If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Newton's third law of motion is clearly stated. Any attempt by you to change Newton's words to support your version of events or understanding of science is clear proof that you are playing by your own rules and reject whatever you don't like.

There is no reason for me to summarize anything. Cole's video stands on its own. Once again you claim he is wrong, yet you have not performed any experiment to prove he is wrong.

You have been shown links to similar experiments that, should Cole be right, should also demonstrate the same result. (Metabunk thread for eg.) They do not show the same result. They show progressive global collapse of the models. Clearly something is wrong with Cole's experiment. Cole's are set up in such a fashion as it cannot globally fail. However other models are set up such that they can. Therefore Cole's assumptions about the simplistic application of Newton's laws of motion must be in error.

Cole's also does not model any mechanism in any way similar to what is a widely accepted scenario for the WTC tower progression to global structural failure.

IOW, Cole's models are in effect useless.
 
This is the first time you have listened to me. Let's try to make it two.

Of course it's the first time I've listened to you. It's the first time you said anything to me.

And, since my latest post was in reply to two of your posts (in this thread, and in the "Summary" thread), we're actually making it three, not two. That means I have listened to, conservatively speaking, all of your posts directed to me.

Nonsense. The above statement is utter nonsense. What consensus are you referring to? How many architects and structural engineers are there on the planet? Of this total number, how many of them have been presented with all of the evidence that ae911truth has regarding the collapse of WTC1, WTC2 and WTC7?

Non sequitir. The consensus exists, regardless of whether the engineering community as a whole has been presented with all of AE911's "evidence". You may choose to argue that AE911's presentation would sway the consensus otherwise, but that does not affect the fact the consensus exists. (When AE911 did try to formally bring their claims up in front of AIA, they were overwhelmingly rejected, so that is not a promising start.)

Do you know this number? No, you don't. Neither do I, but I do know that not every one of them has seen all of the evidence. I also know that not all of those who have seen the evidence are willing to publicly support a new investigation. This does not mean they don't think the official story is correct, it simply means they won't say anything publicly.

But according to you, anyone with "common sense" and "basic physics" can figure out what really happened. So why the appeal to the McGuffin of AE911's "evidence", which somehow hasn't been presented in the right way or to enough people or whatever? You're not being very consistent.

What you assume is that because there are not more architects and engineers talking about the issue then it must mean they all agree with the official story. This is utter nonsense, and there is no logic whatsoever in your conclusion. Silence is not support of the official story.

Nope. I'm saying that what relevant professional societies have issued formal positions on the causes of the WTC collapses do not support claims such as controlled demolition, nor do the bulk of analyses done by technically competent experts. This contrasts sharply with the qualifications and body of work done by ad hoc advocacy groups such as AE911. Like it or not, that is a consensus. If you can offer actual evidence that the bulk of engineers, architects, etc., think otherwise, you are certainly welcome to offer it, but you cannot use argument from silence to support your views.

I'm saying his opinions are not based in logic. I will reject opinions that have no logical basis, regardless of who says them...

Asking for credentials will determine if he is an engineer or in a related profession. I would give more credibility to statements made by people in these professions, if they didn't reject basic science.

You're still missing the point. How do you know whether an actual expert's arguments "have no logical basis", or "reject basic science"? How do you know whether "basic science" - assuming you understand it - is all that's necessary?

Can a person in grade school understand Newton's laws of motion? Yes. Stop making that an issue. You are trying to add unnecessary complexity

No. I am trying to address the issue of necessary complexity, and what if anything you have done to understand it. It does not appear you have done so.

...to confuse people and make them assume they have to be experts to see what really happened. This is nonsense. You don't need to have a Master's in physics to understand Newton's laws of motion.

Yes, I routinely see this exact argument advanced by Apollo "hoax" believers. No, I'm not trying to confuse anyone, least of all you. I'm trying to get you to think about the nature of your claims, and whether you are doing what is necessary to properly support them.

This is constructive criticism. I'm trying to show you that you can't simply assert, from a layman's position (i.e., yours, by your own declaration), that a truly complex set of failures can be reduced to "basic physics" and "common sense", and have a defensible basis for your claims. Especially when you reject all, as far as I can tell, the experts who don't agree with you.

Good question. Do any of Cole's statements contradict what I already know about science? No. That is how I validate what I am seeing.

No, that's circular. I asked you how you validate that your "basic" knowledge is correctly applied to the problem, which you have decided is correctly represented by Cole. But you're telling me that you validate Cole because his claims are in line with your "basic" understanding.

If this is truly your answer, that means you haven't really validated that your "common sense" and "basic physics" really suffice to address the issue. That is a big problem for you, especially when coupled to your apparent determination that experts who disagree with you are somehow compromised. The extreme evolution of this is someone like FatFreddy88/DavidC/rocky/etc., who states that anyone who disagrees with his claims about 9/11, Apollo, etc. must be lying or deluded. I heartily recommend you do not go down that path.
 
They are extremely relevant, and your refusal to answer the questions is possibly proof that you are not a scientist, architect, or engineer.


Exactly. Anyone can read and count. Anyone can also come to a conclusion. The fact that anyone can come to a conclusion does not mean that conclusion is right.

The issue is that you have refused to provide your qualifications and/or educational background, but you have posted something that on the surface looks quite official and authoritative. What you have done is apply your own artificial and meaningless criteria (as a person who is not a scientist, architect, or engineer), and used it to make a conclusion regarding the qualifications of people who are scientists, architects, or engineers. Don't you see a problem with this?

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. You are certainly entitled to make your own conclusions. The issue is that your conclusions are those of an average person, not a person who is a scientist, architect, or engineer. Because of this, I do not give any credibility to your conclusions.



Let me eliminate all doubt from your mind. I have made no claims of being qualified as an engineer or architect.

Any follow-up questions?
 
Asking for credentials will determine if he is an engineer or in a related profession. I would give more credibility to statements made by people in these professions, if they didn't reject basic science.

And how will you know if they reject basic science?

Don't bother to answer, we already know your answer.

It's whether they agree with you or not.

So all you're really saying is you'll accept the opinions of those who agree with you, and reject everything else.

Aren't you?

There's two words for that: CONFIRMATION BIAS.

Hank
 
That is a big problem for you, especially when coupled to your apparent determination that experts who disagree with you are somehow compromised. The extreme evolution of this is someone like FatFreddy88/DavidC/rocky/etc., who states that anyone who disagrees with his claims about 9/11, Apollo, etc. must be lying or deluded. I heartily recommend you do not go down that path.

He's already far down that path. He's said as much and in the post you're responding to.

I'm saying his opinions are not based in logic. I will reject opinions that have no logical basis, regardless of who says them...

...I would give more credibility to statements made by people in these professions, if they didn't reject basic science.

Also here:
This fact, and I agree that you have stated a fact, only proves one thing. It proves that no recognized professional group will go against the official story. It does not prove anything else.

Hank
 
Another couple of quotes with no comment necessary.

I am not an expert; therefore, none of my conclusions should be taken as though they were given by an expert. As I said in my earlier post, we are all entitled to have opinions and make conclusions. My opinions are not expert opinions, and they are not the conclusions of an expert.

The issue is that your conclusions are those of an average person, not a person who is a scientist, architect, or engineer. Because of this, I do not give any credibility to your conclusions.
 
They show the effects of sulfidication, not melting as a result of exposure to sulfur,
Any sulfur even the huge lead acid batteries in the Cat Gen sets would cause that effect, or it can be caused by reduced sulfur from the interaction of fire with the buildings structure to create a Stack Chimney effect.
If a Stack effect occurs Aluminothermic reactions are also possible as a result of oxidation of finely divided Iron Oxidations.

Yes.

Thank you very much for the help. I appreciate that. :thumbsup:
 
In my post comparing the TT and experiment gravitational loads, four errors in Coles’s experiment claiming to prove that the collapse of the TT should have been arrested are identified.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11187414#post11187414


For comparing KE:
Error 5: In the Towers the entire floor weight falls on the floor below. In Cole only half the weight falls to the floor below, the other half remains supported by the ledgers.


Error 6: In the TT the floors fell ~152” between each impact, picking up velocity at each floor, whereas in Cole’s experiment the boards fall ~2 1/2 “ (1 1 /2” boards at ~ 4” oc) . The difference in velocity and KE between the TT collapses and Cole’s experiment is enormous. In Cole’s experiment the incremental boards’ resistance is eventually greater than the small KE from this short fall. If this were a question in my high school physics test I would work on it.


Cole’s experiment that claims the collapse of the TT should have been arrested after a few floors errs due to the failure to correctly proportion the scale, and model the experiment to the actual conditions.


Cole could just as easily claim that his experiment proves that heavier than air objects can’t fly.
 
You claim Cole is wrong. If you make a claim, you have the burden to prove you are right. If you want to prove you are right, the only way you can do this is to perform an experiment that proves Cole is wrong. No one has done this.

Provide a mathematically correct model of Cole's experiment, or you have no proof of your invalid claims.

I could prove Cole wrong easily if I chose to but there is no incentive.
 
Exactly. Anyone can read and count. Anyone can also come to a conclusion. The fact that anyone can come to a conclusion does not mean that conclusion is right.
That applies squarely to Cole's video. That's something that I already noted and you ignored. The conclusions he draws from his experiments are not valid, because his experiments don't apply to his claims.
 
You are most welcome, Cole's sulfidication experiment was also a joke, because he didn't
Induce a structure capable of having multiple fire dynamics and or a stack effect.

You mean where Cole insulated the steel with wallboard... that was, wow, dumber than dirt.
 
Here is an explanation of the scientific model. It is the first result when I Googled "scientific method". No, that does not mean it's the most correct, but I'm going to post it first.

http://www.sciencebuddies.org/science-fair-projects/project_scientific_method.shtml

Here are the steps they list:
Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results

Do you see the term, "mathematical model" anywhere in that list? No.

On that same page you will see a link to comparing the scientific method to the engineering design process. Here is the link - http://www.sciencebuddies.org/engin...eering-design-compare-scientific-method.shtml

Here are the steps:
Define the Problem
Do Background Research
Specify Requirements
Brainstorm Solutions
Choose the Best Solution
Do Development Work
Build a Prototype
Test and Redesign

Do you see the term mathematical model anywhere in that list?

Here is a link to the scientific method on wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method

It's interesting to note the following text in the wikipedia article, "not all steps take place in every scientific inquiry (or to the same degree), and are not always in the same order."

Here is a link to the scientific method that focuses on physics - http://teacher.nsrl.rochester.edu/phy_labs/appendixe/appendixe.html

Here, we can see the following text explanation:
I. The scientific method has four steps

1. Observation and description of a phenomenon or group of phenomena.

2. Formulation of an hypothesis to explain the phenomena. In physics, the hypothesis often takes the form of a causal mechanism or a mathematical relation.

3. Use of the hypothesis to predict the existence of other phenomena, or to predict quantitatively the results of new observations.

4. Performance of experimental tests of the predictions by several independent experimenters and properly performed experiments.

This time we do see the term mathematical relation, but the entire sentence says causal mechanism or mathematical relation. It also says "often" and not always.

This article does not have the term "mathematical model" in the steps, even though it appears directly related to physics - http://physics.ucr.edu/~wudka/Physics7/Notes_www/node6.html

This article also does not mention "mathematical model" in the order you claim it must occur- http://www.sciencemadesimple.com/scientific_method.html

This article also makes no mention of "mathematical model" in the order you claim it must occur - http://sciencefairproject.virtualave.net/scientific_method.htm

I picked the first results in a basic search. Only one of the results possibly supports your argument, and even then it does not prove your argument is 100 percent correct.

Here is my original quote -

You are assuming that I don't understand the scientific method so that you can once again attack me. Once again, you have failed.

If you didn't already know what acceleration was due to gravity, how would you find it out? Simple. You would perform experiments first. You would drop objects and measure the velocity as it changed over time. You would record the data. Once you dropped enough objects and had enough data you would then attempt to create a mathematical model to explain what you saw. Then, you would perform more experiments to see if your mathematical model held up.

Your argument says that you would simply try to make a mathematical model without doing any experiments. How on earth could you do this if you had no data? How do you get the data you need to create the mathematical model? Simple. You perform experiments.

Now, did you really want to keep arguing with me, or will you finally admit you are out of your league? Your attacks are meaningless, tiring, ineffective, and they only prove that you have no idea what you are talking about, regardless of the subject matter.

Wow, you wrote a whole bunch of :words: and posted links that all agreed with my list, in some cases identically, in an attempt to disagree with what I said on the basis that none of the had the actual words "Mathematical Model"? And all this without gleaning the apparent understanding that a Mathematical model is merely the constructing of a Hypothesis using Mathematics to describe the system the Hypothesis is about.

None of the links specifically state "Mathematical Model" because real scientists and engineers understand this. Even your favourite scientist, Sir Issac Newton knew this. F=ma start out life as a mathematical model for a hypothesis and the via experiment was proven. Newton didn't do a bunch of experiments and then come up with his formulas, he observed the world, came up with his formulas and then put them to the test, this is how Science works.

Seriously, your post is a monument to the ability to Google stuff, all while having as total lack of ability to understand it when it's read.

Bwahahahahahaha.

OK, seriously. Bwahahahahahaha.

Despite everything I just posted about the scientific method, you still claim Cole didn't follow it.

OK. Let's do this step by step.

Here is scientific method

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results


1. Ask a question.
How did the towers collapse?

2. Do background research.
Watch videos of the collapse. Read what NIST has said. NIST said the pancake theory was incorrect. NIST says the pile driver theory is correct.

3. Construct a hypothesis.
NIST's papers don't match what is observed. NIST might be wrong. What experiment will duplicate the observed motions?

4. Test your hypothesis by doing an experiment.
Cole tries to replicate the pancake theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole tries to replicate the pile driver theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole then does another experiment which he calls the controlled demolition theory. He is trying to replicate the observed motion of the collapses of the twin towers, which is down and out. His experiment more closely matches the observed motion of the actual collapse.

5. Analyze the data and draw a conclusion.
The data shows that the pancake theory and pile driver theory do not match experiment. If it does not match experiment, it must be wrong. The data shows that removing the support columns in sequence, as best he can, closely mimics the motion observed during the actual collapse. Conclusion, NIST was wrong. If NIST was wrong, we need a real investigation.

6. Communicate the results.
Cole did. He posted the video.

Please explain how any math is needed. You are simply throwing every red herring you can at this because it's kicking your *****.

Where is a laughing dog where you need one.

Let's take each step.

1. Ask a question.
How did the towers collapse?

Okay so this is a good start, Observation, the Towers Collapsed. We want to explain it.

2. Do background research.
Watch videos of the collapse. Read what NIST has said. NIST said the pancake theory was incorrect. NIST says the pile driver theory is correct.

This is where you start going off track. The above is not background research. Backgrounds research would include such things as learning how the towers were constructed. What materials were used. Learning how hot office materials and fire burned, learning how the strength of steel varies by temperature. Learning what Dynamic loading of each floor could withstand was. When you do watch the video or explore the images, then you do it so as to note and answer questions like "Did the initial impact of the upper section strike the floor-pan or was it against the outer columns?" This makes a difference so you need to know. Doing your background research is for two very important reasons. First we may need to explain a lot of things with out hypothesis, so we need to know what they are, and secondly, when we design our experiments we need the details to control the variables so we can test our hypothesis alone. Merely watching videos and reading what someone else has said doesn't do that.

3. Construct a hypothesis.
NIST's papers don't match what is observed.

This is not a hypothesis.

NIST might be wrong.

Nor is this

What experiment will duplicate the observed motions?

Or this.

A Hypothesis is a testable supposition or proposed explanation made on the basis of limited evidence as a starting point for further investigation and is made without any assumption as to whether or not it is true.

"The collapse was propagated by a gravity driven mass of falling debris overwhelming and destroying the floor pan's connectors to both outer wall and core, resulting in the loss of stabilization for the outer skin and the now freed floor pan and rubble continuing to be accelerated by gravity into the floor below, thus repeating the cycle."

This is a hypothesis. It is one that we can both seek out evidence for in the actual collapses themselves, and we can create experiments to test it and attempt to falsify it.

4. Test your hypothesis by doing an experiment.
Cole tries to replicate the pancake theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole tries to replicate the pile driver theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole then does another experiment which he calls the controlled demolition theory. He is trying to replicate the observed motion of the collapses of the twin towers, which is down and out. His experiment more closely matches the observed motion of the actual collapse.

And here we have some major issues. Because the proper background research wasn't done, or if it was, it was ignored, Cole's Experiments are totally pointless towards the claimed Hypothesis. If none of his models are analogues to the WTC Towers, and none of them are, then how can any result he gets from his models be applied to them? Not one of his models comes close to the actual structure or materials of the WTC Towers. It's like doing a speed experiment with a Mini Cooper Clubman S to prove that a Ferrari 880 Spider is incapable of doing zero to 60 in three seconds because it takes the Mini 7 seconds. If Cole is trying to achieve the (non) hypothesis you claim, then he is literally comparing Apples and Banjos.

5. Analyze the data and draw a conclusion.
The data shows that the pancake theory and pile driver theory do not match experiment. If it does not match experiment, it must be wrong. The data shows that removing the support columns in sequence, as best he can, closely mimics the motion observed during the actual collapse. Conclusion, NIST was wrong. If NIST was wrong, we need a real investigation.

No, what it shows is that pancake theory and pile driver theory do not match Cole's experiment. The reason being that Cole's experiments didn't factor in all of the appropriate data into the experiment to actually make his experiments relevant.

Your on statement prove this...

The data shows that removing the support columns in sequence

But see, here's one of your, and Cole's, major problems. The WTC didn't have supporting columns in the traditional sense. The floor-pans were hung between both the outer skin and the core rather then being directly supported by it. There were no lattice like beams and columns holding up any of the floor pans. The floor trusses were hooked onto connectors that had been welded onto the side of the outer skin columns and to the Core. To have "removed the supporting columns" they would have had to remove the outer walls of the building, which would have left very obvious explosive marks in the external steel, marks that were never found. The external skin of the building broke apart at the welding joints entirely consistent with a gravity based collapsed, not the explosive removal of columns. This lack of Explosive damaged steel falsifies that claim of the columns being removed to make the floors collapse by itself, though other reasons also would do so.

In the end, if the Experiment doesn't agree with reality, the Experiment is wrong.
 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

PhantomWolf, a great response! But I fear wasted on the intended.

For the reasons he already stated: "I'm saying his opinions are not based in logic. I will reject opinions that have no logical basis, regardless of who says them... I would give more credibility to statements made by people in these professions, if they didn't reject basic science ."

i.e. You don't agree with him, so your post will be rejected.

He's accepting only affirmative posts at this point in his journey. All others will be swatted aside. Watch.

He's already said he doesn't want any words pointing out Cole's (or his) errors:
You're right, no one is going to tell me any experiment is wrong unless they show me, by experiment, why it's wrong. ... So far, not one single one of you has done anything to prove Cole wrong. You have simply insulted him and posted meaningless words.

Hank
 
Last edited:
The observations include not only the collapse... but the materials which were scattered about... What is the story they tell? Not one of being exploded apart! The collapse process based on the steel in the pile was clearly not one employing CD devices.

Whatever started the avalanche somehow destroyed the structure at and above the plane strike zone. This could have been CD devices. Does the evidence support this initiation? No. It supports a structural failure/collapse of a structure that was losing its integrity and its load paths to the foundation. Finally dropping and causing the ROOSD and breaking apart of the columns below.

Cole's work has nothing to do with the real world collapse, nor the structure, and the way it was assembled... and it fails because of scale alone.
 
I am not an expert; therefore, none of my conclusions should be taken as though they were given by an expert. As I said in my earlier post, we are all entitled to have opinions and make conclusions. My opinions are not expert opinions, and they are not the conclusions of an expert.

My conclusions, although not made by an expert, are based on an accurate and correct understanding of basic physics. To a certain degree, they are also based on common sense, even though that is admittedly a vague term that can not be quantified. What I see does not match what I am being told. If there were no experts telling me I was right, then the only logical conclusion is that I must be wrong. The issue is that one group of experts say I'm right, and the other group is not saying I'm wrong, they have simply ignored the basic physics and pretend not to see what is clearly there.
One small group, a small percentage of which have the qualifications you call for, agree with you. ( more properly put, you agree with them)

A very large group of persons, the great majority of which have the qualifications you call for, have rejected the conclusions you support.

You say you are not an expert but then claim to be expert enough to determine that a huge cadre of experts are ignoring physics that you say you are not expert in.
 
Cole's also does not model any mechanism in any way similar to what is a widely accepted scenario for the WTC tower progression to global structural failure.
I note your diplomacy referring to "what is a widely accepted scenario". As you know I would be much blunter. There are three schools of understanding as to what was the mechanism of Twin Towers progression stage collapse.

They are:
A) Models based on the presumption that columns remained in line - resisting the collapse

B) Models truly representing the real event - where the progression collapse mechanism bypassed the columns - cutting out most of the column resistance which would result from axial loading.

C) Some "mix and match" of those two resulting from a range of contentious factors.

The "mix and match option of "C)" is untenable leaving a clear choice for models - EITHER "A)" columns in line which Coles models are OR "B)" - "real event" models - Which Coles models definitely are not and Mick West's recent efforts are a most commendable demonstration model. (BTW - Specifically a demonstration - not quantified engineering modelling - but that is a derail I need not pursue at this stage. ;) )

So:
IOW, Cole's models are in effect useless.
CORRECT. They are useless from the outset as models to explain the actual WTC Twin Towers progression stage collapses BECAUSE they do not model those actual collapses.

It is disappointing to see many members pussy-footing around that fatal premise giving partial credence to FalseFlag's game playing nonsense.

Newton's third law of motion is clearly stated. Any attempt by you to change Newton's words to support your version of events or understanding of science is clear proof that you are playing by your own rules and reject whatever you don't like.
Word salad gobbledegook.

There is no reason for me to summarize anything. Cole's video stands on its own. Once again you claim he is wrong, yet you have not performed any experiment to prove he is wrong.
Bleeding ridiculous. The demand is both unnecessary and impossible to satisfy.

The first stages of any modelling experiment are define what you are modelling. Coles has chosen to define a model - a set of other people's collected models actually - which DO NOT model WTC Twin Towers collapse. His models are invalid without need for any further discussion.

The real event was a different model - which actually is so simple that modelling serves very little purpose. But let that aspect pass.

BUT to suggest that anyone would need to conduct an experiment to show that a wrong model is wrong and correct model is right is asinine ridiculous.

AND I'll go the step further - there is IMO no way that an experiment COULD be designed to show that the underlying model is right or wrong - when it is already bleedingly obvious to observation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom