If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
What? Who TF are you to demand that? What are your qualifications? You clearly have no science background, nor maths or engineering. You aren't capable of casting judgement on the work of engineers, yet you feel free to dismiss the works of multiple highly qualified specialists whilst lauding some idiot on YouTube. Frankly, this has gone from performance art to sheer stupidity.

I asked a question. You have obviously chosen not to answer it.
 
What? Who TF are you to demand that? What are your qualifications? You clearly have no science background, nor maths or engineering. You aren't capable of casting judgement on the work of engineers, yet you feel free to dismiss the works of multiple highly qualified specialists whilst lauding some idiot on YouTube. Frankly, this has gone from performance art to sheer stupidity.


Think of FF as a little doggy running around the 9/11 sub-forum knocking things over and cocking its leg whenever it comes across a post.
 

Here many of the people you are conversing with are scientists and engineers, vastly superior in experience to Cole.
You and Cole can't give a mathematical model of his experiment, why not what is Cole hiding Banzant gave a theoretical limited case model of the collapses, Dr.Greening and David B. Benson gave a mathematically correct model of the energies of the collapses.
What's Cole's problem why can't he do the work of an engineer?
 

I believe that the US government did some sort of investigation and report into the destruction by al quaeda of the WTC, and I believe that you have rejected this report. Is this, or is this not, correct?
 
I believe that the US government did some sort of investigation and report into the destruction by al quaeda of the WTC, and I believe that you have rejected this report. Is this, or is this not, correct?

What report?
 
Oh, you are unaware of the reports into 9/11. Interesting.
What reports? There are lots. Which ones do you want me to comment on? Do you want me to comment on the ones that are misleading, incomplete, and fraudulent, or did you want me to comment on the ones firmly based on facts and the scientific method?
 
I would like you to comment in anything.
So far you haven't given us any clue as to what you think hapoened.
All we get are rhetorical and leading questions followed by rejection of any answers.
Why not tell us what you think happened? Which reports are incomplete or fraudulent and why?
 
How about yours? You clearly don't know **** about science.
Oh, so now you're using the time-honoured "huh? What are you talking about?" type of argument.

This is your opinion. I have only said I am not an expert. I have never claimed I know nothing about science.

If you, and the other skeptics, would clarify your arguments I might not need to keep asking what you mean.
 
This is your opinion. I have only said I am not an expert. I have never claimed I know nothing about science.

If you, and the other skeptics, would clarify your arguments I might not need to keep asking what you mean.

Can you give me one example of a correct experiment Cole has done, just one, that relates to the twin towers, and 9/11/2001?
 
This is your opinion. I have only said I am not an expert. I have never claimed I know nothing about science.

But you clearly don't know anything. You're taking Cole's video at face value without making any sort of research, and when people here are telling you that it's wrong and are spoon-feeding you the research, you ignore them. You have lost the benefit of the doubt long ago; you are willfully ignorant.
 
But you clearly don't know anything. You're taking Cole's video at face value without making any sort of research, and when people here are telling you that it's wrong and are spoon-feeding you the research, you ignore them. You have lost the benefit of the doubt long ago; you are willfully ignorant.
What research do I need to do?
You're right, no one is going to tell me any experiment is wrong unless they show me, by experiment, why it's wrong.

This thread has been open for weeks and not one person has shown, be experiment, that Cole is wrong. What are you waiting for? I don't care what you say. I care what you do. So far, not one single one of you has done anything to prove Cole wrong. You have simply insulted him and posted meaningless words.
 
What research do I need to do?
You're right, no one is going to tell me any experiment is wrong unless they show me, by experiment, why it's wrong.

This thread has been open for weeks and not one person has shown, be experiment, that Cole is wrong. What are you waiting for? I don't care what you say. I care what you do. So far, not one single one of you has done anything to prove Cole wrong. You have simply insulted him and posted meaningless words.

Have you read The Banzant, Greening, & Benson paper, because it shows the math, although it is a theoritcal paper.

Have you Read Dr. Frank Greening's site 9/11 myths?
Please keep in mind Dr. Greening is banned from ISF.
 
What research do I need to do?
You're right, no one is going to tell me any experiment is wrong unless they show me, by experiment, why it's wrong.

This thread has been open for weeks and not one person has shown, be experiment, that Cole is wrong. What are you waiting for? I don't care what you say. I care what you do. So far, not one single one of you has done anything to prove Cole wrong. You have simply insulted him and posted meaningless words.

Visit Metabunk and look at the experiments (models) Mick has going... they show the progressive floor collapse in a more faithful way then Cole's do as per usual. He abuses science or is a junk scientists who likes to believe he's not and convince naive people he's not.
 
Visit Metabunk and look at the experiments (models) Mick has going... they show the progressive floor collapse in a more faithful way then Cole's do as per usual. He abuses science or is a junk scientists who likes to believe he's not and convince naive people he's not.
Hasn't FF been directed to that Metabunk thread already?
It would indicate error on his part that no one has demonstrated by experiment that Cole is wrong.

It seems that what FF means is that no one has duplicated Cole's models and had a different result.:rolleyes:
 
What research do I need to do?

You've been told repeatedly that you don't understand science, physics, building construction, demolition and collapse. I find it odd that you ask me this question now.

You're right, no one is going to tell me any experiment is wrong unless they show me, by experiment, why it's wrong.

Do you not understand why that is nonsense?

This thread has been open for weeks and not one person has shown, be experiment, that Cole is wrong.

That's because it's not required, regardless of your stupid argument. One does not need to make an experiment to discredit another experiment. Not a single scientist or expert in the world is going to disagree with my previous statement.
 
As I have previously stated, the Towers, connections Fail when 2600LBS is dropped 12 feet, giving the towers 36% resistance to collapse.

Cole's models have between 325% to 542% resistance to collapse by my best estimates.
Based on the factors of energy vs strength.

Cole's structures are impossible to collapse because, he hasn't matched the energy values properly because he has no mathematical model of his experiments.

That old bugbear, scaling. Never goes away...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom