Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

The Flash makes the points better than I can:
(Borrowed from skeptic.com)
Flash said:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astr...why_don_t_they_publish_scientific_papers.html
Here is the article showing that the the anthropogenic climate change does nor generate a flood of pro and con articles in the scientific journals. The latter would be the case if it was a genuine controversy.
National Science Board member James Lawrence Powell wrote a post that is basically a slam-dunk of debunking. His premise was simple: If global warming isn’t real and there’s an actual scientific debate about it, that should be reflected in the scientific journals

Oh my. Powell looked at 13,950 articles. Out of all those reams of scientific results, how many disputed the reality of climate change?

Twenty-four. Yup. Two dozen. Out of nearly 14,000.
Phil Plait of Bad Astronomy then goes on:
let this be clear: There is no scientific controversy over this. Climate change denial is purely, 100 percent made-up political and corporate-sponsored crap. When the loudest voices are fossil-fuel funded think tanks, when they don’t publish in journals but instead write error-laden op-eds in partisan venues, when they have to manipulate the data to support their point, then what they’re doing isn’t science.

It’s nonsense. And worse, it’s dangerous nonsense. Because they’re fiddling with the data while the world burns.
 
It might help if they came to a consensus to what that problem is.

As the energy of the system increases, extreme weather events will become more common, with potentially devastating consequences. If you are looking for complete, 100% consensus, you won't find it. Hell, even A&E911T has (a couple) actual engineers. :D


*puts on flame proof suit*

I am of the opinion that there is evidence for AGW, but also evidence for a normal warm cycle going on as well.

But my beef isn't about the cause of Global Warming. It's with the chicken little sky is falling rhetoric.

Different groups have latched into AGW and used hyperbole involving the possible consequences as a tool to forward their own agenda. ( the "teepee" thing Travis mentioned). Many of the leading lights of the environmental movement have since come forward and stated that perhaps their initial claims about global mayhem were overstated, and the time frame given for mass destruction were wrong.

When you make a grandiose statement, it makes the front page, when you retract it 4 years later, it gets a tiny blurb on page 12....

I think that the lunatic fringe has hijacked AGW and THIS has a lot to do with why so many people are skeptical. It isn't the science proving it's occurring, it's the claims of the consequences that are inconsistent and tend to err on the side of absurdity.


And that is completely valid. I think some of the problem comes when the news see something like "A sea rise of 5m possible by 2100 according to one outcome of one model," and print "Scientists say world will end by 2100." A combination of lazy, sensationalist reporting, combined with the intellectual laziness of the news consumer feeding said lazy reporting. IMHO, obviously.
 
Because they’re fiddling with the data while the world burns.

this is the sort of alarmist nonsense I'm talking about. He could have made his point much more scientifically, but he felt the need to throw this hyperbole on the end to generate emotion in the reader. That is bad science writing.
 
Sorry Chicken Littles, Global Cooling is Here

From Forbes

Peter Ferrara, Contributor
| 5/31/2012 @ 3:26PM |111,891 views

Sorry Global Warming Alarmists, The Earth Is Cooling

"Climate change itself is already in the process of definitively rebutting climate alarmists who think human use of fossil fuels is causing ultimately catastrophic global warming. That is because natural climate cycles have already turned from warming to cooling, global temperatures have already been declining for more than 10 years..."

http://www.forbes.com/sites/peterfe...lobal-warming-alarmists-the-earth-is-cooling/
 
another problem I have with the entire AGW thing, is it's become a dadburn irritating battle of "my scientists are better than yours" which makes it all into a dogmatic issue regarding "what scientists tell me the information I can use to forward my agenda?" rather than "what's the truth"

I, see no problems with global warming, it was bound to happen eventually anyway. Inconvenient? yep, but what in life isn't? (and I have no heirs, so to hell with this place, I'll be long dead by then)
 
another problem I have with the entire AGW thing, is it's become a dadburn irritating battle of "my scientists are better than yours" which makes it all into a dogmatic issue regarding "what scientists tell me the information I can use to forward my agenda?" rather than "what's the truth"

Last I heard, the scientific consensus among climate scientists was that AGW is a fact. However, every field has their own crackpots and morons. There is a very good reason I choose A&E911T as an example.

I, see no problems with global warming, it was bound to happen eventually anyway. Inconvenient? yep, but what in life isn't? (and I have no heirs, so to hell with this place, I'll be long dead by then)


Are you saying that issues should only be addressed if they directly affect you?
 
I was being a smarmy dick!!! ;)


seriously though, I think that there isn't much we can do about it. The third world is developing, and as they develop they will pollute. Unless we find a way to make them skip some steps things are going to get a lot worse before they get any better.

I ALSO feel that reactionary policies and ineffective alternate energy sources are NOT the answer. Electric cars are worse for the environment than a Humvee. Solar isn't realistic for the average person due to startup costs. Hydrogen fuel cells may work, but I haven't seen how long they anticipate the infrastructure to be of a sufficient level to meet realistic demand. (not to mention that for these things to make a speck of difference they have to make their way to the secondary market where much of the world buys it's vehicles).

I think smart, long term, perhaps not yet developed, ideas are where to go. holey band aids aren't gonna cut it. and when 2/3rds of the worlds population is more concerned with survival rather than climate... what can you really do?
 
I was being a smarmy dick!!! ;)

Well, I'll certainly never begrudge anyone for that :D


seriously though, I think that there isn't much we can do about it. The third world is developing, and as they develop they will pollute. Unless we find a way to make them skip some steps things are going to get a lot worse before they get any better.

I ALSO feel that reactionary policies and ineffective alternate energy sources are NOT the answer. Electric cars are worse for the environment than a Humvee. Solar isn't realistic for the average person due to startup costs. Hydrogen fuel cells may work, but I haven't seen how long they anticipate the infrastructure to be of a sufficient level to meet realistic demand. (not to mention that for these things to make a speck of difference they have to make their way to the secondary market where much of the world buys it's vehicles).

I think smart, long term, perhaps not yet developed, ideas are where to go. holey band aids aren't gonna cut it. and when 2/3rds of the worlds population is more concerned with survival rather than climate... what can you really do?

All valid concerns. I think one of the biggest problems is the USan reluctance to adopt nuclear power. I blame The Simpsons, and I'm only partially being ridiculous.
 
Well, I agree, but the same environmental groups that fought like hell against Nuclear power are now starting to realize their mistakes. The public has been inundated with "Nukes, BAD!" for so long, I can't really blame them for being a little sketchy. (Think of the late 70's early 80's in Hollywood with film like The China Syndrome and Silkwood) 3 mile island and Chernobyl don't help much either.

let's face it, we Americans are kind of reactionary in our thinking. Everything is fine and dandy ,until there's a problem, and no matter how "once in a lifetime" or flukey the problem was, we tend to want to scrap the entire thing, or legislate it into the ground.


ETA: from my looking at the portrayal of AGW and the way it's been marketed to people, here in the USA anyway, it appears to be more about making individuals "feel like they are making a difference" rather than actually accomplishing anything. I can kind link it to how waste disposal companies recycle almost everything they take in so there's no real need for the recycle bins. But people complain that they want the recycle bins, so everybody gets one. Even though the company is gonna sift through most of your trash anyway and find the stuff they can recycle as that's one of the ways they make money.
 
Last edited:
And that is completely valid. I think some of the problem comes when the news see something like "A sea rise of 5m possible by 2100 according to one outcome of one model," and print "Scientists say world will end by 2100." A combination of lazy, sensationalist reporting, combined with the intellectual laziness of the news consumer feeding said lazy reporting. IMHO, obviously.

This is a big problem both in public education and in media reporting. Not a lot of ordinary folks know enough statistics to be able to see through the BS headlines, although they shouldn't be written as BS in the first place, I agree.
 
From Forbes

So Robert you dodged my question on the Vatican so I'll take that as your acceptance that your 'marxists lefties' statement was flawed and unevidenced. Thanks for admitting you were wrong.
 
GWD is an interesting one for me. When I used to lecture on this sort of stuff I advised students that our problem was that we are constrained in our perceptions of nature by our morphology and our longevity - it's difficult for us to measure reliably processes that take place over many decades, centuries and longer.

My personal belief is that warming is a natural part of our climate cycle, but our activities can't help. The temperature balance when our fossil fuels were laid down in a high carbon environment was one established over millions of years, and we have puked that carbon right back out there in a couple of centuries. I've seen many deniers who seem to believe that we can carry on with impunity, and if nothing else the debate has encouraged us to pay attention to our energy sources and the consequences of our industrial activity.

What I really don't like is a general scientific consensus dictating what the general scientific consensus is and will always be. Yes, the evidence may be overwhelming and convincing, but I am uncomfortable with science deciding that the absolute proof is in and shouting down all opposition with our fingers in our ears going 'la-la-la-la'. Science is not about diktat, it is about evidence and rational discussion. Contrary opinions should be examined and debated in the appropriate fora, not dismissed out of hand because if opposes the currently favoured view.

There is also a lot of general misunderstanding about what warming will do to the climate, and most people seem to think we'll all be wandering around northern England in speedos in December before long, whereas what was actually predicted was an increase in extremes (certainly for maritime temperate regions like the UK), which pretty much seems to be happening.

It isn't helped by a lot of hysterical woo promoted by the 'green' movement, which promotes a variety of panacea based on very little evidence and a lot of high-minded assumptions. Massive metal wind turbines produced by heavy industry are being touted as a solution to our energy needs when in reality they are never likely to recover the carbon cost of their production, and their benefits are largely economic than environmental as long as they are heavily subsidised and energy prices are controlled by global politics. Even recycling paper is of dubious benefit - it still needs collecting, processing and re-distributing, while the forests used to produce new paper are a good way of fixing carbon and are managed well.

The answer is to use less, not the same but different, or we will be just as screwed as we always were, and will just go to our ecological doom with a smug sense of self-satisfaction, a hemp suit and our own hand-knitted yoghurt to fuel our stern lecturing of the lower orders who ignored our preaching.

Has it warmed or not? Difficult to tell when the instruments with which we measure things have improved so much compared with those used decades and centuries ago, we are not entirely comparing like with like, but come on - you don't need a weather man to see which way the wind blows.

Is it a religion? Like anything that opposes the majority view, it gets people frothing at the mouth and finding spooks in the cupboards, and people put motives in the minds of their opponents that are not necessarily there. Once people have convinced themselves they are being lied to (whether they are or not), they'll worship any false god placed before them no matter if it makes sense or not.

Posted from a nice warm house on an electricity guzzling laptop while wearing man-made fibres.
 
Well, I agree, but the same environmental groups that fought like hell against Nuclear power are now starting to realize their mistakes. The public has been inundated with "Nukes, BAD!" for so long, I can't really blame them for being a little sketchy. (Think of the late 70's early 80's in Hollywood with film like The China Syndrome and Silkwood) 3 mile island and Chernobyl don't help much either.

let's face it, we Americans are kind of reactionary in our thinking. Everything is fine and dandy ,until there's a problem, and no matter how "once in a lifetime" or flukey the problem was, we tend to want to scrap the entire thing, or legislate it into the ground.


ETA: from my looking at the portrayal of AGW and the way it's been marketed to people, here in the USA anyway, it appears to be more about making individuals "feel like they are making a difference" rather than actually accomplishing anything. I can kind link it to how waste disposal companies recycle almost everything they take in so there's no real need for the recycle bins. But people complain that they want the recycle bins, so everybody gets one. Even though the company is gonna sift through most of your trash anyway and find the stuff they can recycle as that's one of the ways they make money.
I see a similar mindset here in Vermont. There is a large overlap of people that are fighting to get the VT Yankee nuclear power plant shut down, and who are also fighting wind turbine generation projects. I'm sorry, but our electricity has to be generated by something. It seems to me a lot of these folks play the green card, but in reality it's really about NIMBY. If the electricity is generated elsewhere (such as the fact our power companies have recently stopped buying much VT Yankee power, but are buying nuke power from Seabrook in NH, and from other out of state sources that have nuclear in the mix) they don't seem to have the anywhere near the same level of indignation about how it's being generated.
 
From Forbes

Peter Ferrara, Contributor
| 5/31/2012 @ 3:26PM |111,891 views

Sorry Global Warming Alarmists, The Earth Is Cooling

"Climate change itself is already in the process of definitively rebutting climate alarmists who think human use of fossil fuels is causing ultimately catastrophic global warming. That is because natural climate cycles have already turned from warming to cooling, global temperatures have already been declining for more than 10 years..."

http://www.forbes.com/sites/peterfe...lobal-warming-alarmists-the-earth-is-cooling/

Why should we accept the op-ed piece of a lawyer with respect to the science of climate change? His articles are mainly on economic issues, so on what is he basing his opinion, other than the economic impact of dealing with climate change?
 
To cut through the chaff one needs to look at what isn't in dispute:

Glaciers are in decline world wide.

The arctic sea ice has been shrinking.

The major ice sheets are destabilizing.

Most of the hottest years on record are very recent.

Carbon Dioxide is a greenhouse gas.

Human activity is putting huge amounts of previously sequestered CO2 into the atmosphere.


Conclusions?
 
All valid concerns. I think one of the biggest problems is the USan reluctance to adopt nuclear power. I blame The Simpsons, and I'm only partially being ridiculous.

Slight derail: is there really a significant opposition to nuclear in the US, or is it mostly NIMBY?
 
Slight derail: is there really a significant opposition to nuclear in the US, or is it mostly NIMBY?


I think that most of the opposition is in the form of NIMBY, but I haven't done much research on the issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom