If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have read the analysis you have performed.

Before I post my conclusions, would you please provide your educational background? Are you a scientist, architect, or engineer? If so, what is the highest degree you have obtained, and what special licenses or credentials do you possess?

I choose to not answer your questions on the grounds that they are not relevant.

The study I did, anyone could do. It's reading and counting.

You could do it, as well.
 
You do experiments first, then you do the math to understand your observations.

This is so far from right that we are going to need a new term to define it, because wrong simply won't cut it, or as someone much smarter then me once said, you are so far from right, you're not even wrong.

You do not do the experiment first, the Experiment is one of the the last steps in the scientific process.

#1 - Observation. We observe a real world phenomenon and wish to explain it.
#2 - Hypothesis. We create a hypothesis or mathematical model that can explain our observation.
#3 - Prediction. We use our hypothesis or our model to create a testable prediction
#4 - Experimentation - We develop and run an experiment under controlled circumstances to see if our prediction holds up.
#5 - Repetition. Repeat steps #3 and #4 until a prediction fails, or we run out of predictions to make.
#6 - Conclusion. If a prediction fails, then return to Step #2 and either modify our Hypothesis/Model to account for failed prediction, or create a new hypothesis that would explain all observations including the failed prediction. If no Predictions have failed, then Hypothesis becomes a Theory and accepted as the likely truth.

This is Cole and your problem, you don't understand these stages and skip the really important ones of #2 and #3. Cole isn't testing any Hypothesis and has no idea how to control for such a test anyways, and you just go for the ride with him because of your ignorance about science.

You fail to understand that Cole's experiments need no rebuttal by experiment because they are totally meaningless. Had he done them with a testable hypothesis behind them and conducted them in a correctly controlled environment, then and only then would they be worth while, but currently they have all of the scientific value of a video of a kitten falling off a windowsill.

 
Last edited:
I was bored so thought I would watch the first video. All I can say is, HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA :D

I mean, wow. How could anyone believe this "experiment" was remotely relevant to anything that happened on 911?
 
The house didn't collapse when the Kitten fell off inside the window, so we know it was an inside job.

There's a joke in that. :D A little puerile, I know.

Crazy, do the pics of the so-called 'melted steel' (FEMA) in the first video evince the eutectic effect upon the heated steel, as opposed to 'melted' as claimed?

And, does the WTC5 pic of the twisted column demonstrate the failure of the argument posited in the video as a rebuttal to the Blacksmith's experiment?



I'm sorry about the questions, but I have to ask someone and your work and knowledge I hold in high regard (among many others on this site).
 
Last edited:
There's a joke in that. :D A little puerile, I know.

Crazy, do the pics of the so-called 'melted steel' (FEMA) in the first video evince the eutectic effect upon the heated steel, as opposed to 'melted' as claimed?

And, does the WTC5 pic of the twisted column demonstrate the failure of the argument posited in the video as a rebuttal to the Blacksmith's experiment?



I'm sorry about the questions, but I have to ask someone and your work and knowledge I hold in high regard (among many others on this site).

They show the effects of sulfidication, not melting as a result of exposure to sulfur,
Any sulfur even the huge lead acid batteries in the Cat Gen sets would cause that effect, or it can be caused by reduced sulfur from the interaction of fire with the buildings structure to create a Stack Chimney effect.
If a Stack effect occurs Aluminothermic reactions are also possible as a result of oxidation of finely divided Iron Oxidations.

Yes.
 
This is so far from right that we are going to need a new term to define it, because wrong simply won't cut it, or as someone much smarter then me once said, you are so far from right, you're not even wrong.

You do not do the experiment first, the Experiment is one of the the last steps in the scientific process.

#1 - Observation. We observe a real world phenomenon and wish to explain it.
#2 - Hypothesis. We create a hypothesis or mathematical model that can explain our observation.
#3 - Prediction. We use our hypothesis or our model to create a testable prediction
#4 - Experimentation - We develop and run an experiment under controlled circumstances to see if our prediction holds up.
#5 - Repetition. Repeat steps #3 and #4 until a prediction fails, or we run out of predictions to make.
#6 - Conclusion. If a prediction fails, then return to Step #2 and either modify our Hypothesis/Model to account for failed prediction, or create a new hypothesis that would explain all observations including the failed prediction. If no Predictions have failed, then Hypothesis becomes a Theory and accepted as the likely truth.
Should be noted that in physics, sometimes mathematical 'observations' come first. The math makes predictions then experiment is used to confirm, then the conclusion may be that the math reflects reality.
 
I was bored so thought I would watch the first video. All I can say is, HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA :D

I mean, wow. How could anyone believe this "experiment" was remotely relevant to anything that happened on 911?

but FF says that these experiments are to illustrate a supposed Newtonian dictate. Nothing to do with WTC ,,until Cole or FF want it to. Then its direct proof of CD.
 
but FF says that these experiments are to illustrate a supposed Newtonian dictate. Nothing to do with WTC ,,until Cole or FF want it to. Then its direct proof of CD.

If it is pure Newtonian physics then it fails, because it has not been proven by Newton's equations as Newton would require it be, no correct mathematical model no proof.
 
They show the effects of sulfidication, not melting as a result of exposure to sulfur,
Any sulfur even the huge lead acid batteries in the Cat Gen sets would cause that effect, or it can be caused by reduced sulfur from the interaction of fire with the buildings structure to create a Stack Chimney effect.
If a Stack effect occurs Aluminothermic reactions are also possible as a result of oxidation of finely divided Iron Oxidations.

Yes.

Similar effects are well knowncin coal fired boilers thatcuse high sulfur coal.

I have helped to repair a firebox and boiler throat plate that had similar damage.
 
I choose to not answer your questions on the grounds that they are not relevant.
They are extremely relevant, and your refusal to answer the questions is possibly proof that you are not a scientist, architect, or engineer.

The study I did, anyone could do. It's reading and counting.
Exactly. Anyone can read and count. Anyone can also come to a conclusion. The fact that anyone can come to a conclusion does not mean that conclusion is right.

The issue is that you have refused to provide your qualifications and/or educational background, but you have posted something that on the surface looks quite official and authoritative. What you have done is apply your own artificial and meaningless criteria (as a person who is not a scientist, architect, or engineer), and used it to make a conclusion regarding the qualifications of people who are scientists, architects, or engineers. Don't you see a problem with this?

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. You are certainly entitled to make your own conclusions. The issue is that your conclusions are those of an average person, not a person who is a scientist, architect, or engineer. Because of this, I do not give any credibility to your conclusions.
 
This is so far from right that we are going to need a new term to define it, because wrong simply won't cut it, or as someone much smarter then me once said, you are so far from right, you're not even wrong.

You do not do the experiment first, the Experiment is one of the the last steps in the scientific process.

#1 - Observation. We observe a real world phenomenon and wish to explain it.
#2 - Hypothesis. We create a hypothesis or mathematical model that can explain our observation.
#3 - Prediction. We use our hypothesis or our model to create a testable prediction
#4 - Experimentation - We develop and run an experiment under controlled circumstances to see if our prediction holds up.
#5 - Repetition. Repeat steps #3 and #4 until a prediction fails, or we run out of predictions to make.
#6 - Conclusion. If a prediction fails, then return to Step #2 and either modify our Hypothesis/Model to account for failed prediction, or create a new hypothesis that would explain all observations including the failed prediction. If no Predictions have failed, then Hypothesis becomes a Theory and accepted as the likely truth.

Here is an explanation of the scientific model. It is the first result when I Googled "scientific method". No, that does not mean it's the most correct, but I'm going to post it first.

http://www.sciencebuddies.org/science-fair-projects/project_scientific_method.shtml

Here are the steps they list:
Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results

Do you see the term, "mathematical model" anywhere in that list? No.

On that same page you will see a link to comparing the scientific method to the engineering design process. Here is the link - http://www.sciencebuddies.org/engin...eering-design-compare-scientific-method.shtml

Here are the steps:
Define the Problem
Do Background Research
Specify Requirements
Brainstorm Solutions
Choose the Best Solution
Do Development Work
Build a Prototype
Test and Redesign

Do you see the term mathematical model anywhere in that list?

Here is a link to the scientific method on wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method

It's interesting to note the following text in the wikipedia article, "not all steps take place in every scientific inquiry (or to the same degree), and are not always in the same order."

Here is a link to the scientific method that focuses on physics - http://teacher.nsrl.rochester.edu/phy_labs/appendixe/appendixe.html

Here, we can see the following text explanation:
I. The scientific method has four steps

1. Observation and description of a phenomenon or group of phenomena.

2. Formulation of an hypothesis to explain the phenomena. In physics, the hypothesis often takes the form of a causal mechanism or a mathematical relation.

3. Use of the hypothesis to predict the existence of other phenomena, or to predict quantitatively the results of new observations.

4. Performance of experimental tests of the predictions by several independent experimenters and properly performed experiments.

This time we do see the term mathematical relation, but the entire sentence says causal mechanism or mathematical relation. It also says "often" and not always.

This article does not have the term "mathematical model" in the steps, even though it appears directly related to physics - http://physics.ucr.edu/~wudka/Physics7/Notes_www/node6.html

This article also does not mention "mathematical model" in the order you claim it must occur- http://www.sciencemadesimple.com/scientific_method.html

This article also makes no mention of "mathematical model" in the order you claim it must occur - http://sciencefairproject.virtualave.net/scientific_method.htm

I picked the first results in a basic search. Only one of the results possibly supports your argument, and even then it does not prove your argument is 100 percent correct.

Here is my original quote -
Because I have experiments from Cole. You do experiments first, then you do the math to understand your observations.

You are assuming that I don't understand the scientific method so that you can once again attack me. Once again, you have failed.

If you didn't already know what acceleration was due to gravity, how would you find it out? Simple. You would perform experiments first. You would drop objects and measure the velocity as it changed over time. You would record the data. Once you dropped enough objects and had enough data you would then attempt to create a mathematical model to explain what you saw. Then, you would perform more experiments to see if your mathematical model held up.

Your argument says that you would simply try to make a mathematical model without doing any experiments. How on earth could you do this if you had no data? How do you get the data you need to create the mathematical model? Simple. You perform experiments.

Now, did you really want to keep arguing with me, or will you finally admit you are out of your league? Your attacks are meaningless, tiring, ineffective, and they only prove that you have no idea what you are talking about, regardless of the subject matter.
 
Last edited:
In Cole's experiment, what was being measured, and how? How was(were) the measuring instrument(s) calibrated?
 
You do not do the experiment first, the Experiment is one of the the last steps in the scientific process.
From Cole's video starting at 3:45-

We use physical models all the time, and it's from those physical models and observations where the math and simulations are developed - never the other way around.
 
Exactly. Anyone can read and count. Anyone can also come to a conclusion. The fact that anyone can come to a conclusion does not mean that conclusion is right.

The issue is that you have refused to provide your qualifications and/or educational background, but you have posted something that on the surface looks quite official and authoritative. What you have done is apply your own artificial and meaningless criteria (as a person who is not a scientist, architect, or engineer), and used it to make a conclusion regarding the qualifications of people who are scientists, architects, or engineers. Don't you see a problem with this?

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. You are certainly entitled to make your own conclusions. The issue is that your conclusions are those of an average person, not a person who is a scientist, architect, or engineer. Because of this, I do not give any credibility to your conclusions.

By your own standard then, what are your qualifications to make conclusions in this regard?

We then move to note that no recognized professional group, ASCE, AIA, CTBUH among them, have no issue with impact and fire damage leading to collapse initiation which proceeded through global collapse. You accept that these organizations are populated by many persons with qualifications to render a conclusion?
 
On that same page you will see a link to comparing the scientific method to the engineering design process. Here is the link - http://www.sciencebuddies.org/engin...eering-design-compare-scientific-method.shtml

Here are the steps:
Define the Problem
Do Background Research
Specify Requirements
Brainstorm Solutions
Choose the Best Solution
Do Development Work Build a Prototype
Test and Redesign

Do you see the term mathematical model anywhere in that list?.
Yes.
 
In Cole's experiment, what was being measured, and how? How was(were) the measuring instrument(s) calibrated?

From Cole's video at 1:25 -

So, any objects that have that have similar accelerations will have the same direction and the same sequence of net force, and it's independent of scale.

1. Similar accelerations = similar directions of force

2. Same sequence of net force

3. Independent of scale

His experiments are how he demonstrated similar accelerations, similar directions of net force, and the same sequence of net force.

What instrument is needed to observe how two objects have the same sequence and same direction of net force? I think the only instrument a person needs to calibrate is their brain, so they understand what they see with their eyes.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom