If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
<snip>
Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics. My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.<snip>

This statement of yours is utterly unsupported by your posting, given your recalcitrance at accepting correction about your complete and pervasive misunderstanding as to the nature of the abject failure of Cole's "demonstration".

Your mind is made up; and you will allow no amount of helpful education to assist you in overcoming even your most basic error.

Then again, you seem to be unable to remember that you left the thread in high dudgeon, never to return...
 
This statement of yours is utterly unsupported by your posting, given your recalcitrance at accepting correction about your complete and pervasive misunderstanding as to the nature of the abject failure of Cole's "demonstration".
Please perform an experiment that shows Cole is wrong. Once someone, anyone, performs an experiment to prove Cole is wrong then you can claim I don't understand basic physics.
 
Your posts support the reverse claim.
Please copy and paste one of my claims which clearly shows I don't understand basic physics. If you choose to copy and paste a claim of mine, please make sure you post a link to a credible source that clearly shows why my statement about basic physics is wrong.

Make sure you state why the link you provide clearly proves I am wrong.
 
Please copy and paste one of my claims which clearly shows I don't understand basic physics.

You must think that this sort of argument is very clever, but here's some news for you: it isn't. You are basically using a "tactic" whereby you constantly ask people to post, re-post and re-re-post stuff over and over again in some transparent pretense that you never saw that stuff before.

You've been told and shown where you were wrong over and over and over. Don't pretend that it didn't happen, because no one believes you. What you type doesn't change reality, and you are making yourself look like a total fool for everybody to see.
 
You are being deliberately obtuse. My point is that posting the school textbook definition of science doesn't really mean you understand what it's about.
Really? How hard is it to understand Newton's laws of motion? Well, I know how hard it is for skeptics to understand them, but to everyone else they are pretty basic stuff.
 
You've been told and shown where you were wrong over and over and over. Don't pretend that it didn't happen, because no one believes you. What you type doesn't change reality, and you are making yourself look like a total fool for everybody to see.
No, I have not been shown, even one time, that Cole is wrong. Skeptics have repeatedly made written arguments that claim Cole is wrong, but no one has performed an experiment to prove he is wrong. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.
 
Please perform an experiment that shows Cole is wrong. Once someone, anyone, performs an experiment to prove Cole is wrong then you can claim I don't understand basic physics.

In 56 pages, you have not allowed yourself to learn anything. Cole's own "demonstrations" show that Cole is hoping to get way with misapplying actual physics.

Say what you will, it is still the issue of scaling that makes Cole's "model" a simply irrelevant tool for considering how a tower of a much different scale, with much different size/strength ratios, actually collapsed. It is the problem of dropping a hamster on a MatchboxTM model in order to predict what would happen were you to drop an elephant on an actual car...

Nor does your posing change that.
 
In 56 pages, you have not allowed yourself to learn anything.

Please provide one fact that I have refused to learn. Don't post an opintion that you claim I have not learned, post a fact that you claim I have not learned.

Cole's own "demonstrations" show that Cole is hoping to get way with misapplying actual physics.
Please provide proof he is hoping to get away with misapplying physics. If you claim he has performed his experiments in some sort of parallel universe where the laws of motion are different, then please perform the exact same experiments and show the results.

Say what you will, it is still the issue of scaling that makes Cole's "model" a simply irrelevant tool for considering how a tower of a much different scale, with much different size/strength ratios, actually collapsed. It is the problem of dropping a hamster on a MatchboxTM model in order to predict what would happen were you to drop an elephant on an actual car...

Cole clearly addresses the issue of scaling. I copied and pasted his exact words in a previous post. You make a claim that he is wrong. Your claim is nothing without proof. Please perform an experiment that shows that the direction of force and the sequence of force are dependent on scale.

Here is the text of the post where Cole addresses the issue of scale:
From Cole's video at 1:25 -

Cole's narration - "So, any objects that have that have similar accelerations will have the same direction and the same sequence of net force, and it's independent of scale."

1. Similar accelerations = similar directions of force

2. Same sequence of net force

3. Independent of scale
 
Last edited:
...Cole clearly addresses the issue of scaling. I copied and pasted his exact words in a previous post. You make a claim that he is wrong. Your claim is nothing without proof. Please perform an experiment that shows that the direction of force and the sequence of force are dependent on scale.
But Cole's experiments failed to model the WTC event. Big fail. What happened to your constant acceleration?

And....
At the 480 post you made a promise...
... This is my final post in this thread. ...

You lie about stuff, and 9/11... as you broke this promise over 47 times
If you understood physics, you would understand Cole's experiments failed.
 
It must be from 40 pages ago at least that we were talking about requiring maths as a critical part of the analysis of any ...... any.......experiment, yet you keep asking about it. Therefore, in the context of you asking (in a manner which suggests you have never heard the suggestion before) what maths has to do with an experiment, my answer ("if you've got to ask you'll never know") seems pretty apposite.

No, your answer seems more nonsensical than anything else.
 
<posturing snip>

Is it your contention, then, that the damage done to a MatchboxTM car when a hamster is dropped on it is a good, predictive model of the damage that would be done to a Fiat 500 if an elephant were to be dropped upon it (to say nothing of the relative experiences of the hamster and the elephant...)?
 
It is the problem of dropping a hamster on a MatchboxTM model in order to predict what would happen were you to drop an elephant on an actual car...

Please show that similar accelerations will nothave similar directions of net force. Please show that similar accelerations will not have similar sequences of the net forces involved.

Please drop a hamster on a matchbox car, and then drop an elephant on an actual car. Then, comparing the two events, please explain how the direction of the net forces and sequence of the net forces are different. The magnitude of the forces are not relevant, because the magnitude of the net forces is not what Cole was demonstrating.

Please post a link to an experiment how scale is dependent on the direction of net forces and the sequence of those net forces. If you can do this, you can prove Cole is wrong.
 

Yes.

How hard is it to understand Newton's laws of motion?

I don't know. How are you coming along with that one?

No, I have not been shown, even one time, that Cole is wrong.

See what I mean? You keep insisting that things that have happened haven't happened. You keep doing this over and over. I can only come to the conclusion that you are well aware that you are wrong, but that your ego does not allow you to admit it.

But here it is again: Cole's experiment has nothing to do with the WTC towers, their construction or their collapse. That's why it's wrong.

If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

And that's a false statement, right there.

Read my whole post.

I did. You said that anything other than experiment is worthless words and I'm applying the same logic to you. You have subsequently admitted that you cannot make an experiment that proves this other poster wrong, and therefore you admit that they are right.

I'm sorry if your own logic just bit you in the ass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom