If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

It's not racism to make a true statement about a group of people. The ancient Hebrews were almost entirely illiterate. They had an oral history because of that fact. I've heard arguments that they likely made their living off of hearding goats, but 1) am aware that no culture can survive entirely in such a fashion (you need craftsmen and sedentary farmers, at minimum), and 2) am willing to be proven wrong here.

This statement isn't racism for another, more subtle reason, though: It wasn't JUST the Hebrews that were illiterate and largely herdsmen. EVERYONE in that time and in that place was. The Hebrews aren't singled out here; atheists don't believe what any of the other illiterate goat-herding tribes said either. The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.

So it's not "Because they're Hebrews they're illiterate goat-herders and therefore are wrong", but rather "These were illiterate goat-herders and were wrong; oh, and they happened to be Hebrews".

The thing is, no one talks about other societies like that or makes that sort of response to other historical issues. For instance, would you really think someone would dismissively say "Tacitus wrote for a bunch of illiterate farmers" or anything like that? It was also incredibly bizarre to claim that a book was written for the illiterate in the first place for obvious reasons. The NT in particular specifically includes documents written from one person to another to read, not just stuff to be read before a crowd or something. So even if we agree on the vast majority of people being illiterate (and since the original post lumped the NT and therefore the Jews of the 1st and 2nd century in there, I'm not sure if that would apply that well to the later periods), it's really irrelevent, since those illiterate people weren't the ones who were writing or being written for.

Basically, the whole "illiterate goat herders" and "bronze age goat herders" and the like doesn't add a thing to any real discussion and is only used to be dismissive of a text. And the fact that it seems to be specifically ancient Jews who are the ones described dismissively like this rather than, say, the Greeks and Romans really does give off a racist vibe, even if it's completely unintentional.


I should note that I'm not using this as any sort of defense of the Biblical texts or that one shouldn't keep in mind the issues ancient people had with sources. I'm an atheist, and I find claims like the Mosaic authorship of anything to be as ridiculous as everyone else here.
 
Last edited:
It's not just that--the use of words changes over time. Thomas Paine makes a very good argument that "to prophesy" used to mean "to make music", including numerous chapters and verses that are nonsensical if you use the modern definition of the verb but which are perfectly logical if you use Paine's interpretation. I wasn't referring to science in my post, but to linguistics.

That's one of the odd quirks of bible literalism. It tends to be tied to the King James version specifically. Partly this is for the obvious reason that most bible literalists are weak on Greek and Hebrew. It's also because it's a reasonably fixed point. If you don't go with the King James, then you have to select from a wide range of alternatives, all with their own agendas. The trouble with KJ is that it's written in an archaic English, which needs to be interpreted. It's certainly not obvious what the words mean - so there has to be a translation of a translation. It's also the case that King James commissioned his translation partly as a conservative reaction to the radical Tyndale version. He certainly didn't want the divine right of kings undermined. Oddly, in the USA the KJ tends to be venerated by the same patriots who revere the Pilgrim Fathers who fled from James' religious persecution.

The arguments that get under the skin of our resident Biblical literalists the most amount to exactly this as well--they say that the literal interpretation presented by atheists is wrong, because it violates their literalistic interpretation.

It's not racism to make a true statement about a group of people. The ancient Hebrews were almost entirely illiterate. They had an oral history because of that fact. I've heard arguments that they likely made their living off of hearding goats, but 1) am aware that no culture can survive entirely in such a fashion (you need craftsmen and sedentary farmers, at minimum), and 2) am willing to be proven wrong here.

This statement isn't racism for another, more subtle reason, though: It wasn't JUST the Hebrews that were illiterate and largely herdsmen. EVERYONE in that time and in that place was. The Hebrews aren't singled out here; atheists don't believe what any of the other illiterate goat-herding tribes said either. The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.

So it's not "Because they're Hebrews they're illiterate goat-herders and therefore are wrong", but rather "These were illiterate goat-herders and were wrong; oh, and they happened to be Hebrews".

I think it's reasonable to expect people living as the Hebrews did to be ignorant of scientific issues compared with ourselves, but that doesn't necessarily mean that their culture was morally inferior.
 
Gao said:
The thing is, no one talks about other societies like that or makes that sort of response to other historical issues. For instance, would you really think someone would dismissively say "Tacitus wrote for a bunch of illiterate farmers" or anything like that?
It was either Pliney the Elder or Virgil, I forget which, that wrote about the ecology of dragons, including statements such as elephants being their natural enemies. Yes, I HAVE heard people dismiss the writings of people who didn't know any better as simply too ignorant to address. It's a consequence of dealing with Quaternary paleontology--you get to sift through a number of myths.

It was also incredibly bizarre to claim that a book was written for the illiterate in the first place for obvious reasons.
No one ever claimed that. The claim is that the OT is a compelation of oral histories established for people who were illiterate. If you can prove that the OT was written down by ancient Hebrews I'd honestly love to see it. It would be one of the greatest archaeological finds of all time, right up there with King Tut's tomb.

And the fact that it seems to be specifically ancient Jews who are the ones described dismissively like this rather than, say, the Greeks and Romans really does give off a racist vibe, even if it's completely unintentional.
That's actually your problem, not ours. The reason that Hebrews are described as bronze-age goat herders is because the OT was established in the bronze age, and most people of that area were goat herders. The reason Romans aren't described as either is because they WEREN'T either--they were in the iron age (gladiuses and pilums included iron components), and their farming methods were very different (large plantations run by slaves, rather than herding animals). The Greeks were in the bronze age, but again, they lived differently and thus the goat-herder thing doesn't apply. And in both cases comparatively large portions of the population were literate. And please refer to the first line I wrote in this post--we DO dismiss what the Greeks and Romans said as simply too ignorant to be worth our time, all the time.

Finally, it must be remembered that no one is trying to force their ethics on people who don't share them based on the Greeko-Roman pantheon or mythology. People ARE trying to force me to comply with their way of life based on the Jewish mythology (if anyone thinks this is an insult, please look up the term before you fly off the handle). The Jews weren't the only illiterate goat-herding tribe out there at the time, but it's not atheists that are singling them out. The people trying to cram their beliefs down our throats (through such things as dictating reproduction rights according to their beliefs, trying to establish their mythology as science, etc) did so. We're not going to waste our time pointing out the obvious fact that other ignorant goat-herders were ignorant goat-herders just to make a handful of people feel better.
 
westprog said:
I think it's reasonable to expect people living as the Hebrews did to be ignorant of scientific issues compared with ourselves, but that doesn't necessarily mean that their culture was morally inferior.
It also doesn't mean that it's morally superior. And as I've said before, if you're comfortable with a god that's omnipotent and omniscient but can't take the time to explain something as simple as "No, no, lobsters are different from fish--see? No bones", that's fine. But to anyone outside of your belief, it looks exactly like what would happen if a bunch of people with no knowledge of the issue wrote a book pretending it was authored by their god.
 
The thing is, no one talks about other societies like that or makes that sort of response to other historical issues. For instance, would you really think someone would dismissively say "Tacitus wrote for a bunch of illiterate farmers" or anything like that? It was also incredibly bizarre to claim that a book was written for the illiterate in the first place for obvious reasons. The NT in particular specifically includes documents written from one person to another to read, not just stuff to be read before a crowd or something. So even if we agree on the vast majority of people being illiterate (and since the original post lumped the NT and therefore the Jews of the 1st and 2nd century in there, I'm not sure if that would apply that well to the later periods), it's really irrelevent, since those illiterate people weren't the ones who were writing or being written for.

Basically, the whole "illiterate goat herders" and "bronze age goat herders" and the like doesn't add a thing to any real discussion and is only used to be dismissive of a text. And the fact that it seems to be specifically ancient Jews who are the ones described dismissively like this rather than, say, the Greeks and Romans really does give off a racist vibe, even if it's completely unintentional.


I should note that I'm not using this as any sort of defense of the Biblical texts or that one shouldn't keep in mind the issues ancient people had with sources. I'm an atheist, and I find claims like the Mosaic authorship of anything to be as ridiculous as everyone else here.
.
One of the things the Gutenburg Bible achieved was letting the illiterate (non-Latin speaking) population read what's there, in their language. Didn't have to rely on Father Childlover to tell them what he said the book said.
 
The thing is, no one talks about other societies like that or makes that sort of response to other historical issues. For instance, would you really think someone would dismissively say "Tacitus wrote for a bunch of illiterate farmers" or anything like that?

Nobody ever based a religion on the writings of Tacitus, a religion that was responsible for the Crusades, the Inquisition, the Magdalen Laundries and all the other awful things that Christianity has done.
 
It also doesn't mean that it's morally superior. And as I've said before, if you're comfortable with a god that's omnipotent and omniscient but can't take the time to explain something as simple as "No, no, lobsters are different from fish--see? No bones", that's fine. But to anyone outside of your belief, it looks exactly like what would happen if a bunch of people with no knowledge of the issue wrote a book pretending it was authored by their god.

The claim that the bible is a scientific text dictated by god is clearly debunked. However, many of the moral rules starting with the decalogue remain appropriate guidelines today, even among atheists.
 
The claim that the bible is a scientific text dictated by god is clearly debunked. However, many of the moral rules starting with the decalogue remain appropriate guidelines today, even among atheists.

This is hardly a winning argument, as this puts the Bible in the same category as LOTR, the Horatio Hornblower series, etc. And again, if you're comfortable with an omnipotent, omniscient being making a text with glarring and obvious errors, that's your call. But you must admit that from the outside it seems patently rediculous, and undermines the credibility of the claim that the Bible is anything more than the mythology of a group of people not substantially different from any of the other groups of people running around at the time. In other words, if you don't already believe the book is the word of God, there's no reason to draw that conclusion because it's indistinguishable from any other mythology in terms of knowledge of how the world works.
 
The claim that the bible is a scientific text dictated by god is clearly debunked. However, many of the moral rules starting with the decalogue remain appropriate guidelines today, even among atheists.

Exactly. Is it perfectly possible to live a good moral life without the need of one of the many sky daddies.
 
Exactly. Is it perfectly possible to live a good moral life without the need of one of the many sky daddies.

Well, it's more than that. If the author(s) of the Bible can't get the basics right, like lobsters aren't fish and bats aren't birds and rabbits don't chew cud, what are the odds that they got the vastly more complicated stuff right? If you make basic errors you can't expect people to take you seriously when you start talking about bigger issues.
 
Last edited:
Well, it's more than that. If the author(s) of the Bible can't get the basics right, like lobsters aren't fish and bats aren't birds and rabbits don't chew cud, what are the odds that they got the vastly more complicated stuff right? If you make basic errors you can't expect people to take you seriously when you start talking about bigger issues.
But snakes talk. That much we do know. :rolleyes:
 
How did the snake present the apple? Roll it along the ground with its nose?
 
Genesis 3. It's not long.
Genesis 3:1-5.

3 Now the serpent was more crafty than any of the wild animals the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, “Did God really say, ‘You must not eat from any tree in the garden’? ”

2 The woman said to the serpent, “We may eat fruit from the trees in the garden, 3 but God did say, ‘You must not eat fruit from the tree that is in the middle of the garden, and you must not touch it, or you will die.’”

4 “You will not certainly die,” the serpent said to the woman. 5 “For God knows that when you eat from it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.”
So...snakes talk?
 
The snakes have just learned their lesson, that's all.

"Man, it really didn't work out so well the last time we talked. Maybe we should just keep our traps shut from now on."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom