If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is your claim that the video is so degraded you can't use it to measure acceleration?

No. My point is that your claim the acceleration was constant is unsupported in the evidence you have provided.

I ask again for the raw data, data which should include 30 measurements per second of video examined.
 
You are aware that Einsteins Relativity has supplanted Newton, right?

You are aware that Kepler and Maxwell refined Newton's Laws?

You are aware that Newton's Laws break down when applied to various situations and make a lot of assumptions about the Universe that aren't correct?

There is actually some truth to your statements.

If we were talking about particle physics, then I might not be focusing on Newton as much. We are not talking about particle physics, so we don't need to be talking about general relativity.
 
No. My point is that your claim the acceleration was constant is unsupported in the evidence you have provided.

I ask again for the raw data, data which should include 30 measurements per second of video examined.

I don't think it exists. If it does exist, I'm not the one you should be asking to find it.
 
This is an ugly game.

Here we have a quarterback, name is FalseFlag, opening on offence.
There, we have a defensive line (ISF debunkers).

The D-linemen are mostly major NCAA stuff, averaging 250 pounds.
The Q is first year junior high, 90 pounds, hasn't learned to properly throw a ball, and comes without O-linemen or receivers. All he tries to do is dodge or fumble - but he hasn't learned that, either.

Evil tackles!
Not a pretty sight.

LOL, I haven't seen someone thrashed here this badly in awhile. Comedy Gold!
 
It's not rare at all on a forum like this, where most participants are interested in a true exchange of ideas.

It's quite different from what you're used to in the "Truth Movement," where the slightest heresy is quickly struck down, and where anyone who dares questions truther claims is smeared with labels like "sheeple."

I presume you'll be voting for Trump?

wow, a page per dinner break... you missed it, he was teaching truther physics 500 posts ago, or so, and it continues.
 
This is really amazing. I have provided no evidence whatsoever that would give even the slightest insight into my political views, yet despite the fact that no evidence exists, you have come to a conclusion.

Your conclusion is 100 percent wrong.

Had you the slightest sense of humor, you would have seen my Trump remark was a not-so-subtle reference to the "circle-the-wagons" mentality of truthers like your self:
It's not rare at all on a forum like this, where most participants are interested in a true exchange of ideas.

It's quite different from what you're used to in the "Truth Movement," where the slightest heresy is quickly struck down, and where anyone who dares questions truther claims is smeared with labels like "sheeple."

Anyway, as you were. We haven't had such a righteous schooling of a clueless commentator since, well, since ergo declared
I'm not sure even a moon-sized field or mountain of rubble, dropped from a height of 12 feet would entirely crush the WTC.

Please continue with your flailing.
:popcorn1
 
There is actually some truth to your statements.

If we were talking about particle physics, then I might not be focusing on Newton as much. We are not talking about particle physics, so we don't need to be talking about general relativity.

lol
... Imagine you have a neutrino and you accelerate it towards the surface of the earth. Neutrinos are so small they can pass through the entire earth without being affected. Does this violate Newton's first law? Nope. If a neutrino stays in motion without an external force acting on it then it will stay in motion forever. If a neutrino actually came to rest so...?
You can't keep your BS straight; is your purpose to post BS and make fun of 911 truth... it is working...

So far you have failed to make any points;; except, exposing no useful knowledge of physics. As if you googled up physics, with a cut and paste failure.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it exists. If it does exist, I'm not the one you should be asking to find it.

It was your claim in this very thread, so you are exactly the person I should be asking. The graph you provided supports a claim of average acceleration being a certain value, but nothing more. Certainly your claim of constant acceleration is unsupported.

Do I recall correctly that the graph had 6 data point per second? So five raw measures were blended in some way for each data point. It is also likely some sort of moving average was used to further filter and smooth the data.

By the way, there is nothing wrong with data reduction techniques such as these as long as you fully disclose what techniques were used and restrict your conclusions accordingly. You didn't because you likely didn't know, but did your source disclose them and limit conclusions to those justified by the reduced data? If not, why not?

Be that as it may, we are left with your constant acceleration claim being de-rated to merely average acceleration. Floor-to-floor collisions are now admissible within your framework since while the collisions will impact (pun intended) the instantaneous acceleration, the average acceleration could still appear as your graph presented it.
 
No, I'm not. Thank you, though, for proving the point that you have attempted to milk that for everything it's worth. *Spoiler* It's worth nothing, because it was a nothing more than a hypothetical scenario to illustrate a point.

...and yet you "hypothetically" constructed it completely incorrectly, with a glaring error based on...


...wait for it...


...it'll live here on the internet...


...scaling.
 
No, I didn't. He misunderstands Newton's third law, and so do you.
I didn't just say that, I gave a credible source and and example of why he's wrong. Your failure to accept this does not mean you're correct.

Really? Well, I think you're ducking Myriad's point because you simply don't understand it well enough to even attempt to refute it. Prove me wrong by at least making the attempt.
 
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.

Ummm...no.

Newton;'s First Law of Motion is the classical description of inertia, and how it works.

...wait: I'll bet this turns out to be just another "hypothetical", when you realize how wrong the corner into which you have painted yourself is.

As wrong as your inability to understand why the composition of "quicksand" is germane to your inability to correctly understand how it applies.
 
Last edited:

I have corrected my original post.

The edited post is also pasted below:

Edited 3/15/16

The text in red is wrong. I was provided this link in a later post, and NIST does give an explanation.

Here is the link to the NIST paper:

http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/f..._qa_082108.cfm

Here are the two relevant sentences:

During Stage 2, the north face descended essentially in free fall, indicating negligible support from the structure below. This is consistent with the structural analysis model which showed the exterior columns buckling and losing their capacity to support the loads from the structure above.

My statement that NIST did not provide an explanation was entirely wrong.

They did provide an explanation. My opinion is that their explanation in wrong because their explanation does not match their computer models.
 
It was your claim in this very thread, so you are exactly the person I should be asking. The graph you provided supports a claim of average acceleration being a certain value, but nothing more. Certainly your claim of constant acceleration is unsupported.

Do I recall correctly that the graph had 6 data point per second? So five raw measures were blended in some way for each data point. It is also likely some sort of moving average was used to further filter and smooth the data.

By the way, there is nothing wrong with data reduction techniques such as these as long as you fully disclose what techniques were used and restrict your conclusions accordingly. You didn't because you likely didn't know, but did your source disclose them and limit conclusions to those justified by the reduced data? If not, why not?

Be that as it may, we are left with your constant acceleration claim being de-rated to merely average acceleration. Floor-to-floor collisions are now admissible within your framework since while the collisions will impact (pun intended) the instantaneous acceleration, the average acceleration could still appear as your graph presented it.

What graph?

I am pretty sure I didn't post any graphs.

You're also talking about average acceleration. Average acceleration is a meaningless number. The issues are constant acceleration and how long it was observed.
 
FF. If I have a football and I tape that football to the passenger seat of my car, then drive around a racecourse circuit, does the ball have uniform motion under Newton's 1st Law?
 
Really? Well, I think you're ducking Myriad's point because you simply don't understand it well enough to even attempt to refute it. Prove me wrong by at least making the attempt.
I'm not ducking anything, and I have proven you are both wrong. Your refusal to accept my proof is not enough to legitimately claim I am wrong.
 
FF. If I have a football and I tape that football to the passenger seat of my car, then drive around a racecourse circuit, does the ball have uniform motion under Newton's 1st Law?
I don't accept your challenge to derail this discussion further.
 
I'm not ducking anything, and I have proven you are both wrong. Your refusal to accept my proof is not enough to legitimately claim I am wrong.

Oh, my mistake: I thought you weren't responding to it because you were at least aware that you didn't understand it. Now I see that you didn't understand it well enough to realize that you weren't responding to it. Seriously: Try reading it again without all the defensive willful ignorance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom