If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Scale is such a dead issue. Several skeptics have already agreed with me on this. Why do you keep bringing it up? You are wasting your time.

Then are you prepared to show all energy values in Cole's experiments are = Mathematical in Scale, to the real event?
That is a part of documentation Cole forgot to include to validate his Hypothesis, and failure to include that information invalidates, Falsified Cole's experiments.

Energy values matter in physics and engineering, you make the claim Cole's experiments are valid, please provide the mathematical validations, you can do that right?
 
Nope.

We won't have the answers unless we get a real investigation. Why is that so hard to understand?

Because you've shown repeatedly that you don't understand the investigation that's already been done. Since you don't understand building collapse or a host of other things, you are not qualified to claim that the official conclusions are wrong.

And your username sure doesn't inspire confidence in your first sentence above.

Scale is such a dead issue.

It sure as hell is not, but I'm aware of your problems with it.


You're a poster child for Dunning-Kruger, FalseFlag. You understand nothing about any of the issues involved in this thread but you are adamant that you know more than anyone else.

Is "making a video about reptiloids" an experiment?

There's an experiment in the video.

What you fail to understand is that doing an experiment, in and of itself, does not necessarily prove the claim the experimenter is making.

That is the problem with Cole's video.
 
No one has said scale is a dead issue.

Get a golf ball and a bowling ball. Drop the golf ball from waist height onto your foot. If scale is a dead issue, then the bowling ball should cause the same amount of force to your foot.

But you won't drop it, will you?

Yes, they have said that scale is a dead issue. It is not relevant to Newton's laws. What you are referring to is a difference in the mass between two objects. Newton's laws apply equally to both objects.

You are destroying your credibility by clinging to a non-issue.
 
Here's a novel idea: why don't you instead start being skeptical of Cole and perform an experiment yourself?
I don't need to be skeptical of an experiment. Skepticism applies to the conclusions one makes after performing an experiment.
 
Then how does NMSR's video relate, but not Cole's? Denial is not an acceptable answer.

No one's denying anything except you. We are _explaining_ things to you. It's no one's fault but your own that you refuse to listen because you're convinced that you already know better, when in fact you know nothing.

I don't need to be skeptical of an experiment.

Then you believe people when they show you perpetual-motion machines?

Cole's entire experiment is based on a non sequitur. You sure as hell should be skeptical of it.
 
It appears we have a new batch of skeptics taking the place of the skeptics that appeared earlier. I will not continue to rehash the same arguments. This is my final post in this thread.

I posted a video to an experiment. Posting a link is nothing more than posting a link. Yes, I agree with the conclusions made by Mr. Cole, but that is irrelevant. All I did was post a link.

Numerous skeptics have made claims that Cole is wrong, yet not ONE single skeptic has posted a link to any experiment anywhere that proves even one of Cole's conclusions is wrong. Without experiment to support the claim, words are meaningless.
This is my response to all future posts in this thread, so if you choose to respond please understand that this will be my reply.
 
Yes, they have said that scale is a dead issue. It is not relevant to Newton's laws. What you are referring to is a difference in the mass between two objects. Newton's laws apply equally to both objects.

You are destroying your credibility by clinging to a non-issue.

The difference in mass between two objects is exactly the point. He's trying to compare a skyscraper to a small stack of boards.

If scale is not an issue, then a martial artist should be able to chop through multiple floors of a building the same way he does with wood blocks.
 
I don't need to be skeptical of an experiment. Skepticism applies to the conclusions one makes after performing an experiment.

No Scepticisms applies in interpretation of conditions of the performance of materials in the experiment, based on the energy values applied too them.
Then on hypothesis drawn from the experiment or experiments so Scepticism starts before the experiment is ever done, and a mathmatical model of the energy values is presented, between the theory A what is expected, and B what the experiment shows occured.
 
This is my final post in this thread.

I guess I'll go with option #2, then: you know full well that you're wrong.

I posted a video to an experiment. Posting a link is nothing more than posting a link. Yes, I agree with the conclusions made by Mr. Cole, but that is irrelevant. All I did was post a link.

Because you believe it. Your claim, your burden. Repeating this:

Without experiment to support the claim, words are meaningless.

Over and over does not make it true.

This is my response to all future posts in this thread, so if you choose to respond please understand that this will be my reply.

Please understand that you are still wrong.
 
Cole's video fails, no support from OP author with ~480 posts

Cole's video stands on its own.
Prove it. You can't after 480 posts? Why not?
You never supported the video, and failed to realize it was BS.
This is your evidence for your failure to support the lies and BS you posted?
... If I'm wrong, ...
Posting Cole's video makes you wrong. An inability to realize how silly the video is, a red flag of wrong. An inability to support Cole's work after 480 posts; that is failure times 480.

You posted nonsense from Cole, you have to prove it is right, or explain why it is wrong. Prove it right, or retract the failed work of Cole.
You debunked Cole with a better experiment... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc You are now a debunker, you debunked Cole; you can't support his claims or video, so you posted a better model. You debunked Cole... was that on purpose, or what

You can't support Cole's work.
Cole has no valid points. You failed to support a point/claim and explain why Cole is right. Why refuse to support the BS you post.

... This is my final post in this thread ...
Never posted support for Cole, and posted a better experiment which debunks Cole.

Failure to prove any Cole claims after 480 posts... irony was posting an experiment which shows Cole is a fraud, and failed to model the WTC collapse.

... This is my final post in this thread ...
 
Last edited:
.......This is my final post in this thread.......

You've said that before. You lied. At the same time you hoped that all our relatives were killed in the next terrorist attack, and told us that we were all paid shills. Why should we take this latest declaration as anything other than yet another lie?
 
It appears we have a new batch of skeptics taking the place of the skeptics that appeared earlier. I will not continue to rehash the same arguments. This is my final post in this thread.

I posted a video to an experiment. Posting a link is nothing more than posting a link. Yes, I agree with the conclusions made by Mr. Cole, but that is irrelevant. All I did was post a link.

Numerous skeptics have made claims that Cole is wrong, yet not ONE single skeptic has posted a link to any experiment anywhere that proves even one of Cole's conclusions is wrong. Without experiment to support the claim, words are meaningless.
This is my response to all future posts in this thread, so if you choose to respond please understand that this will be my reply.

Pensil leads,as connections, wooden boards as floor slabs, drop a 110,000 LBS weight down
On that, remember you said size, Scale does not matter, so my just propose experiment is valid.
 
You have the burden of proof if you want to state that any experiment is wrong. Words are not enough.
That's nonsense. An experiment is an experiment. It's not right or wrong; it's a piece of data. It's the interpretation of the experiment that can be right or wrong, and that interpretation is in Cole's words. Of course it suffices to use words to show why Cole's words on the interpretation of his experiment are wrong.
 
<snip>
I will not waste my time responding when I know my posts will be moved or edited. We are all adults. There is no reason a forum such as this needs any moderation whatsoever. If we want to attack each other, then so be it. We have two choices: we can leave, or we can respond. We don't need a third party using their biased judgement editing and moving posts.<snip>

The only posts that were "moved or edited" were, in fact, posts that violate the MA (which you signed in order to join the site and do your preaching in the first place).

Seems to be one more thing you fail to comprehend.
 
This is an example of a false equivalency, and a poor one at that.



That's not the way this works. It's certainly the way you want it to work, but I'm not buying it. If you say Cole's experiment is flawed, perform your own experiment showing why Cole's is flawed.



OK. Once again, let me post this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc

Say the exact same thing you just posted about the video above, and all of the other ones like it, that are performed by skeptics.

Go ahead. I dare you.

People have wasted a lot of time trying to explain to you that the problem is not that "Cole's experiment is flawed"; it's simply irrelevant. The problem is that the conclusion he draws from that experiment is idiotic -- "not even wrong." Apparently, you lack the scientific understanding, mechanical aptitude and logical reasoning skills to understand why that's so. But then you also find illogical and contradictory excuses for ignoring plenty of real-world demonstrations that Cole is an idiot: Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers.

But you are correct that the NMSR video doesn't tell us anything about what happened to the towers, and the reason is scale. But then, that wasn't its purpose. Its purpose was to demonstrate the idiocy of claims made by a poster named Heiwa, who said such a collapse was impossible under any circumstances. It just so happens that is also tells us something about the idiocy of Cole's conclusion.

I suspect the real problem here is that you don't even understand Cole's argument well enough to state it in your own words. If you could at least achieve that level of understanding, then perhaps there would be some reason to continue this otherwise pointless thread.
 
Then how does NMSR's video relate, but not Cole's? Denial is not an acceptable answer.

People have wasted a lot of time trying to explain to you that the problem is not that "Cole's experiment is flawed"; it's simply irrelevant. The problem is that the conclusion he draws from that experiment is idiotic -- "not even wrong." Apparently, you lack the scientific understanding, mechanical aptitude and logical reasoning skills to understand why that's so. But then you also find illogical and contradictory excuses for ignoring plenty of real-world demonstrations that Cole is an idiot: Verinage demolitions, Ronan Point, and Skyline Towers.

But you are correct that the NMSR video doesn't tell us anything about what happened to the towers, and the reason is scale. But then, that wasn't its purpose. Its purpose was to demonstrate the idiocy of claims made by a poster named Heiwa, who said such a collapse was impossible under any circumstances. It just so happens that is also tells us something about the idiocy of Cole's conclusion.

I suspect the real problem here is that you don't even understand Cole's argument well enough to state it in your own words. If you could at least achieve that level of understanding, then perhaps there would be some reason to continue this otherwise pointless thread.

William is correct, FF. The Heiwa Challenge is posted here:
No structure or tower can be destroyed by gravity from top down initiated by local structural failures up top, i.e. that the weak top crushes the strong bottom.

The NMSR video completely demolishes Heiwa's claim.

It was never intended to be a realistic scale model of the Twin Towers. That would require some serious money to build (all those scaling issues!).

However, it's quite obvious that the NMSR video shows a model that is a much better scaled representation of the towers than Cole's ridiculous effort with stiff boards.

Cole's video is right up there with this one by TruthMakesPeace (Rick Shaddock):

:D
 
I can't believe I'm doing this.

YouTube video "experiments" showing that scale is important in structural modeling:





Note that this concept is so simple that it can be taught to small children by other small children.

Since Cole fails to address--or even acknowledge--even the most basic and obvious problems of scale in structural modeling, his YouTube video "experiment" is useless. It would be wrong to draw any conclusions about the behavior of full scale structures from his work.

But in fact it's not necessary to disprove him by experiment. One can simply point out the extensive body of knowledge about problems of scale in structural modeling, that Cole does not account for. This lapse alone disproves him. Indeed, by omitting the known requirements, his experiment stands as its own disproof.

Which is what everyone has been saying since the beginning of the thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom