If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't need to prove anything. Cole's video stands by itself. If you are so certain he is wrong, then you have the burden of proof. Again, you can say whatever you want, but words are meaningless without experiment to back them up.

Why not say you have no idea how to back up the failed experiments; you failed at physics, I guess you can't see the experiments don't match the WTC towers in any fashion.
How do you scale up the fire crackers? How much TNT? Can you do the science to help Cole? no
 
It doesn't mean it's all correct or anyone has to do anything.
We are in 100 percent agreement. No one needs to do anything, but, if you want to say Cole is wrong, then prove your statement is correct by performing an experiment. It really is that simple.
 
Why not say you have no idea how to back up the failed experiments; you failed at physics,
Proof? Also, if you could prove I have failed at physics, how does my physics failure affect the results of Cole's experiments?

I guess you can't see the experiments don't match the WTC towers in any fashion.
How do you scale up the fire crackers? How much TNT? Can you do the science to help Cole? no

How do you scale up this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc

Please explain why the NMSR experiment is OK, but Cole's experiment is not.
 
We are in 100 percent agreement. No one needs to do anything, but, if you want to say Cole is wrong, then prove your statement is correct by performing an experiment. It really is that simple.

To save me the hassle, why don't you prove to me he is correct.
 
What I think does not matter. What does matter is that if you want to say that Cole is wrong you need to prove he is wrong by performing an experiment. Simply saying he is wrong is meaningless.

Not true at all. Let's say that Cole's videos were supposed to be to show that ice melts faster when dropped, well then I can certainly say that as far as showing how fast ice melts, Cole's videos are totally useless, I don't need an experiment to prove that, because his experiments clearly have nothing to do with the speed of ice melting.

This is the point, if the experiment done isn't set up in such a way as to show what the person doing the experiment is trying to show, then it doesn't take a further experiment to show that the first experiment was flawed, all that is required is the pointing out of the flaws.

The way you answer questions it is quite clear that you know this, but you are so unwilling to admit it that you dodge and spin and make stuff up to try and avoid how badly the experiments that Cole did were constructed.

This is why you don't get passed the entire Newton's Law stick, but the fact is that Cole is clearly not trying to just show how Newton's Laws work, so demanding that people disprove Newton's Laws to disprove the video is bizarre and you know this, but you're unwilling to back down from your position because it harms your narrative.

The problem is that as far as the building collapse goes, Cole's Videos are useless because his models are not in any way representative of the Tower's construction and so nothing he does in them can be applied directly to what would have happened to the Towers. All his experiments show is that if you drop a large weight onto a stack of wooden boards held up by several different methods then, due to the forces and materials involved, different things happen to them, and this is all it shows.

Trying to extrapolate the results of Cole's experiment to anything beyond his models is the truly pointless and meaningless thing.
 
Last edited:
Please come up with a better trick than this.

The video stands on its own.

So, you haven't read anything at all in this thread. Why did you bother starting a thread and then not reading the responses?
 
Not true at all. Let's say that Cole's videos were supposed to be to show that ice melts faster when dropped, well then I can certainly say that as far as showing how fast ice melts, Cole's videos are totally useless, I don't need an experiment to prove that, because his experiments clearly have nothing to do with the speed of ice melting.

This is an example of a false equivalency, and a poor one at that.

This is the point, if the experiment done isn't set up in such a way as to show what the person doing the experiment is trying to show, then it doesn't take a further experiment to show that the first experiment was flawed, all that is required is the pointing out of the flaws.

That's not the way this works. It's certainly the way you want it to work, but I'm not buying it. If you say Cole's experiment is flawed, perform your own experiment showing why Cole's is flawed.

The problem is that as far as the building collapse goes, Cole's Videos are useless because his models are not in any way representative of the Tower's construction and so nothing he does in them can be applied directly to what would have happened to the Towers. All his experiments show is that if you drop a large weight onto a stack of wooden boards held up by several different methods then, due to the forces involved, different things happen to them, and this is all it shows.

OK. Once again, let me post this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc

Say the exact same thing you just posted about the video above, and all of the other ones like it, that are performed by skeptics.

Go ahead. I dare you.
 
Last edited:
So, you haven't read anything at all in this thread. Why did you bother starting a thread and then not reading the responses?
You should ask yourself this.

I posted a video. Skeptics say the experiment is meaningless and the conclusions are wrong, yet not one skeptic had performed any experiment whatsoever proving Cole's video is wrong.

The question should be, why do skeptics keep posting when they know that words are meaningless?
 
The video has been repeatedly shredded. It is inherently wrong, and your stupid comment that "scale doesn't matter" was also shredded. You have nothing. Cole has nothing. You have been told, and shown, repeatedly that you and Cole have nothing. Your every argument has been demolished. You either read those demolitions of your crap and didn't understand them, or you didn't read them. Which was it?
 
If you want to claim it's a trick, then at least claim it's Cole's trick.

But you started the thread and posted the video. You are by implication endorsing and promoting Cole and his ideas.
It's your burden. not ours.
 
The video has been repeatedly shredded. It is inherently wrong, and your stupid comment that "scale doesn't matter" was also shredded. You have nothing. Cole has nothing. You have been told, and shown, repeatedly that you and Cole have nothing. Your every argument has been demolished. You either read those demolitions of your crap and didn't understand them, or you didn't read them. Which was it?

If you can't show him a Youtube video it doesn’t count.
 
I predict this thread will churn on like this into the summer and if I were to go away until August when I came back it will be in exactly the same place.

It is one of the marks of a CT that nothing is ever conceded, decided or advanced.
 
FalseFlag posted a video FalseFlag can't support with facts and evidence; refuses to

... I posted a video. ...
Which you can't support with evidence; and never will.
You can't summarize Cole's work. As if you failed to study the video; the video you posted and can't support with facts and evidence.
 
But you started the thread and posted the video. You are by implication endorsing and promoting Cole and his ideas.
It's your burden. not ours.

Posting a video does not create any burden.

Making a claim that the video is inaccurate puts the burden of proof on you. If you make the claim, you have the burden to prove that your claim is true. You can choose to use words, but unless you can support your words with experiment, your words are meaningless.

Simple.
 
What I think does not matter. What does matter is that if you want to say that Cole is wrong you need to prove he is wrong by performing an experiment. Simply saying he is wrong is meaningless.

Take a nine volt battery, place it on a flat level surface, then place a triple a battery on top, tap the 9volt with your fingers so it slides forward.

The battery on top will roll backwards do to inertia but the 9volt is not impeded much by the energy transfered to the battery to start it rolling.
That is because the energy to start the battery rolling is less than the energy to move the battery forward.

No I have just propose an experiment that shows Cole is wrong, if you wish to continue then
Please show where the magical mystery force you say exists to prevent the top mass, from falling though the bottom Structure comes from.

You have too account for the energy values and the work, your physics is fatally flawed, no experiments are needed to show the forces are severely out of balance.

Cole's experiments prove nothing more than either he is an incompetent engineer when it comes to doing structual engineering, or more likely a fraudulent one,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom