Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

I have laid out the exact issue that I was discussing. If you have questions about the scenario proposed by acbytesla you will wish to address it with him.

No, you are the one who claims the ethics agreement was breached and thus have the responsibility for supporting that claim. Again to be clear, simply saying that Clinton met people who donated to the Foundation is not evidence of a breach. Only if one directly led to the other would there be a breach.

It simply can't be that hard to offer evidence? A donor with an attack of conscience? A disgruntled staffer? A State Department official angry at being involved in'pay for play'? Anything at all other than dodgy 'statistical analysis'?
 
No, you are the one who claims the ethics agreement was breached and thus have the responsibility for supporting that claim. Again to be clear, simply saying that Clinton met people who donated to the Foundation is not evidence of a breach. Only if one directly led to the other would there be a breach.

That is PRECISELY the scenario proposed by acbytesla. Once AGAIN I reiterate that I was responding to this scenario:

Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him.

My question is "so what?"
 
As I've said there times now in this thread, your body of work WRT sourcing and citations cannot in any way be trusted to support whatever argument you think it does.

In short, we've clicked your links before, many times, and they're severely lacking. Start showing good faith and maybe we'll start clicking again.

You want evidence but then admit you don't read the evidence he provides, yet you still respond to his posts with personal attacks or other forum violations.

If you don't care to actually debate his arguments and evidence then either put him on ignore or scroll past
 
That is PRECISELY the scenario proposed by acbytesla. Once AGAIN I reiterate that I was responding to this scenario:

There is a difference between taking a meeting and making a foreign policy decision. One matters, the other, not so much.
 
this thread isn't about me.
Indeed. But isn't it wonderful to have our own hall monitor checking all the liberals passes?

I agree with you. using that famous definition of insanity as a basis, it make prefect sense to stop clicking links until we can expect a different result.
 
There is a difference between taking a meeting and making a foreign policy decision. One matters, the other, not so much.

Here's a question for you Big Dog. What if the CEO from the Gates Foundation contacted Hillary Clinton through her aid and said that the Prince was going to make a large donation to the Gates Foundation's efforts on combating malaria if Hillary met with the prince. Would it be wrong for her to take that meeting?
 
Here's a question for you Big Dog. What if the CEO from the Gates Foundation contacted Hillary Clinton through her aid and said that the Prince was going to make a large donation to the Gates Foundation's efforts on combating malaria if Hillary met with the prince. Would it be wrong for her to take that meeting?

Of course
 
Really? You see I think it would be wrong not to. And it would be "ethically" wrong not to.

I disagree. I think it's clearly wrong to allow people to pay (in whatever form) to a 3rd party (i.e. not the US government) in order to have influence with the US government. The property that is being sold (in this case, access to our government's chief diplomat) belongs to the citizens of the country, and it is not Hillary's right to give it away or sell it for the benefit of any other party.
 
I disagree. I think it's clearly wrong to allow people to pay (in whatever form) to a 3rd party (i.e. not the US government) in order to have influence with the US government. The property that is being sold (in this case, access to our government's chief diplomat) belongs to the citizens of the country, and it is not Hillary's right to give it away or sell it for the benefit of any other party.

No its not. You seem to have a misunderstanding what the Secretary of State does. The person in that position is all about America's image abroad. He/she meets with business leaders, NGOs and charities worldwide as well as foreign leaders. That's kind of the job description. If it is in that person's power to improve the lives of people in the US or abroad without compromising America's security or hurting America's business why wouldn't they do it?

As for influence, you pretend that Hillary is going to sell the country out for a donation for malaria medicine. Maybe the influence is a good thing. What if the prince has an idea on how to improve relations with the US or improve the effectiveness of charities at work abroad? Is the Secretary of State limited to listen only to "official channels"?

I guess I take a more practical approach than you do. People who are willing to make large donations to make the world a better place should be listened to.
 
People who are willing to make large donations to make the world a better place should be listened to.

He is not "willing to make large donations to make the world a better place" he is making a donation to get access to the US SoS.
 
Why do I get the sense your hypothetical isn't really hypothetical?

Did it actually happen? :D

Not to my knowledge. What did happen was that Doug Band of the CFC emailed Huma suggesting that the SOS meet with with the crown prince of Bahrain. Someone she had met with several times before. There were no donations contingent on the meeting.

I was just extending the scenario to "what if there was" or "if it was another charity not with the name Clinton on it"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom