If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Proof? Also, if you could prove I have failed at physics, how does my physics failure affect the results of Cole's experiments?



How do you scale up this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc

Please explain why the NMSR experiment is OK, but Cole's experiment is not.

The Geohagen model used toothpicks as "floor" connections to the column.

Had he used steel bolts instead even the first "floor" would have arrested progression.

THAT is scaling. Same model but the column connections are scaled different and make a big difference. You say scale doesn't matter. You are what is called "wrong".

In at least one of Cole's models he drops weight on the "floor" and the "floor" breaks. The connection to columns remains intact. Well first off that is not the mechanism of progressive collapse seen in either of the three WTC collapses. One then wonders how it is supposed to relate to those events at all then. ????

Second, had he really wanted to model a WTC-esque progressive collapse he would have designed different floor to column connections. It looks like he used 1X1 strips of lumber nailed or screwed to the columns. He probably could have jumped up and down on those floor seats and not peeled them away from the columns.
Obviously the floor seats on his columns were scaled way above the strength that a more appropriate model would use.

Redesign?

A much better model is being discussed right now in the Metabunk forum, as I am sure someone has pointed out already.

If Cole is simply trying to demonstrate that application of Newton's laws would dictate that the falling mass must arrest, then the Geohagen model should also support Cole. It doesn't, therefore the simplistic and erroneous claims Cole makes re:Newton, must be in error.
 
Last edited:
...... those of us who do believe that the tower's destruction was led by truss connection failure from massive overload, to produce a summary we can all use? anytime a CT comes on JAQing about the towers we just post a link to that summary.

So, in keeping with my own suggestion:
Generic description of the collapse progression of the two WTC towers:

Video evidence demonstrates aircraft impact destroyed or bent a number of perimeter columns. A lesser amount of core column severance or damage is expected. Some floor spans also directly damaged.

Aircraft fuel spread through several vertically adjacent floors of the structure and ignited. This created a condition of very large area office contents fire on those floors with various levels of rubblization of the contents. This is a fire condition rarely if ever, reached within seconds of fire initiation in large office structures.

Aircraft impact debrided spray on fire insulation in varying degree, on a significant number of structural components on impact floors. This reduced fire resistance of those structural steel components.

Structural response to impact was a redistribution of loads previously carried by missing or foreshortened ( due to being bent) columns. Load redistribution was not even across all remaining columns.

Fire spread and movement was similar, but not identical, on each involved level and also spread to higher levels. Heat began affecting steel structural components, both vertical and horizontal, and the connecting components between them on all fire involved levels.

Floor spans had long trusses with their lower chords exposed to the heat and the trusses in several areas began sagging. A few areas had already seen truss or truss to perimeter connection failure at impact.

Perimeter columns and truss to perimeter connecting components heated less than the core columns and truss to core structure components. The interface between long span trusses and core was a belt truss rather than direct connection to core columns.

Core columns are subject to heating basically from all sides, over the several floors fully involved in the fires, and over the course of fire spread around each level.
( that is to say a column at level x may heat more on one face than that same column at level x-1 or x+1 but that over the several levels involved some columns are heated on all sides and taking into account the changes through time)
The capability of the structure to resist any collapse was being eroded. One very obvious indication of this is the inward bowing of part of the perimeter. Each tier also twisted and tilted noticeably up to collapse. These demonstrate that the structure was responding to further weakening due to the heat. Loads were continually changing and redistributing during this time.
At some point a redistribution caused one or more columns to exceed its capacity. Column capacity in this case does not necessarily mean it original engineered load bearing ability. Loads were not necessarily on axis and columns were not necessarily at room temperature, both of which would tend to lower any individual column's strength.

At this point a rapid redistribution the remains structure occurred, rapidly causing other columns to exceed capacity, causing another rapid load shift and column failures progressed to all columns over one or more levels.

A large section of the upper building then falls, accelerating to next contact. A combination of factors result in few if any buckled columns impact on lower parts of themselves. Upper falling section column ends are the first contacts with lower structure. That contact would be proximate to the lower section columns and thus the greatest impact occurs near or directly on lower floor truss to column connecting components.

This is occurring both to long span truss to column connecting components, at perimeter and belt truss, as well as with the core's beams running between core columns.

As upper mass continues its lowest floor begins contacting lower floors. This first contact is between floor systems that are already severely compromised. They are among those that have been affected by impact and heat and one has suffered loss of connections to columns as per last paragraph.

Both upper structure and lower structure now have major connection failures, both in the vertical/horizontal connections as well as connections between column sections. The later is due to both the destruction of Lateral Support and the buffeting collisions from the falling mass.
Perimeter column "trees" peel away, the first to do so are on the order of 1000 feet above ground as they pivot away.

Collapse continues with a relatively small amount of falling mass being ejected at the collision interface. Since initial contact was an order of magnitude greater than that which the long span open floors could absorb, little effect is seen on the falling mass. This means that the still intact portion of upper mass will continue to accelerate.

Again first contact is the lower column ends, though some movement of those column ends might not see them directly affecting column\truss(or beam) connections , they will spear through that next lower floor.

Next long span floors will now be impacted by more mass , albeit more rubblized, that is necessarily moving faster than first contact. Those floor spans must also be hit by an order of magnitude greater load thanthey can withstand, and indeed greater than at that earlier, first contact impact.

There existed no mechanism by which this floor truss and perimeter peel destruction could be arrested as this continues.

The core area beam destruction lags that of the long span destruction since those beams are heavier and shorter. Perimeter peel necessarily lags long span destruction as it is a direct result of that long span truss destruction.

Core columns stripped of inter-core Lateral Support succumb to a combination of slender column buckling and heavy buffeting from falling debris. A relatively small, heavily damaged, portion of the core remains after long span floor and perimeter destruction ( no longer being buffeted by debris impact) but cannot remain intact and it comes apart as well





How's that?

Beats hell out of ROOSD or any summarizing acronym, in descriptive ability. Not so much in brevity though.

I invite ftfy's
 
Last edited:
I can't believe I'm doing this.

YouTube video "experiments" showing that scale is important in structural modeling:





Note that this concept is so simple that it can be taught to small children by other small children.

Since Cole fails to address--or even acknowledge--even the most basic and obvious problems of scale in structural modeling, his YouTube video "experiment" is useless. It would be wrong to draw any conclusions about the behavior of full scale structures from his work.

But in fact it's not necessary to disprove him by experiment. One can simply point out the extensive body of knowledge about problems of scale in structural modeling, that Cole does not account for. This lapse alone disproves him. Indeed, by omitting the known requirements, his experiment stands as its own disproof.

Which is what everyone has been saying since the beginning of the thread.

This post is undeniable proof that you refuse to read the posts in this thread. Not one person has said that scale is not important when it comes to scale models. The issue is that scale does not apply when it comes to demonstrating Newton's laws of motion. Your tricks are tiring.
 
This post is undeniable proof that you refuse to read the posts in this thread. Not one person has said that scale is not important when it comes to scale models. The issue is that scale does not apply when it comes to demonstrating Newton's laws of motion. Your tricks are tiring.

Then you won't mind addressing post 2064
 
This post is undeniable proof that you refuse to read the posts in this thread. Not one person has said that scale is not important when it comes to scale models. The issue is that scale does not apply when it comes to demonstrating Newton's laws of motion. Your tricks are tiring.
What happened to the constant acceleration...
As with all 9/11 truth claims, statements and assorted BS... lies

... This is my final post in this thread. ...
cue 3 dog night

You destroy your credibility by bringing up these examples. This post also proves that you refuse to read the posts in this thread.
Like this?
... This is my final post in this thread. ...

The best part of the nearly 500 posts you made, one of them refuted Cole. Cole's claims and experiments fail on their own, and you posted a video which refutes the intent of Cole.
 
Last edited:
This post is undeniable proof that you refuse to read the posts in this thread. Not one person has said that scale is not important when it comes to scale models. The issue is that scale does not apply when it comes to demonstrating Newton's laws of motion. Your tricks are tiring.

FF, you're acting a bit like Wile E. Coyote after realizing he's run off a cliff, and that the earth is no longer supporting him.

The issue is that scale DOES matter when it comes to making experiments regarding the collapses of the Twin Towers. Cole tries to mince around this, but it's very, very clear that he thinks he is doing experiments that reflect upon the tower collapses, and not simply verifying Newton's laws of motion.

Don't take my word for it, just listen to Cole himself:
While not perfect, it looked like I was starting to replicate the motions we observed for the twin towers.

Did you notice that Cole didn't say
While not perfect, it looked like I was starting to replicate the demonstrations of Newton's laws of motion.

No, he said
While not perfect, it looked like I was starting to replicate the motions we observed for the twin towers.

Q.E.D.
 
William is correct, FF. The Heiwa Challenge is posted here:
The NMSR video completely demolishes Heiwa's claim.
You obviously have not read the entire page. You have chosen one paragraph, just one, to make an irrelevant point.

Using a larger version of the model in the video, with exactly the same materials, have NMSR drop 15 discs on a stack of 85 discs. Post the results.
 
You destroy your credibility by bringing up these examples. This post also proves that you refuse to read the posts in this thread.

How...odd...to speak of "destroyed credibility", when you had to come back to a thread you claimed to have left in order to do so.

You are acting both the pot, and the kettle.
 
You obviously have not read the entire page. You have chosen one paragraph, just one, to make an irrelevant point.

Using a larger version of the model in the video, with exactly the same materials, have NMSR drop 15 discs on a stack of 85 discs. Post the results.

And you fail to realize the equation E=mc3 even applies to Newtons Laws, and that energy and strength change with the amount of mass in a given space.

I asked you to prove mathematically that Cole's experiments are relevant my experiments have already been mathematically proven accurate. Cole's can not be if they can then by all means do so, or you have no valid argument.
 
You just made my point for me.

I wouldn't be so fast to head off on your victory lap just yet.

Think about what you said. Think about it.

I don't need to think about it, I wrote it, though you need to because you're so fast trying to claim victory you're missing the important stuff.

So, you're saying you can demonstrate a progressive collapse without using a model of the towers.

Of course you can. What you can't do is say that the progressive collapse is the same as the one that occurred in the Towers because not all progressive collapses are identical.

If NMSR can do it, why can't Cole?

He did. Remember the collapse he created in the video when he used the pizza stand things on their side? That was a progressive collapse, and ironically it was closer to the WTC 1&2 collapse mechanism than the NMSR collapse technique. So yes, Cole DID create a progressive collapse, but creating one and creating a model of the progressive collapse that occurred in the WTC are different things, just as having models of a Ford GTO and Ferrari Spider are different, though both are cars. None of Cole's models, even the pizza thingie collapse are representative of the WTC collapses.

I really didn't think you would take the dare, but you did. Thanks.

This is because you don't understand the situation you are actually in, or what's required. Cole's videos are actually able to show two principles that can be applied to the WTC collapses. They can't be used as models of the towers and the conclusions he draws are the experiments is totally false because his experiments don't back up his conclusions due to factors he doesn't take into consideration, but that's not to say that nothing can be gleaned from them. It's just that neither you or he actually know what the experiments really show, nor how to apply that information to the real world. People have been trying to explain it to you, but instead of listening and learning you think you know it all and refuse to allow any knowledge in. This really is truly sad.
 
What do Newton's laws of motion address?

And around in circles we go.

Consider this. A baseball thrown by a person and a Tennis ball fired from a Tennis ball launcher will both act in similar ways based on the Laws of Motion, Correct?

Can we then declare that since both balls acts in accordance with the laws of motion, that firing a tennis ball from a launcher is a valid representation of a thrown base ball?
 
Last edited:
And around in circles we go.

Consider this. A baseball thrown by a person and a Tennis ball fired from a Tennis ball launcher will both act in similar ways based on the Laws of Motion, Correct?

Can we then declare that since both balls acts in accordance with the laws of motion, that firing a tennis ball from a launcher is a valid representation of a thrown base ball?

Shoot a bullet though air it travels thousands of yards,

Shoot a bullet though water it travels hundreds of yards.

Shoot a bullet though ballistic jell it goes several feet.

Shoot a bullet into granite it ricucets off.

All these situation obey Newtonian physics, only the resistance to travel changes.
Do to increased strength of the materials, an increased energy in the physical structure of
The atomic bonding.

Going up in Scale changes the energy from gravity applied to mass.
Coming down in Scale increases the energy of the electron bonding of elements.

That will effect the way Newton's laws apply.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom