It's not racism to make a true statement about a group of people. The ancient Hebrews were almost entirely illiterate. They had an oral history because of that fact. I've heard arguments that they likely made their living off of hearding goats, but 1) am aware that no culture can survive entirely in such a fashion (you need craftsmen and sedentary farmers, at minimum), and 2) am willing to be proven wrong here.
This statement isn't racism for another, more subtle reason, though: It wasn't JUST the Hebrews that were illiterate and largely herdsmen. EVERYONE in that time and in that place was. The Hebrews aren't singled out here; atheists don't believe what any of the other illiterate goat-herding tribes said either. The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.
So it's not "Because they're Hebrews they're illiterate goat-herders and therefore are wrong", but rather "These were illiterate goat-herders and were wrong; oh, and they happened to be Hebrews".
The thing is, no one talks about other societies like that or makes that sort of response to other historical issues. For instance, would you really think someone would dismissively say "Tacitus wrote for a bunch of illiterate farmers" or anything like that? It was also incredibly bizarre to claim that a book was written for the illiterate in the first place for obvious reasons. The NT in particular specifically includes documents written from one person to another to read, not just stuff to be read before a crowd or something. So even if we agree on the vast majority of people being illiterate (and since the original post lumped the NT and therefore the Jews of the 1st and 2nd century in there, I'm not sure if that would apply that well to the later periods), it's really irrelevent, since those illiterate people weren't the ones who were writing or being written for.
Basically, the whole "illiterate goat herders" and "bronze age goat herders" and the like doesn't add a thing to any real discussion and is only used to be dismissive of a text. And the fact that it seems to be specifically ancient Jews who are the ones described dismissively like this rather than, say, the Greeks and Romans really does give off a racist vibe, even if it's completely unintentional.
I should note that I'm not using this as any sort of defense of the Biblical texts or that one shouldn't keep in mind the issues ancient people had with sources. I'm an atheist, and I find claims like the Mosaic authorship of anything to be as ridiculous as everyone else here.
Last edited: