Invited on another Psychic's Show

I was not "asking for evidence." I am genuinely interested to know which of my opinions are, or even seem to you to be, "dubious at best" if you gave an example, it might help me to change my opinion, or to express it better, in future.
 
I can certainly understand you (or anyone) saying that my friend MamaLisa and Sylvia are "similar", but if you are saying here that My Susan, because she is a Christian, is "similar" to Sylvia, I can't understand that in the slightest.
Would you say that Susan is similar to MamaLisa? If so, that's just one degree of separation from Sylvia. You may not understand why I see some similarities. I'm fine with that. The reasons why really don't matter in this context because it's more about the perception existing than being a "fair" perception. It exists for me and apparently for some others. The actual head count is unknown.

I don't think that it would be "getting personal", but I would truly be interested to know 1) what you think others think I have accomplished, and 2) what, if anything, you think I have accomplished. Feel free to PM me the answer if you'd rather not answer it here. Thanks.
I said all I am interested in saying about that subject. If I want to address it, I'll go back to the threads I read in the past or respond when I see it mentioned again. I doubt I will, though, since I don't see much accomplished by either myself or others changing our opinions.

On a related note: In the future please don't send me a PM bugging me about unanswered (less than 24 hours in this case) posts in a thread and/or offer to discuss things via PM (as if I didn't see your offer above before you sent a PM to me). If I want to respond, I will at a time of my own choosing and through the medium of my choice, which will almost always be in the thread.

It's a little creepy and stalker-ish.
 
Support it? That would depend on how it was written, and the evidence it presented. Create it myself? No. I have too much unstarted and unfinished web sites already. Plus, I doubt there is enough evidence about her out there from which to create a site. I didn't choose Browne for a target just because she is famous/successful, although that played into it (see the site's FAQ page), but primarily because there was a wealth of her output (books, videos, weekly Montel appearances and more) to sift through for material from which articles could be produced. MamaLisa has only a weekly radio show (that I know of). Also. Browne's material was full of incredibly offensive stuff (telling parents of missing children that their child was alive or dead, etc.) The one psychic reading I had heard MamaLisa give was when she took a call from a woman who wanted to know if a party she was planning would go well.

You wanted an example of what I consider a dubious opinion based on facts. I think your reasoning for choosing Sylvia is seriously flawed. The fact that's so much information out there for research means that the battle was already lost. Most (not all) "famous" people are only famous for a relatively short period of time. They struggle along for sometimes a very long time, then they have a relatively fast rise towards a peak. They stay there for a while, sometimes briefly, sometimes for several years, then their careers decline. However, there's often enough momentum to keep them going along at much higher level than before their rise for many years.

What might look like a successful "stop" will most likely be nothing more than the typical decline. For every Johnny Carson, David Letterman or Oprah Winfrey there are dozens of talk show hosts who fizzle out without anybody trying to stop them. Typically they do better than before their gig because of the boost they got. Sylvia seems to have a pretty good gig going to this day. It's not like she's working from a small storefront in a strip mall.

The better target is someone like MamaLisa. It doesn't matter if she's deluded or fraudulent since the motives don't change how much someone is injured emotionally or financially by such a person. She needs to be stopped before her star rises. It's silly to wait for hours of video, several books, and dozens magazine interviews for you to be able to research. People like her need to be stopped before their stars rise.

You know, horses, barn doors and all that.
 
Poppycock!

The only "credibility" skeptics should grant to anyone is that the person has proven to be reliable when presenting facts, thus we don't need to be as concerned about checking details or sources. Of course, we should never assume that anyone is 100% accurate in their facts, but I think it's acceptable to give someone the benefit of the doubt if in the past their facts always check out. The StopSylvia site is an example of good research, so when it comes to facts, he's earned some credibility.

Beyond that, anyone who grants his opinions more value than anyone else's opinion is not being skeptical. He's not a spokesperson for anyone but himself. Honestly, I find some of his opinions based on the facts to be dubious at best. He, like anyone else, is a source of ideas, and those ideas should be evaluated accordingly.

This type of "hero worship" (can't think of a better term) is exactly the same kind of uncritical thinking that allows woo to grow and thrive. The term "skeptical movement" makes me cringe because it's all too often about beliefs (psychics are bad, homeopathy is stupid) when the real message should be about the processes that get a person to those conclusions. If someone's judgment of a person's opinion is affected by that person calling a psychic a "dear friend" and/or being married to a Christian, that's exactly the type of thinking that skeptics should be fighting against.

On a practical level, though, it calls into question motives of a site like StopSylvia. It's a legal and honest attack on a person's legal livelihood. Some people don't take kindly to it, but it's justified by seemingly a sense of moral outrage.

Where is that moral outrage with this "dear friend?" How about dating a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christianity? Did he have to start dating her in the first place? Maybe it was love at first sight (don't believe in it), but if his convictions are so strong as to justify an ongoing campaign against other people, it certainly seems hypocritical to invite similar people into his life.

When asked, "Why pick on Sylvia?" I can see explaining how time and resources are limited. What I can't see is befriending other psychics while attacking one or two in particular.

From my perspective, I don't care how this affects how people judge his opinions since even considering his opinions as having inherent value is decidedly unskeptical. I don't want to get personal with Mr. Lancaster, but if I were prone to that line of thinking, I would have rejected him as a candidate because I think he's accomplished far less than people give him credit for. And that's all I really want to say about that.

Well, aren't you opinionated. Here we go again, instead of "groupie" we now have "hero worship". Just another insidious way of trying to silence those in support of Robert's work.

Pages have been posted about a phrase he used once. OK. But now you seem to have a sense of "moral outrage" over his dating and marrying "a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christanity"?

What a repulsive attack. And, one that is totally unrelated to his work.

Enjoy your black and white, humorless world. I pity you.
 
Well, aren't you opinionated. Here we go again, instead of "groupie" we now have "hero worship". Just another insidious way of trying to silence those in support of Robert's work.

Pages have been posted about a phrase he used once. OK. But now you seem to have a sense of "moral outrage" over his dating and marrying "a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christanity"?

What a repulsive attack. And, one that is totally unrelated to his work.

Enjoy your black and white, humorless world. I pity you.

ulia, I appreciate your (totally non-groupie, non-heroworshippy support, but I think you are mischaracterizing Isabella's post. I think that a careful re-reading of her post will show that instead of criticizing my relationship with Susan, she is critizing those who would judge my credibility on that relationship.

Since that was mixed in with things such as her calling some of my opinions "dubious", it was easy to mistake her meaning.
 
You wanted an example of what I consider a dubious opinion based on facts. I think your reasoning for choosing Sylvia is seriously flawed. The fact that's so much information out there for research means that the battle was already lost. Most (not all) "famous" people are only famous for a relatively short period of time. They struggle along for sometimes a very long time, then they have a relatively fast rise towards a peak. They stay there for a while, sometimes briefly, sometimes for several years, then their careers decline. However, there's often enough momentum to keep them going along at much higher level than before their rise for many years.

What might look like a successful "stop" will most likely be nothing more than the typical decline. For every Johnny Carson, David Letterman or Oprah Winfrey there are dozens of talk show hosts who fizzle out without anybody trying to stop them. Typically they do better than before their gig because of the boost they got. Sylvia seems to have a pretty good gig going to this day. It's not like she's working from a small storefront in a strip mall.

The better target is someone like MamaLisa. It doesn't matter if she's deluded or fraudulent since the motives don't change how much someone is injured emotionally or financially by such a person. She needs to be stopped before her star rises. It's silly to wait for hours of video, several books, and dozens magazine interviews for you to be able to research. People like her need to be stopped before their stars rise.

You know, horses, barn doors and all that.

First, thanks for giving me an example of something I have said or done which you deemed "dubious". But I think you have (perhaps understandably) mistaken one of the reasons I chose Browne as the focus for a "Stop Site" as the only or even main reason I chose her. More below.
 
Isabella, I am going to describe the process by which I chose Sylvia Browne as the focus for a Stop Site, in a typical (for me anyway) TMI fashion (but please bear with me - it all fits together in the end):

The focus for my first Stop Site (StopKaz.com) just about fell into my lap. Kaz had spoken at my mother's church, and my mother had told Susan about it, who told ME about it. I became incensed that not only was this woman apparently making money by lying about her having been at Ground Zero on 9/11, but she had somehow gotten my mother - generally a very sensible person - to BELIEVE her.

I created the site for two reasons:

1) To Stop, as best I could, this woman from continuing to profit from that tragedy, and

2) To convince my mother that Kaz was a fraud.

When Kaz did indeed stop profiting from that tragedy - whether because of my site or from the natural decline of her career (and my mother had decided Kaz was a fraud), people on this forum urged me to pick a new focus on whom to try the same "Stop" approach.

Different categories of people who I felt needed stopping came to mind, including Faith Healers and Psychic Mediums. But My Susan, who had believed in the abilities of John Edward, James Van Praagh and Sylvia Browne when we met, and had seen me fuming at the television when they were on, said to me "if you think they are really harming people, stop complaining about it and do something about it!" So I narrowed my focus down to someone in the category of Psychic Mediums - but I knew it would be impossible to prove that the whole category was fraudulent, so I had to pick one of them as my focus - but which?

I felt that if I could disprove - or at least, cast a fair amount of doubt upon one of the most well-known of them, it had a chance of helping more people than doing so with some streetcorner one, and, I felt, people would be more likely to apply the lesson about a "big name" psychic to psychics/mediums in general. I could imagine them saying or thinking " of COURSE that streetcorner psychic is phony, but what about the really successful ones? They wouldn't be that successful if they were phony!" Yes, it's a fallacious Appeal to Popularity, but I still felt it would be used. At this point, I narrowed my focus to the three most popular/famous psychics in America at the time: Edward, Van Praagh and Browne. But which of these?

This is where my purportedly "dubious" dxecision came into play. I knew that the site, as I envisioned it, would rely heavily on presenting examples of the psychic's predictions and readings, and comparing those with what had really come to pass. In order to use that sort of an approach, the more examples of the psychic's readings and predictions I could find and research, the better. With dozens of published books, and years of TV appearances (including a weekly gig on the Montel Williams Show), Sylvia Browne seemed to provide the largest trove of research material, placing her at the top of my list.

Still "dubious" to you?
 
Well, aren't you opinionated.
Opinionated? No. Have strong opinions? Yes. There's a difference, though I don't see how your claim about me is relevant other than to get personal with me.

Here we go again, instead of "groupie" we now have "hero worship". Just another insidious way of trying to silence those in support of Robert's work.
I did say that it was for a lack of a better term. People do call him their hero. I get that from quotes like, "You are my hero, too, Robert. Keep up the good work! We're all behind you."

I think we have a different definition of supporting someone's work. I don't consider praising a person to be the same as supporting their work. Providing new information, correcting misinformation, constructive criticism and suggestions I consider to be supporting the work.

Pages have been posted about a phrase he used once. OK. But now you seem to have a sense of "moral outrage" over his dating and marrying "a woman who believes in the nonsense that is Christanity"?

What a repulsive attack. And, one that is totally unrelated to his work.

Enjoy your black and white, humorless world. I pity you.
Thank you for providing a wonderful example of just what I'm talking about. You've attacked me personally and misrepresented my arguments in doing so. Who is trying to silence whom?

I did not express moral outrage about his choice of spouse. I feel no moral outrage. Re-read what I wrote with that in mind instead of your own knee-jerk, preconceived notion. In the future if you want a response from me, leave out the personal remarks and dramatic language.
 
MamaLisa and Sylvia ARE similar. They are both psychics. Overall, they are both guilty of the same thing, potentially able to do the same harm. I haven't heard Robert state otherwise (?).

Is it possible for a skeptic to be close friends with a psychic? To be happily married to a Christian? A Muslim? An astrologer? A homeopath?

If not, why not?

Does a skeptic have to be completely non-woo in every way in order to be a skeptic? Does a skeptic have to refuse friendships with believers in order to 'set a good example' for other skeptics? Does a skeptic have to be a non-believer, for that matter?

Do you have to limit your friendships to skeptics in order to be a credible skeptic?

If so, if Robert had a belief like that, I would probably still be a woo.

The way I see it is this: Robert has already explained that he is hoping MamaLisa might learn to think skeptically by virtue of their friendship. Of course he would hope that; it is something very dear to his heart. And it is quite possible that without a friendship with Robert, she never would.

To me that is perfectly in keeping with the type of work Robert has been doing over the years. It is, especially, perfectly in keeping with a man who fell in love with his wife without regard for whether she was a Christian or a Hindu or a Sikh.

Here's the thing, and I hope Robert doesn't mind me saying this. He doesn't care what you believe. If he likes you, he likes you. He shares his skeptical beliefs and values as you talk with him. It is just who he is and it comes out in the way he approaches the world. He recommends skeptical books that have been meaningful to him. He is obviously upset by the charlatans and he will tell you so, even if you have just professed to belief in one of them (I know this from personal experience). He doesn't mince words or tiptoe around what he thinks. He will explain why. He just tells it like he sees it. And if you start to adopt some of this skepticism for yourself, all the better. He loves that, I think. But he has still been your friend all along.

Robert won me over to an interest in skepticism through his friendship. I really liked him as a person, I liked his attitude and his calm rationality. Above all, Robert won me over because he never made it seem like he was trying to change me. He just respectfully discussed things with me when I asked.

What he does is completely his own thing. He doesn't do what Richard Dawkins does, or even approach things in quite the same manner as James Randi, whom he holds in the highest respect. In my book, there is a place for all of them - all types of skeptics, all kinds of activism. The more, the better.

One final thing: There are going to be some times when a Stop Site is the best approach. There will be times when confrontation is needed. There will be other times, as in my case, where just being friendly may be helpful. Even as a Tarot-card reading woo, I did not need a StopExMinister web site.

Has Robert formed a friendship with MamaLisa in order to change her? You know, I bet not. I don't think that's his way. As I said, I think it can't help but be his hope, since it means so much to him, that she'll pick up some appreciation for skepticism, kind of like I did. But he is willing to reach out to us and be friendly. He genuinely likes us, go figure. He finds other things to focus on, I guess, than the things we disagree on. Maybe partly he enjoys a chance to talk about skepticism where it's needed most.

Maybe, in spite of the outrage he feels at the potential harm that can be done by psychics and mediums, he is still able to remain friendly with those of us who are kind and sincere and at least attempting to be reasonable in our approach to the world (?). Maybe he recognizes a good heart himself, when he sees one.

So, even though I have joked about being a groupie, the fact is groupie is misleading. I'm just happy to have a friend like Robert. I'm happy he was there to introduce me to skepticism in his way. He has a heart of gold.

He is genuinely interested in what people have to say. Even if you criticize him, he wants to hear what you think. If you have an opinion about something, he's going to listen, though if he disagrees, he will not hesitate to tell you.

Yeah, I think he did a great job on the StopSylvia site, and because of my background with Sylvia, that also was important to me, but that wasn't the half of it.
 
MamaLisa and Sylvia ARE similar. They are both psychics. Overall, they are both guilty of the same thing, potentially able to do the same harm. I haven't heard Robert state otherwise (?).

Is it possible for a skeptic to be close friends with a psychic? To be happily married to a Christian? A Muslim? An astrologer? A homeopath? If not, why not?

Does a skeptic have to be completely non-woo in every way in order to be a skeptic? Does a skeptic have to refuse friendships with believers in order to 'set a good example' for other skeptics? Does a skeptic have to be a non-believer, for that matter?

Do you have to limit your friendships to skeptics in order to be a credible skeptic?

If so, if Robert had a belief like that, I would probably still be a woo.

The way I see it is this: Robert has already explained that he is hoping MamaLisa might learn to think skeptically by virtue of their friendship. Of course he would hope that; it is something very dear to his heart. And it is quite possible that without a friendship with Robert, she never would.

To me that is perfectly in keeping with the type of work Robert has been doing over the years. It is, especially, perfectly in keeping with a man who fell in love with his wife without regard for whether she was a Christian or a Hindu or a Sikh.

Here's the thing, and I hope Robert doesn't mind me saying this. He doesn't care what you believe. If he likes you, he likes you. He shares his skeptical beliefs and values as you talk with him. It is just who he is and it comes out in the way he approaches the world. He recommends skeptical books that have been meaningful to him. He is obviously upset by the charlatans and he will tell you so, even if you have just professed to belief in one of them (I know this from personal experience). He doesn't mince words or tiptoe around what he thinks. He will explain why. He just tells it like he sees it. And if you start to adopt some of this skepticism for yourself, all the better. He loves that, I think. But he has still been your friend all along.

Robert won me over to an interest in skepticism through his friendship. I really liked him as a person, I liked his attitude and his calm rationality. Above all, Robert won me over because he never made it seem like he was trying to change me. He just respectfully discussed things with me when I asked.

What he does is completely his own thing. He doesn't do what Richard Dawkins does, or even approach things in quite the same manner as James Randi, whom he holds in the highest respect. In my book, there is a place for all of them - all types of skeptics, all kinds of activism. The more, the better.

One final thing: There are going to be some times when a Stop Site is the best approach. There will be times when confrontation is needed. There will be other times, as in my case, where just being friendly may be helpful. Even as a Tarot-card reading woo, I did not need a StopExMinister web site.

Has Robert formed a friendship with MamaLisa in order to change her? You know, I bet not. I don't think that's his way. As I said, I think it can't help but be his hope, since it means so much to him, that she'll pick up some appreciation for skepticism, kind of like I did. But he is willing to reach out to us and be friendly. He genuinely likes us, go figure. He finds other things to focus on, I guess, than the things we disagree on. Maybe partly he enjoys a chance to talk about skepticism where it's needed most.

Maybe, in spite of the outrage he feels at the potential harm that can be done by psychics and mediums, he is still able to remain friendly with those of us who are kind and sincere and at least attempting to be reasonable in our approach to the world (?). Maybe he recognizes a good heart himself, when he sees one.

So, even though I have joked about being a groupie, the fact is groupie is misleading. I'm just happy to have a friend like Robert. I'm happy he was there to introduce me to skepticism in his way. He has a heart of gold.

He is genuinely interested in what people have to say. Even if you criticize him, he wants to hear what you think. If you have an opinion about something, he's going to listen, though if he disagrees, he will not hesitate to tell you.

Yeah, I think he did a great job on the StopSylvia site, and because of my background with Sylvia, that also was important to me, but that wasn't the half of it.

hi ex minister

you are missing the main point though. imo. you are not taking into account the difference between a beleiver and a practioner of woo. and there is a big difference. as i stated before it is the difference between the conned and the con artist.

i have friends that believe in astrology, 9/11 conspiracy, god, you name it. they are all good people and not stupid either. the people i and others take issue with are the practitioners, the people who put these ideas forward to vulnerable people for PROFIT.

This difference is something i would be eager to hear you address.

thanks

lxxx
 
hi ex minister

you are missing the main point though. imo. you are not taking into account the difference between a beleiver and a practioner of woo. and there is a big difference. as i stated before it is the difference between the conned and the con artist.

i have friends that believe in astrology, 9/11 conspiracy, god, you name it. they are all good people and not stupid either. the people i and others take issue with are the practitioners, the people who put these ideas forward to vulnerable people for PROFIT.

This difference is something i would be eager to hear you address.

thanks

lxxx

Hi s pepys,

I do understand your point here. In a way I of course agree. I also take issue with con artists more so than believers, and people who profit from this.

For me it is not so clearcut, though. When I first met Robert, I was still doing past life regressions for paying clients. I don't know if I ever told that to him back then, actually. But if you had called me a con artist, I would have slugged you. I was sincerely convinced that I was doing good work that was legitimate and healing.

So I was a practitioner and a woo, but I was sincere. Does that make me a con artist? In my way of thinking, a con artist is someone who is deliberately deceiving for profit, but maybe I have a narrow view of it just because of my own personal experience.

If someone is a practitioner, does that make them a con artist? Or is it their intention?

See, to me, someone who deliberately takes advantage of the grieving by posing as a medium is lower than the slime of the earth.

Someone who really believes they can contact the deceased and help grieving people heal, but is in fact deluded? Well, that's just really sad. But it's different to me.

You might have objected strenuously to what I was doing as a past life regressionist, you might have rolled your eyes at some of my weird New Age beliefs, but if you had gotten to know me like your current friends, would you have responded at all to the fact that I was, at least, sincere?

Maybe it's just me! I'm perfectly open to the possibility that I see things differently because of my own experience.

Anyway, even 911 conspiracy theorists can do damage if they are able to convince the people around them that they are right. You know? Same with people into astrology, if they manage to convince friends and family. If they are lecturing in the community center for free, they are still not doing anyone any favors. Many woo beliefs have their potential for harm, even if only in a small circle, and even if no one seems to be profiting monetarily from it.

Maybe the thing you respond to in your woo friends is not so much that they aren't profiting, but you know they really believe their crazy stuff, and you know they are otherwise intelligent, decent people? Because, again, not profiting isn't the same as not harming. Maybe eventually they will benefit from knowing you.

So we don't know MamaLisa. What if she's sincere and decent, too? When it comes to who we befriend, maybe sincerity plays a role.

That in no way excuses her actions - what she is doing, as I said, is still as potentially harmful as what Sylvia does - but it does put her in a different category as a person, and perhaps as a potential friend.

For me, the longer I have looked into all of this, the more I realize that, either way, I object. Woo believer, woo practitioner, sincere or not, it is still probably not helping anything in the long-run. But when it comes to friendships, I definitely would make a distinction between hucksters and sincere people who think they are helping. I would be the first to tell the sincere person that they could still potentially cause harm, but I still would feel much friendlier toward them than a deliberate con. I can relate to the sincere person; I can understand their life stories, what led them to believe the way they believe, and much of the time, even if they have a neighborhood psychic thing going on for money, I can still be friends with them. I used to be one. I get it. So maybe it's just different for me.
 
ExM, Thanks so much for that. And, you're right: I did not become friends with MamaLisa, nor you, nor Susan, with the intent of changing any of you. That would not be a friendship at all. I did hope to learn from all of you, and, with some luck, teach some things to you all as well. To me, shared learning is a solid part of any friendship. I'm glad in so many ways to be able to call all three of you my friends.
 
Another thought or two on my dating a Christian: I have already noted here that, without My Susan, I would most likely be dead. But here are less dramatic, but stll very tangible ways in which she has played a very important role in my skeptical accomplishments (whatever those may be): If I wasn't dating a Christian, I don't know that I would have ever even heard of Kaz. My mother rarely shared with me any of her church goings-on, knowing how I felt about church in general. So, when she was bursting at the seams with excitement about Kaz's appearance at her church, she shared the story not with me, but with Susan (who smelled a rat and shared the story with me that night). So, had I not done the purportedly "non-skeptical" thing of dating a Christian, there would probably never have been a StopKaz site, without which there probably never have been a StopSylvia site. And it was Susan's urging me to "do something about" my loathing of what Edward, vanPraagh and Browne were doing that led me to choose Browne as the focus of my second Stop site. Had I not so recklessly dated a Christian, it is probable that StopKaz, StopSylvia, and the sites evidently inspired by them (StopRobbie, StopJenny, etc) would never have been created.
 
I wonder if those who seem to be saying that being friends with a believer in woo is fine, but with someone who makes a living from woo is not would also say that dating/marrying a Christian is fine, but dating/marrying a minister is not.
 
I wonder if those who seem to be saying that being friends with a believer in woo is fine, but with someone who makes a living from woo is not would also say that dating/marrying a Christian is fine, but dating/marrying a minister is not.

what if you had a website attacking someone else for being a minister whilst married to one? would that be hypocritical?

the whole deluding/conning topic is an interesting one. i think there is a difference between different types of woo regarding whether someone is delusional or not. a minister can beleive in god without ever being in contact with him. you can do a regression on someone and beleive it is working too (ex minister) a homeopath may see results due to placebo and other factors. i dont beleive a medium can do a reading without being actively cold reading. they must be aware of the techniques they are using. is sylvia browne self deluded?

does that make what she does okay?

lxxx
 
what if you had a website attacking someone else for being a minister whilst married to one? would that be hypocritical?

first, SSB is not "attacking" Browne.

It simply points out facts about her.

So, if I had a web site which pointed out the facts about a specific minister, whilst I was married to another minister about whom those facts were not true, (say, a site about Fred Phelps whilst married to a minister who did NOT participate in rabidly homophobic behavior), then NO, it would not be hypocritical. If the only thing which the web site pointed out about Phelps was the fact that he is a minister, then it would indeed be odd, if not hypocritical, for me to be married to another minister, homophobic or not.

i dont beleive a medium can do a reading without being actively cold reading. they must be aware of the techniques they are using.

It may be hard to believe, and must take some mental gymnastics, but if a tarot reader can be cold-reading unawares (ala ChillZero), is it really that far a leap to a psychic/medium to do so?

is sylvia browne self deluded?

The truth is, we can't know for certain. personally, I don't think someone can be self-deluded for fifty years running. And, with some of her gaffes so well documented, I can't see how she could remain self-deluded without willfully being so.

does that make what she does okay?

No. But some documented cases of what she does are so horrific (telling Opal Jo Jennings' grandmother that Opal was alive and in forced prostitution on the other side of the world when in fact Opal was dead and buried near her home) that - to me at least - the delusional/knowingFraud issue is unimportant, and she should be stopped either way. If you have good evidence of MamaLisa doing something like that, I would most likely no longer call her my friend. (I assume that was where we were heading here.
 
Last edited:
No. But some documented cases of what she does are so horrific (telling Opal Jo Jennings' grandmother that Opal was alive and in forced prostitution on the other side of the world when in fact Opal was dead and buried near her home) that - to me at least - the delusional/knowingFraud issue is unimportant, and she should be stopped either way. If you have good evidence of MamaLisa doing something like that, I would most likely no longer call her my friend. (I assume that was where we were heading here.


Hello, Mr. Lancaster. For the record, I don't care who you're friends with. However, it's been shown that "MamaLisa" claims to communicate with the dead:

The testimonies on her site include one person saying she'd contacted their grandfather, so she evidently does claim to contact the dead.


Let's say that you're right, Mr. Lancaster, and "MamaLisa" doesn't make up horrible stories in the same vein as Sylvia Browne. Wouldn't it still be wrong? Even if "MamaLisa" said something as seemingly innocent as, "Your dead grandather wants me to tell you that he loves you," it'd still be wrong, in my opinion. She'd be toying with somebody's emotions and memories, and exploiting a serious matter for personal gain.

"MamaLisa" also claims to perform psychic healings, and she appears to be willing to work on cold cases for law enforcement. Once again, even if she doesn't make up horrible stories like Browne (keep in mind that we don't know whether she does or not), isn't it still wrong? Is she not exploiting highly serious matters for personal gain? That seems plenty icky to me.

By the way, what's her opinion on your skepticism?
 
Last edited:
A question, Robert. The believes in woo/profits from woo distinction raises this dilemma.

I agree that, being an adult, you have the right to be friends with whoever you like. It doesn't bother me that you are on personal terms with a psychic- but where do you draw the line on people who profit from woo? Are there any interpersonal relations you would refuse to have?

For instance, if you knew of a psychic who had done real damage, would you then refuse to be friends with them? What if Lisa crossed into Sylvia Browne territory and said something that really hurt a police case, for example?

Would you think that being friendly with someone who commits real wrongs would be crossing a line and corrupting yourself and your integrity? Would you think it out of the question to have anything personal to do with that individual, besides showing them regular politeness?

Would you refuse to be friends with a Sylvia Browne or James Van Praagh, even if she/he was a fairly pleasant person as a person? Could you ever be friends with someone like that?

I have a friend who is a conservative Catholic Republican and I wouldn't dream of refusing to associate with him on that basis. When he was against the so-called Ground Zero mosque and spouted off to me about it, I politely disagreed with him. Same with his stance on illegal immigration from Mexico and other issues. I thought he was dead wrong- but it didn't affect our friendship.

But if he were in favor of, say, the racial profiling of Mexicans and Arabs and really wanted these people's rights to be violated, I might have to rethink why I'm friendly with this guy. And, since he wants to be a policeman and then wants to go to law school and become a prosecutor, if he ever personally racially profiled minorities, ordered others to do it or was part of a system that did it, I'd almost certainly refuse to be friends with someone like that. If he ever, for example, used slurs towards Arabs/Muslims or assaulted an Arab/Muslim in something even resembling a bias crime, I'd never tolerate it.

There's a difference between being a conservative (which you are absolutely allowed to be) and being an idiot and a bad person (which you aren't allowed to be, legally or morally).

Do you feel that being into woo carries the same distinction? "You are allowed to believe in woo and/or practice it but you aren't allowed to X" ?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom