If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you can't show him a Youtube video it doesn’t count.

I never said you have to show me a YouTube video. I said that if you make a claim, you need to support your claim by experiment. You can post the experiment on Vimeo, or anywhere else. I don't care.
 
FalseFlag's 466 posts fail to support Cole's folly

466 posts by FalseFlag, the OP author, no evidence, no support, no facts to back up Cole's delusions.
 
Take a nine volt battery, place it on a flat level surface, then place a triple a battery on top, tap the 9volt with your fingers so it slides forward.

The battery on top will roll backwards do to inertia but the 9volt is not impeded much by the energy transfered to the battery to start it rolling.
That is because the energy to start the battery rolling is less than the energy to move the battery forward.

No I have just propose an experiment that shows Cole is wrong, if you wish to continue then
Please show where the magical mystery force you say exists to prevent the top mass, from falling though the bottom Structure comes from.

You have too account for the energy values and the work, your physics is fatally flawed, no experiments are needed to show the forces are severely out of balance.

Cole's experiments prove nothing more than either he is an incompetent engineer when it comes to doing structual engineering, or more likely a fraudulent one,

What?
 
466 posts by FalseFlag, the OP author, no evidence, no support, no facts to back up Cole's delusions.

Cole's video stands on its own.

Rinse.

Repeat.

2024 posts in this thread. 468 by me. That means, according to you, that skeptics have 1556 posts with "no evidence, no support, no facts to back up their delusions." If I'm wrong, please link me the experiment that proves this.
 
Last edited:
Posting a video does not create any burden.

Making a claim that the video is inaccurate puts the burden of proof on you. If you make the claim, you have the burden to prove that your claim is true. You can choose to use words, but unless you can support your words with experiment, your words are meaningless.

Simple.

I did the experiment years ago to prove Cole Wrong, with the real type of bolts and welds in the world trade center, why should I spend Time and money again to show Cole's BS, is BS?

2600 LBS dropped 12 ft. Will shatter any connection in the world trade center and brings the buildings down as seen in all the Video footage of the falling towers.
 
This is an example of a false equivalency, and a poor one at that.

I'm not trying to show an equivalence, I'm pointing out that an experiment, any experiment, is done to test something, and just because an experiment claims to be able to test it, doesn't mean it actually can and it doesn't mean that you have to do a different experiment to prove the first one doesn't do what it claims to test.

That's not the way this works.

Actually that's exactly how it works. The burden is on the experimenter to not only do an experiment, but to make sure that the design of the experiment is suitable to actually demonstrate the principle they are conducting the experiment to show. Cole doesn't do this. The fact the design of his experiments are flawed for trying to show what he is claiming, totally undercuts the claims he then makes based on those experiments.

It's certainly the way you want it to work, but I'm not buying it. If you say Cole's experiment is flawed, perform your own experiment showing why Cole's is flawed.

Hogwash. You might as well claim that the only way to show that a car is poorly designed is by building a car yourself to show it. That pointing out that mounting its wheels on the roof and making them square won't actually work to make the car move is not a way to show the car design is flawed.

Anyone that understand the experiments and the principles he is trying to show can speak as to if the experiment is flawed without conducting their own, just as anyone that is able to understand how a car operates can tell you if it's design means that it won't function without building their own one.

OK. Once again, let me post this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZNXb8Jd6zc

Say the exact same thing you just posted about the video above, and all of the other ones like it, that are performed by skeptics.

Go ahead. I dare you.

It's a nice example of a progressive collapse, but it's not a model of the Towers. It demonstrates certain principles that can be applied to the collapses, but that's it, it certainly isn't structurally the same as the towers, and nor is it's progressive collapse related to that of the towers. But then it's not supposed to be a representative of the towers, it's merely supposed to demonstrate a progressive collapse.

What's your point?
 

We are talking resistance to motion, the top battery experts inertia upon the lower one but because it is round the resistance from it's inertia is lower, than an object of the same weight
Placed on top the 9 volt battery.

That is an experiment that proves energy values can vary, in application of Newtonian physics. Fore you to show Cole's experiments have any value you must and it is hour's and Cole's burden of proof to show his experiments have equal energy Values to the real event.
I understand why you will never do that, because Cole's experiments are nothing but frauds totally irrelevant Frauds.
 
It's a nice example of a progressive collapse, but it's not a model of the Towers. It demonstrates certain principles that can be applied to the collapses, but that's it, it certainly isn't structurally the same as the towers, and nor is it's progressive collapse related to that of the towers. But then it's not supposed to be a representative of the towers, it's merely supposed to demonstrate a progressive collapse.

What's your point?

You just made my point for me. Think about what you said. Think about it. So, you're saying you can demonstrate a progressive collapse without using a model of the towers. If NMSR can do it, why can't Cole?
I really didn't think you would take the dare, but you did. Thanks.
 
Yes. I blame the government for failing to conduct and/or allow a thorough, properly-funded, transparent, and independent investigation into the collapse of WTC7.

Don't you also blame the government for 9/11 itself?

Aren't you being hypocritical by decrying blaming someone, namely the Muslims who perpetrated the attack, while blaming others yourself?
 
I am 100 percent positive that you need to ask yourself this question before you ask anyone else.

Considering that you don't understand the issue of scaling, which is a fundamental issue, I don't put any weight on your positiveness.

Mr. Cole made a video. If you want to publicly say his video is wrong you are certainly free to use whatever words you want; however, your words are meaningless unless you provide an experiment backing them up.

Again, you don't understand burden of proof. Cole has not proven anything, and pointing out the flaws of the experiment, which has already been done, is quite sufficient. That you gleefully ignore those criticisms does not make them go away.

You have the burden of proof if you want to state that any experiment is wrong.

Nope.
 
Please come up with a better trick than this.

The video stands on its own.

Or, in this case, collapses on its own.

By your "logic", someone making a video about reptiloids in the White House is proof that there are, and we have to prove it wrong. If we worked that way, nothing would ever get done and we'd never have working theories for anything because we'd waste all our time proving nonsense wrong.

It's the burden of the claimant to show that their ideas are correct, not the other way around.
 
Don't you also blame the government for 9/11 itself?

Nope.

We won't have the answers unless we get a real investigation. Why is that so hard to understand? Everyone in this forum, regardless of their position, should support a real, independent, properly funded investigation. There has not been one.
 
Considering that you don't understand the issue of scaling, which is a fundamental issue, I don't put any weight on your positiveness.

Scale is such a dead issue. Several skeptics have already agreed with me on this. Why do you keep bringing it up? You are wasting your time.
 
Please provide proof of this statement.

Who do you think did the experiments into this for Benson and Greening, Cole can't debunk an experiment that's actually was done years ago that shows him definitely wrong.

That sum is used in the maxwell equation, mathematics proves Cole wrong.

The Maxwell equation shows that a 1 foot off center eccentric strike of 100,000 Pounds will
Break any connection in the twin towers, 100,000 pounds is only 2600 LBS, Dropped 12 feet.

There is simply not enough resistance to the upper mass to slow said upper mass significantly in the towers, ant it has been proven mathematical and logically and is non disputable.

If you wish to dispute it you have to establish the energy values in Coles experiments and present them for discussion.
 
By your "logic", someone making a video about reptiloids in the White House is proof that there are, and we have to prove it wrong. If we worked that way, nothing would ever get done and we'd never have working theories for anything because we'd waste all our time proving nonsense wrong.

Is "making a video about reptiloids" an experiment? You should learn what an experiment is before continuing.
 
Who do you think did the experiments into this for Benson and Greening, Cole can't debunk an experiment that's actually was done years ago that shows him definitely wrong.

That sum is used in the maxwell equation, mathematics proves Cole wrong.

The Maxwell equation shows that a 1 foot off center eccentric strike of 100,000 Pounds will
Break any connection in the twin towers, 100,000 pounds is only 2600 LBS, Dropped 12 feet.

There is simply not enough resistance to the upper mass to slow said upper mass significantly in the towers, ant it has been proven mathematical and logically and is non disputable.

If you wish to dispute it you have to establish the energy values in Coles experiments and present them for discussion.

Again, please provide a link to an experiment or other credible source that supports your claim that "2600 pounds dropped from 12 feet could break any connection in the WTC."
 
Scale is such a dead issue. Several skeptics have already agreed with me on this. Why do you keep bringing it up? You are wasting your time.

No one has said scale is a dead issue.

Get a golf ball and a bowling ball. Drop the golf ball from waist height onto your foot. If scale is a dead issue, then the bowling ball should cause the same amount of force to your foot.

But you won't drop it, will you?
 
This is an example of a false equivalency, and a poor one at that.

No, it's called an analogy. Are you participating in a "being wrong" Olympics of some sort?

That's not the way this works. It's certainly the way you want it to work, but I'm not buying it. If you say Cole's experiment is flawed, perform your own experiment showing why Cole's is flawed.

Nonsense. Cole's video does NOT relate to the towers' collapse, full stop.

words are meaningless

Then why do you keep using them?

Words shred nothing without experiment to support them.

This is simply you trying to play skeptic, but failing to understand the terms and methods involved. We see that all the time: repeating terms and playing with the burden of proof as if you think you'll somehow confuse people who know what those terms and methods mean. You keep asking other people to perform experiments, but yourself are clearly incapable of understanding how these experiments work or what they would entail. You don't even understand when to ask for an experiment or how the burden of proof works. Here's an example:

Posting a video does not create any burden.

Making a claim that the video is inaccurate puts the burden of proof on you.

This is laughable to anyone who understands burden of proof. Everyone keeps telling you this, but you refuse to educate yourself on the issue. You are either entirely convinced that all the effort should lie with people who disagree with you, or you, as PhantomWolf point out, are fully aware of how wrong you are, but cannot bring yourself to admit it publicly.

Please provide proof of this statement.

Here's a novel idea: why don't you instead start being skeptical of Cole and perform an experiment yourself?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom