proving it's occurring, it's the claims of the consequences that are inconsistent and tend to err on the side of absurdity.
Rather than say basically the same thing regarding my feelings about GW, I'll just say "what Stank said". :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom