s_pepys
Muse
- Joined
- May 31, 2010
- Messages
- 761
Forget the "dear friend" thing for thme moment. How does having a show on a paranormal network - where I promote skepticism - "smack of hypocrisy"?
you are not promoting skepticism by appearing on this show in my opinion. you are adding to its credibility as the "token skeptic". maybe the sgu should get a psychic presenter or homeopath as part of their line up to add "balance too"? and im sorry but leaving aside the "dear friend" comment leads me to assume that you agree that this, at least, is an hypocrisy on your part.
So now the credibility of SSB is gone? All of the evidence and facts presented there are now meaningless because I am friends with a psychic and have a skeptical show on a paranormal station?
the evidence and facts are still correct. it looks however more like a vendetta against one person rather than the community of psychics that are all as bad as each other. that is what sylvia fans have always acused you of and now you give them ammunition. again imo. it would be the same for any woo.
Who says that's what I am "purely basing" my decision on?
what other reasons then?
And you are "purely basing" my "lost credibility" on this wager/assumption?
dont understand the point, sorry?
You seem to be making yet another assumption here - that Lisa is knowingly fraudulent.
http://idealeventmanage.com/mamalisa.html
you seem to be making the mistake of confusing someone who beleives in woo with someone who makes a business out of it. lisa is the latter. i have friends that beleive all sorts of rubbish. there is a BIG difference. she does all the usual stuff, helping law enforcement, talking to lost love ones, exorcising demons etc. the beleivers are the victims, this woman is the culprit. i think lee harvey oswald thought he was in the right too. (not the best analogy i know, but you get my meaning.
Please remind me, because I remember NO reaction from other psychics. To what are you referring?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzkgskUkOlE
rosemary altea and jr discussing the hornbeck thing. note rosemary trying to distance herself from sylvia as if she is somehow different or better. by your reasoning robert she is correct to say "dont throw the baby out with the bathwater" or "we should all be more skeptical of mediums" randi doesnt humour that opinion and neither should you. There were also similar comments from van prague and edward. surprised you havnt seen them.
And you seem to be basing this decision on several unwarranted (in my opinion) assumptions, and your being "put in mind" of something I don't recall even happening (and it is something I think I would know about and remember if it had happened)
see above link.
Again, you seem to be assuming you know something which you do not.
see above links. look at her websites and advertising! man, i linked to two. theres a lot more stuff from her and her "crew".
Well, thank you for taking the time to tell me.
thats okay. im sorry if i have offended you but like i said. you were doing good work and this could easily set all that back.
lxxx
Last edited: