Invited on another Psychic's Show

if i where to come on this forum and state i was "dear friends" with sylvia browne, you would all tear me a new one and rightly so.

If you came on here and said that you were "dear friends" with Sylvia Browne, despite not believing that she has any real psychic powers and being generally skeptical of psychic claims in general, I'd expect you to get a pretty warm reception... except from the childish "us-versus-them" posters. Which is my point.
 
just a guy with a couple of websites dedicated to stopping certain "evil" psychics whilst being "dear friends" with others.

why not start a STOPMAMALISA.com site? would you support that?

lxxx
 
If you came on here and said that you were "dear friends" with Sylvia Browne, despite not believing that she has any real psychic powers and being generally skeptical of psychic claims in general, I'd expect you to get a pretty warm reception... except from the childish "us-versus-them" posters. Which is my point.


so do you not think it is an us versus them scenario? is there a middle ground?

lxxx
 
so do you not think it is an us versus them scenario? is there a middle ground?

lxxx

Well, sure. The middle ground is to talk to the poster about why what Sylvia is doing is wrong, and also about how to be skeptical regarding paranormal claims. Again, it's a way of thinking, not some sort of political party or religious group.
 
Well, sure. The middle ground is to talk to the poster about why what Sylvia is doing is wrong, and also about how to be skeptical regarding paranormal claims. Again, it's a way of thinking, not some sort of political party or religious group.

you would have to tell them that what sylvia is doing is wrong so thereffore what they are doing is wrong also. If i had a "dear friend" who was commiting crimes against vulnerable people. conning them of there money i would have to be honest with them and say that i couldnt in all consciousness continue with our relationship until they addressed their behaviour.

i wouldntt slowly try to talk them round to eventually deciding that it is actually wrong to steal from vulnerable people.

you are forgetting that this "dear friend" is a medium too.


Also i think that they would view the relationship as trying to convert you to there way of thinking too.

so you are both trying to slowly, slyly convert each other. that to me is the religious political thinking you mentioned.

lxxx
 
Ok.

Something I still don't understand:

How does being friends with "someone on the other side of the fence" weaken one's credibility? Has anyone actually given any sort of evidence to this? Other than their own opinion, that is?

I am mainly interested in Reno's response, but would like to read anyone's.

I would also like to know, Reno, how you would go about teaching critical thinking to a person who strongly believes in "woo."

I am not being antagonistic here, nor defending my husband. I see what he's doing and the results. I'm having a difficult time coming up with another method that would bring the same or better results.
 
you would have to tell them that what sylvia is doing is wrong so thereffore what they are doing is wrong also. If i had a "dear friend" who was commiting crimes against vulnerable people. conning them of there money i would have to be honest with them and say that i couldnt in all consciousness continue with our relationship until they addressed their behaviour.
snip

In this country (US), being a "medium" is, unfortunately, not a crime. Do you know MamaLisa personally? Do you know for fact that she does not believe she has psychic powers? You are assuming she is a con-artist. Having lived in the world of "woo" as long as I did, I know most of the small potatoes truly believe they have a gift.

Sylvia was an easy target. (Sorry, Babe.) There was a lot out there, publicly, on her. Reaching the smaller targets and changing their way of thinking requires more consideration, more patience, more kindness. Taking your tac would only drive a "woo" further away and do nothing to promote critical thinking.

Yeah, I know. Anecdotal. I wish someone would do a study. I can only give my opinion, based on 47 years of living in the world of "woo."
 
this "dear friend" thing and the whole para radio slot smacks of hypocrisy to me though

Forget the "dear friend" thing for thme moment. How does having a show on a paranormal network - where I promote skepticism - "smack of hypocrisy"?

and it does take away the credibility of the stop sylvia site.

So now the credibility of SSB is gone? All of the evidence and facts presented there are now meaningless because I am friends with a psychic and have a skeptical show on a paranormal station?

you cant denounce one psychic as abhorrent but be dear friends with another purely based on the amount of success each has had.

Who says that's what I am "purely basing" my decision on?

i would wager that this "dear friend" would love to be in sylvia brownes shoes.

And you are "purely basing" my "lost credibility" on this wager/assumption?

they are both con artists who prey on the vulnerable just one of them has been more successful at it, so far.

You seem to be making yet another assumption here - that Lisa is knowingly fraudulent.

im put in mind of the reaction of other psychics to the shawn hornbeck affair.

Please remind me, because I remember NO reaction from other psychics. To what are you referring?

i cant read this thread and continue supporting stopsylvia site anymore.

And you seem to be basing this decision on several unwarranted (in my opinion) assumptions, and your being "put in mind" of something I don't recall even happening (and it is something I think I would know about and remember if it had happened)

you cant pick and choose who you discredit depending on personal
relationships.

Again, you seem to be assuming you know something which you do not.

sorry robert. i just feel slightly dissappointed.

lxxx

Well, thank you for taking the time to tell me.
 
Man, you at least have to admire the cojones on folks like Brat and Reno who admire your work so much that they get the right to tell you with whom you can be friends.

Lot of talk about RSL's "dear friend" comment here. When I read it, I presumed it was mere hyperbole, but I suppose when you get to be a public figure like RSL you have to choose your words carefully.

It does bug me, though, that disagreement with RSL's methods leads to accusations that he's sympathetic to--or outright complicit in--promotion of the paranormal. I've never seen RSL be a prick to anyone, but I've also never seen him break from the basic principle that any paranormal claim is invalid unless subjected to objective testing. "I'm friends with a purported psychic" just isn't the same thing. Conflation of the two is a mistake I expect to see from woos.
 
Is RSLancastr's goal to "represent skeptics," or is it to promote critical thinking?

And if the goal is to promote critical thinking, shouldn't he be doing it where critical thinking is most needed? Why care about who he befriends if the goal is accomplished? Unless, it's not the goal you care about to begin with. Since skeptics think differently about a broad range of topics, how can one man represent all skeptics?

If Robert is indeed a "public figure" as many of you seem to think of him, isn't he a rather minor one, and then only in a certain circle (someone didn't like it when I used the word "community") of like-minded people?

What would you do to rid the world of those who take advantage of those who do not think critically? Robert is trying to make the pool of non-critical-thinkers a bit smaller. You are welcome to stand up and do what you think should be done, and in the way you think it should be done. Instead of citicizing others, get off your butts and make a difference in the world. Don't look to or wait for someone else to do it for you.
 
I'll chime in and state that I agree with Reno and Brattus although Reno framed his post in a kinder way. There are other people who feel as we do but hesitate to post in this thread due to the likelihood of an "RSL groupie attack".

I wasn't going to respond, but since this isn't the first time I've been refered to as a "groupie", even if not named specifically, because I support Robert's style of skepticism.

It is interesting how that label of groupie gets tossed out, and causes me to feel an undercurrent of something that lies beneath the lable. It is like, 'Uh-Oh, if I stand up for Robert, they will jump on me and call me something silly like groupie!'. And here I thought that term went out in the 60's! It is a subtle way of trying to manipulate someone to be silent, and to not engage.

Uhmm . . . keeping silent was never my thing. See, I may not agree with every decision Robert makes. And, I have criticized him about certain things when we have spoken. Some things I would do and chose differently. But I have never questioned his integrity, nor have I ever felt the significant work he has done promoting skepticism is anything short of commendable.

As far as thinking less of someone because they are Christian, or because they are a believer, and then removing them from our lives, and forbid a friendship is just silly. It also makes for a far more restricted and less full life.
 
But responding to post like this is a complete waste of time anyway because it is either RSL way or troll. No grey areas at all.
I call a little grey.

As for his style of communicating with kindness, I ask you: If someone invited you into their home, would you go hoping to start a fight? My momma taught me better, and I'll wager yours did, too. This station is their home. Robert is the intelligent, respectful guest at the party who has a differing point of view that may be interesting.
I like that metaphor.
Back in 2002, I posted in this forum about the fact that I was dating a woman, and had discovered, on one of our first dates, that she fully believed in the "abilities" of John Edward, and that, on my first visit to her home, I had found a book by Sylvia Browne. I said that I had been saddened by this, but intended to keep datimg the woman, as I felt quite a connection to her.

Some in that thread said things like "I could never date someone wo was that far gone!" and some went as far as to urge me to "dump her". Perhaps some said (or at least thought) that my credibility as a skeptic was on the line.

That woman, of course, was My Susan, who is now known here as my Better Half. She now no longer believes in Edward's or Browne's "abilities", and is my (and my sites') greatest supporter. In fact, it is quite possible that, wsithout her urging, neither StopKaz nor StopSylvia would have ever been created. And, as most here know, without her, I would most likely have died from my stroke.

I know that a relationship with a believer in woo may seem miles different from a relationship with someone who makes a living from woo.

But the point is that if I had worried back in 2002 what the people in this forum thought of my choice of friends, I would have missed out on what turned out to be the love of my life, StopKaz and StopSylvia might never have come to be, and I might be pushing up daisies right now.

You wouldn't be pushing up daisies -- it would be worse -- you would be warehoused with damaged people. Susan singlehandedly saved you. I rarely use the word heroic, but she kept a kind of blog on this site and her single-minded heroic effort to get you more than your lousy insurance wanted to offer is partly what saved you coupled with her own motivation for you to work hard. When you say Susan saved you your are speaking the truth.

My mom has done the same for my dad. It's a rare thing.
 
I wasn't going to respond, but since this isn't the first time I've been refered to as a "groupie", even if not named specifically, because I support Robert's style of skepticism.

It is interesting how that label of groupie gets tossed out, and causes me to feel an undercurrent of something that lies beneath the lable. It is like, 'Uh-Oh, if I stand up for Robert, they will jump on me and call me something silly like groupie!'. And here I thought that term went out in the 60's! It is a subtle way of trying to manipulate someone to be silent, and to not engage.

Uhmm . . . keeping silent was never my thing. See, I may not agree with every decision Robert makes. And, I have criticized him about certain things when we have spoken. Some things I would do and chose differently. But I have never questioned his integrity, nor have I ever felt the significant work he has done promoting skepticism is anything short of commendable.

As far as thinking less of someone because they are Christian, or because they are a believer, and then removing them from our lives, and forbid a friendship is just silly. It also makes for a far more restricted and less full life.

I thought I was the only one, besides perhaps Beeg Seestor, who called themselves an RSL groupie. I know he has some acolytes, too. He has an awful lot of friends, however.
 
just a guy with a couple of websites dedicated to stopping certain "evil" psychics
I have only one web site dedicated to sropping a psychic - www.stopsylvia.com. Kaz was not a psycjic.
I have sites planned for John Edward and JVP, and for two faith healers (Popoff and Hinn) and Trudeau and but they have yet to get off the ground.

whilst being "dear friends" with others.

Again, only one: MamaLisa.




why not start a STOPMAMALISA.com site? would you support that?

lxxx

Support it? That would depend on how it was written, and the evidence it presented. Create it myself? No. I have too much unstarted and unfinished web sites already. Plus, I doubt there is enough evidence about her out there from which to create a site. I didn't choose Browne for a target just because she is famous/successful, although that played into it (see the site's FAQ page), but primarily because there was a wealth of her output (books, videos, weekly Montel appearances and more) to sift through for material from which articles could be produced. MamaLisa has only a weekly radio show (that I know of). Also. Browne's material was full of incredibly offensive stuff (telling parents of missing children that their child was alive or dead, etc.) The one psychic reading I had heard MamaLisa give was when she took a call from a woman who wanted to know if a party she was planning would go well.
 
You wouldn't be pushing up daisies -- it would be worse -- you would be warehoused with damaged people. Susan singlehandedly saved you. I rarely use the word heroic, but she kept a kind of blog on this site and her single-minded heroic effort to get you more than your lousy insurance wanted to offer is partly what saved you coupled with her own motivation for you to work hard. When you say Susan saved you your are speaking the truth.

My mom has done the same for my dad. It's a rare thing.

At the risk of being labeled an RSL's Better Half's groupie, I must beg to disagree. Were it not for her quick thinking and her insisting on calling 911 when I had my stroke, I would likely have died from it (the docs were surprised it didn't kill me) or, at the least, I would have suffered far more brain damage than I did. And, as I have said many times: Without My Susan, I would probably be dead. But, without her, my life would not be worth living. true in many, many ways.
 
I wasn't going to respond, but since this isn't the first time I've been refered to as a "groupie", even if not named specifically, because I support Robert's style of skepticism.

It is interesting how that label of groupie gets tossed out, and causes me to feel an undercurrent of something that lies beneath the lable. It is like, 'Uh-Oh, if I stand up for Robert, they will jump on me and call me something silly like groupie!'. And here I thought that term went out in the 60's! It is a subtle way of trying to manipulate someone to be silent, and to not engage.

Uhmm . . . keeping silent was never my thing. See, I may not agree with every decision Robert makes. And, I have criticized him about certain things when we have spoken. Some things I would do and chose differently. But I have never questioned his integrity, nor have I ever felt the significant work he has done promoting skepticism is anything short of commendable.

As far as thinking less of someone because they are Christian, or because they are a believer, and then removing them from our lives, and forbid a friendship is just silly. It also makes for a far more restricted and less full life.

Julia, you are 100% right about the "groupie" thing. It is a rotten way to make people hesitant to express support of me, for fear of being so derisively and dismissively labeled. Good call!
 
And, to toot my own horn, I will say the following: today, in the para-x chat room, one of the chatters told me that she wouldn't miss my show, because she has learned so much from it. When I asked what she had learned, she said that first, she had learned about Sylvia, whom she had believed in. She said that she had learned from THAT that she would more closely examine claims like that before she buys into them. From that, and other things I am hearing over there, it seems that pedrhaps, while I am losing credibility with some here, I am gaining it with some there.

And, while it does bother me that I'm losing some respect here, the people THERE are the ones it is more important that I reach, i think.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom