If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would I reject my own opinions?

Interesting admission. I would, and do, change my opinions all the time in the face of evidence. It wouldn't have taken me 56 pages to have understood quite clearly that my opinion was flat-out wrong if I had been in your shoes. It wouldn't have taken 56 posts. To say, as you have just done, that your opinions are impervious to facts, is revealing.
 
Did he get a chance to present all of his evidence to everyone who voted? No.
He is not making the same mistake again this year. The resolution he is presenting this year will contain the evidence that indicates NIST's version of events is wrong.
Would that be the same evidence he said he'd present to the Europeans two years ago?

How'd that work out?
 
*sigh*

You claim I don't understand Newton's laws of motion. Please provide a link to a post where I show that I don't understand Newton's laws of motion. Once you show this, please provide another link to a credible source that proves I am wrong.

No. There are 30 pages plus of discussion of your shortcomings in this area, in this thread. You have a fundamental misunderstanding of physics, and Newton, and that has been shown over and over in this thread.
 
Interesting admission. I would, and do, change my opinions all the time in the face of evidence. It wouldn't have taken me 56 pages to have understood quite clearly that my opinion was flat-out wrong if I had been in your shoes. It wouldn't have taken 56 posts. To say, as you have just done, that your opinions are impervious to facts, is revealing.

Did I ever say my opinions were not based on facts? No. If my opinions are based on facts, why would I reject them? If I learn new facts, I might change my opinion, but that is different from rejecting it.
 
Did I ever say my opinions were not based on facts? No. If my opinions are based on facts, why would I reject them? If I learn new facts, I might change my opinion, but that is different from rejecting it.

Your opinions are NOT based on facts. There isn't any substance behind any of them, and there are huge, childish, misunderstandings of physics and building structure. Who'll ever forget the classic which brought me into the thread in the first place, your ridiculous bollocks about every floor supporting all the floors above.
 
No. There are 30 pages plus of discussion of your shortcomings in this area, in this thread. You have a fundamental misunderstanding of physics, and Newton, and that has been shown over and over in this thread.

Please provide proof.
 
I tried to explain scale to an obstinate truther here once before. My theory was - OK, the top 15 or 20 stories of a building won't crush the rest. How about 50 stories? How about 100 stories? How about 10,000 stories? That resulted in a theoretical "moon-sized field of rubble" dropped from one story above them not destroying the World Trade Center towers.

If someone were game, they could do the same with rodents and mammals and a matchbox car or Volkswagen. Good luck! :thumbsup:



{:hamster: < :dogt: < :kangaroo: < :hippo: < :elephant: }


_________________________________________

:mysteryma​
 
Did he get a chance to present all of his evidence to everyone who voted? No.
He is not making the same mistake again this year. The resolution he is presenting this year will contain the evidence that indicates NIST's version of events is wrong.
The problem is, he needs to get David Ray Griffen to do the presentation. As Gage said himself, it wasn't until a American professor of philosophy of religion and theology explained it to him did it become clear.
 
Last edited:
From Cole's video at 1:25 -

So, any objects that have that have similar accelerations will have the same direction and the same sequence of net force, and it's independent of scale.

1. Similar accelerations = similar directions of force

2. Same sequence of net force

3. Independent of scale

His experiments are how he demonstrated similar accelerations, similar directions of net force, and the same sequence of net force.

What instrument is needed to observe how two objects have the same sequence and same direction of net force? I think the only instrument a person needs to calibrate is their brain, so they understand what they see with their eyes.

What standard do we calibrate the brain against?
 
I just now answered your question in that thread.



Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics. My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.

Your next question is, what is my educational background. Answer: It's more than enough to understand basic physics. You can take a grade-school science class and understand Newton's laws of motion. I know you going to argue against this, because you must argue against everything I say. That does not mean you are right, or that I am wrong.

When are you going to do so?
 
Please perform an experiment that shows Cole is wrong. Once someone, anyone, performs an experiment to prove Cole is wrong then you can claim I don't understand basic physics.

That experiment happened on 911, three times.
 
Newton's third law of motion is clearly stated. Any attempt by you to change Newton's words to support your version of events or understanding of science is clear proof that you are playing by your own rules and reject whatever you don't like.

The list of things that you don't understand just never gets any shorter, does it? The force of gravity between the Earth and the building are equal and opposite to each other. When the building was standing, the contact force and reaction between the two were also equal and opposite to each other, but that's a completely different force. When the building was standing, the contact force must have been equal to (but not the same thing as) the gravity force, because it they weren't equal, the building wouldn't stand up. When the top mass was set in motion, the impact forces in the collisions were also equal and opposite on the colliding objects, but there is absolutely no reason to think they were equal to the force of gravity. In fact, the collapse is simply convincing evidence that they weren't equal. I have not "change[d] Newton's words to support [my] version of events or understanding science"; you simply don't understand how to apply them in a real-world situation.

There is no reason for me to summarize anything. Cole's video stands on its own.

If you could state Cole's argument in your own words, it might help in pinpointing where your reasoning fails you. But I suspect you are correct: there's no good reason to waste time doing that.

Once again you claim he is wrong, yet you have not performed any experiment to prove he is wrong.

You keep saying that, and yet the experiment in the NMSR video proves Cole is wrong. Instead of realizing why that's so, you try to weasle out of it by suddenly realizing that that model is not an accurate dynamic model of the WTC towers -- which it was never intended to be, unlike Cole's models. It does, however, show quite clearly that there must be something wrong with Cole's reasoning: the collapse proceeds all the way down, apparently never once violating Newton's laws. Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers are also proof that Cole's conclusion must be wrong -- progressive vertical collapse can go through any number of floors without explosives -- and again, you try to dodge that by saying they weren't the same type of construction as the WTC. That's about as self-refuting a rebuttal as I've ever seen: Cole's small-scale models (which bear no pertinent similarity to the WTC towers) are supposed to tell us something about the WTC, but full-size building collapses don't tell us anything unless they are exactly the same construction as the WTC. What a hoot.
 
... The entire structure collapsed as if there was nothing there. ...
This is a lie, and lies are what 9/11 truth uses to fool a fringe few to believe CD; silent explosives CD.

Prove, "The entire structure collapsed as if there was nothing there." Prove it; you can't do the physics, or take the time to "time" the collapse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom