If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is the definition of scale, according to the Cambridge dictionary:
the ​relationship of the ​size of a ​map, ​drawing, or ​model of something to the ​size of the ​actual thing.
Source: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/scale

Some of you keep using the earth and moon as examples of scale. What you are really trying to say is that the size of the object affects Newton's first law of motion. You are wrong. Neither scale nor size affects Newton's first law of motion.

Interesting attempt at cherry picking. That is, in fact, one of the Cambridge Dictionary's definitions of "scale" (out of 15 or so--congratualtions: you have discovered that English has homophones).

A more appropriate source for you to consider would be here.

I repeat, since you have not read it yet: It is not that the scale of the Earth and the Moon mean that Newton's First Law of Motion does not apply. The Earth and the Moon will accelerate toward each other (as described by Newton's First Law of Motion) until the forces acting between them, and upon them, are balanced (at which point you will have on semi-solid, nearly spherical, mass).
 
Last edited:
You're misunderstanding the Third Law. The force of body A on body B is equal and opposite to the force of body B on body A. This is as true in GR as it is in Newtonian mechanics. There doesn't need to be an outward force on either object.

I would recommend that you too work through Myriad's Horse Cart problem. It's really quite instructive, once you get it, as to what reaction forces react against.



I am a physicist, and I can see that the fallacy perpetrated by the progressive collapse deniers is much simpler than that. They effectively assume that, when a section of the structure collides with the section below, it magically ceases to exist. They assume that its potential energy is used up and that it can't acquire any more, when in fact it's still there and still falling, hence releasing yet more potential energy. And, hence, Ronan Point as an example, which despite FalseFlag's ignorant dismissal is in fact a classic example of progressive collapse, and would be acknowledged as such by any competent structural engineer. Each collapsing floor released more debris, not less, so the destructive force increased rather than decreasing as the collapse progressed. The invocation of Newton's Third in the first place is completely fallacious, and appears to stem from scientific illiteracy if not outright dishonesty.

Dave

That's because chandler is looking at gravity as a Newtonian force where the energy of the colliding masses cancels out Dave, I am not.
The force exerted by the upper mass on the lower mass by the upper masses gravity well, as far as I can tell, is equal too, about 2.5 hydrogen atoms.
It is insignificant given the gravitational well produced by the earth.

I am probably not right Dave and I value your knowledge I am merely going into an appraisal
Of Chandler's theories based on how he represents them.
 
Interesting attempt at cherry picking. That is, in fact, one of the Cambridge Dictionary's definitions of "scale" (out of 15 or so00congratualtions: you have discovered that English has homophones).

A more appropriate source for you to consider would be here.

I repeat, since you have not read it yet: It is not that the scale of the Earth and the Moon mean that Newton's First Law of Motion does not apply. The Earth and the Moon will accelerate toward each other (as described by Newton's First Law of Motion) until the forces acting between them, and upon them, are balanced (at which point you will have on semi-solid, nearly spherical, mass).

Actually I think you'll find it's his second law that describes the motion under F=ma.

I'd also debate that the forces are unequal. The forces are equal, but just greater then the force required to deform the materials that make up both Earth and Moon meaning that both deform under the the forces being applied
 
Actually I think you'll find it's his second law that describes the motion under F=ma.

I'd also debate that the forces are unequal. The forces are equal, but just greater then the force required to deform the materials that make up both Earth and Moon meaning that both deform under the the forces being applied

If I may nit-pick, just a bit:

F=ma quantifies the forces.

The First Law describes the effects of the forces.

(I did not say the forces are unequal, but unbalanced--the tensile forces holding the bodies in shape are less than the attraction of their masses for each other. The centers of the masses will accelerate toward each other until equilibrium is reached...as you say, they will deform under the forces.)
 
And, hence, Ronan Point as an example, which despite FalseFlag's ignorant dismissal is in fact a classic example of progressive collapse, and would be acknowledged as such by any competent structural engineer. Each collapsing floor released more debris, not less, so the destructive force increased rather than decreasing as the collapse progressed. The invocation of Newton's Third in the first place is completely fallacious, and appears to stem from scientific illiteracy if not outright dishonesty.

Dave

Are you trying to compare Ronan Point to any of the events on 9/11?

Ronan Point was a cheap Plattenbau thrown together by cowboy builders, and was damaged by dun, dun, dun! an explosion.

Far from being a steel framed high rise, it was literally a house of cards held together by gravity and hope.

But, even though a gas explosion occurred high up (18/22), only a small section of this sub-standard building suffered any sort of failure, it did not dustify itself. In fact, it was rebuilt since there was only minimal damage.

Your argument is invalid.
 
Just let him hold out a 20 pound rock straight in front of him for 10 minutes. Maybe then hè understands gravity.
 
Chainsaw, the weight of the upper mass is a gravitational force between that mass and the entire earth (of which the lower mass is an insignificant part). The reaction force is therefore a pull by the upper mass on the entire earth (again including the lower mass as an insignificantly tiny portion). The gravitational force of the upper mass on the lower mass alone is, as you say, extremely small, but that doesn't matter in assessing the overall applicability of Newton's laws here.

That reaction force really exists, even though we usually disregard it. When a ten-pound weight rests on the ground, it really does pull the earth toward it with a force of ten pounds, not just a few molecules' weights worth of force.

We don't notice this for two reasons. One is that the ten pound force is insignificant compared with the mass of the entire earth. The other is that the reaction force really does attract all the matter of the entire earth more or less evenly, rather than being noticeably concentrated toward the closet portion of it. So, for instance, dirt doesn't get lifted up off the ground when you hold a weight above it.
 
Are you trying to compare Ronan Point to any of the events on 9/11?

Ronan Point was a cheap Plattenbau thrown together by cowboy builders, and was damaged by dun, dun, dun! an explosion.

Far from being a steel framed high rise, it was literally a house of cards held together by gravity and hope.

But, even though a gas explosion occurred high up (18/22), only a small section of this sub-standard building suffered any sort of failure, it did not dustify itself. In fact, it was rebuilt since there was only minimal damage.

Your argument is invalid.

What building was dustified?
 
Are you trying to compare Ronan Point to any of the events on 9/11?

Ronan Point was a cheap Plattenbau thrown together by cowboy builders, and was damaged by dun, dun, dun! an explosion.

Far from being a steel framed high rise, it was literally a house of cards held together by gravity and hope.

But, even though a gas explosion occurred high up (18/22), only a small section of this sub-standard building suffered any sort of failure, it did not dustify itself. In fact, it was rebuilt since there was only minimal damage.

Your argument is invalid.

It's perfectly valid for debunking the Truther fallacy that, somehow, a falling storey can only do one storey's worth of destruction below it. This typically takes the form "If 12 storeys fall then collapse should arrest 12 storeys down". This fallacy (as was pointed out by Dave earlier and has been repeated in this forum thousands of times) is based on forgetting that with each storey of fall the original mass gets moving again together with the added mass of the destroyed floor.

FalseFlag has repeated the fallacious argument.

The quality of the building is neither here nor there for this purpose.
 
Far from being a steel framed high rise, it was literally a house of cards held together by gravity and hope.


Literally a house of cards? They must not have used Hallmark cards, because they didn't care enough to send the very best.

Maybe they got confused and put the high cards on the top (an understandable mistake). When they built Trump Tower they avoided that problem by building it entirely out of trump cards.

But we all know jet fuel can't meld sevens! 9/Jack was an inside straight! Call their bluff; it's all a trick!
 
Last edited:
Literally a house of cards? They must not have used Hallmark cards, because they didn't care enough to send the very best.

Maybe they got confused and put the high cards on the top (an understandable mistake). When they built Trump Tower they avoided that problem by building it entirely out of trump cards.

But we all know jet fuel can't meld sevens! 9/Jack was an inside straight! Call their bluff; it's all a trick!

Well played, with finesse.

:bigclap:
 
It's perfectly valid for debunking the Truther fallacy that, somehow, a falling storey can only do one storey's worth of destruction below it. This typically takes the form "If 12 storeys fall then collapse should arrest 12 storeys down". This fallacy (as was pointed out by Dave earlier and has been repeated in this forum thousands of times) is based on forgetting that with each storey of fall the original mass gets moving again together with the added mass of the destroyed floor.

FalseFlag has repeated the fallacious argument.

The quality of the building is neither here nor there for this purpose.

There are so many problems wrapped together in there it is hard to know where to start.

When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.

This is a very interesting point when you look at how much of the basements in the WTC complex survived with minor damage. According to your progressive collapse theories, everything would have sunk down to bedrock, possibly digging new holes to Tibet, when this is clearly not the case.

Isn't this also how you account for the instantaneous creation of massive dust clouds? The structural integrity of the standing stories manages to crush and be crushed by the falling mass, ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.
 
There are so many problems wrapped together in there it is hard to know where to start.

When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.
Would it? Why then do you question flight 93?

This is a very interesting point when you look at how much of the basements in the WTC complex survived with minor damage. According to your progressive collapse theories, everything would have sunk down to bedrock, possibly digging new holes to Tibet, when this is clearly not the case.
Strawman. Nobody made that claim but you.

Isn't this also how you account for the instantaneous creation of massive dust clouds?
No.

The structural integrity of the standing stories manages to crush and be crushed by the falling mass, ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.
Incoherent.
 
There are so many problems wrapped together in there it is hard to know where to start.

When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.

In the cases of WTC and Ronan point the impacting/impacted storeys were essentially identical.

This is a very interesting point when you look at how much of the basements in the WTC complex survived with minor damage. According to your progressive collapse theories, everything would have sunk down to bedrock, possibly digging new holes to Tibet, when this is clearly not the case.

There was massive damage to the basements and almost total destruction of the PATH subway station (4 storeys down). But the form and strength of the structures down there (which included the foundations) was different so the collapse arrested eventually.

Isn't this also how you account for the instantaneous creation of massive dust clouds? The structural integrity of the standing stories manages to crush and be crushed by the falling mass, ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.

Yes, and the collapse acceleration would depend, to an extent, on mass being ejected from the building's footprint. But new mass is always being added in the collapse zone.
 
Last edited:
There are so many problems wrapped together in there it is hard to know where to start.

When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.

This is a very interesting point when you look at how much of the basements in the WTC complex survived with minor damage. According to your progressive collapse theories, everything would have sunk down to bedrock, possibly digging new holes to Tibet, when this is clearly not the case.

Isn't this also how you account for the instantaneous creation of massive dust clouds? The structural integrity of the standing stories manages to crush and be crushed by the falling mass, ejecting not only dust and ash, but entire steel sections laterally into nearby buildings at great speed.
What survived in the Basement?
Are you saying the basement is not the same as a WTC tower floor which can only hold 29,000,000 pound max?
Since the basement is not like a WTC floor, the basement will be damaged according to how much energy it can take, and thus, parts of the basement will be damaged, some will be less damage. Some might look perfect... but there was damage deep into the basement.
Did you resaerch this before you made up BS? No.
You can treat the mass as mass, and what you said does not make much sense except as an opinion on mass.
What was the speed of ejection? BTW, the ejections were driven by the gravity collapse, and the energy from gravity stored in the WTC towers.
Ejections were part of the energy of collapse, with 576,210,000,000 joule of energy in each tower released, what is the problem? Too much energy? Can you quantify the energy required for the steel ejected? Got an example you can't figure out.

It is not a theory, you have BS theories, what happened to the WTC towers is reality, not theory; a gravity collapse. The dust is mostly wallboard and insulation and concrete; failure to do research shows up again.

The collapse was driven by what a WTC floor can hold, and thus the Basement is no longer a WTC floor, but what the WTC was built on, and thus the mass will destroy sections of the basement and be arrested... but then you make up BS instead of checking the engineering results of months of digging out the WTC. You are denying physics now, with your BS high speed junk?

The gravity collapse is not a theory, and the dust is a product of the collapse.
 
Last edited:
Are you trying to compare Ronan Point to any of the events on 9/11?

Yes, because as any competent structural engineer understands, there are some similarities from which common lessons can be learned. For example:

But, even though a gas explosion occurred high up (18/22), only a small section of this sub-standard building suffered any sort of failure,

However, sections of the building whose static loads were undeniably supported by the structure nevertheless failed under dynamic loading in a downward progressing collapse. There are parallels, and the key to learning things is to understand how different events are and are not similar rather than rejecting all prior knowledge because the present situation is not exactly the same.

it did not dustify itself.

Oh, for Christ's sake, change the bloody record and stop parroting truther ********. Neither did the WTC.

Dave
 
When you are dealing with stories falling, mass is not the only consideration, you also have to look at the structural strength of what is falling, and whatever is resisting it, otherwise anything that falls to the ground would end up in a hole half as deep or more as it is tall.

You've got the wrong problem there. If Cole were right that every falling floor could destroy exactly the same amount of material from the structure below, then starting demolitions from the bottom would be a very bad idea. It would be a better idea to stop trying to hold a competition to see who can make up the stupidest piece of cartoon physics, an area where I'll gladly acknowledge Cole's mastery.

Dave
 
... , it did not dustify itself. In fact, it was rebuilt since there was only minimal damage.

Your argument is invalid.
What was the argument?

Are you using the old 911 truth, "dustify itself". (576,210,000,000 joules available per tower)

lol, dustify. 911 truth's proof of BS coming in big piles faster than free-fall.


Define...
great speed.
Please define in feet per second, or meters per second, be exact please.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom