Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

I disagree. I think it's clearly wrong to allow people to pay (in whatever form) to a 3rd party (i.e. not the US government) in order to have influence with the US government. The property that is being sold (in this case, access to our government's chief diplomat) belongs to the citizens of the country, and it is not Hillary's right to give it away or sell it for the benefit of any other party.

Ah, the "We the people" argument? Do you hold a plebiscite? Or do you accept that we're a Republic and that our elected representatives should make those calls. The President is elected, if indirectly, and the Executive is appointed by the POTUS. Or do we have to ask the population directly.

You will grind the business of governing to a halt in order to take an "ethical" stand about a political opponent.

And let's cut to the chase. Would anyone arguing the ethics here please show the forms and procedures pertaining to "Requirements for Individuals to Make an Appointment With a Cabinet Level Office Holder in the Government of the United States". Is that a 22D-11? Or a 31B-14, Revised? Is there such a procedure? How does one get in to see the Secretary of whatever? What form, format, procedure would the hypothetical or actual Prince follow? How would YOU get in to see Secretary Kerry? Right now. Today.

Meh? Like anyone else, I'd reach into my packet of networking connections and find someone who knows someone who might have a link, whether from Kerry's campaign history, his military service, his wife's family connections, whatever. I'd be least likely to say to myself, "Self, just call Washington and ask for an appointment."

I guess in Freetopia this isn't that hard because everyone knows everyone else and the Alderperson is available at all times. It's a little harder in a country of 330,000,000 and a world of six billion.
 
Indeed. But isn't it wonderful to have our own hall monitor checking all the liberals passes?

I agree with you. using that famous definition of insanity as a basis, it make prefect sense to stop clicking links until we can expect a different result.
I'll second that. At some point it becomes pointless to look at yet another link, there will be no evidence in the next one either.
 
Ah, the "We the people" argument? Do you hold a plebiscite? Or do you accept that we're a Republic and that our elected representatives should make those calls. The President is elected, if indirectly, and the Executive is appointed by the POTUS. Or do we have to ask the population directly.

You will grind the business of governing to a halt in order to take an "ethical" stand about a political opponent.

And let's cut to the chase. Would anyone arguing the ethics here please show the forms and procedures pertaining to "Requirements for Individuals to Make an Appointment With a Cabinet Level Office Holder in the Government of the United States". Is that a 22D-11? Or a 31B-14, Revised? Is there such a procedure? How does one get in to see the Secretary of whatever? What form, format, procedure would the hypothetical or actual Prince follow? How would YOU get in to see Secretary Kerry? Right now. Today.

Meh? Like anyone else, I'd reach into my packet of networking connections and find someone who knows someone who might have a link, whether from Kerry's campaign history, his military service, his wife's family connections, whatever. I'd be least likely to say to myself, "Self, just call Washington and ask for an appointment."

I guess in Freetopia this isn't that hard because everyone knows everyone else and the Alderperson is available at all times. It's a little harder in a country of 330,000,000 and a world of six billion.
Wait, in that country of 330,000,000 if you eliminate Democrats, progressives, liberals or others not of the favored political position, it's much easier. In fact, I'm sure these issues would never even be discussed by those left, er right. :)
 
Last edited:
Holy irony Batman

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 0 and rule 12 in quote
Could you help me out here? Did you look at the evidence in question that you are saying Noah did not?

Or am I just helplessly lost in this discussion?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ah, the "We the people" argument? Do you hold a plebiscite? Or do you accept that we're a Republic and that our elected representatives should make those calls. The President is elected, if indirectly, and the Executive is appointed by the POTUS. Or do we have to ask the population directly.

You will grind the business of governing to a halt in order to take an "ethical" stand about a political opponent.

And let's cut to the chase. Would anyone arguing the ethics here please show the forms and procedures pertaining to "Requirements for Individuals to Make an Appointment With a Cabinet Level Office Holder in the Government of the United States". Is that a 22D-11? Or a 31B-14, Revised? Is there such a procedure? How does one get in to see the Secretary of whatever? What form, format, procedure would the hypothetical or actual Prince follow? How would YOU get in to see Secretary Kerry? Right now. Today.

Meh? Like anyone else, I'd reach into my packet of networking connections and find someone who knows someone who might have a link, whether from Kerry's campaign history, his military service, his wife's family connections, whatever. I'd be least likely to say to myself, "Self, just call Washington and ask for an appointment."

I guess in Freetopia this isn't that hard because everyone knows everyone else and the Alderperson is available at all times. It's a little harder in a country of 330,000,000 and a world of six billion.

Of course I agree that in the interest of efficiency we should give the benefit of the doubt to the judgment of the people delegated the authority to make those calls. But those people in authority should know that making it a habit of giving preferential access to people who give money to their friends is not, by any stretch, ethically acceptable.

Generally, proof of such unethical behavior is hard to come by, especially on a case by case basis. But when we have enough examples, as I think we do in Hillary's situation, we can draw statistical inferences of systematic behavior. I think it's clear that there was a close relationship between the Clinton Foundation and her office. Executives of the Clinton Foundation made, on average, one call per week to Hillary's office while she was Secretary of State. We have emails in which a Clinton Foundation executive explicitly requested a meeting with Hillary because somebody was a "good friend" of the Foundation (read "big donor"), which is not only clear evidence that such requests were made, but is also clear evidence that executives at the Foundation had every reason to expect results . And we have from the AP study that more than half of the individuals acting privately (i.e. not representing any government) who had meeting with Hillary during her tenure were Clinton Foundation donors.

So, I think the evidence is quite clear that preferential access was systematically granted to Clinton Foundation donors. Is that a pattern of preferential access that is beneficial to the US government and its citizens? No, I don't think it can reasonably be argued that it is. There is nothing special about the Clinton Foundation except that it is associated with Hillary Clinton itself.

In the case of the Gates Foundation, a one-off grant of access at the request of Bill Gates would be fine. A systematic grant of access to his requests would not be. It's hard to question the judgment behind a one-off. It's quite a different matter to question the judgment of a policy that was tacitly in place.
 
Last edited:
Of course I agree that in the interest of efficiency we should give the benefit of the doubt to the judgment of the people delegated the authority to make those calls. But those people in authority should know that making it a habit of giving preferential access to people who give money to their friends is not, by any stretch, ethically acceptable.

Their friends in this case are people in Africa dying of AIDS.

Do you think America has an issue with helping people get better?
 
But those people in authority should know that making it a habit of giving preferential access to people who give money to their friends is not, by any stretch, ethically acceptable.

And by their friends you mean people suffering with HIV/AIDS?


Generally, proof of such unethical behavior is hard to come by, especially on a case by case basis.

So hard to come by that you haven't offered any.

But when we have enough examples, as I think we do in Hillary's situation, we can draw statistical inferences of systematic behavior

Yes we know what you think, where are these examples you refer to? And inferences are not evidence unless you can provide details of a rigorous statistical analysis to back them up.


So, I think the evidence is quite clear that preferential access was systematically granted to Clinton Foundation donors.

And again, we know what you think, please provide this evidence you keep referring to.

It's quite a different matter to question the judgment of a policy that was tacitly in place.

And another claim that you have failed to back up. Pages of this and nothing has risen above opinion and suspicion. Evidence is required and it's sorely lacking.
 
And by their friends you mean people suffering with HIV/AIDS?

Of course not. Do you think the Clintons would be friends with people suffering from HIV/AIDS? Not a chance in hell. Their friends would be those running (and living large off of) the Foundation.
 
Of course not. Do you think the Clintons would be friends with people suffering from HIV/AIDS? Not a chance in hell. Their friends would be those running (and living large off of) the Foundation.

Yet it was Bill who got the ball rolling on the Global Fund, Bill who fixed Bush's fundie paleo colonial program to take it away from the fat hawgs at Big Pharma,.... in addition to the work the Clinton Foundation does.

You still haven't addressed the illusions you maintain in your mentioning of Bush's pet project. Is this another case of never speaking with your mouth full and you've actually learned that there was considerably less to the philanthropy than you'd been led to believe. Or are you going to try to defend that nonsense? Be careful, though.... to do so, you have to "take the good with the bad", and your high moral standards don't actually allow that.
 
Of course not. Do you think the Clintons would be friends with people suffering from HIV/AIDS? Not a chance in hell. Their friends would be those running (and living large off of) the Foundation.

Unreal.

How about if their friends are the people who run these countries and local groups tasked with distributing the assistance that the CF clearly provides?

Is there no space in the mind of an extreme right-wing hater that there's any possible way the Clinton Foundation does ANY good whatsoever?
 
Unreal.

How about if their friends are the people who run these countries and local groups tasked with distributing the assistance that the CF clearly provides?

Is there no space in the mind of an extreme right-wing hater that there's any possible way the Clinton Foundation does ANY good whatsoever?

Well, I don't know about those guys, but there is space in my mind for that. I think it's almost certain that the Clinton Foundation does some good. It's hard not to with all of that money. I'm skeptical that it does net good, however, because I think it's probably run more for the aggrandizement of the Clintons and their cronies than it is for the good of humanity. And I think it's extremely unlikely that it is as effective a charity as the Red Cross or as effective a foundation (i.e. disburser of grants) as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

Belying its name, the Clinton Foundation has been set up more as a charity than a foundation. I suspect it's because the operational control of the programs that it funds gives more opportunity for graft.
 
Well, I don't know about those guys, but there is space in my mind for that. I think it's almost certain that the Clinton Foundation does some good. It's hard not to with all of that money. I'm skeptical that it does net good, however, because I think it's probably run more for the aggrandizement of the Clintons and their cronies than it is for the good of humanity. And I think it's extremely unlikely that it is as effective a charity as the Red Cross or as effective a foundation (i.e. disburser of grants) as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

Belying its name, the Clinton Foundation has been set up more as a charity than a foundation. I suspect it's because the operational control of the programs that it funds gives more opportunity for graft.

Sorry, but the evidence (tough word, I know) proves you're wrong.
 
Yet it was Bill who got the ball rolling on the Global Fund, Bill who fixed Bush's fundie paleo colonial program to take it away from the fat hawgs at Big Pharma,.... in addition to the work the Clinton Foundation does.

You still haven't addressed the illusions you maintain in your mentioning of Bush's pet project. Is this another case of never speaking with your mouth full and you've actually learned that there was considerably less to the philanthropy than you'd been led to believe. Or are you going to try to defend that nonsense? Be careful, though.... to do so, you have to "take the good with the bad", and your high moral standards don't actually allow that.

Sometimes I don't understand what your point is. Do I need to justify the success of Bush's PEPFAR? I actually don't know much about it, but I know it has been given bipartisan praise, and that George Bush has extremely high approval rates in Africa because of it. My point in bringing it up is that the AIDS/HIV problem in Africa was already being addressed with massive resources. It sounds to me like a public relations stunt to have the Clinton Health Access Initiative join the effort. There's nothing like joining a winning team after it's clear that it's winning and then basking in the reflected glory of the success.
 
Sometimes I don't understand what your point is. Do I need to justify the success of Bush's PEPFAR? I actually don't know much about it, but I know it has been given bipartisan praise, and that George Bush has extremely high approval rates in Africa because of it. My point in bringing it up is that the AIDS/HIV problem in Africa was already being addressed with massive resources. It sounds to me like a public relations stunt to have the Clinton Health Access Initiative join the effort. There's nothing like joining a winning team after it's clear that it's winning and then basking in the reflected glory of the success.

Maybe that comfort you're feeling is from living in a country that wasn't devastated by HIV. There's plenty of "need" to go around. And PEPFAR ignored a whole lot of that need. A) The shrub's Republican-driven program insisted on an high-ground moral stance on prostitution that denied access to millions, and B) By treating it as a typical top-down imperialist colonial policy, they were able to funnel the government's money back into the coffers of Big Pharma - many of whom are NOT American companies, just great big old rich corporations.

Not to mention the huge amount of it that was financed by the American taxpayer, and that one of the items that Pepfar lists is that they proudly support the Global Fund. Why would the shrub need to start Pepfar? There's already a big organization out there tackling HIV/AIDS. Why I suspect it was just self-aggrandizement and a chance for Bush and his cronies to travel the world and book five star hotel rooms. I mean.... "malaria"? Gimme a break! There are already dozens of NGOs out there fighting malaria. Just color me suspicious, that's all.


>>> Are you getting the point, yet? <<<
 
The problem with joining these debates is that one side throws **** around like confetti, and if you call them out as the BS peddlers they are, the mods come out of the woodwork.
 
Of course not. Do you think the Clintons would be friends with people suffering from HIV/AIDS? Not a chance in hell. Their friends would be those running (and living large off of) the Foundation.

And we have another evidence free claim.

ETA: and paying people salaries to run the CF does not count, unless you can demonstrate those salaries and expenses are out of line with other similarly sized charities.
 
Last edited:
I must say, there are a lot of pathetic arguments floating here. My favourite is "someone else is doing similiar thing already, so good done in that area by Hillary's charity does not count". HDS, indeed.

The problem with joining these debates is that one side throws **** around like confetti, and if you call them out as the BS peddlers they are, the mods come out of the woodwork.
As you can see above, you CAN call out BS without pointing at anyone personally.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom