If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you now trying to say that the reason you've ignored so many posts from so many people is that you didn't see them. :rolleyes:

What? What does your argument have to do with your post?

I answer every post that is relevant. No, I answer more than that. This is a double standard. You want me to answer just so you can get another chance to say I'm wrong without providing conclusive proof I am wrong.

If you just want to talk to someone, there are other places you can do this.
 
Your logic is flawed. You have demonstrated you do not understand Newton's first law. You are the one who does not understand it. If you would keep things simple to start, you might eventually understand it. Then, once you actually understood it, you could move on to more complex examples. Start small. Understand the basics first, then continue on to more complex concepts.


Simply saying that I'm wrong doesn't count. You must clearly prove I'm wrong, with an example citing your sources and reasoning.

Where have I heard that before ? Oh yah you said it. Its a direct quote.

Please entertain us. Explain why I'm wrong.
 
Why doesn't it matter? Is it because you don't want it to matter?
It doesn't matter because the core pulled the perimeter down through the girders, and it's inevitable that it gave way. How the perimeter fell would yield no information on how to prevent the core from collapsing in the first place.
 
Please entertain us. Explain why I'm wrong.
It won't matter. I have already given an example to prove my understanding. I then had a skeptic say my example was not wrong.

I will not waste any more time on this. You refuse to accept basic physics laws. You don't like what I'm saying, even if it's correct. Because of this you will take any of my examples to absurd levels, apply absurd and nonsensical additional scenarios to them, and then say I'm wrong. I know this because you have already done it. I know this because others have already done it. I'm not wasting any more time on this. Learn Newton's first law on your own. You clearly do not understand it right now. Your example is proof of that.
 
If NIST is wrong about freefall, then every single one of their conclusions, measurements, observations and assertions can be called into question. You can't have it both ways.
If NIST is wrong about an insignificant detail that was rushed into the report and has no impact on their analysis, it means nothing of that sort.
 
If your example was truly representative of newtons first law, I should be able to put on a spacesuit, climb inside your vacuum, and give your object a little kick. I'm going to give it an upwards kick like you would a soccer ball. If your example holds true to Newtons first law it should travel in a strait line at a constant speed (uniform motion) forever. Unfortunately you have Earths gravity field in your example, and as soon as I kick it it will start accelerating back towards the surface of the Earth at 9.8m/s/s where it will eventually come to rest.

If your example can't go from rest to uniform motion or vice versa then it is not representative of newtons first law and your application is flawed.

Your logic is flawed. You have demonstrated you do not understand Newton's first law. You are the one who does not understand it. If you would keep things simple to start, you might eventually understand it. Then, once you actually understood it, you could move on to more complex examples. Start small. Understand the basics first, then continue on to more complex concepts.

Wow.
#dunning-kruger
:jaw-dropp
 
It won't matter. I have already given an example to prove my understanding. I then had a skeptic say my example was not wrong.

I will not waste any more time on this. You refuse to accept basic physics laws. You don't like what I'm saying, even if it's correct. Because of this you will take any of my examples to absurd levels, apply absurd and nonsensical additional scenarios to them, and then say I'm wrong. I know this because you have already done it. I know this because others have already done it. I'm not wasting any more time on this. Learn Newton's first law on your own. You clearly do not understand it right now. Your example is proof of that.



In other words you can't come up with a real world example of a object in uniform motion and you don't understand why you can't think of one.

This should be a sign that your understanding Newton is flawed.
 
Are you not capable of providing proof with your statements? Oh, sorry, now I see the NMSR at the end of your NIC, so I know the answer.

I bookmarked your example with "dunning-kruger", not to "prove" anything, but rather as a handy pointer next time I need a classic, obvious example of the Dunning–Kruger effect, "a cognitive bias in which relatively unskilled persons suffer illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability to be much higher than it really is."

One of my favorite scientists said "Science isn't always about 'proooving' this or that, but simply being able to say which things are more or less likely."

You're welcome.
 
In other words you can't come up with a real world example of a object in uniform motion and you don't understand why you can't think of one.

This should be a sign that your understanding Newton is flawed.

A car travels west at a constant speed of 50 miles per hour. That is uniform motion. The direction is constant and the speed it constant.
 
I bookmarked your example with "dunning-kruger", not to "prove" anything, but rather as a handy pointer next time I need a classic, obvious example of the Dunning–Kruger effect, "a cognitive bias in which relatively unskilled persons suffer illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability to be much higher than it really is."

One of my favorite scientists said "Science isn't always about 'proooving' this or that, but simply being able to say which things are more or less likely."

You're welcome.

What you might want to do is prove why the example you quoted was correct. Please explain why all of his statements are correct.
 
What? What does your argument have to do with your post?

I answer every post that is relevant. No, I answer more than that. This is a double standard. You want me to answer just so you can get another chance to say I'm wrong without providing conclusive proof I am wrong.

If you just want to talk to someone, there are other places you can do this.

No sir, you've answered much less than that, and what you have answered has been mostly with games and double-talk. You've ignored posts by me and by others, and you've ignored important points in posts while only responding to the ones you thought you could win a debate point with.

Cole's models are similar to the WTC towers in only one trivial way: They're a set of horizontal planes separated by some type of vertical support. Yep, you can also say that the direction of gravity is the same for both (although you never got around to explaining why you think that's an issue), and certainly the laws of physics are the same for both (same criticism, plus the observation that the laws of physics are independent of your understanding of them), but then we've run out of similarities. You've repeatedly been given both the scientific and logical reasons plus technical references to explain why you can't infer anything about the dynamic behavior of the WTC towers from models that do not have any dynamic similarity to those towers, and yet Cole claims to do just that. ETA: You've also ignored that Verinage demolition, Ronan Point and Skyline towers are real-world "experiments" that prove Cole's conclusions are wrong. Why are you still asking what he got wrong?
 
Last edited:
What you might want to do is prove why the example you quoted was correct. Please explain why all of his statements are correct.

I don't have to.

The fact that you can't see why waypastvne is obviously correct is why it's such a perfect example of #dunning-kruger.
 
I don't have to.

The fact that you can't see why waypastvne is obviously correct is why it's such a perfect example of #dunning-kruger.

You won't explain why he's wrong because you don't want to admit he's wrong. That is the reason you won't do it. You just feel the need to take a cheap shot.
Whatever.
 
"Fighting ignorance" was meant as a global statement. It was not solely directed at you.

I see, is that why you quoted my post not directed at you? Maybe you should focus, right now you're all over the place.


Good luck getting an answer, he's ignored several posts already in hopes we'd all forget after a few days. Now he's gish galloping into a section of the NIST report he doesn't seem to understand.

Typical twoofer behaviour.

I have life. Fighting the ignorance of others is not my full time job.
 
Let's count the dodges shall we.

You are arguing against NIST. If you were correct, they would not have discussed something that was not favorable to their version of events. If you are so certain you are right, write NIST and have them change their report.

What you fail to realize is that Chandler was the one who got NIST to admit freefall, so he has already passed the challenge I just gave you.

Dodge

I don't see a PayPal link anywhere in any of his videos. Do you?

Dodge

Um, think about what you have written. What is Cole demonstrating? He's demonstrating Newton's laws of motion, correct? If he's demonstrating Newton's laws of motion, and only Newton's laws of motion, then "scale" in a non-issue.

Oops. Think about what you post next time. You just took away your arguments and supported mine.

What you're really claiming is that scale is not an issue in Newton's laws of motion, unless it involves an attempt to prove that skeptics are wrong. Then, scale matters, because, well, skeptics can't allow anything that might prove them wrong.
Dodge
No. Asking me meaningless questions is the only way you can attempt to remain relevant in this discussion.


I gave my answer. You just ignored it. It's there. Go look. It's there.
Dodge
And this point is really meaningless, because the instantaneous velocity of the reference point at each measurement could be the same. You are trying to use the definition of something to try to lessen its importance. If this was a valid argument, NIST would use it.
Dodge
You just won't learn. Stop asking me meaningless questions.
Dodge
Again, this is just another attack with no proof.

Also, your post is just a lame dirty trick. You know my post referred to the concept that Newton's laws of motion are not scale-dependent.

Is this really the best you can do? If so, you are wasting your time.
Dodge
I'm not missing anything, and the second part of your sentence proves my point. Think about what you wrote.
Dodge
Can you provide the original video? You might be right, but without the video we won't know for sure, will we? I wonder why it is so hard to find? Could that be some sort of clue?

I completely agree that 5fps doesn't seem right.

That still begs the following question. If the quality of the video was too poor to measure velocity, why would NIST use it? Why would they admit something they didn't have to?
Dodge
If NIST didn't have to admit freefall, why would they? It's obvious they tried to ignore it during their first drafts.
Dodge
I have not cited myself as an authority or expert on anything. I have already explained my tone was sardonic.

I am amused at your response, though.
Dodge
If your argument is valid, why didn't NIST use it?
Why does the feature exist in the program if it's so unreliable?
Dodge
I have learned from corrections that are actually correct. I do know how to sort the BS from what is actually true.
Dodge
Please provide a credible source that confirms this definition. Let's start there.
Dodge
I'm not confusing Newton's laws of motion with anything.

Do you throw darts at a wall full of words to generate your post? Looking at your post I can't think of any other reasonable explanation.
Dodge
Where something is posted does not necessarily affect its credibility. You are beating a dead horse with this argument.
Dodge
My post is correct, valid, and it can stand on its own. I am not the one trying to use Newton for his own purposes.
Dodge
It is relevant. If it wasn't they would not discuss it. What you are doing, clearly and undeniably, is ignoring something you don't like. That is the only explanation.
Dodge
Let me be perfectly clear. Your arguments involving semantics are meaningless.
Dodge
If you're going to call me incompetent then at least point to the actual video. This is nothing more than a dirty trick. It shows just how low you will go.

This is NOT the video Chandler used. The absence of the CBS logo is one clue, and the extremely low quality and pixelation is another clue. I already knew about the videos you posted.

You should learn the definition of incompetence before you use it again. You should also look up fraud.
Dodge
So, you admit I'm right. If so, I don't need to explain, because you have done it for me.
Dodge
Post the original video used in NIST's calculation and we will talk about artifacts. Actually, no we won't. Does NIST mention this? If they don't, then why does this matter?
Dodge
Watch the video. You can infer whatever you want.
Dodge
It's worth noting how you failed to retract the incompetence remark.
Dodge
OK, then find the actual video NIST used, and the actual video Chandler used. Please post working links. If you can't find it then I guess you aren't looking for facts and truth, according to your own statement.
Dodge
Perhaps you should ask NIST the same question. Perhaps what you are claiming is true, but not relevant. Maybe, just maybe, the exact value isn't so much the issue. Maybe the approximation is good enough. Maybe the issue is that your trying to confuse the real issue with smoke-and-mirrors tactics.

Again, this is the pressing question. If any of your arguments were valid, why didn't NIST use them?
Dodge
Why do you infer this? Where and how is he wrong?
Dodge
Please provide a link to this. Which computer model shows complete structural failure over 8 floors, and then the top of the building descending for the same distance.



So you support a real, independent investigation to resolve all these issues, right? I mean 3 buildings collapsed and thousands died. Don't you think we should be 100 percent correct about every single aspect of the collapse, no matter how minute?

LOL. Gotcha.



Agreed. That's why I said "whatever remaining columns collapsed simultaneously."


Newton disagrees. So does NIST. So does David Chandler.

Dodge

If NIST is wrong about freefall, then every single one of their conclusions, measurements, observations and assertions can be called into question. You can't have it both ways.
Dodge
OK, but don't you think they need to know how a building collapsed in order to prevent future collapses? Don't you think the time in which a building fell is a clue about how the building collapsed?
Dodge
Why doesn't it matter? Is it because you don't want it to matter?
Dodge
What? What does your argument have to do with your post?

I answer every post that is relevant. No, I answer more than that. This is a double standard. You want me to answer just so you can get another chance to say I'm wrong without providing conclusive proof I am wrong.

If you just want to talk to someone, there are other places you can do this.
Dodge
It won't matter. I have already given an example to prove my understanding. I then had a skeptic say my example was not wrong.

I will not waste any more time on this. You refuse to accept basic physics laws. You don't like what I'm saying, even if it's correct. Because of this you will take any of my examples to absurd levels, apply absurd and nonsensical additional scenarios to them, and then say I'm wrong. I know this because you have already done it. I know this because others have already done it. I'm not wasting any more time on this. Learn Newton's first law on your own. You clearly do not understand it right now. Your example is proof of that.
Dodge


Insignificant?

OK.

Delusions are so hard to abandon. I feel for you.

Dodge

You won't explain why he's wrong because you don't want to admit he's wrong. That is the reason you won't do it. You just feel the need to take a cheap shot.
Whatever.

Dodge

I gave my example. It is correct. I said nothing about gas, or acceleration or deceleration. I said nothing about forces. I will not. End of discussion.

Dodge

Way to go champ, at this rate you'll get to the "truth" in no time!

:sdl:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom