Invited on another Psychic's Show

Robert, you think maybe the lesser psychics are all too happy to become dear friends with someone who's been dismantling the career of their chief competitor? They may hope befriending you will help shield them from becoming one of your next victims.
 
Privately (well not now that I've posted it!) I tend to agree with Brattus and Zeno but it's really none of my business who you are friends with and I have plenty of friends who have different religious, political, woo or sporting affiliations.

I guess what some of us might be struggling with is that those friendships are usually based around years of association encompassing all sorts of other things we do have in common, agree on etc - indeed the 'conflict' may have only come to light many years in when the friendship was already on a firm footing.

I guess it might be a question of definition here as I struggle with the concept of someone becoming not just a friend but a 'dear friend' after a couple of telephone conversations (however long) - indeed, I'd suggest you barely know them. I certainly wouldn't describe such a relationship as anything other than 'an aquaintance'. Sure you can be 'friendly' with them, find them surprisingly nice despite their lies / delusions (after all, Hitler was apparently extremely charming - c'mon, about time this thread was 'Godwinned' :D) but describe them as a 'friend' let alone a 'dear friend'? - not in my world.... Perhaps it's my British reserve but you seem to give away your friendship very cheaply (which I acknowledge may be far more to your credit than mine;)) - must be an American thing - you're all over-emotional nuts anyway;)...as opposed to us emotionally crippled Brits.

Anyway, not sure what I've added to this thread but I respect the work you do / have done, strongly suspect you're a much nicer person than me but struggle to square the phrase 'dear friend' with someone with whom your only connection is a couple of telephone conversations around the fact that they stand for everything you're pretty much against (at least in the context of your connection with them).
 
But what about his wife? You're asking Robert to take sides on a fundamental level and while I agree with a lot of what Reno says (I don't see how I personally could become friends with a con-artist or deluded mental case), the reality isn't as neat and ordered as all that.

Robert's wife, if I recall, is a Christian. Is he supposed to dump her because of her (in your eyes) deluded beliefs, because he represents the skeptics community now and is under a microscope?

My family is full of religious whackos, and yet I love them. Granted, I'm not a public voice for atheism or rational thinking, but I've managed to find common ground with them and we get along fine, with copious amounts of compartmentalizing (we don't discuss religion, witches or politics).

I believe a person CAN be good friends (or even love) a person with fundamentally different beliefs. It just takes more work, that's all.

I don’t think Robert has to dump anyone he counts a dear friend, or a wife, despite their delusions or beliefs. I do, however, think that Robert should consider his position before deciding to become dear friends with a professional psychic and then announcing it to the world.

As I said above, Reno, I knew when I mentioned my friendship with MamaLisa that it would raise some eyebrows. If there are some who believe that my having done so robs me of whatever credibility I had built up, I guess that I will just have to live with that. I think that anyone who weighs what I have said and done over the years - including my friendship with MamaLisa - and cpncludes that I have lost my credibility - is welcome to their opinion.

If I said you had lost all credibility, I think that would have been an exaggeration. But it does harm your credibility being dear friends with a professional psychic Robert, whether you agree or not. On this site, you are pretty much preaching to the choir. We all know you and we know what your intentions are regarding skepticism. You yourself have said, as has your Susan, that you must reach a wider audience. How do you think people outwith this site and circle will view you as a voice of balance and reason when you say your dear friend is a professional psychic? I fear they will think, ok, let’s have a look at his Stop sites, but he’s best friends with a con-artist, so let’s look at it with a pinch of salt. Like I said, it’s a knock to your credibility. Maybe not from the majority of people who know you, but we’re already on your team. What about those who aren’t yet decided?

Back in 2002, I posted in this forum about the fact that I was dating a woman, and had discovered, on one of our first dates, that she fully believed in the "abilities" of John Edward, and that, on my first visit to her home, I had found a book by Sylvia Browne. I said that I had been saddened by this, but intended to keep datimg the woman, as I felt quite a connection to her.

Some in that thread said things like "I could never date someone wo was that far gone!" and some went as far as to urge me to "dump her". Perhaps some said (or at least thought) that my credibility as a skeptic was on the line.

That woman, of course, was My Susan, who is now known here as my Better Half. She now no longer believes in Edward's or Browne's "abilities", and is my (and my sites') greatest supporter. In fact, it is quite possible that, wsithout her urging, neither StopKaz nor StopSylvia would have ever been created. And, as most here know, without her, I would most likely have died from my stroke.

It wouldn’t be appropriate for anyone to comment on your relationship with your wife

I know that a relationship with a believer in woo may seem miles different from a relationship with someone who makes a living from woo.

It is.

But the point is that if I had worried back in 2002 what the people in this forum thought of my choice of friends, I would have missed out on what turned out to be the love of my life, StopKaz and StopSylvia might never have come to be, and I might be pushing up daisies right now.

Decline to comment

I also, back in 2001, was scorned by many here for having struck up friendships with some of the believers over at the now-defunct "Friends of John Edward" forum, especially with Pam Blizzard, the woman who founded and ran that forum. Had I paid attention to those here who urged me to abandon those friendships, I would have missed out on much there, too. One friend - yes, a dear friend I made there was a woman named Julia, whose friendship saw me through some very dark personal times, including my divorce from my first wife. And it was, in part, her urging and advice which helped me to establish my relationship with Susan. Julia, who no longer believes in psychics, and now posts here as wasapi, is a friend who I dearly love to this day.

It doesn’t matter a bean if you are friends, dear friends, or bosom buddies with believers in whatever brand of nonsense they choose. We’re not talking about your relationship with believers. We’re talking about your relationship with a professional con-artist, practicing her craft and taking money for it in the very field that you’re meant to be STOPping.

I think it safe to say that my friendships with Julia, Pam Blizzard, and others I met at Friends of John Edward were what allowed me to have the less-confrontational approach on my StopKaz and StopSylvia sites - an approach which, I will add, some here scorned, saying that I should be more strident in what I said about them and their followers. Had I taken the harsher approach some here suggested, I don't think those sites would have acheived...whatever they had acheived. Nor would I have been likely to have been given a voice on an "all-paranormal" radio network, where I will acheive... something.

So perhaps you will better understand why I have no intention of renouncing my friendship with MamaLisa. I think that my friendship with her - and my nascent friendships with other hosts, owners and chatters there - are healthy, and help me in "building the bridge" I hope to build between skeptics and believers.

Your friendship with her is not the same as your friendship with other hosts owners and chatters – unless any of them are also practicing professional charlatans.

It may mystify - or even offend some here, but my friendships on that side of the bridge are as important to me as are those on this side.

Ands, in a very real sense, for someone here who is a "fan" of my skeptical endeavors to urge me to renounce my friendship with MamaLisa, is to say "I love what you have accomplished, now change the way you accomplish it."

I know you’re not quoting me here because I have never asked you to change the way you have accomplished what you already have. Actually, it’s you that is making changes now: you’ve become dear friends with the very thing we are all trying, in our own way, to stop. That’s a change.

I think that my track record - as a Skeptic AND as a chooser-of-friends, speaks for itself.

I think that up until now, your record as a chooser-of-friends spoke nothing as it did not relate to your credibility.

I just do not understand this paragraph. But I think the reason could be due to definitions. Can you please define what you mean by a friend? How different opinions can two people have and still be friends?

I think giving my definition of a friend won’t do anything to help you understand the last paragraph and I don’t think my idea of what a friend is has much bearing on this discussion.

I find it amusing that there are people who claim to be a part of the critical-thinking community who, quite obviously, don't care whether the community ever grows. In their opinion, apparently, one must come to their senses on their own, or by following the example of people who are in a whole different community than one currently belongs to. Some on this forum would rather sit back lazily and criticize others who do not think the way they do or act the way they do than get to know others who do not share their beliefs - or lack of. Perhaps they just don't care. If we all follow their example, the skeptical movement will be stunted, will never grow. And believers will continue to view those who "think critically" as arrogant jerks who don't have a clue.

When Robert and I met, I had spent 47 years believing in psychics and other paranormal things which skeptics call "woo." I grew up in a home where these beliefs were encouraged and taught. Robert made it clear to me early-on what his "belief system" was, and would answer any question I fired at him for other possible explanations for what I believed to be true with kindness, sincerity, and patience. He planted a seed in my mind that perhaps what I believed could be explained away. All it took after that was my watching a show on tv, put on by skeptics, about how psychics, mentalists, etc, do what they do. I watched the show because I wanted to understand Robert's pov better, so I could more easily discuss the subjects with him. I didn't expect to have what Oprah calls an "aha moment."

Robert's style of convincing works. Maybe not all the time, perhaps not with everyone. My point is, he truly believes that everyone should use critical thinking skills to better avoid being hurt or taken advantage of. He genuinely cares about others who are vulnerable simply because they are not using those skills - whether they have spent a lifetime surrounded by those who were either deluded or frauds, or are suffering loss so profound that they are searching for answers anywhere they can get them. And he finally decided to do something about making sure more people, those who need it most, have access to those skills.

He is an activist for skepticism and critical thinking. Someone else earlier in this thread had opined that we may listen - perhaps heed is a better word - to the opinion of a friend over a stranger, or someone we perceive as an "enemy" as many in the woo camp perceive skeptics. Robert makes friends easily, and uses this skill to introduce other skills to people. This does not, in my humble opinion, lessen or take away from, in any way, shape or form, his credibility as a skeptic or critical-thinker. It strengthens him. It garners respect from those being hurt. Evidence for my opinion can be found in the membership of this forum, several of whom have come here because of what Robert has said and done and his style of doing so.

Thanks for your opinions.

I'm not sure whether you are asking Reno or asking me. I had considered that my definition of "friend" may be at the root of the problem here, so I'll take a stab at explaining what the word means to me.

I'm not sure that I can, come to think of it...

Perhaps I should think on this some more before I post on it.

But I will say that some of what has been said in this thread reminds me of a grade-schooler saying to another "If you're going to be friends with Sally, I'm not going to be friends with you any more!!" Of course, a friend who would say that was not really a friend to begin with. (Am I wandering into a "no true friend" fallacy? But, to withold one's friendship based on the behavior of another is not being a friend. So, for me to have witheld my friendship from
lisa, in effect saying "If you continue being a psychic, I won't be your friend", would have been just as disingenuous, I think.

Strawman. No-one said anything of the sort.

Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. Skepticism is a disposition towards the evidence, a method of thinking about claims and beliefs -- not some sort of exclusive clique.

Agreed


Who Robert is friends with says absolutely nothing about whether or not he evaluates claims with skepticism, nor does it challenge his "credibility" as a skeptic.

First part is right, second part is wrong. For the reasons already stated above which I won’t repeat.

People who display these toxic, us-versus-them attitudes should seriously consider leaving gradeschool and joining the adult community.

Ad Hom.

And, for those who may be thinkiing that Being friends with someone who BELIEVES in psychics is ONE thing, but being friends with somrone who CLAIMS to be psychic is another thing entirely, I will submit that this may well depend on whether thr claimed psychic is Self-deluded or is a knowing fraud. I can't know for certain, but I think that Lisa is the former. Do I think that I might some day enablr her to recognize her delusion? It would be cool if that were to happen, but it is not something I am counting on, nor is it why I became friends with her. But, if she is self-deluded, is it possible that hearing a respectfully skeptica; point of view on her "abilities", from someone she considers a dear friend, might lead her to re-examine her delusion? Of course it is possible.

Some of you may remember a poster here - I think it was ChillZero - who came to this forum convinced that she was displaying supernatural powers when she did Tarot readings. With thw support and encouragement of forumites, she re-examined what she did and determined it was simply cold-reading. Chill is now very much a skeptic. Would this have happened had she been met here with nothing but hostility and derision? Probably not. So even a practitioner of woo shouldn't be assumed to be somehow unworthy of friendship.


Unless there’s credibility at stake.

I was directing it at Reno. It is up to him to make his case, which I do not think he has done very well

I think I have done so.

So it is reasonable for someone, like me, to help him do so. He might not be 100% wrong, so we all might learn something.

I’ll assume that due to the difficulty in communicating emotional context by writings from someone who is not a professional author, you didn’t intend to make that last remark seem so condescending and patronising.

It does raise the issue of what reasons should you terminate a friendship? But then that is another thread.

Agreed

Privately (well not now that I've posted it!) I tend to agree with Brattus and Zeno but it's really none of my business who you are friends with and I have plenty of friends who have different religious, political, woo or sporting affiliations.

I guess what some of us might be struggling with is that those friendships are usually based around years of association encompassing all sorts of other things we do have in common, agree on etc - indeed the 'conflict' may have only come to light many years in when the friendship was already on a firm footing.

I guess it might be a question of definition here as I struggle with the concept of someone becoming not just a friend but a 'dear friend' after a couple of telephone conversations (however long) - indeed, I'd suggest you barely know them. I certainly wouldn't describe such a relationship as anything other than 'an aquaintance'. Sure you can be 'friendly' with them, find them surprisingly nice despite their lies / delusions (after all, Hitler was apparently extremely charming - c'mon, about time this thread was 'Godwinned' :D) but describe them as a 'friend' let alone a 'dear friend'? - not in my world.... Perhaps it's my British reserve but you seem to give away your friendship very cheaply (which I acknowledge may be far more to your credit than mine;)) - must be an American thing - you're all over-emotional nuts anyway;)...as opposed to us emotionally crippled Brits.

Anyway, not sure what I've added to this thread but I respect the work you do / have done, strongly suspect you're a much nicer person than me but struggle to square the phrase 'dear friend' with someone with whom your only connection is a couple of telephone conversations around the fact that they stand for everything you're pretty much against (at least in the context of your connection with them).

This.
 

Nope. Ad hom is attacking the arguer rather than the argument. I attacked the argument itself as immature -- and characterized those who choose to behave this way as behaving childishly. Not an ad hominem at all -- instead a criticism you should consider responding to directly.
 
Robert, you think maybe the lesser psychics are all too happy to become dear friends with someone who's been dismantling the career of their chief competitor? They may hope befriending you will help shield them from becoming one of your next victims.

I suppose this is a possibility - and one have considered, even back when I was chatting with James Van Praagh last year.
 
Nope. Ad hom is attacking the arguer rather than the argument. I attacked the argument itself as immature -- and characterized those who choose to behave this way as behaving childishly. Not an ad hominem at all -- instead a criticism you should consider responding to directly.

Wrong again. Calling the arguers children who should seriously consider leaving gradeschool and joining the adult community is an ad hom.

But, I'll respond directly as you asked so nicely:

People who display these toxic, us-versus-them attitudes should seriously consider leaving gradeschool and joining the adult community

Toxic attitude - your opinion, not mine.
leaving gradeschool - I did
joining the adult community - I did

Happy now?
 
Privately (well not now that I've posted it!) I tend to agree with Brattus and Zeno but it's really none of my business who you are friends with and I have plenty of friends who have different religious, political, woo or sporting affiliations.

DIFFERENT SPORTING AFFILIATIONS?!?!

Now you have gone too far! :D

I guess what some of us might be struggling with is that those friendships are usually based around years of association encompassing all sorts of other things we do have in common, agree on etc - indeed the 'conflict' may have only come to light many years in when the friendship was already on a firm footing.

Understood. Yes, my friendship with MamaLisa was forged rather quickly - especially given our "positions". I will comment on this more in a subsequent post.

[/QUOTE]I guess it might be a question of definition here as I struggle with the concept of someone becoming not just a friend but a 'dear friend' after a couple of telephone conversations (however long) - indeed, I'd suggest you barely know them. I certainly wouldn't describe such a relationship as anything other than 'an aquaintance'. Sure you can be 'friendly' with them, find them surprisingly nice despite their lies / delusions (after all, Hitler was apparently extremely charming - c'mon, about time this thread was 'Godwinned' :D) but describe them as a 'friend' let alone a 'dear friend'? - not in my world.... Perhaps it's my British reserve but you seem to give away your friendship very cheaply (which I acknowledge may be far more to your credit than mine;)) - must be an American thing - you're all over-emotional nuts anyway;)...as opposed to us emotionally crippled Brits.[/QUOTE]

I have been thinking about the term "dear friend" and, again, will go into my thoughts on it later.

Anyway, not sure what I've added to this thread but I respect the work you do / have done, strongly suspect you're a much nicer person than me but struggle to square the phrase 'dear friend' with someone with whom your only connection is a couple of telephone conversations around the fact that they stand for everything you're pretty much against (at least in the context of your connection with them).

Understood.
 
Wrong again. Calling the arguers children who should seriously consider leaving gradeschool and joining the adult community is an ad hom.

Nope. It's an honest assessment of the level of maturity expressed by their behavior.
 
hey all

i tend to agree with brattus and others although not quite as vehemently. i am a big fan of STOPSYLVIA and feel RSL Lancaster has been a worthy advocate of critical thinking in the past.

this "dear friend" thing and the whole para radio slot smacks of hypocrisy to me though and it does take away the credibility of the stop sylvia site. you cant denounce one psychic as abhorrent but be dear friends with another purely based on the amount of success each has had. i would wager that this "dear friend" would love to be in sylvia brownes shoes. they are both con artists who prey on the vulnerable just one of them has been more successful at it, so far.

im put in mind of the reaction of other psychics to the shawn hornbeck affair. i cant read this thread and continue supporting stopsylvia site anymore. you cant pick and choose who you discredit depending on personal relationships.

sorry robert. i just feel slightly dissappointed.

lxxx
 
Then I suggest you contact Webster's to inform them there has been a change of definition to Ad Hominem.

Okay, I'll bite... give Webster's definition of ad hominem, and then show how I'm meeting it.
More specifically, please explain exactly what argument I'm trying to fallaciously invalidate by pointing out something in your character that is irrelevant to that argument.
 
Last edited:
Strawman. No-one said anything of the sort.

It wasn't a direct quote. I said that what was being said in this thread reminded me of that gradeschool behavior, which it did. Not a strawman, but a statement of fact. And I spoke that comparison to two others who had been following this thread, and they both agreed that the comparison was apt. You obviously disagree. Perhaps the comparison is unfair, though I don't think it is. but it is NOT a strawman.
 
Okay, I'll bite... give Webster's definition of ad hominem, and then show how I'm meeting it.
More specifically, please explain exactly what argument I'm trying to fallaciously invalidate by pointing out something in your character that is irrelevant to that argument.

Start a new thread for this.
 
Start a new thread for this.

There's no need -- the answer is obvious. I wasn't trying to invalidate your argument by attacking the character of your behavior; I was attacking the character of your behavior directly because I directly disapprove of your behavior. This isn't ad hominem; it's direct criticism, and not in any way fallacious.
"This guy's math proof is wrong because he's a slob" is an ad hominem. "This guy is a slob; it's disgusting; he should learn some manners" is not an ad hominem. It's a direct criticism of behavior, and can be addressed directly.
 
It wasn't a direct quote. I said that what was being said in this thread reminded me of that gradeschool behavior, which it did. Not a strawman, but a statement of fact. And I spoke that comparison to two others who had been following this thread, and they both agreed that the comparison was apt. You obviously disagree. Perhaps the comparison is unfair, though I don't think it is. but it is NOT a strawman.


Well perhaps I had my logical fallacies mixed then. Perhaps it was a bit of Ad Hom rather than Strawman to hint that people were acting like gradeschoolers.
 
There's no need -- the answer is obvious. I wasn't trying to invalidate your argument by attacking the character of your behavior; I was attacking the character of your behavior directly because I directly disapprove of your behavior. This isn't ad hominem; it's direct criticism, and not in any way fallacious.
"This guy's math proof is wrong because he's a slob" is an ad hominem. "This guy is a slob; it's disgusting; he should learn some manners" is not an ad hominem. It's a direct criticism of behavior, and can be addressed directly.

Take it to another thread.
 
Well perhaps I had my logical fallacies mixed then. Perhaps it was a bit of Ad Hom rather than Strawman to hint that people were acting like gradeschoolers.

And, again, criticizing someone's behavior is not ad hom unless the criticism is unrelated to the argument and being used to undermine the credibility of the arguer.
You're arguing against a skeptic to be friends with a non-skeptic using "us-versus-them" language. Calling this behavior childish and immature is not Ad Hom; it's a direct attack on the character of the behavior. As even the Wikipedia definition of ad hominem points out, it's not even a fallacy to address character that is relevant to the behaviors and arguments being discussed.
 
Take it to another thread.

Sorry, but you've repeatedly used the "fallacy == dismissal" fallacy. You've responded to someone's criticism against you by simply naming a fallacy and then failing to respond further, essentially dismissing their argument on that basis.
In other words, you've MADE whether or not the original criticism/argument is actually the fallacy you've labelled, relavent to the current thread.
You could, of course, actually address the substantive points made against you, in which case this would no longer be true. But you called my post an Ad Hom no less than three times. You brought it up; and you're wrong.
 
And, again, criticizing someone's behavior is not ad hom unless the criticism is unrelated to the argument and being used to undermine the credibility of the arguer.
You're arguing against a skeptic to be friends with a non-skeptic using "us-versus-them" language. Calling this behavior childish and immature is not Ad Hom; it's a direct attack on the character of the behavior. As even the Wikipedia definition of ad hominem points out, it's not even a fallacy to address character that is relevant to the behaviors and arguments being discussed.

if i where to come on this forum and state i was "dear friends" with sylvia browne, you would all tear me a new one and rightly so. especially if i was a vocal critic of, say, john edward. is it not an us versus them scenario then?

lxxx
 
I don’t think Robert has to dump anyone he counts a dear friend, or a wife,
Whew!!

I do, however, think that Robert should consider his position before deciding to become dear friends with a professional psychic and then announcing it to the world.

My "position"?

I appreciate the compliment, but you sound as though you are talking to Catherine, making sure she understands her upcoming position as a member of the Royal Family or something. I know that I am looked upon by some here as something more than "just one of the gang". But while I treasure that and appreciate it immensely, in my eyes, as I have said many times here over the years, I'm just a guy with a couple of web sites.



If I said you had lost all credibility, I think that would have been an exaggeration. But it does harm your credibility being dear friends with a professional psychic Robert, whether you agree or not. On this site, you are pretty much preaching to the choir. We all know you and we know what your intentions are regarding skepticism. You yourself have said, as has your Susan, that you must reach a wider audience. How do you think people outwith this site and circle will view you as a voice of balance and reason when you say your dear friend is a professional psychic? I fear they will think, ok, let’s have a look at his Stop sites, but he’s best friends with a con-artist, so let’s look at it with a pinch of salt. Like I said, it’s a knock to your credibility. Maybe not from the majority of people who know you, but we’re already on your team. What about those who aren’t yet decided?

I think that the facts on SSB speak for themselves.

It wouldn’t be appropriate for anyone to comment on your relationship with your wife

Nor was it appropriate for people to tell me to "dump her" when we were dating, but some did.


We’re talking about your relationship with a professional con-artist, practicing her craft and taking money for it in the very field that you’re meant to be STOPping.

I will be saying more about Lisa later in this thread.



Your friendship with her is not the same as your friendship with other hosts owners and chatters – unless any of them are also practicing professional charlatans.

Some ofthe other hosts are indeed practicing psychics. Whether or not I would classify them as "professional" or not is on a case-by-case basis, I suppose.


I know you’re not quoting me here because I have never asked you to change the way you have accomplished what you already have.

No, but an intrinsic part of how I've accomplished what I have has been my unconventional (to some) associations with various people on "the other side of the fence", from members of paranormal forums to the owners of those forums, to various practitioners of woo (up to and including my online chats with Van Praagh). So, to question my association with MamaLisa is, in effect saying "We love what you've done, but quedstion your methods."

And no, I am not saying that any criticism of me is saying this. But, whether you can see it or not, my associations with these people over the years has played a key role in giving me the perspective that I have, which has played a large part in my acheivements. Of course, even if we assume that all my associations up until now were good ideas, that does not guarantee that my association with MamaLisa is.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom