If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is part of the key reason he is wrong, gravity is able to overcome electromagnetism, because it isn't a force. There fore it can never truly be at balance, that's why you jump and fall back to earth instead of flying off the planet.

What does this have to do with Newton's first law of motion?
 
You completely missed Myriad's point
No, I didn't. He misunderstands Newton's third law, and so do you.
I didn't just say that, I gave a credible source and and example of why he's wrong. Your failure to accept this does not mean you're correct.
 
True, but when someone is having trouble grasping the concept of atomic particles, you don't jump right in with Electrons being a negatively charged wave form with mass called a lepton, orbiting the nuclei of the atom within a 3D probability shell rather than it being a particle which orbits in a defined singular orbit like a planet, do you?
Atomic particles? Electrons?
Why is it impossible for you simply to focus on Newton's first law of motion?
 
Not correct Gravity is pulling all the building down at the same time, the only opisite force is provided by electromagnetism.

So there will be no equal and opisite reaction to a force that does not exist.

Gravity does not obey the laws of Newtonian forces because Gravity is not a force.

You really outdid yourself on this one.
 
How many posts in a row do you think he'll make before he realizes why he is wrong....

Unless..... :D
 
I can't stop laughing. This thread is pure comedy gold. A perfect example of Dunning-Kruger effect.

Misunderstandings of basic, simple concepts in just about every scientific discipline connected with events on 9/11 is one of the cornerstones of "trutherism".

You can obviously post in this forum, so why don't you point out where Newton is wrong, or point out where I don't understand Newton's first law of motion.
 
No, that's wrong. Newton's theory of gravitation can't predict Mercury's orbit because the energies and velocities involved are too high for it to be a good enough approximation. However, that doesn't invalidate the Third Law; the gravitational force exerted by the sun on Mercury is precisely equal and opposite to the gravitational force exerted by Mercury on the sun at any and every instant, even in the relativistic limit, otherwise we lose conservation of momentum and conservation of energy. And, in the low energy / velocity approximation, which was clearly satisfied by all the events of 9/11, it's perfectly reasonable to treat gravity as a simple force.

Dave

This is pretty rare. One skeptic correcting another skeptic is not something I see often.
 
Were you aware that a video analysis exists, done by Tony Szamboti, author of the Missing Jolt paper that was published on ae911's website that shows the decelerations you say don't exist?

Cole is behind the times.

Please post this paper and show everyone where in the paper this claim is made. Thanks.
 
You can obviously post in this forum, so why don't you point out where Newton is wrong, or point out where I don't understand Newton's first law of motion.

I do enjoy how you are beginning to realize that you or Newton are wrong.

Protip, it is you...
 
I made no claim. You claimed to have no qualifications.
Your post implies I am wrong. Please prove I'm wrong regarding the issue of interlacing and uncompressed frames. How are they related to each other? How does my subsequent explanation prove that I have no qualifications when it comes to video?
 
...and you've returned and made nearly fifty more posts since then.
I changed my mind.
I have a point to prove, and I'm going to prove it. No, no one here is going to accept it, but it will remain on this forum and the internet for anyone to see.

It's coming. Be patient.
 
You made the asinine claim that

.

It is not that Newton's First Law of Motion does not apply because of scale, but that your idea that the Moon could be placed "at rest" on the Earth's surface, and stay there, motionless with respect to each other, with full structural integrity.

I'm not falling for this again. I stated yesterday that my post was simply an acceptance of a hypothetical scenario to prove a point. You, and others, jumped on that to distract everyone from the real discussion. I won't make that mistake again.
 
You DID, in fact, say:


Are you retracting that?

No, I'm not. Thank you, though, for proving the point that you have attempted to milk that for everything it's worth. *Spoiler* It's worth nothing, because it was a nothing more than a hypothetical scenario to illustrate a point.
 
You really want to avoid just talking about Newton's first law of motion. I admire your consistency.

As I just said, if you think Newton is wrong, contact your local university or the media and let them know.

You are aware that Einsteins Relativity has supplanted Newton, right?

You are aware that Kepler and Maxwell refined Newton's Laws?

You are aware that Newton's Laws break down when applied to various situations and make a lot of assumptions about the Universe that aren't correct?
 
FalseFlag, have you ever worked through the Horse Cart Problem? It's a standard student exercise for learning to understand and correctly apply basic Newtonian physics instead of falling into common errors.

The problem is this: A horse is hitched to a cart. The cart is motionless. The horse pulls on the cart; this applies a force to the cart, in the forward direction (the way the horse is facing). But the cart, by Newton's third law, applies an equal force to the horse, in the opposite direction. Because the forces are balanced, the cart will not move.

Given that horses can in fact pull carts, what is wrong with the reasoning in the previous paragraph? There is a more accurate explanation of what actually happens when a horse pulls a cart, which is in fact consistent with Newton's laws. Can you provide it?

Right now we are talking about Newton's first law of motion.

I will answer your question, only in regards to Newton's first law of motion. When we get to Newton's third law of motion, I will expand on my answer.

If the cart is at rest, it will only move when an unbalanced force is applied. Again, I am only going to discuss this example in terms of Newton's first law of motion. Bring this up again when we get to Newton's third law of motion.
 
Your example ignores the ability of the materials involved to resist the forces being applied to them. However, assuming the objects can resist the forces, your example is not wrong.
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.
 
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.

No, he's talking about Object's ability to resist deformation under a force.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom