hi ex minister
you are missing the main point though. imo. you are not taking into account the difference between a beleiver and a practioner of woo. and there is a big difference. as i stated before it is the difference between the conned and the con artist.
i have friends that believe in astrology, 9/11 conspiracy, god, you name it. they are all good people and not stupid either. the people i and others take issue with are the practitioners, the people who put these ideas forward to vulnerable people for PROFIT.
This difference is something i would be eager to hear you address.
thanks
lxxx
Hi s pepys,
I do understand your point here. In a way I of course agree. I also take issue with con artists more so than believers, and people who profit from this.
For me it is not so clearcut, though. When I first met Robert, I was still doing past life regressions for paying clients. I don't know if I ever told that to him back then, actually. But if you had called me a con artist, I would have slugged you. I was sincerely convinced that I was doing good work that was legitimate and healing.
So I was a practitioner and a woo, but I was sincere. Does that make me a con artist? In my way of thinking, a con artist is someone who is
deliberately deceiving for profit, but maybe I have a narrow view of it just because of my own personal experience.
If someone is a practitioner, does that make them a con artist? Or is it their intention?
See, to me, someone who deliberately takes advantage of the grieving by posing as a medium is lower than the slime of the earth.
Someone who really believes they can contact the deceased and help grieving people heal, but is in fact deluded? Well, that's just really sad. But it's different to me.
You might have objected strenuously to what I was doing as a past life regressionist, you might have rolled your eyes at some of my weird New Age beliefs, but if you had gotten to know me like your current friends, would you have responded at all to the fact that I was, at least, sincere?
Maybe it's just me! I'm perfectly open to the possibility that I see things differently because of my own experience.
Anyway, even 911 conspiracy theorists can do damage if they are able to convince the people around them that they are right. You know? Same with people into astrology, if they manage to convince friends and family. If they are lecturing in the community center for free, they are still not doing anyone any favors. Many woo beliefs have their potential for harm, even if only in a small circle, and even if no one seems to be profiting monetarily from it.
Maybe the thing you respond to in your woo friends is not so much that they aren't profiting, but you know they really believe their crazy stuff, and you know they are otherwise intelligent, decent people? Because, again, not profiting isn't the same as not harming. Maybe eventually they will benefit from knowing you.
So we don't know MamaLisa. What if she's sincere and decent, too? When it comes to who we befriend, maybe sincerity plays a role.
That in no way excuses her actions - what she is doing, as I said, is still as potentially harmful as what Sylvia does - but it does put her in a different category as a person, and perhaps as a potential friend.
For me, the longer I have looked into all of this, the more I realize that, either way, I object. Woo believer, woo practitioner, sincere or not, it is still probably not helping anything in the long-run. But when it comes to friendships, I definitely would make a distinction between hucksters and sincere people who think they are helping. I would be the first to tell the sincere person that they could still potentially cause harm, but I still would feel much friendlier toward them than a deliberate con. I can relate to the sincere person; I can understand their life stories, what led them to believe the way they believe, and much of the time, even if they have a neighborhood psychic thing going on for money, I can still be friends with them. I used to
be one. I get it. So maybe it's just different for me.