Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

And we have another evidence free claim.

ETA: and paying people salaries to run the CF does not count, unless you can demonstrate those salaries and expenses are out of line with other similarly sized charities.

I have repeatedly posted evidence that Blumenthal and Huma were collecting checks from the Foundation while working full time elsewhere.
 
Maybe that comfort you're feeling is from living in a country that wasn't devastated by HIV. There's plenty of "need" to go around. And PEPFAR ignored a whole lot of that need. A) The shrub's Republican-driven program insisted on an high-ground moral stance on prostitution that denied access to millions, and B) By treating it as a typical top-down imperialist colonial policy, they were able to funnel the government's money back into the coffers of Big Pharma - many of whom are NOT American companies, just great big old rich corporations.

Not to mention the huge amount of it that was financed by the American taxpayer, and that one of the items that Pepfar lists is that they proudly support the Global Fund. Why would the shrub need to start Pepfar? There's already a big organization out there tackling HIV/AIDS. Why I suspect it was just self-aggrandizement and a chance for Bush and his cronies to travel the world and book five star hotel rooms. I mean.... "malaria"? Gimme a break! There are already dozens of NGOs out there fighting malaria. Just color me suspicious, that's all.


>>> Are you getting the point, yet? <<<

First of all, PEPFAR turned out to be instrumental to the Global Fund's success. Second of all, this thread isn't about George Bush and whether the success of his anti-AIDS/HIV program was real or illusory. It is about (in part) whether the Clinton Health Access Initiative's (CHAI's) success was real or illusory.

I have seen no evidence that CHAI made a material contribution to the effort. The claims in the annual report are all vague and subjective, and it's not easy to separate out what its contribution might have been. The vagueness of the claims makes me skeptical. Also, I think the burden of proof is on those who claim the Clinton Foundation (including CHAI) has been an effective charity. The fact that it meets all the criteria of a slush fund is obvious. The Clintons and their cronies control the money. The question is "how much of that money went to actual charitable work, and how much went to BS?" The Charity Watch rating tells us nothing because, given how the Clinton Foundation was structured (i.e. as an operating charity and not as a foundation), BS would be counted as charitable work.
 
I have repeatedly posted evidence that Blumenthal and Huma were collecting checks from the Foundation while working full time elsewhere.

And what work did they do for the Foundation? Is their remuneration different from that of people performing the same roles at other charities? if you are going to demonstrate that the CF did anything wrong you need to show it was run in a way that is different from other similar charities, is that really so hard to do? You could just take the word of people like Charity Watch who vet charities, but you've simply chosen to disregard their findings.
 
And what work did they do for the Foundation? Is their remuneration different from that of people performing the same roles at other charities? if you are going to demonstrate that the CF did anything wrong you need to show it was run in a way that is different from other similar charities, is that really so hard to do? You could just take the word of people like Charity Watch who vet charities, but you've simply chosen to disregard their findings.

as far as has been shown, they did nothing at all for the Foundation other than collect checks. In fact, Huma was working full time at State when she was getting those checks (oh and checks from Teneo too, and the Clintons personally)

People at the foundation openly complained about Blumenthal being hired.
 
Also, I think the burden of proof is on those who claim the Clinton Foundation (including CHAI) has been an effective charity.

And if the title of this thread was 'The Clinton foundation is a wonderful charity' you would be right. Since however The OP is based on the claim that it was used for influence peddling/slush fund the burden of proof is on those like yourself supporting those claims.
 
as far as has been shown, they did nothing at all for the Foundation other than collect checks. In fact, Huma was working full time at State when she was getting those checks (oh and checks from Teneo too, and the Clintons personally)

People at the foundation openly complained about Blumenthal being hired.

So does 'as far as has been shown' mean they did they did nothing or that you didn't try to find out? And what about those other charities? Surely you must have done a comparison to see how far out of line the Clinton Foundation is?

Oh and could you post the names of some of those people who complained openly? or point me to the post where you did so?
 
So does 'as far as has been shown' mean they did they did nothing or that you didn't try to find out? And what about those other charities? Surely you must have done a comparison to see how far out of line the Clinton Foundation is?

Oh and could you post the names of some of those people who complained openly? or point me to the post where you did so?

False dichotomy.

On May 18 the New York Times reported that longtime Clinton family associate Sidney Blumenthal was working with individuals who had business interests in Libya at the same time that he sent Secretary of State Hillary Clinton what she's described as "unsolicited" intelligence reports about that country. It's also been known that Blumenthal worked for the nonprofit Clinton Foundation at that time. A Politico story now reports more about Blumenthal's role with the Foundation: He was paid $10,000 a month for "full-time" work whose value was apparently questioned by other staffers.

http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slat...clinton_foundation_salary_10_000_a_month.html
 
So?

Do you take issue with folks working more than 1 job?

I don't. Blumenthal is pretty much a non-issue for me. He was a friend of the Clintons and I don't see anything wrong with hiring your friends; Blunenthal had no real influence in the US government other than having a close relationship with the Clintons. Not a big deal, really.

Where I do have a problem is when one of those jobs is working directly under the Secretary of State. Huma Abedin most certainly had influence in the US government as Deputy Chief of Staff. She should not have two jobs, especially working for the SOS's charity dealing with donors. That's a huge red flag.
 
I don't. Blumenthal is pretty much a non-issue for me. He was a friend of the Clintons and I don't see anything wrong with hiring your friends; Blunenthal had no real influence in the US government other than having a close relationship with the Clintons. Not a big deal, really.

Where I do have a problem is when one of those jobs is working directly under the Secretary of State. Huma Abedin most certainly had influence in the US government as Deputy Chief of Staff. She should not have two jobs, especially working for the SOS's charity dealing with donors. That's a huge red flag.

well except as pointed out, he started collecting a paycheck from the Foundation AFTER Obama vetoed his hiring in the State Department and then proceeded to act as Hillary's private intelligence agency without portfolio, and send her half ass intelligence reports that Hillary passed on to Senior staff at State.
 
False dichotomy.

Asking you to show there was a difference between the operation of the Clinton Foundation and other charities is a 'false dichotomy'? So you have no basis for judging the actions or employment practices of the CF?




So we've gone from $200,000 dollars to $100,000 dollars and from staffers 'openly' complaining to 'apparently', and still no evidence of impropriety.
 
Asking you to show there was a difference between the operation of the Clinton Foundation and other charities is a 'false dichotomy'? So you have no basis for judging the actions or employment practices of the CF?

So we've gone from $200,000 dollars to $100,000 dollars and from staffers 'openly' complaining to 'apparently', and still no evidence of impropriety.

Several blatant Rule of So strawmen.

He collected $120,000 per year from The Clinton Foundation, $200,000 from media matters affiliates.

Please get the basic facts correct.

It is your claim the other charities hired people like Blumenthal. Feel free to prove it if you wish, I think it is a silly argument given what we know Blumenthal was doing while on that payroll (sending Hillary faulty intelligence). Kindly, however refrain from shifting the burden of an argument you created out of whole cloth to me.

Prove that other charities hire political hacks like Sid Blumenthal after being vetoed for a position with the State Department and I will show you another pay for play operation like the CFF
 
Last edited:
Several blatant Rule of So strawmen.

He collected $120,000 per year from The Clinton Foundation, $200,000 from media matters affiliates.

Please get the basic facts correct.

It is your claim the other charities hired people like Blumenthal. Feel free to prove it if you wish, I think it is a silly argument given what we know Blumenthal was doing while on that payroll (sending Hillary faulty intelligence). Kindly, however refrain from shifting the burden of an argument you created out of whole cloth to me.

Prove that other charities hire political hacks like Sid Blumenthal after being vetoed for a position with the State Department and I will show you another pay for play operation like the CFF

No at the heart of this is the claim that the CF was operated as some sort of slush fund, or that favours were done by Hilary Clinton as SoS in exchange for donations. So showing that the CF operated differently from other charities would be a significant step to doing so, especially given a major charity watchdog gave it an A rating, strongly suggesting it has done nothing out of the ordinary. At this point not one shred of evidence has been shown that Clinton spent CF money to fund her lifestyle or political campaign, nor that she in anyway shape or form used her office to provide favours to those who donated. Show either of those things happened, it really is that simple.
 
I don't. Blumenthal is pretty much a non-issue for me. He was a friend of the Clintons and I don't see anything wrong with hiring your friends; Blunenthal had no real influence in the US government other than having a close relationship with the Clintons. Not a big deal, really.

Where I do have a problem is when one of those jobs is working directly under the Secretary of State. Huma Abedin most certainly had influence in the US government as Deputy Chief of Staff. She should not have two jobs, especially working for the SOS's charity dealing with donors. That's a huge red flag.
Yeah, I know more smoke :rolleyes:

Death by a thousand unfounded accusations cuts, that's the Republican plan. Sadly it works for some.
 
Several blatant Rule of So strawmen.

He collected $120,000 per year from The Clinton Foundation, $200,000 from media matters affiliates.

Please get the basic facts correct.

It is your claim the other charities hired people like Blumenthal. Feel free to prove it if you wish, I think it is a silly argument given what we know Blumenthal was doing while on that payroll (sending Hillary faulty intelligence). Kindly, however refrain from shifting the burden of an argument you created out of whole cloth to me.

Prove that other charities hire political hacks like Sid Blumenthal after being vetoed for a position with the State Department and I will show you another pay for play operation like the CFF
What a bunch of amorphous crap. What or who is people LIKE Blumenthal? I can show you politically connected people from both parties as CEOs, board members and advisors with major charities. One who comes to mind is Samantha King. I'm sure there are lots of others.

What I keep reading in your posts, is bs piled onto bs. You have nothing that even appears as corruption but that doesn't slow down this absurd ridiculous innuendo you keep slathering into every post.

It's the same thing every time. You post some fact or falsehood and say, it's the smoking gun. Yet it's not. Hundreds of posts and there is nothing to see unless you're squinting with Clinton Hater glasses on.

Take them off. It might help your objectivity.
 
I don't. Blumenthal is pretty much a non-issue for me. He was a friend of the Clintons and I don't see anything wrong with hiring your friends; Blunenthal had no real influence in the US government other than having a close relationship with the Clintons. Not a big deal, really.

Where I do have a problem is when one of those jobs is working directly under the Secretary of State. Huma Abedin most certainly had influence in the US government as Deputy Chief of Staff. She should not have two jobs, especially working for the SOS's charity dealing with donors. That's a huge red flag.
Agreed. It was/is incredibly sloppy and inappropriate.
 
Agreed. It was/is incredibly sloppy and inappropriate.

True but it in no way speaks to the issue of whether the CF is being run as a slush fund or Clinton abused her position as SoS to provide access/favours in exchange for donations.
 
One thing I learned from all this:

The Clinton Foundation seems to have done quite a lot of good in the world, and I was not previously aware of this. This makes me considerably happier to vote for Hillary in the election.
 
One thing I learned from all this:

The Clinton Foundation seems to have done quite a lot of good in the world, and I was not previously aware of this. This makes me considerably happier to vote for Hillary in the election.

I know, right? I had no idea. It's amazing what you learn when you're made to study a little.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom