Invited on another Psychic's Show

first, SSB is not "attacking" Browne.

It simply points out facts about her.

So, if I had a web site which pointed out the facts about a specific minister, whilst I was married to another minister about whom those facts were not true, (say, a site about Fred Phelps whilst married to a minister who did NOT participate in rabidly homophobic behavior), then NO, it would not be hypocritical. If the only thing which the web site pointed out about Phelps was the fact that he is a minister, then it would indeed be odd, if not hypocritical, for me to be married to another minister, homophobic or not.



It may be hard to believe, and must take some mental gymnastics, but if a tarot reader can be cold-reading unawares (ala ChillZero), is it really that far a leap to a psychic/medium to do so?



The truth is, we can't know for certain. personally, I don't think someone can be self-deluded for fifty years running. And, with some of her gaffes so well documented, I can't see how she could remain self-deluded without willfully being so.


No. But some documented cases of what she does are so horrific (telling Opal Jo Jennings' grandmother that Opal was alive and in forced prostitution on the other side of the world when in fact Opal was dead and buried near her home) that - to me at least - the delusional/knowingFraud issue is unimportant, and she should be stopped either way. If you have good evidence of MamaLisa doing something like that, I would most likely no longer call her my friend. (I assume that was where we were heading here.

what is true about sylvia browne that is not true about mamalisa phillips?

as far as tarot is concerned, it is the cards that are doing the cold reading as much as the reader so it isnt comparible to true cold reading imo.

its a pretty safe bet that she knows what shes doing, same applies to mamalisa too.

people above have echoed my view on your last statement. mamalisa is a healer, medium, psychic, demon hunter, police investigator, secretary and who knows what else. according to her own words (apart from secretary).

if she has "helped" police investigations she must of said something to them even if they didnt beleive a word. a good deal of the time when a psychic says they have helped the police the police with their investigations it usually means they have called the police with a prediction and generally are ignored or it comes to nothing and its also likely to be a serious crime, especially murder or missing persons.

healing people is another dangerous one but i know you are aware of this as sylvias speciality is medical diagnosis.

i fail to see any difference between the two.

lxxx
 
Last edited:
what is true about sylvia browne that is not true about mamalisa phillips?

There are 90+ articles on SSB full of specific things Sylvia Browne has done, none of which MamaLisa has done, to my knowledge. The Opal Jo Jennings reading. The Shawn Hornbeck reading. Holly Krewson, et al... The Sago Mining Disaster... contradicting herself in her books time and again. Founding a church which sold fake "diamond" jewelry... I could go on and on.

as far as tarot is concerned, it is the cards that are doing the cold reading as much as the reader so it isnt comparible to true cold reading imo.

Cold reading is used in ALL "fortune-telling", whether via tarot cards, tea leaves, runes, I ching, or psychic mediumism.

its a pretty safe bet that she knows what shes doing, same applies to mamalisa too.

Perhaps MamaLisa does, but I don't know that, and neither do you. I don't think she does, and that is based on several conversations I've had with her (and, perhaps some wishful thinking on my part, I'll admit).

people above have echoed my view on your last statement. mamalisa is a healer, medium, psychic, demon hunter, police investigator, secretary and who knows what else. according to her own words (apart from secretary).

if she has "helped" police investigations she must of said something to them even if they didnt beleive a word. a good deal of the time when a psychic says they have helped the police the police with their investigations it usually means they have called the police with a prediction and generally are ignored or it comes to nothing and its also likely to be a serious crime, especially murder or missing persons.

Yes, but I have no examples of her doing such things to research. Do you?

healing people is another dangerous one but i know you are aware of this as sylvias speciality is medical diagnosis.

i fail to see any difference between the two.

lxxx

You also fail to show that they are the same.
 
Yes, but I have no examples of her doing such things to research. Do you?


That's the whole point of doing research. Finding examples of her doing such things. You're not willing to do the research where it comes to MamaLisa. That's fine. I feel, in my own humble opinion, it'd do you better just by simply admitting, "I'm not willing to do the research on MamaLisa."




You also fail to show that they are the same.


It seems like you're using Browne's fame as the only yardstick when it comes to them being "the same." If MamaLisa is as famous as Browne, then maybe something should be done it what it seems you're saying.

MamaLisa openly and upon multiple websites advertises her services as Demon Hunter, psychic, police investigator/helper, Medium, and healer; she charges (what did I read...?) like $120 per hour for a telephone reading. Nowhere did I see any disclaimer that it was for amusement purposes only. Therefore, I can make a reasonable conclusion and say that she's putting forth her services as real and true and charging quite a bit of money for it.

Delusional or deliberately manipulative, it doesn't matter at this point.
 
That's the whole point of doing research. Finding examples of her doing such things. You're not willing to do the research where it comes to MamaLisa. That's fine. I feel, in my own humble opinion, it'd do you better just by simply admitting, "I'm not willing to do the research on MamaLisa."

aT THIS POINT, IT'S NOT A MATTER OF WHETHER OR NOT i AM WILLING, oops - so much as it is a matter of the evidence about MamaLisa being far more difficult to obtain (and thus research) than the evidence for Browne is (and was). Is this difficult for others to comprehend, or am I just not being clear about it?

It seems like you're using Browne's fame as the only yardstick when it comes to them being "the same." If MamaLisa is as famous as Browne, then maybe something should be done it what it seems you're saying.

Evidently, I'm not being clear about it. I will try one more time, this time shouting:

TO RESEARCH BROWNE'S CLAIMS, PREDICTIONS AND READINGS, I HAD HER DOZENS OF BOOKS (WRITTEN OVER MANY YEARS), DOZENS OF HOURS OF MONTEL APPEARANCES (INCLUDING WEEKLY CURRENT ONES AND SEVERAL YEARS' WORTH OF TRANSCRIPTS ON LEXIS NEXUS), SEVERAL YEARS OF HER "ANNUAL PREDICTION" LISTS ON HER SITE, TRANSCRIPTS OF HER APPEARANCES ON LARRY KING LIVE, AUDIO RECORDINGS OF HER APPEARANCES ON GEORGE NOORY'S RADIO SHOW, WEB-BASED COPIES OF MANY NEWSPAPER ARTICLES ABOUT HER, AND MANY SKEPTICAL ARTICLES (SUCH AS RAHDI'S AND JOE NICKEL'S) TO USE AS STARTING POINTS.

TO RESEARCH MAMALISA, I HAVE ALMOST NOTHING. I CAN LISTEN TO THE LAST SEVERAL WEEKS' WORTH OF HER SHOWS WHICH, IF THE ONES I'VE HEARD SO FAR ARE ANY INDICATION, WILL HAVE HER NSWERING UNIDENTIFIED CALLERS' UNRESEARCHABLE QUESTIONS ON THEIR PERSONAL LIVES.


Can you see the difference in coming up with meaty/meaningful articles about the two of them?

Or do I need to play with font size and color too?

MamaLisa openly and upon multiple websites advertises her services as Demon Hunter, psychic, police investigator/helper, Medium, and healer; she charges (what did I read...?) like $120 per hour for a telephone reading. Nowhere did I see any disclaimer that it was for amusement purposes only. Therefore, I can make a reasonable conclusion and say that she's putting forth her services as real and true and charging quite a bit of money for it.

Delusional or deliberately manipulative, it doesn't matter at this point.

Then you are more than welcome to do the research and create the Stop Site.
 
aT THIS POINT, IT'S NOT A MATTER OF WHETHER OR NOT i AM WILLING, oops - so much as it is a matter of the evidence about MamaLisa being far more difficult to obtain (and thus research) than the evidence for Browne is (and was). Is this difficult for others to comprehend, or am I just not being clear about it?

Did you not say that you were considering my suggestion to simply ask her about her police cases? I'd say that with a friendship with her you're uniquely well-placed to get information about her straight from the horse's proverbial.
 
Did you not say that you were considering my suggestion to simply ask her about her police cases? I'd say that with a friendship with her you're uniquely well-placed to get information about her straight from the horse's proverbial.

Well, yes and no. As I have said elsewhere (maybe in this thread), MamaLisa is now "out of touch", and I don't expect to be able to speak with her again for another month or two.

I am considering some of the suggestions you and others have made regarding questions I might want to ask her, and working out ways of asking them most likely to elicit cooperation.
 
What if you told her up front you were considering expanding your "Stop" sites to make them more encompasing...as in including others that claim psychic ability, which yes would include her?
 
Well, yes and no. As I have said elsewhere (maybe in this thread), MamaLisa is now "out of touch", and I don't expect to be able to speak with her again for another month or two.

I am considering some of the suggestions you and others have made regarding questions I might want to ask her, and working out ways of asking them most likely to elicit cooperation.

I appreciate this. My post was just in response to your last shouting post where you were saying that you could not gain any information about MamaLisa beyond listening to her last few shows, rather than saying that you could not gain any information about MamaLisa at present. I hope you can appreciate that that's an important distinction.
 
Oh, that final sentence.... Well, she knows you are a skeptic and the "Stop" sites is what you do so it should not come as a shock. I'd just bring it up in conversation and see how it goes.
 
Yes, the final sentence after all the other sentences. As for how and when I broach these subjects with MamaLisa, I'll just have to play it by ear. I chatted this morning with a mutual online friend who said that she thinks it will be two months before Lisa comes bagk, if at all. I'm not sure what all is going on in her life which has caused this sabbatical from the paranormal, but if it is for some of the personal reasons she and I have discussed, I have no intention of hitting her up with this stuff right upon her return.
 
No no, I say hit her up the moment she returns...shine a desk lamp at her for good measure (ala the 30s/40s police movies) :)

Kidding aside, you have a knack (unlike The Knack) for this kind of stuff and are far more diplomatic then I. I'm sure you'll broach the subject at the best time, and in the best way.
 
There are 90+ articles on SSB full of specific things Sylvia Browne has done, none of which MamaLisa has done, to my knowledge. The Opal Jo Jennings reading. The Shawn Hornbeck reading. Holly Krewson, et al... The Sago Mining Disaster... contradicting herself in her books time and again. Founding a church which sold fake "diamond" jewelry... I could go on and on.
here is the list of testimonials on her site. there is plenty more on there too. this is from a quick glance. hopefully she just made them up or got her friends to "testify".





I just sat in a gallery meeting with Mama Lisa at Dragon Con and I was impressed. Without
any prior information from me, she identified the spirit of my niece, down to the fact that she
was bald. She made comments about my career transition that were on target. I would
attend another session with her.

Rosie 9/2010


These emails are from a very dear soul, Joel, whom I had the opportunity to meet earlier in
2010. Here is his photo as well:









Dearest Lisa,
Rarely do I allow someone to use my name in a testimonial. I will make an exception for you
because you are the real deal. You have my endorsement not only because of your unique
talents but also because of the way you use your talents to give hope and help unselfishly to
others. The other reason I give you permission to use our messages is because of the love I
felt flow through me when we held hands and talked and when we hugged, I could feel the
spirit of the Family of Light as you call it. Keep spreading the love and the hope to others.
Thanks for helping me discover my destiny.
Fondly,
Joel


Hi Lisa,
I am doing great. Talking with you for 20 minutes brought the Love of God back into my life
in a strong way. Its is amazing what you are able to see in people. I have finished my family
tree, my destiny, and have the family emailing each other. They were unaware of each other
for the longest time and I have brought closeness to the family in the name of Love. The tree
brought a first cousin and her estranged husband back together and has rekindled their love
of each other. Another cousin has picked up the ball and is chairwoman of bringing together
250 people for a family reunion in August 2011. Your inspiration of letting me know angels
are looking after me has renewed my faith and I have been going back to Temple and am
closer to DAD when I go to the cemetery to talk to him. I have begun mediation and Yoga in
hopes of expanding my mind to other possibilities that my eyes do not see You have become
a pivotal person in my life. Thank you.
Love,
Joel


"After 5 years of having mysterious dreams and visions of my grandfather, massive panic
attacks and heartache from family trouble, my uncle suggested I contact you. After speaking
with you, I feel amazing! You knew about things that I had shared with no one, not even my
closest friends. You gave me help with problems I had, not to mention sound advice. I was
especially impressed that you were able to contact my grandfather! I used to cry for him
constantly and wish for him, and now I walk with my head held high knowing that he is walking
with me. Thank you, Mama Lisa, for being one of God's beautiful instruments and changing
my life! I forever owe you a massive debt of gratitude. "

D, TN


"I have seen Lisa in action more than once, and can honestly say she is no joke. Her
dedication and ability to remove negative energy is unsurpassed. Honestly folks if you have
issues from the spirit realm of any type, Mama Lisa is your girl."

- MacKay, GA

"I was very frightened by the supernatural - desperate, even - but you went to great lengths
to help me, coming the very night I called. You came from across town and through a
thunderstorm. It was a profound relief to be believed and assisted on this level. Your visit was
a life-changing experience, and I am forever grateful."

- Mary, GA

"Lisa and Jeremy are very talented individuals. I had a very nasty spirit in my home, and they
came as soon as I called. They were very professional and quick. They were very concerned
about me and took the time to explain everything they were doing and even involved me in
the process. Mama Lisa is a very dear friend and I would trust her anytime to handle this type
of thing in the future."

- Stephanie, GA

"Lisa and her Crew are unbelievable. I was having some problems in my house with negative
entities and she her crew were able to help me out. They were very informative and explained
the process as they were going. They were very kind to me and my family. She was even
able to help my son with his gift. I would never hesitate to call her again if the need arose.
Thank you!!!"

- Julie, GA


"The PD Crew changed our lives for the positive in ways they don't even realize!"

-Ande, GA





lxxx
 
Last edited:
Cold reading is used in ALL "fortune-telling", whether via tarot cards, tea leaves, runes, I ching, or psychic mediumism.


robert

you are misrepresenting what i said. im not saying it isnt cold reading. what i said was that the cards are the important factor in the reading when using tarot cards. the reader can be totally convinced that it is the cards that are giving information and therefore be self deluded. with a pro (or semi pro) psychic they have to knowingly deceive the person who comes to them.

thay are the cards. thats what i was saying.

lxxx
 
Perhaps MamaLisa does, but I don't know that, and neither do you. I don't think she does, and that is based on several conversations I've had with her (and, perhaps some wishful thinking on my part, I'll admit).



perhaps yes. and perhaps sylvia is too? its still a pretty safe bet that they arent. the highlighted part is very honest, to your credit. it is very telling also. even a well known skeptic can be taken in by a con artist.

lxxx
 
Yes, but I have no examples of her doing such things to research. Do you?


not yet. but i may do some digging. i think you are in a better position to be doing that. in the meantime see above testimonials or visit her website:

http://mamalisacares.com/testimonials.html

You also fail to show that they are the same.


i didnt think i would need to "show" they are the same. isnt it obvious? you too, sir, have failed to show any differences between the two.


lxxx
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom