Invited on another Psychic's Show

Forget the "dear friend" thing for thme moment. How does having a show on a paranormal network - where I promote skepticism - "smack of hypocrisy"?

you are not promoting skepticism by appearing on this show in my opinion. you are adding to its credibility as the "token skeptic". maybe the sgu should get a psychic presenter or homeopath as part of their line up to add "balance too"? and im sorry but leaving aside the "dear friend" comment leads me to assume that you agree that this, at least, is an hypocrisy on your part.



So now the credibility of SSB is gone? All of the evidence and facts presented there are now meaningless because I am friends with a psychic and have a skeptical show on a paranormal station?

the evidence and facts are still correct. it looks however more like a vendetta against one person rather than the community of psychics that are all as bad as each other. that is what sylvia fans have always acused you of and now you give them ammunition. again imo. it would be the same for any woo.


Who says that's what I am "purely basing" my decision on?

what other reasons then?


And you are "purely basing" my "lost credibility" on this wager/assumption?

dont understand the point, sorry?


You seem to be making yet another assumption here - that Lisa is knowingly fraudulent.

http://idealeventmanage.com/mamalisa.html
you seem to be making the mistake of confusing someone who beleives in woo with someone who makes a business out of it. lisa is the latter. i have friends that beleive all sorts of rubbish. there is a BIG difference. she does all the usual stuff, helping law enforcement, talking to lost love ones, exorcising demons etc. the beleivers are the victims, this woman is the culprit. i think lee harvey oswald thought he was in the right too. (not the best analogy i know, but you get my meaning.


Please remind me, because I remember NO reaction from other psychics. To what are you referring?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzkgskUkOlE

rosemary altea and jr discussing the hornbeck thing. note rosemary trying to distance herself from sylvia as if she is somehow different or better. by your reasoning robert she is correct to say "dont throw the baby out with the bathwater" or "we should all be more skeptical of mediums" randi doesnt humour that opinion and neither should you. There were also similar comments from van prague and edward. surprised you havnt seen them.


And you seem to be basing this decision on several unwarranted (in my opinion) assumptions, and your being "put in mind" of something I don't recall even happening (and it is something I think I would know about and remember if it had happened)

see above link.

Again, you seem to be assuming you know something which you do not.

see above links. look at her websites and advertising! man, i linked to two. theres a lot more stuff from her and her "crew".


Well, thank you for taking the time to tell me.



thats okay. im sorry if i have offended you but like i said. you were doing good work and this could easily set all that back.
lxxx
 
Last edited:
Ok.

Something I still don't understand:

How does being friends with "someone on the other side of the fence" weaken one's credibility? Has anyone actually given any sort of evidence to this? Other than their own opinion, that is?

I am mainly interested in Reno's response, but would like to read anyone's.

....

I'll try. An imperfect analogy* would be a Police Inspector openly being 'dear friends' with a known member of the criminal fraternity whilst actively targeting another criminal to 'bring them to justice'. As Lxxx has suggested, this could look like a vendetta on the one and even, at the extreme, a tacit condoning of the other. Yes I accept RSL sticks to his guns on what he believes but openly describing one as a dear friend whilst actively targeting the other could weaken the overall impact as it suggests one is 'not as bad' as the other. People often don't examine these things closely anyway, so whatever RSL specifically says about his beliefs people may well skim that and just note 'Hmmm, even a reknowed sceptic 'approves' of Mama Lisa, she must be good' or just, 'Well obviously Sylvia is a bad egg but Mama Lisa must be alright as she's not being targeted, indeed, RSL is very good friends with her.' Again as Lxxx has suggested, at the very least it could be seen as hypocritical ('he only goes after the ones he happens to dislike') and that can be used to weaken the impact.

Again, as I've said before, I am not presuming to tell RSL who he can be friendly with (and I don't think Reno was either) as that is obviously up to him, just pointing out the potential consequences of highlighting that friendship. I think it was unnecessary to announce the friendship (and a bit premature but that's probably my Brit reserve again!) - he wasn't asked. No problem if he felt he had to give credit that Mama Lisa seemed friendly and polite despite her woo beliefs (as he did with Van Praagh) but no need to use such emotionally charged words as 'dear friend' which conveys a large degree of trust and respect.

Just trying to answer the question of essentially 'What's the harm'.

*I'm not saying the two are exactly the same as one activity is illegal (though the other should be IMHO as well!). Perhaps a better analogy would be say someone active in the Stop Animal Testing community announcing they were 'dear friends' with a scientist involved in animal testing. It's bound to have an impact - unfairly perhaps but hey, that's the world we live in.
 
Last edited:
The one psychic reading I had heard MamaLisa give was when she took a call from a woman who wanted to know if a party she was planning would go well.

Now, this is perhaps an interesting point - have you investigated any of Mama Lisa's claims? The testimonies on her site include one person saying she'd contacted their grandfather, so she evidently does claim to contact the dead. That probably isn't the kind of thing you could check up on, even if you did ask her for that person's details. However, on this page the things she does are described as:

Spiritual Advisor, Psychic Readings, Medium, Physical & Spiritual Energy Cleansings, Healings & Training, Entity Cleansings, Law Enforcement Cold Case Readings.

The last, I would say, is significant. What you could do is to ask her about her cold case readings - what police departments she's worked for, what cases she's worked on, and what her success in these cases have been. It might then be possible to check some of her claims. If she hasn't been hired by the police to do cold case readings, then she is clearly fraudulent, at least in this matter. If she has and has had no success, then she is being disingenuous by mentioning it as part of her profile. If she has, well, then maybe she really is psychic.

Would you be prepared to investigate her claims?
 
I'm a little dissatisfied with my previous post (I had to write it quickly to jump in the shower to go to work) and wanted to expand a little bit.

First and foremost, I think that who you are friends with is entirely down to you. I think we all have friends who we disagree with, perhaps even on huge moral issues.

I also think that the idea that you owe it to anybody to behave in any particular way is patently ridiculous. You've put in years of work doing what you do, and the idea is that all this work means that you owe others? That's nonsensical, to my way of thinking.

But I can see how an uncritical relationship with Mama Lisa could be damaging to your credibility. Not the credibility of StopSylvia, as you say the facts speak for themselves, but to your image as a critical thinker. Perhaps that's not down to you, perhaps it's down to the image of you that people have built up inside their head - that of RSLancaster the sceptic icon, rather than RSLancaster the human being - and perhaps, therefore, it's not something you should concern yourself with.

However, from what you've said, it sounds like you've not looked in to Mama Lisa's alleged abilities too closely and are instead mostly guessing and assuming that she's deluded, rather than fraudulent. Perhaps you simply haven't had the time or inclination, perhaps it hasn't occurred to you to do so, perhaps you're a little afraid that if you did investigate and find her to be a fraud that it would taint your relationship with her. All this is fine - again, you're a grown man beholden to none and nobody can tell you how you should behave. But I can see how such an unwillingness (for whatever reason) could make people think that you're not really the critical thinker that they had previously thought you were.
 
Robert, what do you think of this analogy:

An FBI detective, tasked to take down a big and powerful crime family, becomes "dear friends" with a similar, smaller crime family.

FWIW I think working as a psychic for police on cold cases, as MamaLisa advertises, is abhorrent and possibly criminal.
 
Thanks Ethan, squeegee and Mr. Scott for the recent posts. I would reply to them now, but I need to focus right now on preparing my show for this afternoon/evening. I hope to reply to them after the show.
 
This is something I am having trouble understanding. Is this guilt by association?

Once, when I was training for a job, I overheard someone during break talking about her belief in mediums, psychics, tarot cards. Once, she and I, the only two smokers, went outside during a break to light up. We started talking about many things, though nothing about her belief in woo, just personal things. I liked her immedieatly. She was funny, kind, interesting, and truely listened when I talked about things going on in my life.

We became 'dear friends' very quickly. Yes, there were things we agreed to not discuss. But overall, it was the beginning of a great friendship. When I was sick, she left work early and drove almost 2 hours round-trip to help me. Had I decided to treat her like the enemy, I would have missed out on one of the best friendships I've had.
 
Looking over some of the links s_pepys has posted, it seems MamaLisa also claims to be able to heal illnesses and injuries. I'd say that that's a potentially dangerous claim if it could lead someone to go to her instead of a qualified medical professional. But, more importantly, that's a testable claim. I doubt she's got enough of a media profile for the MDC these days, but I'm sure there's a wealth of sceptic groups out there who would test her claims.

Robert, do you think approaching her about testing her claims is something you'd feel you could do?
 
This is something I am having trouble understanding. Is this guilt by association?

Once, when I was training for a job, I overheard someone during break talking about her belief in mediums, psychics, tarot cards. Once, she and I, the only two smokers, went outside during a break to light up. We started talking about many things, though nothing about her belief in woo, just personal things. I liked her immedieatly. She was funny, kind, interesting, and truely listened when I talked about things going on in my life.

We became 'dear friends' very quickly. Yes, there were things we agreed to not discuss. But overall, it was the beginning of a great friendship. When I was sick, she left work early and drove almost 2 hours round-trip to help me. Had I decided to treat her like the enemy, I would have missed out on one of the best friendships I've had.

hi

i have friends who beleive all sorts of woo also. in fact most people have something they believe that is a bit daft. the difference is that the believers are the victims of people like mamalisa. you cant equate a friendship with a believer and one with a proffessional practitioner of woo.

your friend is the conned, not the con artist. that is the difference. and that is where you change minds imo.

robert can be mates with whoever he likes. thats none of my business. it does call nto question just how he can abhor one medium whilst making allowances for another. it does wiff a wee bit of hypocrisy.

lxxx
 
hi

i have friends who beleive all sorts of woo also. in fact most people have something they believe that is a bit daft. the difference is that the believers are the victims of people like mamalisa. you cant equate a friendship with a believer and one with a proffessional practitioner of woo.

your friend is the conned, not the con artist. that is the difference. and that is where you change minds imo.

robert can be mates with whoever he likes. thats none of my business. it does call nto question just how he can abhor one medium whilst making allowances for another. it does wiff a wee bit of hypocrisy.

lxxx

OK, I understand how you make the distinction. Thank you.
 
Oh, before I forget, Robert, have you asked MamaLisa why she's not interesting in winning Randi's million?
 
Robert, what do you think of this analogy:

An FBI detective, tasked to take down a big and powerful crime family, becomes "dear friends" with a similar, smaller crime family.

FWIW I think working as a psychic for police on cold cases, as MamaLisa advertises, is abhorrent and possibly criminal.
i agree with this.

lxxx
 
While you're posting in this thread, Robert, can you answer my questions? I don't mean to hassle you, as I'm sure you've got other stuff going on but, to my mind, they do rather get to the nub of the matter.
 
Squeegee, I do have a lot going on. And I have composed a couple of things - offline - about my thoughts on my friendship with MamaLisa, and what it does and does not say about me, in my eyes. It may or may not directly address your questions, I'll take a look. I hope to post it today.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom