If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.
I'm curious about this.

You do understand that in order for any force to eject steel sections additional energy must be included to cause this effect.

In other words, whoever designed the alleged cd of the towers was so nefarious that causing failure wasn't enough. They also included extra HE (or whatever your personal theory is) to hurl steel beam sections at great speeds.

Why would anyone exceed the energy requirements of an engineered event for such a pointless act?
 
Any video in a 4:3 aspect ratio can be assumed to be low resolution, interlaced at 29.97 frames per second (2 fields per frame). Any hand held consumer camera from 2001 is likely no better quality than DVD which IS compressed. Professional grade DV in 2001 would have been better but no where near what is available now. Unless the comm link between camera and studio was a high quality ASI/SDI then the signal was downgraded from the uncompressed raw data out of a professional camera.

Certainly all true. I wonder why FalseFlag didn't know that.

Any video uploaded to the internet HAS experienced a re-encoding and MOST likely a re-compression.

Any video on the internet that is downloaded then uploaded again to another site may have experienced yet another compression.

FalseFlag is confident compression doesn't matter. :boggled:

...snip of more excellent points...
They only way to measure acceleration is to measure difference in position and calculate velocity at the data points(as you say about 30 per second,about every 33 milliseconds), and from there determine the acceleration that would account for the differences in velocity.

Here's where I will quibble, and it was a point FalseFlag is oblivious to regarding interlaced video. While the frames are 33 milliseconds apart, the fields are not. The time difference from a point in the odd field of one frame to the "same" point in the even field of the next frame is only 17 ms. Going from even to odd, the time difference is 50 ms. Tracking a moving object from one frame to the next introduces a +/- 17 ms uncertainty in the time measure.

It will average out over a sequence of frames, of course, but if FalseFlag had all the actual raw data to look at, discretization errors plus uncertainty in the inter-frame time (and any instability in the camera position) would guarantee a certain noisiness that we do not see in the cute little graph he's trotted out a couple of times. His data has been smoothed over, and it provides no basis for his constant acceleration claim.
 
Last edited:
Nope, his argument is perfectly valid. Another example: Skyline Towers was a completely different type of structure (cast-in-place reinforced concrete) and a different initiation cause (premature removal of shoring), but the way that the collapse was like Ronan Point and Verinage demolitions and all three WTC buildings was that, once the collapse started, the dynamic loads exceeded the structural strength. At Skyline Towers, the first couple of floors were not fully cured, but after that there was a progressive collapse through at least 20 fully cured stories with no design or construction defects. (And there was quite a bit of "dustification" BTW.)

Avoiding the subject by trying to raise another example. The partial collapse of RP was not like WTC, and it's a stretch for you to try and claim it was, just because gravity played a part in both.

It's good to see you coming out of the "truther" closet -- I think you'll feel better about yourself -- but look what you have done here: You are looking for anomalies that would confirm your belief that there was a conspiracy, so the idea that the collapses were impossible without demolition attracts your attention. When confronted with an example of a progressive collapse which implies that such things are possible, you read the rebuttal on "truther" sites about the shoddy construction. So, you now realize that a progressive collapse is possible but convince yourself that Ronan Point did not have enough structural strength to resist the dynamic loads but the WTC towers did -- without bothering to do any quantitative analysis whatsoever to justify that conclusion. And then, you don't won't to hear about an expert who has done that analysis for WTC, because they must be in on the conspiracy. (Yeah, I know you didn't actually state that last one, but you don't need to.)

That's a complete load of made up bunk. Please do me the favour of not deciding how I get my answers based on nothing whatsoever. I'm quite capable of dismissing your invalid arguments without having to resort to some sort of script, allegedly available from sites I don't even visit.
 
I'm curious about this.

You do understand that in order for any force to eject steel sections additional energy must be included to cause this effect.

Bingo, give that man a teddy bear. That's the whole point. The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large, just as the temperature required to melt steel is quite hot. It's not the sort of thing you can do by casually spilling a cup of coffee.

In other words, whoever designed the alleged cd of the towers was so nefarious that causing failure wasn't enough. They also included extra HE (or whatever your personal theory is) to hurl steel beam sections at great speeds.

Why would anyone exceed the energy requirements of an engineered event for such a pointless act?

Pointless question, I have no idea.
 

Proof 911 truth is based on BS, not science. There is nothing in the video which matches the failure of the WTC. The connections broke in the WTC, not the glass floors, and the upper mass was 12 floors and more. Thus the video is proof some people fall for BS, and 911 truth has no valid claims.

thus proving on national TV the credibility of the 9/11 movement.
No, it proves one of the nerds, is dumber than dirt, and gullible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Cortlandt_St_station_demolished.jpg

you make up a lot of BS without checking... sure saves having to do research, you wave your hands, and make up BS.
 
Last edited:
Avoiding the subject by trying to raise another example. The partial collapse of RP was not like WTC, and it's a stretch for you to try and claim it was, just because gravity played a part in both.



That's a complete load of made up bunk. Please do me the favour of not deciding how I get my answers based on nothing whatsoever. I'm quite capable of dismissing your invalid arguments without having to resort to some sort of script, allegedly available from sites I don't even visit.

Isn't he just trying to explain to you that progressive collapses can happen?
 
It will average out over a sequence of frames, of course, but if FalseFlag had all the actual raw data to look at, discretization errors plus uncertainty in the inter-frame time (and any instability in the camera position) would guarantee a certain noisiness that we do not see in the cute little graph he's trotted out a couple of times. His data has been smoothed over, and it provides no basis for his constant acceleration claim.

Was it Bazant who did his measurements with a large TV screen and a ruler :)
 
Bingo, give that man a teddy bear. That's the whole point. The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large, just as the temperature required to melt steel is quite hot. It's not the sort of thing you can do by casually spilling a cup of coffee.
So have you considered that there was no extra energy required aside from the energy contained within the collapsing building to cause this effect?



Pointless question, I have no idea.
No. Totally relevant since you've brought it up as a supporting point for your....well...umm...what is it you're trying to accomplish here again??
 
Wow, are you really suggesting that for some reason the mass of the block, or the grinded block are different?

Are you saying the impacts will be the same? They have the same mass, but very different reactions to gravity.

Come on, what will happen, stop avoiding the question.
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed breach of rule 0
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bingo, give that man a teddy bear. That's the whole point. The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large, just as the temperature required to melt steel is quite hot. It's not the sort of thing you can do by casually spilling a cup of coffee.
..., I have no idea.
On 911. I agree.

Someone by mistake added physics to their ignore list...

There was no melted steel, and the energy of the WTC collapse was 576,210,000,000 joules, which accounts for the ejected steel energy.
Real physics beats your video BS.

You got a speed yet?
Define...
great speed.
Please define in feet per second, or meters per second, be exact please.

Don't you know anything you make up? Great speed?

As the Gish Gallop enters full blown 911 truth woo, faster than free-fall; at "great speed".

Was it Bazant who did his measurements with a large TV screen and a ruler :)
You mean the work you can't debunk if you tried?>
Bazant can do differential equations on the back of a napkins, where as 911 truth does woo faster than free-fall. How is the dustification going?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FM9FeEgI0Eo
 
Last edited:
Drop it from 12 feet onto a pane of glass, then ask the question again.
Ah so in your world it is different!

Lets see, if it all impacted at roughly the same time the energy input would be pretty much the same but if I dropped 1% of it at a time (spaced by any time interval you'd like) then each individual impact would be less but the net energy after all impacts were accumulated would be the same.

Now, can you relate that to the failure of the WTC towers?
 
Are you saying the impacts will be the same? They have the same mass, but very different reactions to gravity.

Come on, what will happen, stop avoiding the question
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 0 in quote

Must be a long list. You still havent answered my question about the column being ejected into another building. So which building was that? And do you have some photographic proof?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Are you saying the impacts will be the same? They have the same mass, but very different reactions to gravity.

Come on, what will happen, stop avoiding the question
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 0 in quote
Does GPE=mgh change accordingly?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let me get this right.
I take a 5kg block of concrete or granite or similar.
Grind it in to dust and for some reason it no longer weighs 5kg?

It weighs more. You added energy by grinding it. Because Newton.

Newton comes up a lot in these discussions. Whenever someone forces me to watch another 9-11 youtube video, I feel an equal and opposite force to not watch it. This leads to a static equilibrium of no action until I have to pee. (Which Newton did throughout his life.)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom