If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow. Over 130 posts since I stopped this morning. Reading through them all is going to be quite entertaining.
I'm pulling for you buddy...............I bet you can drag this on for at least another 200, maybe more. Don't get your hopes up for a record, that's well into the 10's of thousands.

<see my signature>

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Would someone be willing to summarize the main points of the bowling ball/glass clip and how it relates to 9/11? I watched about 1 minute of the video but found the contestants and presentation so irritating I couldn't concentrate.
 
No, it's not. That's why I'm here. 3000 only counts the Americans who died on 9/11. You need to add over 7,000 American troops who died in pointless wars, and over 1,000,000 Iraqi and Afghani citizens who died as well.

Right. So wouldn't you prefer to conclude from real data and real expertise rather than conspiracy nutjobs who are trying to sell you something?
 
Right. So wouldn't you prefer to conclude from real data and real expertise rather than conspiracy nutjobs who are trying to sell you something?

Nope, he's rather tell people that studied University level Physics a decade or more before 9/11 that they are wrong because of what he saw on a YouTube video.
 
Would someone be willing to summarize the main points of the bowling ball/glass clip and how it relates to 9/11? I watched about 1 minute of the video but found the contestants and presentation so irritating I couldn't concentrate.
That is funny, that is exactly how I felt when you posted Gage's videos of nuts for 911. ... knowing Gage's nuts were idiots on 911, made watching the videos Gage had worse than waterboarding for an engineer, and a pilot trained in escape and evasion... (your transcripts saved a lot of brain cells... okay, one of my two...)

How does it relate to 911? Seriously?

Stop, think collect you wits... (this is 911 truth saying it relates to 911...)

This is 911 truth BS, it relates to 911 because 911 truth nuts said so. It is the only reason it is related to 911; 911 idiots say so.
The video set up, for pointing out one of the "nerds" believes in 911 truth claims, exposes one of the "nerds" as gullible and dumb on 911.

Love FalseFlag; has to be the best name for a 911 truth believer.

No, it's not. That's why I'm here. 3000 only counts the Americans who died on 9/11. You need to add over 7,000 American troops who died in pointless wars, and over 1,000,000 Iraqi and Afghani citizens who died as well.
IS this why you spread the dumbest lies you can on 911? Protesting war, so you lie.
 
Last edited:
That is funny, that is exactly how I felt when you posted Gage's videos of nuts for 911. ... knowing Gage's nuts were idiots on 911, made watching the videos Gage had worse than waterboarding for an engineer, and a pilot trained in escape and evasion... (your transcripts saved a lot of brain cells... okay, one of my two...)
Maybe you could return the favour and transcribe this one for me? :D
 
IS this why you spread the dumbest lies you can on 911? Protesting war, so you lie.

A time honoured tradition. Bill Kaysing started his claims about Apollo being a hoax as a protest to the treatment of Korean War Solders.
 
Maybe you could return the favour and transcribe this one for me? :D

I was going to see where in the video we find out a nerd is a 911 truth nut, but I failed... this is not the first time I saw this; and it will not be last time.

If I do find the exact position of the 911 truth revelation, I will pm you asap

A time honoured tradition. Bill Kaysing started his claims about Apollo being a hoax as a protest to the treatment...

I finished watching "tons" of super-car accidents by what appears to be 911 truth like drivers; after you re-posted the water molecules crushing steel.
 
Last edited:
Would someone be willing to summarize the main points of the bowling ball/glass clip and how it relates to 9/11? I watched about 1 minute of the video but found the contestants and presentation so irritating I couldn't concentrate.

Girl uses 9/11 examples, beats NASA employee (and 2 others). The task was to estimate how many panes of glass would break when a weight is dropped from above.

The answer was not all of them, and the basement, tube station, and surrounding buildings, and the producers car did not catch fire ;)
 
Girl uses 9/11 examples, beats NASA employee (and 2 others). The task was to estimate how many panes of glass would break when a weight is dropped from above.

The answer was not all of them, and the basement, tube station, and surrounding buildings, and the producers car did not catch fire ;)

The video of glass has zero to do with 911, and only fooled 911 truth nuts. Another dumbed down 911 truth follower attempt to spew lies about 911. Big fail, the girl did not use any 911 example to do anything. Which example are you talking about?
You failed to explain what "great speed" is. You can't put math to your own BS.

You have no clue how much the basement was damaged.

The US needs another civil war, ...
This is all you know about the basement damage.
WTCCollapsedSubway3.png
No damage to the basement... was that your claim?
 
Last edited:
I really can't be arsed to follow the next half dozen pages to see whether anyone else has pointed this out; but, FalseFlag, you've answered your own question here, you just can't see it.



The bit after the last comma is simply wrong, but the rest is in principle OK; every time part of the top section hits part of the bottom section, there is an impulse.

Now, try to imagine a situation where, instead of a flat object falling on a flat object in one single collision, you have two complex shapes with bits sticking out all over, one falling on to the other. Each time a bit sticking out from one shape hits a bit of the other, there's an impulse, but only a relatively small one. A moment later another bit hits, and there's another small impulse, then another, then another. If the shapes are complex enoug and there are enough small impulses, they all smear out together into what looks like a constant force, but with little jolts when a few happen together or there's one bigger impulse. That's what we would expect to see if there are no explosives and no magical disappearance of multiple storeys of steel, but instead there's a complicated series of failures of the structure that leads to a highly chaotic collapse. And that's exactly what we saw in all the WTC collapses, and it's also exactly what the best measurements of all the collapses show; lots of micro-jolts from small impulses when part of the structure collides with another part of the structure.

If you understand acceleration as well as you think you do, you should be able to figure out how that works. If you want to, that is.

Dave

This is brilliant. I'm glad you pointed this out. I can assure you that no one else has. I do understand exactly what you are saying.

Here's where your explanation fails. It would be impossible for the chaotic and random micro-jolts to allow a constant acceleration for any length of time, even if that acceleration was considerably less than 9.8m/s/s. I absolutely agree with you, in theory, that micro-jolts would be nearly impossible to detect using the video and film footage that exists.

We also know that WTC7 fell at freefall for a little over 2 seconds. Your example doesn't explain that. NIST admits this, but they don't explain it, either.

I completely understand your post. I do. If you want to use your example to explain why we don't see bigger jolts, then fine. I have no argument. I am not saying I agree with you, but I'm saying that I won't say you're wrong, and I won't argue your points. I have already conceded that you can have magical steel, and a magical building structure, you just don't get to ignore Newton's laws of motion. In your example, I don't believe you have. The issue is that your conclusion regarding constant acceleration is not correct. You account for Newton's third law, but then incorrectly assume that the micro-jolts would combine to create a constant deceleration, opposite of the force of gravity. This is impossible.

Edited 3/15/16
The text in red is wrong. I was provided this link in a later post, and NIST does give an explanation.

Here is the link to the NIST paper:

http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/factsheet/wtc_qa_082108.cfm

Here are the two relevant sentences:

During Stage 2, the north face descended essentially in free fall, indicating negligible support from the structure below. This is consistent with the structural analysis model which showed the exterior columns buckling and losing their capacity to support the loads from the structure above.

My statement that NIST did not provide an explanation was entirely wrong. They did provide an explanation. My opinion is that their explanation in wrong because their explanation does not match their computer models.
 
Last edited:
This is brilliant. I'm glad you pointed this out. I can assure you that no one else has. I do understand exactly what you are saying.

Here's where your explanation fails. It would be impossible for the chaotic and random micro-jolts to allow a constant acceleration for any length of time, even if that acceleration was considerably less than 9.8m/s/s. I absolutely agree with you, in theory, that micro-jolts would be nearly impossible to detect using the video and film footage that exists.

We also know that WTC7 fell at freefall for a little over 2 seconds. Your example doesn't explain that. NIST admits this, but they don't explain it, either.

I completely understand your post. I do. If you want to use your example to explain why we don't see bigger jolts, then fine. I have no argument. I am not saying I agree with you, but I'm saying that I won't say you're wrong, and I won't argue your points. I have already conceded that you can have magical steel, and a magical building structure, you just don't get to ignore Newton's laws of motion. In your example, I don't believe you have. The issue is that your conclusion regarding constant acceleration is not correct. You account for Newton's third law, but then incorrectly assume that the micro-jolts would combine to create a constant deceleration, opposite of the force of gravity. This is impossible.

On wtc7, no it did not, and yes nist explained why truthers were wrong in believing that.

Still giggling, tho.
 
Gravity is not a force,Physics: Laws of Motion - Newton and beyond: http://youtu.be/Ixf9ZyZaE9Q

That's why it has special properties no other force can have.

You can talk about general relativity all you want, but I will not join you.

If you think you have proved Newton is wrong in regards to his first law of motion, I encourage you to contact your local university and let them know.
 
You can talk about general relativity all you want, but I will not join you.

If you think you have proved Newton is wrong in regards to his first law of motion, I encourage you to contact your local university and let them know.

Oh man! :D
 
He's having trouble with Newton, you really think he's ready for the idea that Gravity is actually the result of objects trying to lower their energy states by falling down into a four-dimensional curvature in the space/time continuum?
You really want to avoid just talking about Newton's first law of motion. I admire your consistency.

As I just said, if you think Newton is wrong, contact your local university or the media and let them know.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom