Invited on another Psychic's Show

Squeegee, I do have a lot going on. And I have composed a couple of things - offline - about my thoughts on my friendship with MamaLisa, and what it does and does not say about me, in my eyes. It may or may not directly address your questions, I'll take a look. I hope to post it today.

It's really more about whether you'd be prepared to approach her about testing her claims, or even her statements (re cold cases) for accuracy.
 
Now, this is perhaps an interesting point - have you investigated any of Mama Lisa's claims? The testimonies on her site include one person saying she'd contacted their grandfather, so she evidently does claim to contact the dead. That probably isn't the kind of thing you could check up on, even if you did ask her for that person's details. However, on this page the things she does are described as:



The last, I would say, is significant. What you could do is to ask her about her cold case readings - what police departments she's worked for, what cases she's worked on, and what her success in these cases have been. It might then be possible to check some of her claims. If she hasn't been hired by the police to do cold case readings, then she is clearly fraudulent, at least in this matter. If she has and has had no success, then she is being disingenuous by mentioning it as part of her profile. If she has, well, then maybe she really is psychic.

Would you be prepared to investigate her claims?

First I will say that I was aware of the MamaLisaCares.com web site - I had, in fact, linked to it in the thread where I first mentioned her, and said that we were "dear friends". I had looked through it, though not in any depth. why not in depth? My ability to navigate a web site is not what it once was, and I end up getting frustrated. And my reading ability is also compromised. I know that might be difficult to understand, seeing that I can type page upon page about things like playing cards, but it is true nonetheless.

So, I did not see some of the things which have been pointed out to me in this thread. Had I seen them, would things have turned out differently? It's quite possible, I can't say for certain.

Would I be willing to investigate her claims? I don't know - it partly boils down to what i said earlier about a lack of material.

Someone else asked if I had asked her why she hadn't taken the MDC.

I have not. I will, though.

Don't know when that will be, though. She hasn't been around para-x for two weeks or so, and one of her friends has said that Lisa is "taking time off from the paranormal" for maybe a month or two, and concentrating on the "normal
' part of her life. I guess I should say here that Lisa has a "day job" as a secretary/office assistant. I assume that this, and her husband, children and grandchildren ar4e the "normal" part of her life.

I will also, when we discuss the MDC, offer to advise her on setting up non-official tests of some of her claims, if she'd be interested (I'm thinking of ChillZero's situation.) It is possible, if she is self-deluded, she would be interested in some proper testing that could be done out of the spotlight. Why wouldn't she take the MDC, if she truly thinks she has psychic powers? the MDC is widely considered a sham by believers in the paranormal. Aside from the "there is no million" and other excuses I've heard time and again, I've heard some other stories from believers and psychics lately, which circulate in their communities as sort of "urban legends". a few dayd ago I private chatted with a psychic who claimed that he was present at a non-MDC test of some other psychics' abilities. He said that it was conducted by some other skeptic organization, under the JREF's auspices. He said that the other skeptics running the test did not know that he was a psychic or even a believer. he was there as a volunteer to help with the test. he said that the skeptics running the test openly joked about the fact that the "psychics" being tested were actors hired by the skeptics to portray psychics being tested, so of course they failed the test. He wouldn't or couldn't answer any of my questions about this purpotyed event. But this story - which he had shared with the whole chat room earlier - are taken as gospel by many in believer communities. they are certain that the MDC is a sham and a scam, deliberately set up for no other purpose than to discredit the paranormal.
 
Of course certain people will say that the MDC is a con act. However, if psychic powers were real it would be easy to prove that it is a con act yet no one has actually done it.

Method.
Get a real psychic to generate some publicity, but not enough to show that he is real. He 'reluctantly' agrees to apply for the MDC. He then passes the tests in full publicity. He either gets the million dollars or exposes the MDC as a fraud. Easy.
 
Would I be willing to investigate her claims? I don't know - it partly boils down to what i said earlier about a lack of material.

Surely it would be easy to ask her what police cases she has worked on and what her success rate is? Then you could either contact the police department in question yourself or ask a member of this forum to do so.

That seems, to me, to be the quickest and easiest way of determining whether she is self-deluded or a fraud.
 
Of course certain people will say that the MDC is a con act. However, if psychic powers were real it would be easy to prove that it is a con act yet no one has actually done it.

Method.
Get a real psychic to generate some publicity, but not enough to show that he is real. He 'reluctantly' agrees to apply for the MDC. He then passes the tests in full publicity. He either gets the million dollars or exposes the MDC as a fraud. Easy.

I don't follow how this scenario would prove anything.

For one thing, what do you mean by "in full publicity"?
 
Surely it would be easy to ask her what police cases she has worked on and what her success rate is? Then you could either contact the police department in question yourself or ask a member of this forum to do so.

That seems, to me, to be the quickest and easiest way of determining whether she is self-deluded or a fraud.

I will consider using this approach upon her return, squeege. thanks.
 
As usual, I suspect these peoples' paranormal abilities per se have sweet FA to do with it. I would consider the basic premise that it is all a money-making venture. Therefore anything they do or decisions they make will be aimed at promoting their business. So you can expect their responses to challenges and questions will be made accordingly.

Example: "Will you attempt the MDC?" Their business depends on their credibility, and they know full well the MDC is fair and honest, and they really have no abilities at all. So to attempt it would easily expose their lack of credibility. Therefore the MDC must be avoided, but that avoidance needs to keep their "marks" onside. So the best response is to take the (fake) high road and smear it, call the MDC dishonest at all possible times. Hence the response noted by Robert.

You really do need to think like they do. When you understand it is all literally a "carny" sideshow act trying to separate the money from the fools then everything they do and say makes sense.
 
Example: "Will you attempt the MDC?" Their business depends on their credibility, and they know full well the MDC is fair and honest, and they really have no abilities at all.

I think that many of the self-deluded ones truly think the MDC is rigged. And, who knows, perhaps even some of the knowingly fraudulent ones think so, too. After all, being dishonest themselves, they might see/assume dishonesty in others where there is none.
 
I don't follow how this scenario would prove anything.

For one thing, what do you mean by "in full publicity"?

If you assume that psychic power is real how do you prove that the MDC is fake? The answer is to be seen to take the challenge and to win it. Then it would be obvious when the prize is not given out that something is wrong. If that assumption is not valid then Zep (quoted below) has said what would happen.

As usual, I suspect these peoples' paranormal abilities per se have sweet FA to do with it. I would consider the basic premise that it is all a money-making venture. Therefore anything they do or decisions they make will be aimed at promoting their business. So you can expect their responses to challenges and questions will be made accordingly.

Example: "Will you attempt the MDC?" Their business depends on their credibility, and they know full well the MDC is fair and honest, and they really have no abilities at all. So to attempt it would easily expose their lack of credibility. Therefore the MDC must be avoided, but that avoidance needs to keep their "marks" onside. So the best response is to take the (fake) high road and smear it, call the MDC dishonest at all possible times. Hence the response noted by Robert.

You really do need to think like they do. When you understand it is all literally a "carny" sideshow act trying to separate the money from the fools then everything they do and say makes sense.

If a real psychic did not want to gain any money they could still do a major public service by solving crimes, predicting disasters or whatever they can do. However no one ever does this sort of thing.
 
Brattus and others-

Agreeing to be on someone's show and being cordial to them does not mean agreeing with them.

Bill Maher sometimes had Ann Coulter on his show. Does this mean that Maher agrees with Coulter? Does this mean that Coulter agrees with Maher?

Of course not.
 
Brattus and others-

Agreeing to be on someone's show and being cordial to them does not mean agreeing with them.

Bill Maher sometimes had Ann Coulter on his show. Does this mean that Maher agrees with Coulter? Does this mean that Coulter agrees with Maher?

Of course not.
Has he announced that Ann Coulter is his "dear friend"?
 
Oh, enough with the "dear friend" thing already.

I've written up my thoughts on my having used that phrase, intending to start a new thread with it. we'll see.
 
Stepping back is not neccesary, but refraining from throwing that phrase in my face would be appreciated


Presumably the phrase in question is "dear friend", which AC has used exactly once and then only in response to another poster.

If it concerns you that this is "throwing it in your face" then perhaps your own use of the phrase was ill-considered in the first place, which is rather the point that a few brave souls are attempting to make.

Further, if mentioning your "dear friend" is so upsetting then I might suggest that starting yet another thread to discuss the subject is not going to end well.
 
Your credibility as a skeptic is just as important as your ability to speak to people on both sides in an even and placid manner. Without credibility, your important words can be dismissed and your words are far too important to be dismissed. You have an obligation now Robert, this is no longer a hobby or a personal blog. Whether you like it or not, whether you accept it or not, many skeptics look to you to progress the sceptical movement. You can’t do that if your credibility is in question.

When you make a claim that you are now dear friends with a person who we all know is either deluded or a conwoman, it lessens the power of your actions and words as a proponent of skepticism.

Poppycock!

The only "credibility" skeptics should grant to anyone is that the person has proven to be reliable when presenting facts, thus we don't need to be as concerned about checking details or sources. Of course, we should never assume that anyone is 100% accurate in their facts, but I think it's acceptable to give someone the benefit of the doubt if in the past their facts always check out. The StopSylvia site is an example of good research, so when it comes to facts, he's earned some credibility.

Beyond that, anyone who grants his opinions more value than anyone else's opinion is not being skeptical. He's not a spokesperson for anyone but himself. Honestly, I find some of his opinions based on the facts to be dubious at best. He, like anyone else, is a source of ideas, and those ideas should be evaluated accordingly.

This type of "hero worship" (can't think of a better term) is exactly the same kind of uncritical thinking that allows woo to grow and thrive. The term "skeptical movement" makes me cringe because it's all too often about beliefs (psychics are bad, homeopathy is stupid) when the real message should be about the processes that get a person to those conclusions. If someone's judgment of a person's opinion is affected by that person calling a psychic a "dear friend" and/or being married to a Christian, that's exactly the type of thinking that skeptics should be fighting against.

On a practical level, though, it calls into question motives of a site like StopSylvia. It's a legal and honest attack on a person's legal livelihood. Some people don't take kindly to it, but it's justified by seemingly a sense of moral outrage.

Where is that moral outrage with this "dear friend?" How about dating a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christianity? Did he have to start dating her in the first place? Maybe it was love at first sight (don't believe in it), but if his convictions are so strong as to justify an ongoing campaign against other people, it certainly seems hypocritical to invite similar people into his life.

When asked, "Why pick on Sylvia?" I can see explaining how time and resources are limited. What I can't see is befriending other psychics while attacking one or two in particular.

From my perspective, I don't care how this affects how people judge his opinions since even considering his opinions as having inherent value is decidedly unskeptical. I don't want to get personal with Mr. Lancaster, but if I were prone to that line of thinking, I would have rejected him as a candidate because I think he's accomplished far less than people give him credit for. And that's all I really want to say about that.
 
Beyond that, anyone who grants his opinions more value than anyone else's opinion is not being skeptical. He's not a spokesperson for anyone but himself. Honestly, I find some of his opinions based on the facts to be dubious at best.

And exactly what "opinions based on the facts" might those be, and why are they "dubious at best"?
 
How about dating a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christianity? Did he have to start dating her in the first place? Maybe it was love at first sight (don't believe in it), but if his convictions are so strong as to justify an ongoing campaign against other people, it certainly seems hypocritical to invite similar people into his life.

I can certainly understand you (or anyone) saying that my friend MamaLisa and Sylvia are "similar", but if you are saying here that My Susan, because she is a Christian, is "similar" to Sylvia, I can't understand that in the slightest.

I don't want to get personal with Mr. Lancaster, but if I were prone to that line of thinking, I would have rejected him as a candidate because I think he's accomplished far less than people give him credit for. And that's all I really want to say about that.

I don't think that it would be "getting personal", but I would truly be interested to know 1) what you think others think I have accomplished, and 2) what, if anything, you think I have accomplished. Feel free to PM me the answer if you'd rather not answer it here. Thanks.
 
And exactly what "opinions based on the facts" might those be, and why are they "dubious at best"?

It's not an extraordinary claim to say that I find some of your (or anyone's) arguments dubious, so I really don't see your point in asking for evidence. It would be an extraordinary claim to NOT find at least some arguments from a person to be dubious.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom