If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are so many problems wrapped together in there it is hard to know where to start.

When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.

This is a very interesting point when you look at how much of the basements in the WTC complex survived with minor damage. According to your progressive collapse theories, everything would have sunk down to bedrock, possibly digging new holes to Tibet, when this is clearly not the case.

Isn't this also how you account for the instantaneous creation of massive dust clouds? The structural integrity of the standing stories manages to crush and be crushed by the falling mass, ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.

There were no steel sections ejected laterally into other buildings.
 
I really thought I would get banned, but I'm still alive.
Why would you get banned? Have you been violating the Membership Agreement?

Challenge 1.

Prove Newton's first law is wrong.
Newton's first law is not wrong.

Challenge 1a.

Prove the following example is wrong.

[...]

As long as the net force is zero, the object will stay at rest.
Your example ignores the ability of the materials involved to resist the forces being applied to them. However, assuming the objects can resist the forces, your example is not wrong.

Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law.
The ability of objects to resist forces depends on their material properties, and varies with scale.

Some materials are able to resist relatively great forces at small scales, but are able to resist only small forces at greater scales. One of the biggest challenges in structural engineering is in finding the right materials to use at a given scale, in order to resist the forces at that scale.

Designing and engineering structures that direct forces to joints and foundations made of the right materials for that scale, in a way that is both effective and efficient, is the acme of the profession.

Your example is not wrong; it is just too simplistic to be of much use. Without considering the material properties of the objects involved, and without considering the scales involved, your example doesn't tell us anything about how a real-world scenario would perform, nor how one real-world scenario compares to another. Newton's first law is only the beginning of a long, complex, and difficult journey. It's not the final destination.
 
In the cases of WTC and Ronan point the impacting/impacted storeys were essentially identical.

How can you possibly justify that statement? Not only are the buildings incomparable, but what happened is nowhere near similar.

Go look at the pictures of Ronan point again, and see how large portions of concrete slab did not fall, but practically hinged and remained intact suspended above the damaged area. This also happened in the basements of the WTC complex, and should have happened in the towers and building 7.


There was massive damage to the basements and almost total destruction of the subway station. But the form and strength of the structures down there (which included the foundations) was different so the collapse arrested eventually.

That's nicely vague isn't it, care to be more precise about the extent of this massive damage? Make sure to point out which bits suffered this massive damage, and which bits remained quite intact enough for people to walk through.

Yes, and the collapse acceleration would depend, to an extent, on mass being ejected from the building's footprint.

Of course it would. Nice implied minimalisation.

But new mass is always being added in the collapse zone.

And it is always being resisted, and pulverised, and ejected, and carried by the wind and doing all sorts of things. For each storey that falls, remember that some (large amounts?) of that mass is getting converted into dust, which will have no discernible effect on the floors below. I don't care how much dust you have, it's going to take a hell of a lot of it to break a floor, yet you are including that in your calculations of mass.

So what we are left with is the spandrels, which mostly fell outward, core columns, which tended to fall after the floors collapsed, and the trusses, which strangely don't appear in much of the photographic evidence of the rubble. There were tens of thousands of them, and they should have been scrapped in a pile where the lobbies used to be.

I'm assuming you've seen this video http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2draq1_nerd-wins-challenge-with-9-11-truth-physics-sd_news

As an aside, many of the videos I've seen out there (and some of them are junk) have to use restraining devices to stop parts of the experiments falling off sideways, as the path of least resistance is not always straight down, unless you are on ISF.
 
How can you possibly justify that statement? Not only are the buildings incomparable, but what happened is nowhere near similar.

Go look at the pictures of Ronan point again, and see how large portions of concrete slab did not fall, but practically hinged and remained intact suspended above the damaged area. This also happened in the basements of the WTC complex, and should have happened in the towers and building 7.




That's nicely vague isn't it, care to be more precise about the extent of this massive damage? Make sure to point out which bits suffered this massive damage, and which bits remained quite intact enough for people to walk through.



Of course it would. Nice implied minimalisation.



And it is always being resisted, and pulverised, and ejected, and carried by the wind and doing all sorts of things. For each storey that falls, remember that some (large amounts?) of that mass is getting converted into dust, which will have no discernible effect on the floors below. I don't care how much dust you have, it's going to take a hell of a lot of it to break a floor, yet you are including that in your calculations of mass.

So what we are left with is the spandrels, which mostly fell outward, core columns, which tended to fall after the floors collapsed, and the trusses, which strangely don't appear in much of the photographic evidence of the rubble. There were tens of thousands of them, and they should have been scrapped in a pile where the lobbies used to be.

I'm assuming you've seen this video http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2draq1_nerd-wins-challenge-with-9-11-truth-physics-sd_news

As an aside, many of the videos I've seen out there (and some of them are junk) have to use restraining devices to stop parts of the experiments falling off sideways, as the path of least resistance is not always straight down, unless you are on ISF.

Ok, what weighs more? A bag of steel of 10 kilo, or a bag of feathers of 10 kilo?
 
Your example is not wrong; it is just too simplistic to be of much use. Without considering the material properties of the objects involved, and without considering the scales involved, your example doesn't tell us anything about how a real-world scenario would perform, nor how one real-world scenario compares to another. Newton's first law is only the beginning of a long, complex, and difficult journey. It's not the final destination.

Taking N1L in isolation, I think shape would play a massive part. It's much easier to push a ball than a pyramid (base down) of the same mass ;)
 
How can you possibly justify that statement? Not only are the buildings incomparable, but what happened is nowhere near similar.

Go look at the pictures of Ronan point again, and see how large portions of concrete slab did not fall, but practically hinged and remained intact suspended above the damaged area. This also happened in the basements of the WTC complex, and should have happened in the towers and building 7.

That's nicely vague isn't it, care to be more precise about the extent of this massive damage? Make sure to point out which bits suffered this massive damage, and which bits remained quite intact enough for people to walk through.

Of course it would. Nice implied minimalisation.

And it is always being resisted, and pulverised, and ejected, and carried by the wind and doing all sorts of things. For each storey that falls, remember that some (large amounts?) of that mass is getting converted into dust, which will have no discernible effect on the floors below. I don't care how much dust you have, it's going to take a hell of a lot of it to break a floor, yet you are including that in your calculations of mass.

So what we are left with is the spandrels, which mostly fell outward, core columns, which tended to fall after the floors collapsed, and the trusses, which strangely don't appear in much of the photographic evidence of the rubble. There were tens of thousands of them, and they should have been scrapped in a pile where the lobbies used to be.

I'm assuming you've seen this video http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2draq1_nerd-wins-challenge-with-9-11-truth-physics-sd_news

As an aside, many of the videos I've seen out there (and some of them are junk) have to use restraining devices to stop parts of the experiments falling off sideways, as the path of least resistance is not always straight down, unless you are on ISF.

The steel was not turned to dust, and the mass continues to get larger.

LOL< now dust is mass-less. Cool, make up some delusional version of 911 truth physics; dust is mass free. Cool; keep up the 911 truth work of woo; alive terrorists, unable to figure out which planes, now mass-less dust.

you fail to accept what is alike, and adopt the dustify BS from 911 truth.
Thus a pile of sand can't be treated like mass? Darn, shotguns fail to work in 911 truth fantasy physics world of woo


And then the super physics of 911 truth land...
as the path of least resistance is not always straight down,
There is no path of least resistance BS rule for falling objects; if you had this BS rule no one would be able to tackle anyone. What a stupid rule.

AClark, keep the BS 911 truth tag-lines flowing, I am only posting to capture the BS live.

In one post you exposed you don't realize how the WTC tower or WTC 7 was built; as you say the WTC towers should look like a building they were not like.
The basement of the WTC complex is not like the WTC towers; the towers ended at ground level and slightly above. The typical WTC tower had no concrete structure, it was steel; the floors were light weight concrete on steel pans...
The Basement is not like the towers, or WTC 7.
To tell us how the WTC towers should have stopped falling, or looked like some other buildings is only exposing the lack of research your opinions always end up being built on.
 
Last edited:
Why would you get banned? Have you been violating the Membership Agreement?


Newton's first law is not wrong.


Your example ignores the ability of the materials involved to resist the forces being applied to them. However, assuming the objects can resist the forces, your example is not wrong.


The ability of objects to resist forces depends on their material properties, and varies with scale.

Some materials are able to resist relatively great forces at small scales, but are able to resist only small forces at greater scales. One of the biggest challenges in structural engineering is in finding the right materials to use at a given scale, in order to resist the forces at that scale.

Designing and engineering structures that direct forces to joints and foundations made of the right materials for that scale, in a way that is both effective and efficient, is the acme of the profession.

Your example is not wrong; it is just too simplistic to be of much use. Without considering the material properties of the objects involved, and without considering the scales involved, your example doesn't tell us anything about how a real-world scenario would perform, nor how one real-world scenario compares to another. Newton's first law is only the beginning of a long, complex, and difficult journey. It's not the final destination.

"Challenge 1b. Explain how scale could make any difference in regards to Newton's first law."

On Earth? k..... walks about on frozen lake, puts down square centimeter of steel in vacuum jar, nothing happens.... walks out on frozen lake carrying square meter of steel in vacuum jar, surface breaks, steel plummets to lake bed.
 
FalseFlag, have you ever worked through the Horse Cart Problem? It's a standard student exercise for learning to understand and correctly apply basic Newtonian physics instead of falling into common errors.

The problem is this: A horse is hitched to a cart. The cart is motionless. The horse pulls on the cart; this applies a force to the cart, in the forward direction (the way the horse is facing). But the cart, by Newton's third law, applies an equal force to the horse, in the opposite direction. Because the forces are balanced, the cart will not move.

Given that horses can in fact pull carts, what is wrong with the reasoning in the previous paragraph? There is a more accurate explanation of what actually happens when a horse pulls a cart, which is in fact consistent with Newton's laws. Can you provide it?
Can you prove your challenge is grounded in Newtonian mechanics?
 
The steel was not turned to dust, and the mass continues to get larger.

LOL< now dust is mass-less. Cool, make up some delusional version of 911 truth physics; dust is mass free. Cool; keep up the 911 truth work of woo; alive terrorists, unable to figure out which planes, now mass-less dust.

you fail to accept what is alike, and adopt the dustify BS from 911 truth.
Thus a pile of sand can't be treated like mass? Darn, shotguns fail to work in 911 truth fantasy physics world of woo


And then the super physics of 911 truth land...

There is no path of least resistance BS rule for falling objects; if you had this BS rule no one would be able to tackle anyone. What a stupid rule.

AClark, keep the BS 911 truth tag-lines flowing, I am only posting to capture the BS live.

In one post you exposed you don't realize how the WTC tower or WTC 7 was built; as you say the WTC towers should look like a building they were not like.
The basement of the WTC complex is not like the WTC towers; the towers ended at ground level and slightly above. The typical WTC tower had no concrete structure, it was steel; the floors were light weight concrete on steel pans...
The Basement is not like the towers, or WTC 7.
To tell us how the WTC towers should have stopped falling, or looked like some other buildings is only exposing the lack of research your opinions always end up being built on.

I never understand why they come up with the path of least resistance nonsense tbh. Because according to that rule, they can park their car underneath a falling container, and instead of crushing the car, the container will fall beside the car, since the car will resist the fall.
 
Are you trying to compare Ronan Point to any of the events on 9/11?

Ronan Point was a cheap Plattenbau thrown together by cowboy builders, and was damaged by dun, dun, dun! an explosion.

Far from being a steel framed high rise, it was literally a house of cards held together by gravity and hope.

But, even though a gas explosion occurred high up (18/22), only a small section of this sub-standard building suffered any sort of failure, it did not dustify itself. In fact, it was rebuilt since there was only minimal damage.

Your argument is invalid.

Nope, his argument is perfectly valid. Another example: Skyline Towers was a completely different type of structure (cast-in-place reinforced concrete) and a different initiation cause (premature removal of shoring), but the way that the collapse was like Ronan Point and Verinage demolitions and all three WTC buildings was that, once the collapse started, the dynamic loads exceeded the structural strength. At Skyline Towers, the first couple of floors were not fully cured, but after that there was a progressive collapse through at least 20 fully cured stories with no design or construction defects. (And there was quite a bit of "dustification" BTW.)

It's good to see you coming out of the "truther" closet -- I think you'll feel better about yourself -- but look what you have done here: You are looking for anomalies that would confirm your belief that there was a conspiracy, so the idea that the collapses were impossible without demolition attracts your attention. When confronted with an example of a progressive collapse which implies that such things are possible, you read the rebuttal on "truther" sites about the shoddy construction. So, you now realize that a progressive collapse is possible but convince yourself that Ronan Point did not have enough structural strength to resist the dynamic loads but the WTC towers did -- without bothering to do any quantitative analysis whatsoever to justify that conclusion. And then, you don't won't to hear about an expert who has done that analysis for WTC, because they must be in on the conspiracy. (Yeah, I know you didn't actually state that last one, but you don't need to.)
 
Let me get this right.
I take a 5kg block of concrete or granite or similar.
Grind it in to dust and for some reason it no longer weighs 5kg?
 
How can you possibly justify that statement? Not only are the buildings incomparable, but what happened is nowhere near similar.

ffs. In each case, considered separately, the components were essentially identical.

That's nicely vague isn't it, care to be more precise about the extent of this massive damage? Make sure to point out which bits suffered this massive damage, and which bits remained quite intact enough for people to walk through.

Yet again, you should educate yourself with public sources before sounding off and making demands. The underground damage at WTC is well documented.

And it is always being resisted, and pulverised, and ejected, and carried by the wind and doing all sorts of things. For each storey that falls, remember that some (large amounts?) of that mass is getting converted into dust, which will have no discernible effect on the floors below. I don't care how much dust you have, it's going to take a hell of a lot of it to break a floor, yet you are including that in your calculations of mass.

The dust was primarily smashed gypsum wallboard, insulating material and some comminuted concrete from the floors. Lightweight material, in short, which is why it drifted so readily. Studies (of which you are no doubt ignorant) were performed into the composition of that very dust. Search for 9/11 Lioy et al for an education but don't expect others to do your legwork for you.

But the point remains: at each (theoretical) collision relatively little of the previous floor to be impacted had been ejected - there wasn't enough time between floor impacts for that to happen.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom