Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

To cut through the chaff one needs to look at what isn't in dispute:

Glaciers are in decline world wide.

The arctic sea ice has been shrinking.

The major ice sheets are destabilizing.

Most of the hottest years on record are very recent.

Carbon Dioxide is a greenhouse gas.

Human activity is putting huge amounts of previously sequestered CO2 into the atmosphere.

Conclusions?

Glaciers are always in decline, and also on the increase.

The antartic ice sheets are increasing.

Most of the last ten years are years of cooling.

CO2 is necessary for life. If you want to decrease it, stop breathing.

CO2 also is necesary for plant life, which creates oxogen. Want to stop that too???
 
Okay, I'm switching over to "religion".

or just plain old trolling

picture.php
 
I'm sure there's some kind of "special interpolations" needed to get to Prey's figures.

Yeah like making stuff up just so he can disagree (trolling) or he now believes 'x' because he was told to do so by 'y'. I so look forward to his detailed reply....lol
 
I have a real beef with these "Well I do accept global warming, but I don't think it's as serious as they say" - or "Well, sure the Earth is warming, but we can't really do anything about it" - posts. This is simply another form of AGW denial.

The facts are as conclusive as they can be in science:

- The Earth is Warming.
- We are responsible.
- If we don't act now (not in ten years - now), things will go bad.

It won't destroy humanity, but it will destroy our civilization. It will kill millions of people, destroy our coast-lines and severely affect our food production. You can call this "alarmist" if you want, but it's just science. There's no rational way to deny any of this is happening.
 
I have a real beef with those who make grandiose "sky is falling" statements with no evidence to back it up.

The dang scientists themselves are not making these statements (and those that did have since retracted them as being "excessive").

I would love for you to tell us HOW we are going to stop it. How electric cars are going solve all our problems. How the 3rd world is going to either be stopped from developing or how they will skip the normal developmental steps.

So please, tell us how this can all be averted

ETA: you sound like a fundamentalist , you sound irrational
 
Last edited:
I have a real beef with those who make grandiose "sky is falling" statements with no evidence to back it up.

Have you read the science?

The dang scientists themselves are not making these statements (and those that did have since retracted them as being "excessive").

Quite the opposite. The IPCC reports that make these predictions are seen as "conservative" by most climate scientists.

I would love for you to tell us HOW we are going to stop it.

If I could do that, I would be eligible for a Nobel prize. Fact remains. We need to stop it.

How electric cars are going solve all our problems.

Nobody said they would. Electric cars would be a small part in limiting CO2 emissions.

How the 3rd world is going to either be stopped from developing or how they will skip the normal developmental steps.

With help from the 1st world.

So please, tell us how this can all be averted

As I said, Nobel Prize.

ETA: you sound like a fundamentalist , you sound irrational

You sound like a denialist, you sound irrational.
 
So you are claiming that Lovelock and others haven't backpedaled on their initial claims of mass devastation on the time scales initially reported?

Yelling "stop it" is silly, pointless and does nothing. It's also not so simple as 'the 1st world helping the 3rd world" there are thousands of variables involved in the socio-economic and political climates of all these nations. Unless you are advocating for imperialist style takeovers of course. (which carries it's own set of extreme complications)

All nations can do is the best that they can. They can't force other nations to join in. Not unless you are advocating WW3.

I would assert that spouting claims of global mayhem and "the deaths of millions" without having a reasonable plan of exactly how these people will die, and how it could possibly be averted is lunatic fringe type CT talk. You sound like one of those people.
 
So you are claiming that Lovelock and others haven't backpedaled on their initial claims of mass devastation on the time scales initially reported?

No, I'm claiming exactly what I said. The IPCC reports which is what the what you call "alarmism" is based on is seen by most climate scientists as "conservative", as in, lowballing the issue.

Yelling "stop it" is silly, pointless and does nothing.

Who's yelling "stop it"? I'm trying to get you to understand and accept what the science says - science which you apparently haven't read. The only rational conclusion one can reach from reading the science is that we need to radically alter the way we operate on this planet.

It's also not so simple as 'the 1st world helping the 3rd world" there are thousands of variables involved in the socio-economic and political climates of all these nations.

Which is why I said that if I had a solution, I would be getting the Nobel Prize. The facts, however, don't disappear just because something is hard.

Unless you are advocating for imperialist style takeovers of course. (which carries it's own set of extreme complications)

I am not. I am advocating only what I post. Please stop trying to laden me with ideas or values from your strawman version of reality.

All nations can do is the best that they can. They can't force other nations to join in. Not unless you are advocating WW3.

Force and help are two different concepts. Step 1 is to make everyone aware that there's a problem. You are living proof that there's still more work to be done in step 1.

I would assert that spouting claims of global mayhem and "the deaths of millions" without having a reasonable plan of exactly how these people will die, and how it could possibly be averted is lunatic fringe type CT talk.

I would assert that what you just said is bull crap. From the science, I know how these people will die. Flooded land areas lead to mass exodus and overpopulation. Overpopulation leads to disease and hunger. Climate shift leads to less arable land, which leads to less food production, which leads to more hunger.

Why do I need a plan to fix this in order to point out the problem? Don't you think that's pure unadulterated idiocy? Because I do.

You sound like one of those people.

And you still sound just like a denialist.
 
Last edited:
Your ideas are unrealistic and fanatical. I'm not a denier. But I'm a realist. The problem isn't the first world, it's the developing 3rd world (well and China/India too...if you wanna call them first world) . They frankly, don't care. They are more concerned with feeding their people, moving forward in their input into global economics and other stuff. I don't think pleading at them is going to change much.

Don't call me a denialist because I point out that the "Godfather if AGW' Lovelock has come forward and stated that he was overzealous in his assertions in both scope and time scale. i am not twisting data, I have no agenda, he ***** said it!

Yes, you sound like a fanatic, you have no endpoint, no solution, just mad ranting . I;m done discussing this with you, as i don't feel the need to talk to fanatics. When you can present some real world solutions , then perhaps i will pick this discussion back up again.
 
Your ideas are unrealistic and fanatical.

In that case, you believe science to be unrealistic and fanatical.

I'm not a denier. But I'm a realist.

You may be, but you talk like a denier.

The problem isn't the first world, it's the developing 3rd world (well and China/India too...if you wanna call them first world) .

Wrong. This isn't based on any science. It is based on your ideology. Science doesn't care about ideology.

They frankly, don't care. They are more concerned with feeding their people, moving forward in their input into global economics and other stuff. I don't think pleading at them is going to change much.

I said helping them. Not simply pleading to them.

Don't call me a denialist because I point out that the "Godfather if AGW' Lovelock has come forward and stated that he was overzealous in his assertions in both scope and time scale. i am not twisting data, I have no agenda, he ***** said it!

The "Godfather of AGW"? I thought you denialists thought that was Al Gore. Has he been de-throned?

Fact is, science isn't based on authority. It is based on facts. Fact is the IPCC reports which you dismiss as "alarmist" are seen as "conservative" by most climate scientists. Somehow you seem to have a problem accepting this.

Yes, you sound like a fanatic, you have no endpoint, no solution, just mad ranting .

So for you to accept AGW, I need to come up with a solution to it? And you call my posts mad? :D

I;m done discussing this with you, as i don't feel the need to talk to fanatics.

We're not discussing this. I'm trying to get past your irrational ideological blinkers, and you're responding by doubling down on your irrational beliefs. You are a science denier and a major part of the problem. I hope you grow out of it.

When you can present some real world solutions , then perhaps i will pick this discussion back up again.

Jesus Christ, this is dumb. :eye-poppi
 
I would assert that spouting claims of global mayhem and "the deaths of millions" without having a reasonable plan of exactly how these people will die, and how it could possibly be averted is lunatic fringe type CT talk. You sound like one of those people.
Sounds like you want the scientist to shut up because you don't like hearing what they say. That's one more for the religious camp.
 
When global warming deniers started claiming that the entire scientific staff at NOAA was corrupt they joined the ranks of conspiracy theorists. Following the same path as the 9/11 truthers who dismiss NIST, the Moon landing hoaxers who dismiss NASA, and the Antivaxers who dismiss NIH and CDC.
 
I have a real beef with these "Well I do accept global warming, but I don't think it's as serious as they say" - or "Well, sure the Earth is warming, but we can't really do anything about it" - posts. This is simply another form of AGW denial.

The facts are as conclusive as they can be in science:

- The Earth is Warming.
- We are responsible.
- If we don't act now (not in ten years - now), things will go bad.

It won't destroy humanity, but it will destroy our civilization. It will kill millions of people, destroy our coast-lines and severely affect our food production. You can call this "alarmist" if you want, but it's just science. There's no rational way to deny any of this is happening.

No. Not science, but Junk Science promoted by the purveyors of Marxist "share the wealth" enablers.
 
Your scientific evidence Robert? please show the efvidence to the contary and not your ususal collection of Youtube wierdos unread wikipedia articles, or nutcase websites.
 
Global Warming denial is really the only woo I ever toyed with.

And I can assure you I was concerned very little with facts and science while I was in that phase. Mostly it was just done out of spite against the environmental activist crowd I knew in college.

You see I went into college very concerned about global warming but when I got labeled a "monster" and "shill" because my solution to the problem involved nuclear power I grew very resentful.

"Travis, you aren't thinking outside of the box. We need to make people understand they don't need their microwaves or their idiot boxes and can be perfectly happy in teepees out in nature."

I can completely sympathise with this position. There are some groups that really put the "mental" in "environmental" and those groups, the ones with the placards and the drums, misrepresent the science to further a cause. The cause isn't the environment, it's modern day puritanism.

Essentially what they're saying is that their environmentalism makes them better than other people, and what better way to show how much better than lecturing others on how they should behave? In this respect I would say that the sophomoric/sixth form version of tie-dye environmentalism is like a religion.

But since the past decade has cooled,

The past decade hasn't cooled. A few people have claimed this by carefully choosing the start and end dates of their data to coincide with the El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO). That means they take as a start date the peak of El Nino and as their end point the depth of La Nina and claim that this means the temperature is cooling. The trend over the last two centuries or so, coinciding with the Industrial Revolution is one of startling rise in temperatures and the last decade has been warming, and quickly.

There are warming and cooling cycles but the cooling cycles of today are warmer than the cooling cycles of yesteryear. The same goes for the hotter years too.

Claiming that the last decade has been cooling is a lie.

From Forbes

Peter Ferrara, Contributor
| 5/31/2012 @ 3:26PM |111,891 views

Sorry Global Warming Alarmists, The Earth Is Cooling

"Climate change itself is already in the process of definitively rebutting climate alarmists who think human use of fossil fuels is causing ultimately catastrophic global warming. That is because natural climate cycles have already turned from warming to cooling, global temperatures have already been declining for more than 10 years..."

http://www.forbes.com/sites/peterfe...lobal-warming-alarmists-the-earth-is-cooling/

Peter Ferrara, a lawyer who comments on political and economic news, raises a number of red flags in his article. For one thing he declares the Heartland Institute as the "international headquarters" of "climate realists". He proudly bosts that he spoke at an event on climate science on the subject of "The Economic Implications of High Cost Energy" (as if the economic impact of anything makes any difference to reality) and he crows about the reluctance of real scientists "climate alarmists" to publicly debate their findings.

The latter is the most telling. Scientific debate happens in the technical literature. Not behind a podium. Science is a detail sport. Climate science in particular involves collating data from vast numbers of sources, taming it through use of statistical analysis and basing conclusions on it, to be teased apart, challenged and confirmed by other scientists in the field. It's hard.

Public debate is about grand rhetorical flourishes, feel-good statements and dumbing down to your audience. If your audience is unable to understand statistical analysis then they're probably not good candidates to attend a scientific debate. Which is why it takes place in the literature, a venue which is steadfastly avoided by prominent denialists.

There is also a lot of general misunderstanding about what warming will do to the climate, and most people seem to think we'll all be wandering around northern England in speedos in December before long,

They already do that. Ever been to Newcastle? :D

It isn't helped by a lot of hysterical woo promoted by the 'green' movement, which promotes a variety of panacea based on very little evidence and a lot of high-minded assumptions.

Again I agree with this. But that's why it's important to follow the science. The mistake isn't in heeding scientists, the mistake is in picking a side. In reality we're all on the same side. Just some people don't know it yet.
 
I havent been able to get a suntan in my back garden for the last three years, so on that basis the planet is getting cooler. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom