Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

True but it in no way speaks to the issue of whether the CF is being run as a slush fund or Clinton abused her position as SoS to provide access/favours in exchange for donations.

I don't think there's much evidence that the CF is a "slush fund." But I do think that if high-level State employees also have high-level jobs in the CF then it does speak to the issue of potential pay-for-play.
 
Yeah, I know more smoke :rolleyes:

Death by a thousand unfounded accusations cuts, that's the Republican plan. Sadly it works for some.

They aren't unfounded accusations; the fact that high-level State employees also worked for the CF gives foundation. Let me give you an analogy:

Federal law prohibits doctors who take Medicare and/or Medicaid (virtually every doctor) and their close family members from owning a stake in labs, imaging centers, home health agencies -any independant ancillary service. These are the famous Stark Laws that severely restrict physician practice. The operating principle of these laws is conflict of interest -that a physician would have a financial incentive to refer inappropriately to services they might benefit from. Just the possibility that fraud will happen is apparently enough to legally restrain doctors from businesses that they would otherwise naturally have an interest in. It doesn't matter if a doctor actually refers inappropriately or not; if the relationship is found, the doctor is violating the law and is fined quite severely. Here is a case where the government sees smoke and immediately assumes there is fire.

Why shouldn't we judge Clinton by the same standards? She (and all high-level government officials) should be very careful not to even give the appearance that there is corruption. She may not be doing anything wrong but the potential for wrong-doing should be enough for us to say that she acted inappropriately.
 
They aren't unfounded accusations; the fact that high-level State employees also worked for the CF gives foundation. Let me give you an analogy:

Federal law prohibits doctors who take Medicare and/or Medicaid (virtually every doctor) and their close family members from owning a stake in labs, imaging centers, home health agencies -any independant ancillary service. These are the famous Stark Laws that severely restrict physician practice. The operating principle of these laws is conflict of interest -that a physician would have a financial incentive to refer inappropriately to services they might benefit from. Just the possibility that fraud will happen is apparently enough to legally restrain doctors from businesses that they would otherwise naturally have an interest in. It doesn't matter if a doctor actually refers inappropriately or not; if the relationship is found, the doctor is violating the law and is fined quite severely. Here is a case where the government sees smoke and immediately assumes there is fire.

Why shouldn't we judge Clinton by the same standards? She (and all high-level government officials) should be very careful not to even give the appearance that there is corruption. She may not be doing anything wrong but the potential for wrong-doing should be enough for us to say that she acted inappropriately.

Just because you hire someone you know doesn't meant that there is corruption. Your analogy is also not even close. You're talking about doctors referring people to certain medicines\centers based on their investment. Hillary wasn't "invested" in the government, she wasn't profiting from these people working there.

I guess the company I'm going to work for is completely corrupt. My friend got me the Net Admin job because we've known each other for years, he knows the type of person I am, and that he'll get good solid work from me (We called them references back "in my day"). I also loaned him about $1,000 a few months ago. Neither are connected. I supported a friend, and he ALSO knows what kind of an employee I'd make. They can be separate. You've already admitted that the CF wasn't a slush fund. Why would it matter if Hillary hired him and he'd donated? The link here is pretty flimsy.
 
Last edited:
I don't think there's much evidence that the CF is a "slush fund." But I do think that if high-level State employees also have high-level jobs in the CF then it does speak to the issue of potential pay-for-play.

Or it means that Clinton wanted reliable people in both organizations. Again there is zero evidence provided of any actual pay-for-play.
 
Just because you hire someone you know doesn't meant that there is corruption. Your analogy is also not even close. You're talking about doctors referring people to certain medicines\centers based on their investment. Hillary wasn't "invested" in the government, she wasn't profiting from these people working there.
I think the analogy isn't perfect but it illustrates the problems with conflict of interest and how seriously the government treats even the hint of a conflict in other contexts. Clinton was Secretary of State, a cabinet position with influence over the President and foreign policy. It would be blatantly illegal for her to take money from foreign governments. It may not be illegal for a foreign government to donate to her charity but it gives the appearance of a conflict of interest. Therefore, if the appearance of a conflict (even without evidence of any wrong doing) is enough to heavily fine doctors, then it should at least be enough for us to question Clinton's motives.

I guess the company I'm going to work for is completely corrupt. My friend got me the Net Admin job because we've known each other for years, he knows the type of person I am, and that he'll get good solid work from me (We called them references back "in my day). I also loaned him about $1,000 a few months ago. Neither are connected. I supported a friend, and he ALSO knows what kind of an employee I'd make. They can be separate. You've already admitted that the CF wasn't a slush fund. Why would it matter if Hillary hired him and he'd donated? The link here is pretty flimsy.
Because who cares how private businesses hire people? It's their money. With the high level government officials, there is the potential for influence peddling. That potential should be enough to make it a very bad thing for even creating a situation that looks like influence peddling. That's OUR money and OUR national policy.
 
I think the analogy isn't perfect but it illustrates the problems with conflict of interest and how seriously the government treats even the hint of a conflict in other contexts.

Because that deals with the literal life and death situation of a patient. They may do something that isn't in the best interest of the patient, who is in their care, because they want money. Again, totally different.

Clinton was Secretary of State, a cabinet position with influence over the President and foreign policy. It would be blatantly illegal for her to take money from foreign governments.

Which, of course, she didn't.

It may not be illegal for a foreign government to donate to her charity but it gives the appearance of a conflict of interest.

Who cares about appearances? You're admitting that you know there wasn't any problem, or any pay to play, so is your big gripe about the appearance? It seems like any rational person would say, "That appears to be corrupt." Then look at it and say, "Oh, but it isn't. Cool." End of story. 9/11 looks like a conspiracy by the government to some people, that doesn't make it true.

Therefore, if the appearance of a conflict (even without evidence of any wrong doing) is enough to heavily fine doctors, then it should at least be enough for us to question Clinton's motives.

Question them all you want. No one is trying to stifle you're questioning. That's all you've been doing is questioning and no one here has told you not to. There comes a time when you have questioned it all, looked at the available evidence and say, "I was wrong." That's it. We know that she didn't hire those people because they donated. Yes, people you know will sometimes donate to charities you run. Hell, I buy coupon books I will never use for $20 because it supports my friends' kids that are going to band camp. I donate to a charity called "Food for Crude" in North Dakota because I know someone that helps manage it. It's called a social circle.

Because who cares how private businesses hire people? It's their money. With the high level government officials, there is the potential for influence peddling. That potential should be enough to make it a very bad thing for even creating a situation that looks like influence peddling. That's OUR money and OUR national policy.

There will always be potential for anything. It's the literal definition of the word potential. I've been in charge of hiring at multiple places I've worked, and I can tell you that I would hire someone I know, is trustworthy, and can do the job before I'd hire someone else. It's logical, rational, and it makes sense.
 
Last edited:
Or it means that Clinton wanted reliable people in both organizations.
Well, doctors want reliable people running their lab tests, x-rays, etc.
Again there is zero evidence provided of any actual pay-for-play.
And most doctors don't refer inappropriately. It's the appearance of a conflict that is the problem as it should be for the people entrusted to run our government.
 
Because who cares how private businesses hire people? It's their money. With the high level government officials, there is the potential for influence peddling. That potential should be enough to make it a very bad thing for even creating a situation that looks like influence peddling. That's OUR money and OUR national policy.

Well first off the fact that these individuals worked for both organizations is matter of public record and no one has suggested that this is a criminal/ethical issue in itself, I was under the impression its quite common for staffers and politicians to have outside interests so long as they are declared. Secondly how exactly would working for the CF influence national policy? Are you suggesting that the CF was somehow acting against US national interests in it's activities?
 
Or it means that Clinton wanted reliable people in both organizations. Again there is zero evidence provided of any actual pay-for-play.

well, Hillary signed an ethics agreement that said she was not supposed to be involved in those decisions.

Plus that claim is demonstrably false because she wanted Sid Blumenthal at State and her selection was vetoed by Obama, but he was hired by the CFF anyway.
 
well, Hillary signed an ethics agreement that said she was not supposed to be involved in those decisions.

The ethics agreement said she couldn't hire anyone from The Clinton Foundation and that The Clinton Foundation couldn't hire anyone that used to work at the State Department? Can you show me that part? I read through it and I didn't see anything like that at all.

Plus that claim is demonstrably false because she wanted Sid Blumenthal at State and her selection was vetoed by Obama, but he was hired by the CFF anyway.

Wait, the CFF can't even hire people that DIDN'T work for the government? She asked for him to work at State, the Pres. vetoed it so he went to work at her charity, while she wasn't running it. She didn't take any bribes through him, his emails are mostly tracked through the Benghazi release to have shown....really nothing at all. So even if she doesn't do anything bad, she's still a problem? :confused:
 
Because that deals with the literal life and death situation of a patient. They may do something that isn't in the best interest of the patient, who is in their care, because they want money. Again, totally different.
This deals with issues of national security and foreign and domestic policy. The Secretary of State may be influenced to back deals that aren't good for the American people to help out people who donated to her charity. That is not different.



Which, of course, she didn't.
But her charity did. Russia donated and got their Uranium deal. Even if there was no wrong doing it sure looks like there was. Just like even if doctors don't do anything wrong, the appearance is enough to fine them.



Who cares about appearances?
The Federal Government obviously cares. And President Obama sure does. He asked the Foundation, as a condition of Clinton's appointment to SOS, to sign a Memorandum of Understanding that sought to avoid situations where there could be an appearance of a conflict of interest.
You're admitting that you know there wasn't any problem, or any pay to play, so is your big gripe about the appearance? It seems like any rational person would say, "That appears to be corrupt." Then look at it and say, "Oh, but it isn't. Cool." End of story. 9/11 looks like a conspiracy by the government to some people, that doesn't make it true.
That doesn't fly in the real world. If a public official's financial holdings make it possible that there could be a conflict of interest, they are required to divest themselves of the holding or be disqualified. It doesn't matter if they actually do anything that is a conflict of interest. The potential is enough to make it against the rules.


Question them all you want. No one is trying to stifle you're questioning. That's all you've been doing is questioning and no one here has told you not to. There comes a time when you have questioned it all, looked at the available evidence and say, "I was wrong." That's it. We know that she didn't hire those people because they donated.
Actually, I don't know that. Why did she put Rajiv Fernando on that nuclear policy committee? It looks to me like it was because he was a donor; he certainly wasn't qualified to be on that board.
Yes, people you know will sometimes donate to charities you run. Hell, I buy coupon books I will never use for $20 because it supports my friends' kids that are going to band camp. I donate to a charity called "Food for Crude" in North Dakota because I know someone that helps manage it. It's called a social circle.
Now imagine that the manager of that charity is Secretary of State. You are a big donor who calls up and asks to be put on a committee that you have no qualifications for. Should she put you on that committee?

There will always be potential for anything. It's the literal definition of the word potential. I've been in charge of hiring at multiple places I've worked, and I can tell you that I would hire someone I know, is trustworthy, and can do the job before I'd hire someone else. It's logical, rational, and it makes sense.
Sure, private companies can hire however they want to. But we are talking about positions of public trust. Doctors are entrusted with public funds to provision healthcare appropriately; self-referrals create the potential of impropriety so that is banned. Public officials are entrusted to serve the public good and the USA above their own gain; they are banned from relationships that create even a potential conflict of interest. Public vs private enterprise.
 
Well first off the fact that these individuals worked for both organizations is matter of public record and no one has suggested that this is a criminal/ethical issue in itself, I was under the impression its quite common for staffers and politicians to have outside interests so long as they are declared.
Sure, it's usually not a problem. But when your Deputy Chief of Staff also works for your charity, apparently as a gatekeeper between Foundation donors and the State Department, I think the problems are obvious.
Secondly how exactly would working for the CF influence national policy? Are you suggesting that the CF was somehow acting against US national interests in it's activities?

No, I'm suggesting that granting CF donors privileged access to SOS can influence national policy in the direction that CF donors want. That shouldn't happen.
 
This deals with issues of national security and foreign and domestic policy. The Secretary of State may be influenced to back deals that aren't good for the American people to help out people who donated to her charity. That is not different.

*snip*

Sure, private companies can hire however they want to. But we are talking about positions of public trust. Doctors are entrusted with public funds to provision healthcare appropriately; self-referrals create the potential of impropriety so that is banned. Public officials are entrusted to serve the public good and the USA above their own gain; they are banned from relationships that create even a potential conflict of interest. Public vs private enterprise.

Alright bud, I think I'm good. It's pretty clear that I think most of what you're saying is just grasping at straws. All you've talked about is "appearances" when the evidence that's available about Clinton and the investigations into everything she's done have found nothing. If they investigated those doctors and found no wrongdoing, there would be absolutely no fine at all. So I'm good. Thanks for the chat.
 
Sure, it's usually not a problem. But when your Deputy Chief of Staff also works for your charity, apparently as a gatekeeper between Foundation donors and the State Department, I think the problems are obvious.
Yes, I've highlighted it. It's true, if we make **** up, we get to justify whatever beliefs we like.
No, I'm suggesting that granting CF donors privileged access to SOS can influence national policy in the direction that CF donors want. That shouldn't happen.
I guess "can" is good enough for you. Me, I'll assign guilt when evidence is proven.

This is just like the email thread. Internet judge jury and executioners waddling around "off with her head". When found not guilty, it's a lie it's a conspiracy.

This is critical thinking and is 100% fine here. Makes me want to vomit.
 
Last edited:
So remember how the big dog was claiming that Charity Navigator saw through the Clinton Foundation (as opposed to Charity Watch) and thus didn't rate them. Though of course in the real world, the lack of a rating meant neither a positive or a negative assessment, as they said.

They also said they reserved the right to give it a rating at a later time. Well they just did...four stars/four and 94.74/100. I guess that proves that they were fooled/bought off to as that is what is necessary in order to maintain the whacked out conspiracy theory that the Clinton Foundation is a slush fund and not a charity.

https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=16680
 
Last edited:
So remember how the big dog was claiming that Charity Navigator saw through the Clinton Foundation (as opposed to Charity Watch) and thus didn't rate them. Though of course in the real world, the lack of a rating meant neither a positive or a negative accessment, as they said.

They also said they reserved the right to give it a rating at a later time. Well they just did...four stars/four and 94.74/100. I guess that proves that they were fooled/bought off to as that is what is necessary in order to maintain the whacked out conspiracy theory that the Clinton Foundation is a slush fund and not a charity.

https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=16680


Nothing better than straw men ad hom tu quoques?

She's scum. Scum, I say! Burn the Witch. Benghazi Blumenthal Whitewater FBI Pay-for-Play Blue Dress DuckingBullets ChairmanGowdy HealthProblems VictimBlaming Pantsuits VinceFoster Travelgate arf arf woof woof scum I say burn her bark bark arf arf
 
Last edited:
No, I'm suggesting that granting CF donors privileged access to SOS can influence national policy in the direction that CF donors want. That shouldn't happen.

Well I would imagine anyone who meets the SoS is looking to influence national policy and you have failed to demonstrate that people have been granted access because they made donations. How many of these donors are people who had met with previous/succeeding SoS? How many were people who would have been able to get a meeting regardless of donating?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom