Invited on another Psychic's Show

Well first off when I first started posting on here I was an awestruck fan.
Your Kaz site really impressed me and still does.

yES, i REMEMBER, WHICH IS WHY i SAID ALMOST FROM YOUR FIRST POST. oops, sorry for the caps. :o

But after about 6 months of posting on here I started to notice that no one on here ever disagreed with you regarding anything.

Was it that long? Doesn't seem like it, but my sense of time is all screwy these days.

You started articles about SB smoking cigarettes or not and putting up photos of her desk with an ashtray on it as proof.

Article. Singular. And it, like other articles not directly related to her "psychic abilities", "went to character", as I believe I stated within the article itself. It was to highlight the fact that she even lies about incredibly mundane things, raising the question "if you can't trust her about something this mundane, why trust what she says about anything?"

But we've been over this, Brattus.

No one ever questioned that or anything else you started threads about or posted about.

Not true. although they were definitely in the minority, the critics were always there. Tai Chi, for example, heavily criticized the Smoking article from the day it went up on the site.

No one can be right about everything all the time.

I never claimed to be, nor has anyone here claimed that of me that I'm aware of.

When I first decided to share my opinion I was attacked by your groupies as if I were torturing puppies on live TV.
You would think I was crucifying their Christ the way they carried on.
Something about that just isn't right at all.

I don't remember that, though I do recall your mentioning this before. Had I noticed it at the time, I probably would have tried to stop it. I am by no means above criticism, Brattus. And I doubt that anyone else here thinks I am, either. Perhaps a review of the posts in question (if it was within posts) would reveal that it wasn't so much the fact that you were critical of me, but more the way you went about it, that caused the reaction you describe.

Perhaps "sold out" isn't the right term to use. Maybe coming to a cross road is the correct phrase.

Thanks for rephrasing it. And it's interesting that you should choose the "crossroads" metaphor. I am currently working on a new banner graphic for my show's page on the para-x site, and it shows a ceossroads sign at the intersection of "BELIEF BLVD." and "DOUBT DR.", above a Stop Sign which reads "STOP...AND THINK!" (Meaning "consider the evidence before choosing which road to travel").

Have you asked yourself recently how much value do I really place on my skepticism?

No, because I know that I value it highly. And I don't see how anything I have said or done of late would call that into question.

When you have a one sided conversation going like a web site where no one talks back then you can be as nice and reasoned as you like.
Once you bring the same subject into an open conversation whether it is on a forum like this or a internet radio show that takes calls you can't be nice and ask the questions that need to be asked in order to progress that conversation.

I'm getting the feeling you hope to call into the show and make a scene. I hope not, but if you do, I will just try to address your questions/comments to the best of my abilities.

You have gone from spending a unimaginable amount of time creating and maintaining a web site dedicated to bringing down a big time TV psychic to making excuses for their lies and self delusions because they are nice to talk to on the phone.

Once again I will ask you to either point out where I am supposedly "making excuses for their lies" or take your strawman elsewhere. Seriously, Brattus. Where have I done this?

Gimme a break!

I was about to say that very thing!

You of all people should know that the gift of gab and charisma are standard tools of the trade for those liars, crooks and cons.

Yes, read what I wrote a few posts above about my thoughts after that phone call.

I will use my own pretend psychic powers and predict that in another 6 months you'll be on here actively promoting a psychic or two stating that SB was fake but your new "dear friends" are the real deal.

Care to bet on that prediction?

Hurt, shame and saddened? No way! That has never been my intention. But, I would like you to wake the hell up!

I'm fully awake, Brattus - but thanks again for your concern.

Thanks for your thanks but I doubt it's sincerity.

dON'T KNOW WHAT i CAN DO ABOUT THAT. or the damned CapsLock key either...
 
Just wondering. Critics, may I ask a question? What have you done, what have you spent countless hours doing, that promoted skepicism? A link perhaps?

No one, least of all Robert, has claimed to be perfect. But I believe he deserves a great deal of credit for the difference he has made.

So, in what ways have you made a difference?
 
I appreciate the sentiment Julia, but someone does not need to have "made a difference" before they may criticize someone who you feel has.

But thanks.

ETA: Although I will admit there have been times when someone here has told me that they disapprove of something I've done, and an uncharitable part of me wants to say "as opposed to the way you have done it? And just what way is that?"
 
Last edited:
Years ago, I would listen to Robert rant about psychics, faith healers, and their ilk. One day I said "DO something about it! If it bothers you that much then DO something about it!" So I like to take some credit for his activism in the same way he likes to take some of the credit for my skepticism. The difference he is making is small, and likely will never solve the problem of cunning people taking advantage of others. But he is OUT THERE, meeting and greeting those who have either never learned how to think critically or suffered a major loss which caused them to "overlook" the traps. With his kind and gentle ways, he shows them the way to reason.

But he is one man. It's a daunting task he has undertaken. Just as Krelnik has taken on the "What's the Harm" challenge. (goodness! have you seen that website? it's massive! and yet there are some here who criticize his work, as well.) Instead of encouraging or HELPING further the cause of skepticism, there are some on this forum who DO NOTHING but criticize others.

Brattus says:
"Once you bring the same subject into an open conversation whether it is on a forum like this or a internet radio show that takes calls you can't be nice and ask the questions that need to be asked in order to progress that conversation."

I beg to differ. Robert is doing it - nicely - every day. One example I know he has mentioned in one thread was when a woman was claiming she had an EVP of a baby crying. Robert took her through the things it COULD be in a kind and respectful way. She not only learned something (that baby monitors have a radio frequency), but he showed her how to think critically. I doubt she was converted in this one instance, but perhaps she won't be as ready to accept in the future. Or, perhaps not. The seed is planted all the same.

And, in case anyone is thinking that I am sticking up for Robert because I'm his wife and I love him - I say "Balderdash!" :) Robert and I disagree all the time. Good grief, I'm Christian and he is agnostic, for one thing. We have lively discussions at times. You all here don't see or hear those discussions, so you have a limited amount of information with which to get to know us. When it comes to activism for the critical thinking movement, Robert is my hero. Still, I have no problem telling him when I think he's wrong. Just ask him about it.
 
Yeah, I also tell Robert all the time that I think he's wrong!

OK, not really.

Maybe I might have noticed he was wrong about something once, though, and I just can't think of it right now.

I know, I know, what else would you expect from an Acolyte??
 
By the way, Brattus: you said earlier in this thread that there is such a thing as being "too nice". well, many times over the months - including regarding this thread -i have been told that I am too nice, too patient, with you! I disagree. while I disagree with you (obviously) on some things, I have never felt that you did not merit reasoned responses to your criticisms of me. I've been told I should put you on Ignore, or that I shhould tell you to do something anatomically impossible with yourself. But neither appealed to me. I guess I just deal with those who disagree with me - whether it's you, or a psychic who wants to interview me - a little differently than some.
 
Once again I will ask you to either point out where I am supposedly "making excuses for their lies" or take your strawman elsewhere. Seriously, Brattus. Where have I done this?

What was that you said about Sylvia smoking? Goes to character.
Was that it?
You are now "dear friends" with someone who purports to being a psychic through at least the internet media.
There are only 2 reasons I can think of for making such a claim and that is either attention or fraud.

One of those reasons speaks of self delusion the other being a lying crook.

How you could ever get to "hows the weather where you're at" without first coming to terms with that elephant in the room is where my point lies.

If you are willing and able to accept that persons self delusion or fraud against others or both then you agree with what they are doing and are making excuses for their behavior and yours with talk of building bridges.

Building bridges! LOL! That is a laugh riot!
To build a bridge you need a working foundation on both sides.
On one side you have the strong foundation of basic common sense.
On the other you have talking to dead people through spirit guides and bending spoons with the power of the mind.
I'll say it again!

Gimme a break!

There is no compromise to be reached here.
To even suggest that there is a middle ground to be reached is making a blanket excuse and approval for the fraud, lies and straight up heartless actions to others by all your new "dear friends".

Seriously, Robert. This is where you have done this.

It all goes to character. If you are best buds with one self deluded lying fraud while working to stop another why should anyone take anything you say or do seriously?

If you are so lonely you need the company of self deluded lying frauds then that is a sad thing.
If that is truly the case then you need to stop stopping.
Because that kind of double talking B.S. is exactly the sort of thing you're supposed to be trying to stop in the first place.
 
You can be friends with people even while not thinking and acting the same way. It's empathy, and is the basis of friendship. You can even actively work against their behaviour and still remain friends.

The leap you make from RSL being friends with a purported psychic to "making excuses for their lies" is nonsensical.

I do agree however that who you are friends with does reflect on your character, and I'm hoping that Mr. Lancaster believes this woman to be the self-deluded type of psychic, rather than the cynical scam artist type.
 
Last edited:
I hope this doesn't come across as too groupie-ish and all, but it's always been my experience that people usually listen to their friends, and tend to do less listening to those who openly despise them. So if the ultimate goal here is to change minds (as opposed to simply sharing a laugh among the already converted) I'd think civility is a pretty effective way to go.
 
RSL - Arent you afraid by being nothing but nice to these people that all you do is lend an air of credibility to their fraud?

I mean, I dont expect you to go in all guns blazing, but sometimes you gotta call them out on their BS, and that can hurt feelings.
 
(Originally Posted by RSLancastr
> "Once again I will ask you to either point out where I am
> supposedly "making excuses for their lies" or take your strawman
> elsewhere. Seriously, Brattus. Where have I done this?")

What was that you said about Sylvia smoking? Goes to character.
Was that it?
You are now "dear friends" with someone who purports to being a psychic through at least the internet media.
There are only 2 reasons I can think of for making such a claim and that is either attention or fraud.

As an outsider to this argument, one thing is pretty clear. Your statement about is not an answer to RSLancaster's demand for an example of your previous generalized accusation. If RSLancaster has made excuses for a psychic's fraud or failure, I want to know about it.

Without knowing the specific facts of the "dear friends" reference, I would guess that I might possibly be on your side on that issue. But saying that someone has low standards for friendship is not an answer to the "making excuses" question.
 
What was that you said about Sylvia smoking? Goes to character.
Was that it?
You are now "dear friends" with someone who purports to being a psychic through at least the internet media.
There are only 2 reasons I can think of for making such a claim and that is either attention or fraud.

One of those reasons speaks of self delusion the other being a lying crook.


How you could ever get to "hows the weather where you're at" without first coming to terms with that elephant in the room is where my point lies.

Well, as I said near the top of this thread, I made sure she knew that L believe that anyone who claims to be psychic is either self-deluded or a knowing fraud. She acknowledged that this was my pov (which she would do whichever of those fits her). So, the elephant in the room was acknowledged and discussed. At that point, either of us could have chosen to end the conversation, but neither of us did. One reason I wanted to speak with her was to learn a few things about how hosting a show worked, and I did learn some of that from her. I also, unexpectedly learned a very strong lesson about how someone with a serious medical problem could be tempted to buy into this nonsense even if that person knew full well that it was all crap. I knew thay before - it's only common sense - but to experience it first-hand was a real eye-opener for me, and gives me some strong insight into the pov of some believers. Io be clear, she didn't say that I would be able to walk again by a certain date, but she said some other things which I could easily see a believer putting together as just such a prediction. Did she do so intentionally? It'spossible, but I hope not. I still hope (but can't know) that she is one of the self-deluded kind. And yes, I now consider her a friend. If you think that "goes to my character", I can live with that.

If you are willing and able to accept that persons self delusion or fraud against others or both then you agree with what they are doing and are making excuses for their behavior and yours with talk of building bridges.
You are welcome to see it in that light (and I drop the "strawman" charge. I still think you are putting words in my mouth, but I know choose to believe that you really think that's what I said means, rather than intentionally twisting my words. I guess maybe I think of you as...self-deluded...on that point. :D

Building bridges! LOL! That is a laugh riot!

IIRC, you also thought it humorous that I thought that SSB could convince a fan of SB that she was a fraud. I think that I have published some emails which strongly suggest otherwise. Of course, those emails might have been written by trolls to sucker me, just as Lisa (my psychic friend) may have fooled me into believing she is my friend. But I don't think so - in either case. And I am fully aware that my ego is involved in both cases. Similar to the "I know when someone is lying to me!" trap that my Mother fell into regarding Kaz. Does knowing that I can be fooled prevent me from being fooled? Of course not.

To build a bridge you need a working foundation on both sides.

Well, any metaphor or simile can be pushed to the breaking point. that;s why it is a metaphorical bridge.

On one side you have the strong foundation of basic common sense.

Which of course isn't all that common

On the other you have talking to dead people through spirit guides and bending spoons with the power of the mind.
I'll say it again!

Gimme a break!

No, the foundation - on both sides - is people. Good and bad on both sides. smart and...not-so-smart too. And the "bridge" is not an attempt to make everyone run over to "our side". It is an attempt to show both sides the humanity of those on the other side. Not all skeptics are raging (expletives). Not all believers are simpletons.

And I firmly believe that it is only in an atmosphere of mutual respect that those on either side will truly listen to and consider the pov of the other side.

There is no compromise to be reached here.
To even suggest that there is a middle ground to be reached is making a blanket excuse and approval for the fraud, lies and straight up heartless actions to others by all your new "dear friends".

Brattus, there is ONE person at Para-x whom I have referred to here as a "Dear friend." I have several other friends over there, none of whom (to my knowledge anyway) claim to have any paranormal abilities. they are mostly listeners in the chat room. I have forged many friendships over the past ten years with people in various believer communities. Some, such as Julia/wasapi, have become very dear friends indeed.

Of course[/i there is a "middle ground", if, by that, you mean a place where both sides can co-exist. And that place, like the "foundations", is the two sides' common humanity.

Seriously, Robert. This is where you have done this.

It all goes to character. If you are best buds with one self deluded lying fraud while working to stop another why should anyone take anything you say or do seriously?

I guess I will have to wait and see on that. I think that anyone who decides to not take me seriously for that reason, after my track record, they are not seeing the big picture. But I do acknowledge that it will be a cause of concern for some.

If you are so lonely you need the company of self deluded lying frauds then that is a sad thing.

If that is truly the case then you need to stop stopping.
Because that kind of double talking B.S. is exactly the sort of thing you're supposed to be trying to stop in the first place.

Again, Brattus, thanks for expressing your concerns. I knew full well that some here would be upset by that friendship, so thanks for bringing it out into the open.
 
You can be friends with people even while not thinking and acting the same way. It's empathy, and is the basis of friendship. You can even actively work against their behaviour and still remain friends.
^This.

Thanks, OT. I knew that when I mentioned my friendship with a psychic here, it would be, to some, similar to me saying "I have a good friend who is a purse snatcher. Other than the whole stealing-purses-from-old-ladies thing, he's a great guy!"

I chose to mention it anyway. whether that - or the friendship - was a mistake remains to be seen.

The leap you make from RSL being friends with a purported psychic to "making excuses for their lies" is nonsensical.

I agree, and thanks. but, be careful, or Brattus will say that you are one of a throng of my "fans" out to attack him.

I do agree however that who you are friends with does reflect on your character, and I'm hoping that Mr. Lancaster believes this woman to be the self-deluded type of psychic, rather than the cynical scam artist type.

I certainly hope/think that she is, but I cannot know for certain. But perhaps I delude myself in this!

I hope this doesn't come across as too groupie-ish and all, but it's always been my experience that people usually listen to their friends, and tend to do less listening to those who openly despise them. So if the ultimate goal here is to change minds (as opposed to simply sharing a laugh among the already converted) I'd think civility is a pretty effective way to go.

It's just that simple, isn't it?


RSL - Arent you afraid by being nothing but nice to these people that all you do is lend an air of credibility to their fraud?

I mean, I dont expect you to go in all guns blazing, but sometimes you gotta call them out on their BS, and that can hurt feelings.

I have stated many times there, both on the air (in my show and those of others) that I believe all who claim to be psychic are either self-deluded or knowingly fraudulent. I have also devoted two of my shows to discussing How People who claim to be psychic fool many6 people into believing them

I don't think that qualifies as "nothing but nice." Do you?

As an outsider to this argument, one thing is pretty clear. Your statement about is not an answer to RSLancaster's demand for an example of your previous generalized accusation. If RSLancaster has made excuses for a psychic's fraud or failure, I want to know about it.

Without knowing the specific facts of the "dear friends" reference, I would guess that I might possibly be on your side on that issue. But saying that someone has low standards for friendship is not an answer to the "making excuses" question.
 
As an outsider to this argument, one thing is pretty clear. Your statement about is not an answer to RSLancaster's demand for an example of your previous generalized accusation. If RSLancaster has made excuses for a psychic's fraud or failure, I want to know about it.

So does RSLancastr.

As I understand it,, Brattus thinks that, by forming a friendship with MamaLisa, a purported psychic, and discussing it publically in these forums, I am somehow implicitly "making excuses" for her claim to be psychic.

Without knowing the specific facts of the "dear friends" reference, I would guess that I might possibly be on your side on that issue.

I believe the reference is from a thread I created in February of this year, titled something like "A Psychic Wants to Interview Me!" or perhaps a thread I created later (I am composimg this offline or I would give you a link),

But saying that someone has low standards for friendship is not an answer to the "making excuses" question.

Agreed, and thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
While I appreciate the concern Zep, I do wish that you would give me some credit for not being some totally naive shmuck. I'm no James Randi, but this isn't my first dance either. I've been working both sides of this bridge I'm trying to build since 2001. I've had people saying "nice doggie" to me, and people swinging rocks at me, from BOTH sides, so I am not unaware of the possibilities you mention.

That is, of course, no guarantee that I will be ready for the next rock when it comes (and it WILL come, eventually), but, again, sometimes I wish the predictors of gloom and doom in this regard would stop and consider my track record. It hasn't been spotless, by any stretch of the imagination, but I haven't done badly either.
Naive? Nope, never thought that of you. Schmuck? ...ummm, I'll let your missus decide that. :)

For me, your track record is admirable and exemplary. Nor am I predicting doom and gloom - quite the opposite, I'm very positive for you. I suppose I'm just being a bit cynical when it comes to the con-artists, thinking like some of the nastier psychics have eventually revealed themselves to think. That's how they make their living: conning people. And since I don't want to see you conned, I suppose I'm just reminding you to keep "Shields Up!" as you sail into this new era of being resident skepticism in a non-skeptic planet.
 
If you want to know how Robert would handle tough questions like "what would you do if you witnessed something that you thought was paranormal?" see today's resident skeptic show.

The answer was a good one.
 
Fair enough, Zep. Or should I say "Fair Dinkum"?
No, you wouldn't say that. :D

As a question, the phrase "Fair dinkum?" is asking "Is that [really] so?" or "Genuinely?". As an emphatic response it is a positive confirmation. The phrase can be shortened to one word: "dinkum" or even "dinks" (Aussies do like to abbreviate stuff!). So a colloquial inquiry about the truth of the matter followed by a confirmation of same goes like this:

"Dinks?"
"Dinkum!"
"Mate!"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_English_vocabulary
 
Zep, thanks for the lesson.

I had never heard the expression "fair dinkum" my whole life until I was in my 30s and my three kids all loved a live-action show on the Disney Channel titled Dumbo's Circus, in which all of the characters were animals (actors wearing animal suits). One of the characters was a Koala named Fair Dinkum.

It wasn't until a few years later that I saw it used online - by an Aussie - in its Aussie usage, and understood where Disney had gotten the character's name.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom