Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content
Then I'd suggest more debunking and less personal attacks.

That'd go a long way toward convincing a fence-sitter such as myself.
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12


Here is a link from a charity watchdog that gives the foundation an A rating and says they use an excellent 88% of their funds for charitable programs.

https://www.charitywatch.org/ratings-and-metrics/bill-hillary-chelsea-clinton-foundation/478

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As I've said there times now in this thread, your body of work WRT sourcing and citations cannot in any way be trusted to support whatever argument you think it does.

In short, we've clicked your links before, many times, and they're severely lacking. Start showing good faith and maybe we'll start clicking again.

Every single link I've clicked on has been a whole lot of nothing. A total waste of time.

Here's a charity by all neutral observers is considered one of the better charities, yet with absolutely no proof BD suggests that it is the Clintons slush fund. He then says some of the donors also paid Bill Clinton millions of dollars to speak. The question in my mind is that if Bill and Hillary can easily make millions of dollars just speaking why would they steal from a charity?

A charity which they have NO fiduciary responsibilities whatsoever. One where no one in their family draws a salary or is paid any income. BTW, you can check all this as the Clintons have been releasing their tax returns for decades. Also, as a charitable foundation, the Clinton Foundation undergoes regular audits.

It's tiresome hearing stupid and moronic accusations over and over based entirely on wild innuendo.
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content
Then I'd suggest more debunking and less personal attacks.

That'd go a long way toward convincing a fence-sitter such as myself.
On the fence? Why? There is zero evidence HRC did anything wrong. There is zero evidence the foundation did anything wrong.

If you want to claim to be waiting until all the evidence surfaces to make up your mind, that make sense. But that isn't on the fence. That's simply waiting until you have all the facts.

If you're on the fence now, you're believing **** that hasn't been proven.

If you're one of those if there's smoke there's fire skeptics, I"m sorry I wasted this minute.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, I can't say for sure what Politifact's motivation is, but their analysis is woefully inadequate. They make a ginormous leap from a program started to address a problem (which was already being addressed by other programs) and success in addressing that problem globally (over a 10 year span) to claiming that means the program in question caused the success. They never showed causation, or even tried. In fact, George Bush's PEPFAR gets most of the credit if you ask people in the field, or in Africa, or at the UN.
This is sort of the Obama way of taking credit for things. You say you want to do X. X happens, eventually, although not in the way that was expected or on the timescale desired. And then he takes credit for X. It's a sham.



So am I one of those?

Interesting. You prefer the "missionary position"? Pepfar was riddled with Republican Fundie Ugly Americanism. It is a prime example of "some good coming from a crap program". You can't deny the statistical successes but you similarly need to examine the statistical failures. Nor can you deny the billions wasted by propping up the Colonial top-down model.

The organization established by Bush required brand name high-end pharmaceuticals. It took intervention by the Global Fund and Bill Clinton to get them onto generics. The organization established by Bush was also steeped in American Christian morality, insistence on ABC - abstention, be faithful, condom use. Those are in preferred order, of course, because the morality of a Congressman from New Jersey is really important to a community facing an HIV epidemic.

The Obama administration decided to not flatline Pepfar but to fix it. They got rid of the requirement to buy from big pharma and reduced the costs per patient by 80%. They now work with the Global Fund and get mutual buying power for drugs and medications. The Supremes had to weigh in on their puritanical "pledge", fer crissake.

And you support that program? Because it's by Georgie the W, and thus you can claim a Republican Win! If it's good for General Pharma, it's good for the USA, by crackie. It filled the coffers of the drug giants, it provided work for Bush cronies, and it provided outreach for American Fundie versions of morality.

Seems a lot of those are the same objections you have about the Clinton Foundation. I'm trying to see a difference, really. Perhaps someone could point out the distinctions?
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content


Here is a link from a charity watchdog that gives the foundation an A rating and says they use an excellent 88% of their funds for charitable programs.

https://www.charitywatch.org/ratings-and-metrics/bill-hillary-chelsea-clinton-foundation/478

big dog is well aware of this. And simply hand waves it away saying that the foundation fooled them. Exactly like a conspiracy theorist would.

Good. There's a start. But instead of a simple linkbarf, may I suggest you follow up with exactly how that link makes The Big Dog a CT?

On the fence? Why? There is zero evidence HRC did anything wrong. There is zero evidence the foundation did anything wrong.

If you want to claim to be waiting until all the evidence surfaces to make up your mind, that make sense. But that isn't on the fence. That's simply waiting until you have all the facts.

If you're on the fence now, you're believing **** that hasn't been proven.

If you're one of those if there's smoke there's fire skeptics, I"m sorry I wasted this minute.

Your post is notable for the lack of debunking and trying to make it about me. Thanks anyway.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good. There's a start. But instead of a simple linkbarf, may I suggest you follow up with exactly how that link makes The Big Dog a CT?.

He claims with no evidence whatsoever that the Clinton Foundation isn't a charity and is really a Clinton slush fund. A textbook conspiracy theory. The link debunks that. It is a charity and a good one at that. And in typical conspiracy theory fashion he just hand waves it away saying they were fooled.
 
He claims with no evidence whatsoever that the Clinton Foundation isn't a charity and is really a Clinton slush fund. A textbook conspiracy theory. The link debunks that. It is a charity and a good one at that. And in typical conspiracy theory fashion he just hand waves it away saying they were fooled.

589.gif
 
Why this thread is not in Conspiracy Theories subforum yet?

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
But sure, I will indulge with one example.

There is other charity watch (other than one that Tony Stark mentioned last) called Charity Navigator. It dropped rating from Clinton's Foundation, since they cannot evaluate it with their current methods. Note that "not rated" is not same thing as "zero stars".

Big Dog mispresented it in extremely dishonest way:
Unrated slush fund's "atypical business model can not be accurately captured in our current rating methodology." Charity Navigator.
And of course, in order to maintain his whacked out conspiracy theory claim he has to completely ignore the fact that the reputable charity watchdog refuses to rate the Clinton Foundation.
Check out charity navigator, they did not get scammed by those scumbags.


Charity Navigator clearly states:
Why isn't this organization rated?
We had previously evaluated this organization, but have since determined that this charity's atypical business model can not be accurately captured in our current rating methodology. Our removal of The Clinton Foundation from our site is neither a condemnation nor an endorsement of this charity. We reserve the right to reinstate a rating for The Clinton Foundation as soon as we identify a rating methodology that appropriately captures its business model.
What does it mean that this organization isn’t rated?
It simply means that the organization doesn't meet our criteria. A lack of a rating does not indicate a positive or negative assessment by Charity Navigator.


Let me repeat most important statements there:
Our removal of The Clinton Foundation from our site is neither a condemnation nor an endorsement of this charity. (...) A lack of a rating does not indicate a positive or negative assessment by Charity Navigator.

Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content

Which is why I've asked that this be moved to the Conspiracy Theory subforum. I doubt it'll happen, but it don't hurt to ask I guess.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good. There's a start. But instead of a simple linkbarf, may I suggest you follow up with exactly how that link makes The Big Dog a CT?

May I suggest you read the entire thread? Big Dog has offered endless claims unsupported by any evidence, indeed claims that are contradicted by the available evidence. Calling him a CT or not is largely semantics. On topic can you point to the posts that have you 'on the fence' as to whether the claims made are true or not?

To make it simple those claims are:

1) Donors to the Clinton Foundation received special access to or favours from Hilary Clinton in her role as SoS in return for making those donations.

2) That the CF was used as a 'slush fund' or milked by the Clintons to fund their lifestyle.

So please if you could just point to the evidence that has you thinking these claims might be true?
 
It is not difficult to debate without making it personal. It is not difficult to debate while being civil and polite. It's not even difficult to address the arguments rather than attack arguers.

And yet, here I am having to go through post after post of incivilities and personal attacks, despite every single one of you being well aware that such things breach rule 0 and rule 12.

I could throw posts to AAH, hand out a bunch of yellows, put the thread on moderated status and/or suggest that a little vacation might concentrate minds on the Membership Agreement. That still might happen. However, I'd rather that you took responsibility yourselves for posting within the MA, rather than breaching the rules and waiting for a mod to clear up.

So take this modbox as an instruction to post within your MA; if further moderator attention is needed to this thread then the consequence will be less than pleasant for those who continue to breach the rules.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
The ethics agreement hillary signed in 2009 and that was linked earlier in the thread of course.

We're pretty sure what the ethics agreement says. The request was for you to provide evidence that she exchanged meetings for donations. No fair falling back on the dubious statistical research of sunmaster. Real evidence.
 
The ethics agreement hillary signed in 2009 and that was linked earlier in the thread of course.

Yeah simply saying she met with people who made donations is not the same as saying they got meetings because they made donations. When you can provide evidence of the latter there will be something to discuss.
 
So let's say that's true. Let's even go farther than that. Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him. My question is "so what?" Everyone including Republicans agree that the Foundation is an excellent charity that does good work all over the world. What is wrong with the SecState acknowledging this and taking a meeting?

What do you think the Secretary of State does? Isn't it about foreign relations? Here is an opportunity to have a tangible effect. Why the hell not?

Yes, "taking a meeting" in exchange for money for her foundation is EXACTLY what is proscribed by her "ethics" agreement.

C'mon people, have you not read the agreements yet? Do so.

And your evidence for this claim?

The ethics agreement hillary signed in 2009 and that was linked earlier in the thread of course.

Yeah simply saying she met with people who made donations is not the same as saying they got meetings because they made donations. When you can provide evidence of the latter there will be something to discuss.

I have laid out the exact issue that I was discussing. If you have questions about the scenario proposed by acbytesla you will wish to address it with him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom