If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Right now we are talking about Newton's first law of motion.

I will answer your question, only in regards to Newton's first law of motion. When we get to Newton's third law of motion, I will expand on my answer.

If the cart is at rest, it will only move when an unbalanced force is applied. Again, I am only going to discuss this example in terms of Newton's first law of motion. Bring this up again when we get to Newton's third law of motion.


Whichever law you're discussing, you should be willing to define the terms you use.

So, please define an unbalanced force, and then please tell me whether or not, in your opinion, the cart in the horse and cart scenario experiences an unbalanced force when the horse pulls on it, and then please tell me whether or not, in your opinion, the cart will maintain its uniform state of motion (standing still) or will change its state of motion (move), in accordance with Newton's first law, when the horse pulls on it.
 
Wow, 15 pages in less than 2 days? This must be a record.

As I said before, you can magically remove 20 or 30 floors by whatever means you wish, and then drop the remaining floors on the rest of the building. At the moment of impact, there will be a deceleration. The deceleration will continue until the movement stops, or the top reaches the ground. The only way the top will continue to accelerate is if the lower floors are removed prior to the impact of the upper floors. Go ahead and deny this, but you are denying the most fundamental laws of motion.
Even admitting that there is deceleration, you have no basis to claim that it will continue until the movement stops. Right after the deceleration on impact, gravity takes over, and accelerates the mass again.


Was there a deceleration? No. Should there have been? Yes. That is what matters.
I've repeatedly asked you for proof that there wasn't a deceleration on every impact. You have always ignored the question. Last time was in post 511.
 
No, he's talking about Object's ability to resist deformation under a force.


FF only knows how to apply Newton's Laws to rigid, non-deformable objects.

Therefore, all objects are rigid and non-deformable.

Unless you use explosives.
 
Girl uses 9/11 examples, beats NASA employee (and 2 others). The task was to estimate how many panes of glass would break when a weight is dropped from above.

The answer was not all of them, and the basement, tube station, and surrounding buildings, and the producers car did not catch fire ;)
It was designed to arrest. With enough separation between glass panes, for example, the breakage would have progressed all the way down.
 
"Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law."

On Earth? k..... walks about on frozen lake, puts down square centimeter of steel in vacuum jar, nothing happens.... walks out on frozen lake carrying square meter of steel in vacuum jar, surface breaks, steel plummets to lake bed.

Nice try, but no.

First example. You place the smaller object on the ice and it stays at rest. Does Newton's first law apply? Yes. An object will stay at rest because there are no unbalanced forces.

Second example. You place the larger object on the ice and it stays at rest. Does Newton's first law apply? Yes. An object will stay at rest because there are no unbalanced forces. After the object comes to rest, the ice then breaks, and the object falls. Does Newton's first law of motion still apply? Yes. An external force has been applied and the object now moves.

Your argument is that the mass of the object makes a difference in Newton's first law. Mass makes no difference in Newton's first law of motion. What you have described is a situation in which the object's weight is enough to break the ice. The fact that a larger object can break the ice, but a smaller object can't, has nothing to do with Newton's first law of motion.
 
First, WTC 7 did accelerate at g (the downward force due to gravity, which is 9.8m/s/s) for at least 2 seconds. NIST admits this, but they refuse to explain it.
Clearly you haven't read NIST, or you wouldn't be making that up.
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.

OK, while I'm alive, let's play a game. It's pretty clear from the plethora of skeptics' posts that they love to play games, so let's do it.

Level 1.

Here's the text of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/newton1g.html

Here is another explanation of Newton's first law of motion:
Source: http://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/newtlaws/Lesson-1/Newton-s-First-Law

Here is yet one more explanation of Newton's first law of motion:

Source: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/newt.html

Challenge 1.

Prove Newton's first law is wrong.

Challenge 1a.

Prove the following example is wrong.

Example: A object rests on the surface of the earth. The object is in a vacuum. Since the object is at rest, there is no motion. There is a downward force acting on the object, which is exerted by gravity. Since the object is at rest, there is an opposite force acting on the object in the opposite direction. This force is called the normal force. Since the object is in a vacuum, there is no force exerted by air. The only forces acting on the object are the force due to gravity and the normal force. The forces are balanced, so the net force is zero. As long as the net force is zero, the object will stay at rest.

Once again, prove any part of my example is wrong. Simply saying that I'm wrong doesn't count. You must clearly prove I'm wrong, with an example citing your sources and reasoning.

Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law.

The challenge will be open until someone does it, or 24 hours, whichever happens sooner.

Well it's now more than 24 hours so is it time for another stupid challenge to try to disprove something we think is correct?
 
You are talking about inertia. Inertia is often discussed along with Newton's first law of motion, but they are different concepts. Mass (what is being confused with scale and size) does affect inertia, but it has no effect on Newton's first law of motion.


Uh... Newton's first law is the definition of inertia.
 
Seriously?

Raw video can be either interlaced or non-interlaced. If one were tracking image details as it moved from one scan line to the next, the timing between adjacent scan lines would be rather important, no?
Timing AND position.

Last time I checked, the version of the tracking program that Chandler used didn't support feature tracking, which is a technique to make the problem of position far less significant.
 
Nice try, but no.

First example. You place the smaller object on the ice and it stays at rest. Does Newton's first law apply? Yes. An object will stay at rest because there are no unbalanced forces.

Second example. You place the larger object on the ice and it stays at rest. Does Newton's first law apply? Yes. An object will stay at rest because there are no unbalanced forces. After the object comes to rest, the ice then breaks, and the object falls. Does Newton's first law of motion still apply? Yes. An external force has been applied and the object now moves.

Your argument is that the mass of the object makes a difference in Newton's first law. Mass makes no difference in Newton's first law of motion. What you have described is a situation in which the object's weight is enough to break the ice. The fact that a larger object can break the ice, but a smaller object can't, has nothing to do with Newton's first law of motion.

No difference? But the mass is sitting on the bottom of the lake. As such I expertly addressed the hypothetical you raised.
 
FF... go look at Mick West latest model / experiment at MetaBunk (https://www.metabunk.org/towards-a-...ive-collapse-of-the-wtc-towers-on-9-11.t7396/) to see how the floors collapsed. Mick is a rational guy and a careful thinker. His model is not telling the entire story... but it's pretty darn good.

I have read the article. I have conceded magical steel and a magical building, so your steel and building can do whatever you want other than deny Newton's three laws of motion.

In the video at the end of the article he shows boards collapsing. There is no question the WTC towers collapsed. Does his video show the boards fell at a constant acceleration, or, did they decelerate? I can answer this with 100 percent certainty. I can see the boards were there, I can see the impact before each board falls, and I can hear each impact. Because of this, I am certain there was an impulse deceleration with each impact, and because of this I am certain there was not constant acceleration as the boards collapsed.
 
Right. So wouldn't you prefer to conclude from real data and real expertise rather than conspiracy nutjobs who are trying to sell you something?
I think you should answer that question yourself. I think the nutjobs trying to sell you something are not the truthers.
 
Nope, he's rather tell people that studied University level Physics a decade or more before 9/11 that they are wrong because of what he saw on a YouTube video.

If you studied university-level physics for any length of time, it was time wasted.
 
HAHA!! Man, I hope you are freaking kidding!

I actually burst out laughing when I read that...:thumbsup:

Laugh all you want. Show me where that equation is. You should probably spend less time laughing and more time trying to understand what you are trying to debunk.
 
This is pretty rare. One skeptic correcting another skeptic is not something I see often.

It's not rare at all on a forum like this, where most participants are interested in a true exchange of ideas.

It's quite different from what you're used to in the "Truth Movement," where the slightest heresy is quickly struck down, and where anyone who dares questions truther claims is smeared with labels like "sheeple."

I presume you'll be voting for Trump?
 
I presume you'll be voting for Trump?

This is really amazing. I have provided no evidence whatsoever that would give even the slightest insight into my political views, yet despite the fact that no evidence exists, you have come to a conclusion.

Your conclusion is 100 percent wrong.
 
Laugh all you want. Show me where that equation is. You should probably spend less time laughing and more time trying to understand what you are trying to debunk.

Seriously? It is in the unless clause! C'mon man, you are giving me the giggles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom