If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
By your own standard then, what are your qualifications to make conclusions in this regard?

We then move to note that no recognized professional group, ASCE, AIA, CTBUH among them, have no issue with impact and fire damage leading to collapse initiation which proceeded through global collapse. You accept that these organizations are populated by many persons with qualifications to render a conclusion?


I am not an expert; therefore, none of my conclusions should be taken as though they were given by an expert. As I said in my earlier post, we are all entitled to have opinions and make conclusions. My opinions are not expert opinions, and they are not the conclusions of an expert.

My conclusions, although not made by an expert, are based on an accurate and correct understanding of basic physics. To a certain degree, they are also based on common sense, even though that is admittedly a vague term that can not be quantified. What I see does not match what I am being told. If there were no experts telling me I was right, then the only logical conclusion is that I must be wrong. The issue is that one group of experts say I'm right, and the other group is not saying I'm wrong, they have simply ignored the basic physics and pretend not to see what is clearly there.
 
If you didn't already know what acceleration was due to gravity, how would you find it out? Simple. You would perform experiments first. You would drop objects and measure the velocity as it changed over time. You would record the data. Once you dropped enough objects and had enough data you would then attempt to create a mathematical model to explain what you saw. Then, you would perform more experiments to see if your mathematical model held up.

How could anyone not think it's relevant? If you watched the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2, the similarities are obvious.

You answered your own question: Cole's experiments are irrelevant because he did not follow any of your definitions of the scientific method. Regardless of what stage you think Cole should have done the math, he didn't do any math at any stage, because he is a confessed mathophobe. Instead, he simply asserts that his experiments tell us something about the WTC collapses -- an assertion easily disproved by anyone who understands the math. Doing the math would reveal the effects of scale that you and he don't understand, and which make his experiments pointless and irrelevant to the WTC collapses. Cole is a textbook example of a pseudo-scientist.
 
I am not an expert; therefore, none of my conclusions should be taken as though they were given by an expert. As I said in my earlier post, we are all entitled to have opinions and make conclusions. My opinions are not expert opinions, and they are not the conclusions of an expert.

My conclusions, although not made by an expert, are based on an accurate and correct understanding of basic physics. To a certain degree, they are also based on common sense, even though that is admittedly a vague term that can not be quantified. What I see does not match what I am being told. If there were no experts telling me I was right, then the only logical conclusion is that I must be wrong. The issue is that one group of experts say I'm right, and the other group is not saying I'm wrong, they have simply ignored the basic physics and pretend not to see what is clearly there.

I'm a credentialled engineer. Your claims are bunk.

Now what?
 
We then move to note that no recognized professional group, ASCE, AIA, CTBUH
This fact, and I agree that you have stated a fact, only proves one thing. It proves that no recognized professional group will go against the official story. It does not prove anything else.
 
I'm a credentialled engineer. Your claims are bunk.

Now what?

Really?

Please post your certifications, licenses, and educational history.

You also make an incorrect assumption. You assume that because you are an engineer, your claims must be correct. No. If you are actually an engineer, the only thing you have proven is that you are an engineer. It does not prove you are right. It does give you authority, but authority has nothing to do with being correct or making accurate statements.

You could get any engineer from NIST to post on this forum. They could say whatever they want in support of the official story. That does not mean they are correct. It simply means they are supporting the official story. In fact, I seriously doubt you would find an engineer from NIST posting on this forum because they would not want to continue to destroy their credibility. I'm sure the NIST WTC reports were enough.
 
Really?

Please post your certifications, licenses, and educational history.

You also make an incorrect assumption. You assume that because you are an engineer, your claims must be correct. No. If you are actually an engineer, the only thing you have proven is that you are an engineer. It does not prove you are right. It does give you authority, but authority has nothing to do with being correct or making accurate statements.

You could get any engineer from NIST to post on this forum. They could say whatever they want in support of the official story. That does not mean they are correct. It simply means they are supporting the official story. In fact, I seriously doubt you would find an engineer from NIST posting on this forum because they would not want to continue to destroy their credibility. I'm sure the NIST WTC reports were enough.

I've covered this already:

What? Who TF are you to demand that? What are your qualifications? You clearly have no science background, nor maths or engineering. You aren't capable of casting judgement on the work of engineers, yet you feel free to dismiss the works of multiple highly qualified specialists whilst lauding some idiot on YouTube. Frankly, this has gone from performance art to sheer stupidity.
 
This fact, and I agree that you have stated a fact, only proves one thing. It proves that no recognized professional group will go against the official story. It does not prove anything else.
How does this prove this? The CTBUH for instance was critical of aspects of the NIST reports and they had no problem expressing them.

What it proves is you need an excuse to hand-wave all the worlds experts.
 
Last edited:
From Cole's video at 1:25 -

So, any objects that have that have similar accelerations will have the same direction and the same sequence of net force, and it's independent of scale.

1. Similar accelerations = similar directions of force


How did he measure accelerations? Let's see the data.

2. Same sequence of net force


How did he measure net force? Let's see the data.

3. Independent of scale


What measurement did he show was indecent of scale? Which scales did he compare? Let's see the data.
 
Really?

Please post your certifications, licenses, and educational history.
You first.

And I already have on this very site. I'm curious if your uber-research skills can find that.

You also make an incorrect assumption. You assume that because you are an engineer, your claims must be correct. No.
Wrong. Because I am an actual engineer, I know your claims are incorrect.

If you are actually an engineer, the only thing you have proven is that you are an engineer. It does not prove you are right. It does give you authority, but authority has nothing to do with being correct or making accurate statements.
No, it means that I have the education to recognise that you are talking through your hat.

You could get any engineer from NIST to post on this forum. They could say whatever they want in support of the official story. That does not mean they are correct. It simply means they are supporting the official story. In fact, I seriously doubt you would find an engineer from NIST posting on this forum because they would not want to continue to destroy their credibility. I'm sure the NIST WTC reports were enough.
In other words you are stating that it doesn't matter what evidence in no matter what volume and no expert assessments in no matter what volume would shake you from your unsupported beliefs.

That is called "religion".
 
Last edited:
You answered your own question: Cole's experiments are irrelevant because he did not follow any of your definitions of the scientific method. Regardless of what stage you think Cole should have done the math, he didn't do any math at any stage, because he is a confessed mathophobe. Instead, he simply asserts that his experiments tell us something about the WTC collapses -- an assertion easily disproved by anyone who understands the math. Doing the math would reveal the effects of scale that you and he don't understand, and which make his experiments pointless and irrelevant to the WTC collapses. Cole is a textbook example of a pseudo-scientist.
Bwahahahahahaha.

OK, seriously. Bwahahahahahaha.

Despite everything I just posted about the scientific method, you still claim Cole didn't follow it.

OK. Let's do this step by step.

Here is scientific method

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results


1. Ask a question.
How did the towers collapse?

2. Do background research.
Watch videos of the collapse. Read what NIST has said. NIST said the pancake theory was incorrect. NIST says the pile driver theory is correct.

3. Construct a hypothesis.
NIST's papers don't match what is observed. NIST might be wrong. What experiment will duplicate the observed motions?

4. Test your hypothesis by doing an experiment.
Cole tries to replicate the pancake theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole tries to replicate the pile driver theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole then does another experiment which he calls the controlled demolition theory. He is trying to replicate the observed motion of the collapses of the twin towers, which is down and out. His experiment more closely matches the observed motion of the actual collapse.

5. Analyze the data and draw a conclusion.
The data shows that the pancake theory and pile driver theory do not match experiment. If it does not match experiment, it must be wrong. The data shows that removing the support columns in sequence, as best he can, closely mimics the motion observed during the actual collapse. Conclusion, NIST was wrong. If NIST was wrong, we need a real investigation.

6. Communicate the results.
Cole did. He posted the video.

Please explain how any math is needed. You are simply throwing every red herring you can at this because it's kicking your *****.
 
You first.
The fact that you would even post that is proof you lack the ability to comprehend the most basic things.

Wrong. Because I am an actual engineer, I know your claims are incorrect.
Denial is not proof that my claims are not correct.

In other words you are stating that it doesn't matter what evidence in no matter what volume and not expert assessments in no matter what volume would shake you from your unsupported beliefs.

That is called "religion".

NIST is composed of engineers and scientists, right? There are countless posts on this forum by skeptics that claim that NIST is wrong. So, if NIST is wrong, by many skeptic's own admission, that means scientists and engineers can be wrong, too.

I guess you skipped all of the classes where you needed to apply any logic.
 
Here is scientific method

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results

Did you open your first-year high-school physics book to find that?

Perhaps you shouldn't laugh at people who clearly know a lot more than you on the topic.
 
Sorry, but you must prove his credential wrongs by doing an experiment.

OK. Fair game, although not an experiment. I can't do an experiment, because it would be impossible to do so. I can provide proof, though.

He says he is an engineer. I will believe him. No argument there, I will take him at his word.

He says that because he is an engineer he is right. I say he's wrong. His posts prove I'm right.

Done.

Oh, wait. I can perform an experiment. My hypothesis is that his next post will be more garbage. His next post will be the experiment. Let's watch and see what happens.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom