If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it your contention, then, that the damage done to a MatchboxTM car when a hamster is dropped on it is a good, predictive model of the damage that would be done to a Fiat 500 if an elephant were to be dropped upon it (to say nothing of the relative experiences of the hamster and the elephant...)?

Please see post 2239.

The fact that you continue to argue about the magnitude of forces is undeniable proof that you don't understand Cole's experiments. If you don't understand Cole's experiments, how can you say they are wrong?
 
If you had any sort of grasp of science or logic, you would understand where the onus lay.
You claim Cole is wrong. If you make a claim, you have the burden to prove you are right. If you want to prove you are right, the only way you can do this is to perform an experiment that proves Cole is wrong. No one has done this.
 
<snip of continued recalcitrance>

There is nothing you could do that would more clearly illustrate your outright refusal to learn anything. Standing with your fingers in your ears, chanting, "LALALALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU" would be not one iota more pellucid (but would be a trifle less irritating...)..
 
Please show that similar accelerations will nothave similar directions of net force. Please show that similar accelerations will not have similar sequences of the net forces involved.

Please drop a hamster on a matchbox car, and then drop an elephant on an actual car. Then, comparing the two events, please explain how the direction of the net forces and sequence of the net forces are different. The magnitude of the forces are not relevant, because the magnitude of the net forces is not what Cole was demonstrating.

Please post a link to an experiment how scale is dependent on the direction of net forces and the sequence of those net forces. If you can do this, you can prove Cole is wrong.
Proof! You don't understand scale.

The outcome, how do you scale for outcome to be the same; you ignore Cole's experiments did not look like or act like the collapse of the towers. Blindly fooling a liar with really dumb experiments.

lol, your scaled elephant did not crush the car... like Cole's experiments, thus you proved Cole is wrong, or an idiot; take you pick.

As for the youtubian 9/11 truth fanatics who at best are taking the following action...
standup.jpg
9/11 truth in action...
Cole has no clue what scale is. Cole failed. Cole is believed by a fringe few youtubians, who are dumber than dirt on 9/11, or insane; proof; read the idiotic comments by those who support Cole. A faith based movement of woo.
 
<snip of pervasive error>

It is the fact that I, and others, do, in fact, understand Cole's "demonstration" is what lets us point out that they do not bring any sensible light to bear on the collapse (without firecrackers) of a tower with much different construction than his "model", and vastly different strength weight ratios.

No matter how often you try to misstate the significance of what would happen to a car upon which an elephant was dropped; and what would not happen to a MatchboxTM model upon which a hamster was dropped (to say nothing of how different would be the experience of the hamster and the elephant).
 
You claim Cole is wrong. If you make a claim, you have the burden to prove you are right. If you want to prove you are right, the only way you can do this is to perform an experiment that proves Cole is wrong. No one has done this.

You see, that's not the claim. The claim is that Cole is right.You posted that in your very first post here, and 56 pages later have yet to post a single iota of evidence in support of this youtube video, and then you want us to show that it's wrong. Understanding where the burden of proof lies is just about the most basic thing in science. You don't. This is your fail, not ours.
 
Reasonable enough. Similarly, I do not consider you an expert on engineering, physics, or firefighting topics
This is the first time you have listened to me. Let's try to make it two.

But, generally speaking, his opinions are in line with the consensus of the engineering community.

Nonsense. The above statement is utter nonsense. What consensus are you referring to? How many architects and structural engineers are there on the planet? Of this total number, how many of them have been presented with all of the evidence that ae911truth has regarding the collapse of WTC1, WTC2 and WTC7? Do you know this number? No, you don't. Neither do I, but I do know that not every one of them has seen all of the evidence. I also know that not all of those who have seen the evidence are willing to publicly support a new investigation. This does not mean they don't think the official story is correct, it simply means they won't say anything publicly.

What you assume is that because there are not more architects and engineers talking about the issue then it must mean they all agree with the official story. This is utter nonsense, and there is no logic whatsoever in your conclusion. Silence is not support of the official story.

What you're saying here is that his opinions contradict a relatively small number of engineers with whom you agree. But your agreement rests on implicit assumptions of your own ability to gauge the validity of "your" engineers.

I'm saying his opinions are not based in logic. I will reject opinions that have no logical basis, regardless of who says them.

Then, as I've asked before, what is the point of asking him for his credentials? If he says that WTC buildings collapsed as a result of impact and fire damage, will his credentials have any effect whatsoever on your assessment of his position?

Asking for credentials will determine if he is an engineer or in a related profession. I would give more credibility to statements made by people in these professions, if they didn't reject basic science.


... Which brings us back to the problem of how you establish who is "credible", and how you know you understand and correctly apply "basic physics".
Can a person in grade school understand Newton's laws of motion? Yes. Stop making that an issue. You are trying to add unnecessary complexity to confuse people and make them assume they have to be experts to see what really happened. This is nonsense. You don't need to have a Master's in physics to understand Newton's laws of motion.


Exactly how did you validate the assumptions implicit in your claim? In other words, how do you know that applying your "understand[ing] of basic physics" to your viewing of collapse imagery is done correctly, or even appropriately? How did you validate that you really understand what you're seeing?

Good question. Do any of Cole's statements contradict what I already know about science? No. That is how I validate what I am seeing.
 
Last edited:
Please copy and paste one of my claims which clearly shows I don't understand basic physics. If you choose to copy and paste a claim of mine, please make sure you post a link to a credible source that clearly shows why my statement about basic physics is wrong.

Make sure you state why the link you provide clearly proves I am wrong.

I don't see any point in catering to that request, given your history ignoring and dodging, but I'm pretty sure you must remember when you attempted to equate the force of gravity with the reaction force of impacts in some sort of "equal and opposite" relationship. That was clearly a misunderstanding of basic physics: "In physics, a contact force, is a force that acts at the point of contact between two objects,[1] in contrast to body forces [e.g. gravity]." They are not the same thing and in a dynamic situation there is absolutely no reason to expect them to be equal and opposite. Furthermore, this misconception of basic physics seems to be the cause of your inability to comprehend that Cole's experiment did not demonstrate what he claims it did or what you think it did (which I'm only assuming are the same thing, since you can't seem to summarize Cole's argument in your own words).
 
I don't see any point in catering to that request, given your history ignoring and dodging, but I'm pretty sure you must remember when you attempted to equate the force of gravity with the reaction force of impacts in some sort of "equal and opposite" relationship. That was clearly a misunderstanding of basic physics: "In physics, a contact force, is a force that acts at the point of contact between two objects,[1] in contrast to body forces [e.g. gravity]." They are not the same thing and in a dynamic situation there is absolutely no reason to expect them to be equal and opposite. Furthermore, this misconception of basic physics seems to be the cause of your inability to comprehend that Cole's experiment did not demonstrate what he claims it did or what you think it did (which I'm only assuming are the same thing, since you can't seem to summarize Cole's argument in your own words).

Newton's third law of motion is clearly stated. Any attempt by you to change Newton's words to support your version of events or understanding of science is clear proof that you are playing by your own rules and reject whatever you don't like.

There is no reason for me to summarize anything. Cole's video stands on its own. Once again you claim he is wrong, yet you have not performed any experiment to prove he is wrong.
 
How many architects and structural engineers are there on the planet? Of this total number, how many of them have been presented with all of the evidence that ae911truth has regarding the collapse of WTC1, WTC2 and WTC7?

Judging from the response from the AIA convention vote last year his evidence was not very compelling. He presented his evidence and it was rejected by a vote of around 98% against.
 
.........You don't need to have a Master's in physics to understand Newton's laws of motion..........

But you can't get a Masters in physics unless you understand Newton's Laws. Ergo, any physics post-grad knows the subject. When a number of those have carefully explained to you, repeatedly, in this very thread, that your understanding of Newton's Laws are fundamentally flawed most people would be grateful for the bit of free education they were receiving. You, on the other hand, turn into the 5 year old telling Einstein he is wrong.
 
It is the fact that I, and others, do, in fact, understand Cole's "demonstration" is what lets us point out that they do not bring any sensible light to bear on the collapse (without firecrackers) of a tower with much different construction than his "model", and vastly different strength weight ratios.

No matter how often you try to misstate the significance of what would happen to a car upon which an elephant was dropped; and what would not happen to a MatchboxTM model upon which a hamster was dropped (to say nothing of how different would be the experience of the hamster and the elephant).

What does any of what you have written apply to similar acceleration, similar direction of net force and similar sequences of the net forces. That is what Cole was demonstrating. He clearly says this, and I have posted a link to the part of the video where he says this.

I can't believe you keep clinging to the scale issue. You are destroying yourself. Why do you keep doing it?
 
But you can't get a Masters in physics unless you understand Newton's Laws. Ergo, any physics post-grad knows the subject. When a number of those have carefully explained to you, repeatedly, in this very thread, that your understanding of Newton's Laws are fundamentally flawed most people would be grateful for the bit of free education they were receiving. You, on the other hand, turn into the 5 year old telling Einstein he is wrong.

*sigh*

You claim I don't understand Newton's laws of motion. Please provide a link to a post where I show that I don't understand Newton's laws of motion. Once you show this, please provide another link to a credible source that proves I am wrong.
 
WilliamSeger said:
Hold up. At this point, the hypothesis that Cole actually constructs is that a scale model will tell him something about the behavior of the WTC towers.
Please see post 2239.

LOL, please see the rest of the post you're pretending to respond to:

I'm going to predict that you won't have a cogent reply to the "red herrings" in this post, either. Sadly, you, Criteria, and NotConvinced are a microcosm of what's left of the "truth movement."
 
Judging from the response from the AIA convention vote last year his evidence was not very compelling. He presented his evidence and it was rejected by a vote of around 98% against.
Did he get a chance to present all of his evidence to everyone who voted? No.
He is not making the same mistake again this year. The resolution he is presenting this year will contain the evidence that indicates NIST's version of events is wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom