If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, there isn't.

The problem is that their (=NIST and Chandler's) measurement error is too big to give anything other than an approximate averaged acceleration. More accurate measurements show that it isn't constant. Another poster and I already noted this to you.

You are arguing against NIST. If you were correct, they would not have discussed something that was not favorable to their version of events. If you are so certain you are right, write NIST and have them change their report.

What you fail to realize is that Chandler was the one who got NIST to admit freefall, so he has already passed the challenge I just gave you.
 
Will this be in a post in which you retract your recent claim that it was a measurement of the actual, and not the average, velocity, or do you plan to pretend that you never said that?

Dave

ETA: Just as a reminder:
Yes. Exactly how do you want me to explain my failure to be perfectly clear in my post, other than what I already did?
 
And this, precisely is where you do err.

No one has said that scaling errors mean Newton's Three Laws of motion "do not apply". Instead, it has been rightly pointed out that Cole's "demonstration" fails to take scaling into consideration.

Um, think about what you have written. What is Cole demonstrating? He's demonstrating Newton's laws of motion, correct? If he's demonstrating Newton's laws of motion, and only Newton's laws of motion, then "scale" in a non-issue.

Oops. Think about what you post next time. You just took away your arguments and supported mine.

What you're really claiming is that scale is not an issue in Newton's laws of motion, unless it involves an attempt to prove that skeptics are wrong. Then, scale matters, because, well, skeptics can't allow anything that might prove them wrong.
 
The fact that you can even use the phrase "constant average acceleration" demonstrates a staggering level of incomprehension of the basic concepts involved. The average acceleration over a given time interval is by definition constant over that time period. You are, in effect, claiming that a tautology is a suspicious circumstance.

Your claim tries to assert too much. I have clearly demonstrated that I do understand the concepts involved. The worst you can claim is that I used a redundancy.

And this is comedy gold. The implications of the average acceleration being 9.8ms-2 for 2.25 seconds is that the structure exerted negligible force on the falling section over this period, as would be expected from the initial failure being a multi-storey buckle. The implications of the average acceleration being constant over this period are zero, as it cannot be anything else.

Wow. In this post you admit that multiple stories instantaneously cease to provide support. So, you can no longer argue against NIST. You have just said that multiple stories ceased to provide support, and that caused the upper section to fall for approximately 2.25 seconds at freefall. You're right, this is absolute gold, but there's nothing funny about it.

Here's why it's gold. OMG, I can't believe a skeptic has failed so hard. You have claimed, in your own words, that multiple stories buckled. Freefall is undeniable evidence that they did so instantaneously, and simultaneously. This means that every support column across multiple stories failed at the same time. There is absolutely no other conclusion that supports a freefall of the entire top of the building for any length of time, let alone 2.25 seconds.

Does NIST's computer model show this? No, it doesn't. You admit that multiple stories failed to provide support at once. This failure occurred at the same time in every support column that was providing support to whatever wasn't already removed when the penthouse fell.

Can a progressive collapse cause multiple support columns throughout an entire steel-framed high rise to fail instantaneously and simultaneously? Of course not. You have argued CD for me. Thanks.


No, I believe that Chandler and NIST are able to determine an average acceleration over a given period, and that over a specific period of 2.25 seconds that average acceleration is close to 1G. So we can ignore your strawman questions:
Did NIST admit freefall? Yes. There is no strawman argument involved.


Yes, that is exactly what I'm saying, and anyone competent would agree. The extent to which the measured points deviate from the line is a combination of measurement error and real deviations from constant acceleration, and in the absence of values for one it is not possible to assign a minimum value to the other.
If this mattered as much as you claim it does, why would the program even try to measure acceleration?
Second, if this was correct, why wouldn't NIST say that acceleration can't be measured accurately? That seems like a very simple way to weasel out of the issue, just like you have tried. Is it because they know they can't weasel out of it because the argument you are presenting is false? That seems like the more likely conclusion.
 
Last edited:
Asking you a question seems to be the only way to find out the limits of your admittedly somewhat skewed understanding.

No. Asking me meaningless questions is the only way you can attempt to remain relevant in this discussion.

Nor have you explained (and I am really interested in this) what you think the collapse of the WTC "should have" looked like, since the reality does not suit you.
I gave my answer. You just ignored it. It's there. Go look. It's there.
 
I am sorry to kkep saying this, but Cole ostentatiously ignores the problems of scaling.

No, not because "The Three Laws" "work differently" at different scales, but because his comparison of his scale toy to an actual, full-sized building is inherently false.
No, he does not ignore scale. Scale does not matter, and he addresses the issue near the beginning of his video.
 
Dave, I and others have ALL said, repeatedly, that the plots were AVERAGE velocity points. Odd that you seem to have missed that until just now.

And this point is really meaningless, because the instantaneous velocity of the reference point at each measurement could be the same. You are trying to use the definition of something to try to lessen its importance. If this was a valid argument, NIST would use it.
 
Where? So far it seems you just don't understand physics.
Again, this is just another attack with no proof.

Also, your post is just a lame dirty trick. You know my post referred to the concept that Newton's laws of motion are not scale-dependent.

Is this really the best you can do? If so, you are wasting your time.
 
You're missing that scale here is related to molecular bonds....not rules of motion which pretty much are unchangeable regardless of scale.
I'm not missing anything, and the second part of your sentence proves my point. Think about what you wrote.
 
Its a professional, CBS TV network video from 2001. THEREFORE it IS 29.97 fps (30 fps is an old standard from B&W TV days). If its not 29.97 fps then its not the original video. That would mean that its even of lesser quality than CBS's original.

You said a position measurement was every frame. The graph shows 13 frames over that 2.25 second period. That corresponds to 5.78 frames per second. A 5.78 fps video would be extremely choppy. The video in question isn't choppy, therefore it isn't 5.78 fps.

So either the graph isn't plotting every velocity point, or velocity points were not taken at every frame. The acceleration slope is garnered from the graph which is then either not using every calculated average velocity, or only using those that were calculated, every 8th frame.

Can you provide the original video? You might be right, but without the video we won't know for sure, will we? I wonder why it is so hard to find? Could that be some sort of clue?

I completely agree that 5fps doesn't seem right.

That still begs the following question. If the quality of the video was too poor to measure velocity, why would NIST use it? Why would they admit something they didn't have to?
 
Last edited:
Again, this is just another attack with no proof.

Also, your post is just a lame dirty trick. You know my post referred to the concept that Newton's laws of motion are not scale-dependent.

Is this really the best you can do? If so, you are wasting your time.

Well, one of you is anyway!!
 
No, what you claim is "constant acceleration" is calculated the same way that the average acceleration of the rest of the time period of collapse was. By best fit of a linear slope to the time period in question, this 2.25 second interval. It is therefore by definition also an average over that time period. A closer look by online poster femr2 demonstrated that far from constant, the acceleration during this time period actually exceeded g, and fell below g.

The mere fact that it exceeded g at any point demonstrates that some other mechanism was in play other than strict Newtonian, point mass, physics. Indeed in all things in reality, point mass Newtonian physics is idealistic. Reality is much messier than ideal masses and forces.

There are videos that demonstrate situations in which falling objects exceed g. Two come to mind, the first is the pivoting rod with a mass on the outer end. The rod is allowed to pivot and it reaches the table before the mass that had been resting on the end of the rod.
The second is a 'chain and rod ladder' where the rods form the steps and are connected at an angle to the two chains. there are two that are released at the same time, one falls past a table the other onto the table. The one falling onto the table demonstrably ends up falling faster than the free falling one. Its a transfer of energy of the tilted 'steps' that pulls the chains down, adding force to the still falling portion of the structure.

WTC 7 had had all columns fail below the 8th floor, buckled, tilted, connections sheared, makes little difference its probably a combination of all of them. The upper structure perimeter frame however was still connected but askew, with all floors tilted down towards the 'kink'. That portion of all floors(along the line of the 'kink') would be the first to hit ground. That's not unlike the falling faster than g ladder. In similar fashion, the E-W line of the center of the building also fell sooner than the perimeter and would see the surviving girders between perimeter and core columns, tilted inwards. Their ends hit first.

If NIST didn't have to admit freefall, why would they? It's obvious they tried to ignore it during their first drafts.
 
Fighting ignorance?

You mean like thinking a post was directed towards you when it was clearly addressing someone else?

I can see why you thought it was meant for you though, you exhibit the exact same behaviour.
"Fighting ignorance" was meant as a global statement. It was not solely directed at you.
 
Citation, please. Oh, wait, I'll bold them.

What's that you say? Unsupported assertions? Mindless kneejerk recitation of dogma? Statements based on opinions not facts? Citing yourself as the authority on the subjects of CD and Top Secret ops?

Why yes, your post DOES actually contain all of those. Very impressive fallacy-stacking.

I have not cited myself as an authority or expert on anything. I have already explained my tone was sardonic.

I am amused at your response, though.
 
Not true. Many posters have also been correcting your mistakes when they have happened. You just don't seem to learn from these corrections.

I have learned from corrections that are actually correct. I do know how to sort the BS from what is actually true.
 
"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

Please provide a credible source that confirms this definition. Let's start there.
 
Lets get back to basics. FF is confusing Newton with Statics
I'm not confusing Newton's laws of motion with anything.

Do you throw darts at a wall full of words to generate your post? Looking at your post I can't think of any other reasonable explanation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom