s_pepys
Muse
- Joined
- May 31, 2010
- Messages
- 761
first, SSB is not "attacking" Browne.
It simply points out facts about her.
So, if I had a web site which pointed out the facts about a specific minister, whilst I was married to another minister about whom those facts were not true, (say, a site about Fred Phelps whilst married to a minister who did NOT participate in rabidly homophobic behavior), then NO, it would not be hypocritical. If the only thing which the web site pointed out about Phelps was the fact that he is a minister, then it would indeed be odd, if not hypocritical, for me to be married to another minister, homophobic or not.
It may be hard to believe, and must take some mental gymnastics, but if a tarot reader can be cold-reading unawares (ala ChillZero), is it really that far a leap to a psychic/medium to do so?
The truth is, we can't know for certain. personally, I don't think someone can be self-deluded for fifty years running. And, with some of her gaffes so well documented, I can't see how she could remain self-deluded without willfully being so.
No. But some documented cases of what she does are so horrific (telling Opal Jo Jennings' grandmother that Opal was alive and in forced prostitution on the other side of the world when in fact Opal was dead and buried near her home) that - to me at least - the delusional/knowingFraud issue is unimportant, and she should be stopped either way. If you have good evidence of MamaLisa doing something like that, I would most likely no longer call her my friend. (I assume that was where we were heading here.
what is true about sylvia browne that is not true about mamalisa phillips?
as far as tarot is concerned, it is the cards that are doing the cold reading as much as the reader so it isnt comparible to true cold reading imo.
its a pretty safe bet that she knows what shes doing, same applies to mamalisa too.
people above have echoed my view on your last statement. mamalisa is a healer, medium, psychic, demon hunter, police investigator, secretary and who knows what else. according to her own words (apart from secretary).
if she has "helped" police investigations she must of said something to them even if they didnt beleive a word. a good deal of the time when a psychic says they have helped the police the police with their investigations it usually means they have called the police with a prediction and generally are ignored or it comes to nothing and its also likely to be a serious crime, especially murder or missing persons.
healing people is another dangerous one but i know you are aware of this as sylvias speciality is medical diagnosis.
i fail to see any difference between the two.
lxxx
Last edited: