Identification of the Toshiba radio from PA103

I am not sure what you mean here.

I believe that investigators framed Libya in general and Megrahi/Fhimah in particular for the bombing of 103 for politically motivated reasons. I also believe that any conspiracy involved here will have had to have been a simple one involving as few people as possible.

Sorry, I wasn't being clear. I'm suggesting that the fact that Feraday had extracted the badly damaged compacted pieces of a manual from the collar, and although he could not determine the exact model of radio, in order to cement or corroborate this finding and his assertion that it was one of a particular model of Toshiba containing the bomb, evidence presented that has been found by an innocent member of the public may possibly lend irrefutable weight to his thesis - and pinpoint the precise model.
 
The point I was trying to make earlier with the comparison to 9/11, is that what you are saying about the 5x5 piece of manual being unable to survive the explosion, is the same argument from incredulity that we hear truthers giving over say the passport of one of the hijackers.


OK, I see your point. However, I would submit that not all argument from incredulity is ill-founded.

FWIW I don't think it's possible the cover piece could have survived either, but I am not an explosives expert, I know almost nothing about explosives.


Indeed. Nevertheless, we can see the sort of damage that was sustained by other items in that suitcase. We also know that this wasn't just a physical blowing apart, it was an extremely high-temperature fireball. This is PAPER we're talking about.

I'm not hankering for Longtabber PE's return, but I'd dearly love to hear an explosives expert's opinion on this. I do wish Wyatt had addressed the question.

My point is that Hayes & Feraday are both scientists, neither of them baulked at the idea that a fragile paper fragment could have survived the explosion. There were explosives guys at the AAIB, there have been any number of people since then looking through the evidence, and no-one with any explosives training has stated that a paper manual could not have survived, or was highly unlikely to have done. The defense team at the original trial and at the appeal do not seem to have made that argument.


Mmmm, Hayes was a scientist. Not Feraday. I think it's odd that we haven't even seen this debated. I'd just like to know that this is something these people have actually thought about and accepted, as opposed to something that has been overlooked in all the debate about the timer.

I'd guess that the reason the timer board should not have survived was it was in the radio and the manual was outside and might have been shielded from some of the forces involved in the explosion by the case of the radio as it was being blown apart.


The suitcase was blown apart! By a fireball. The only way I can possibly imagine this happening is if a large enough piece of the radio remained intact to propel the 5-inch square of paper before it, ahead of the fireball. That really means believing the tape transport remained intact, as far as I can see. Fair enough, I'm sure a lot of things weren't found (though I'd have thought something that size would have had a fair chance), but given the shattered state of everything that was found, is it really possible the tape transport wasn't shattered? And even if it wasn't, is it still possible that paper wouldn't have been incinerated?

I haven't heard any expolsives expert speak to the likelihood of any of this, and I really wish there was some information.

I think that if we are talking about when evidence was planted/tampered with/fabricated to point at Libya then we are talking about dates between May and September 1989.

If we assume that PK/689 was a plant, it might well have been done to point to Khreesat, both radios called "Bombeat", PFLP-GC based in Libya, that kind of angle.


That's a can of worms! I can imagine a serious decision to try to implicate Libya (even as a way of turning attention away from Iran), but to start trying to frame Khreesat by fabricating evidence, then leaving him to go after Megrahi? Seems insane.

Remember, the whole point about the RTF-16 was that it was exclusively or almost exclusively sold to Libya. Just like the MST-13.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I've been thinking more about the probability of a scenario where a two-leaf 5-inch square fragment of paper might survive this explosion, fluttering free, and I have to say I'm still having trouble buying it.

I think it would have to have been punched out of the manual by something fairly flat and itself approximately 5 inches square, that was being propelled at the front of the explosion, in the direction of the open air. I don't think I dreamed up the tape transport idea by myself, I think I read it somewhere but didn't pick up on the significance of it at the time. However, that's really the only item that would fit the bill.

So, we'd have the Semtex packed behind the tape transport, and the manual lying flat along the side of the radio - as it might lie if it was packed in the original box with the radio. It's the most likely arrangement, and really, if the manual was loose in the suitcase it seems even less likely a flat 5-inch-square piece could have been punched out as neatly as that. The Semtex goes boom, doesn't shatter the tape transport, but propels it intact towards the open air. It's near the forefront of the explosion, nevertheless the aircraft skin is blown out in front of it. Either a section of the Toshiba case also remains intact between the tape transport and the manual, or the plastic case shatters without significantly shredding the manual. Did the suitcase on the other side of the manual also have a 5-inch-square bit punched out, so helping protect the paper? Was any piece of the suitcase found that was as big as that?

I'm struggling already. It seems to me the manual is incinerated, and if it escapes that, it's shredded by the shattering plastic radio case and/or the shattering suitcase.

So what happens to the tape transport? It's quite a heavy item. We focus a lot on the debris trail of Christmas cards and so on stretching to the North Sea, but the heavy stuff all landed very close to Lockerbie. All the aircraft parts were found in two debris trails that petered out just past Langholm, before the English border. Before you reach the Newcastleton or Kielder forests.

If you superimpose the map of the debris trails on the OS map, you can see that the field where PI995 was (allegedly) found was at about the furthest end of the longer debris trail. Inevitably, any reasonably heavy object is going to have fallen within these debris trails. A tape transport wasn't going to blow as far as a shirt collar - it's relatively heavy, and it has relatively little air resistance.

All that area was gone over with a fine-tooth comb. Most of it is open moor and hillside. There is some woodland, small rivers and burns, and a small reservoir. I don't know if they dragged that. I suppose it's possible a tape transport could have gone into the Winterhope reservoir and not been recovered, so it's maybe a moot point, but in that area they really did pick up everything that wasn't either growing, or a rock.

Nevertheless, we're baulking at the idea of the small timer fragment having survived the explosion. Is the concept of the tape transport surviving the explosion intact, to punch out that sizeable piece of paper and preserve it from incineration as it passed through where the aircraft skin had been blown out, really tenable? That is, assuming the tape transport hadn't been removed to make more room for the Semtex.

It doesn't seem to me that they found any part of that radio bigger than about a square centimetre. I can buy a few similarly-sized scraps of paper surviving by being punched into cloth by these fragments. Beyond that, where's the large surviving piece of radio that punched out a much bigger piece, and how did it manage not to be in bits like the rest of the thing?

I agree, it needs an expolsives expert, but lacking one, common sense will have to do and my common sense is baulking like mad.

Rolfe.
 
Thats the corroborating evidence from a police officer with 20 years experience. He says that PK689 was what Mrs Horton handed in. That it was singed.


I appreciate that point, but I don't think it's conclusive. This is still 11 years later, and we're talking about a policeman who received and sorted quite a lot of stuff. If he'd drawn or photographed or even recorded that description of it as he received it, then that would be conclusive, but he's not referring to any records, he's just "remembering".

The way this works is that the prosecution go over this sort of evidence with their witnesses in advance. They want to know what they're going to say. They don't like surprises. A policeman being asked to give this sort of evidence would be told, well, it was you who took in Mrs. Horton's finds and bagged them. We'll want you to identify one particular piece, OK? It would be described to him, and he might well be shown a photograph of it. Is he going to say, I'm sorry but there was quite a lot of stuff and I really don't remember? Probably not. If what he's shown is conceivably something Mrs. Horton gave him, is he going to fit his description to the evidence he's shown? Probably. If he's really doubtful that that item is actually what Mrs. Horton gave him, is he likely to say so? I would say not, unless he was very very sure. And the chances of him being very very sure about something like that after 11 years do not seem to be high.

So I don't really rate Mr. Walton's evidence any more highly than Mrs. Horton's. She found something quite like that piece of paper and handed it to Mr. Walton with other stuff. I don't see it as conclusive that what was produced in court was the same item.

Rolfe.
 
So I don't really rate Mr. Walton's evidence any more highly than Mrs. Horton's. She found something quite like that piece of paper and handed it to Mr. Walton with other stuff. I don't see it as conclusive that what was produced in court was the same item.

Me neither. Just that this was how the fragment was presented to the trial. As I understand it claims made at a trial that are not contested by the other side are accepted as facts(?)

I believe Mrs Horton found a piece of a Toshiba manual that had the whole word Toshiba written on it. If you find something that has a fragment of a word on it you would remember trying to work out what that word was I think.

Feraday claims that because PK/689 is singed that it must have come from near the explosion. Clearly this is bunk.

There were two possible means for items to become singed. Either they were in the explosion, or they were in close proximity to the fires that broke out on the ground.

I think a much more plausible source for PK/689 is that it was contained in luggage that fell near to Sherwood Crescent, or that it was on the ground already and subsequently became involved with one of the fires. It was singed around the edges as a result of that fire and lifted into the air on a thermal, then blown from there to where Mrs Horton discovered it later.

There is no proof whatsoever that it had any explosives residue on it (is there?) or for that matter traces of aviation fuel that might appear on it if it had been close to a fire started by lots of aviation fuel.

I've been looking through the transcripts for more information on the forensic testing that was done to PK/689 and I can't find any.
 
My problem with this theory is that we're talking about a recognisable page of a manual for a model of radio sold almost exclusively to Libya. The piece of evidence that apparently all on its own caused Feraday to change his mind radically about what model of radio had been used in the IED, to one which could be traced to Libya and which appeared to implicate Libya almost as strongly as the MST-13. We're led to believe that this model of radio wasn't something anyone living in, say, Frankfurt or Stockholm or London, could just pop into Curry's and buy. We're led to believe it was such a specifically Libyan model that is pointed inexorably to that country.

You seem to be suggesting that a manual for such a radio, which turned out to be an absolute godsend to the investigation, just happened to be blowing about Northumberland by pure chance, having no connection to the IED or the "primary suitcase" at all? That it came from a piece of luggage that broke up, but nobody noticed the actual radio among the items recovered on the ground? That someone was carrying such a manual on the plane, but not the radio to go with it? That an innocent passenger just happened to have that manual, pointing so conveniently to Libya?

Toshiba radios are very common, and if that had been a piece of manual from a model widely available in the west, I'd have been agreeing with you entirely. But for a manual from that precise model to be there quite fortuitously? I don't think so.

I don't think the item produced in court was what Gwen Horton found. She herself was very doubtful about it, and I suspect the policeman is just agreeing with what he's been told to agree with, having no clear memory of the item from 11 years ago. So I really, really don't believe that what Gwen Horton picked up was a manual for the Libya-exclusive model, and thus I don't see any real reason to believe it was singed.

I agree with you that she appears to have found a piece of paper with the word Toshiba on it, probably the whole word. Quite possibly part of a manual for a radio or similar item, that was part of an innocent passenger's luggage. Something commonly available in Curry's or Dixon's. I don't see any need for it to have been singed. Mrs. Horton doesn't say she remembers it as being singed. Mr. Walton is, in my opinion, merely describing what he is being shown, rather than clearly remembering the appearance of one of the many pieces of random litter he bagged 11 years previously.

Then, when it appeared politic to make it look as if this atrocity was carried out by someone other than Iran, and IDing the radio as that very identifiable Libyan model seemed like a good way to do it, switching that piece of paper was a very easy way to introduce that evidence. It totally eliminates the need to manufacture provenance, and introduces a witness attesting to its early discovery who is quite clearly not conspiring in anything.

Rolfe.
 
The piece of evidence that apparently all on its own caused Feraday to change his mind radically about what model of radio had been used in the IED, to one which could be traced to Libya and which appeared to implicate Libya almost as strongly as the MST-13. We're led to believe that this model of radio wasn't something anyone living in, say, Frankfurt or Stockholm or London, could just pop into Curry's and buy. We're led to believe it was such a specifically Libyan model that is pointed inexorably to that country.
<snip>

I don't think the item produced in court was what Gwen Horton found. She herself was very doubtful about it, and I suspect the policeman is just agreeing with what he's been told to agree with, having no clear memory of the item from 11 years ago. So I really, really don't believe that what Gwen Horton picked up was a manual for the Libya-exclusive model, and thus I don't see any real reason to believe it was singed.

I agree with you that she appears to have found a piece of paper with the word Toshiba on it, probably the whole word. Quite possibly part of a manual for a radio or similar item, that was part of an innocent passenger's luggage. Something commonly available in Curry's or Dixon's. I don't see any need for it to have been singed. Mrs. Horton doesn't say she remembers it as being singed. Mr. Walton is, in my opinion, merely describing what he is being shown, rather than clearly remembering the appearance of one of the many pieces of random litter he bagged 11 years previously.

Then, when it appeared politic to make it look as if this atrocity was carried out by someone other than Iran, and IDing the radio as that very identifiable Libyan model seemed like a good way to do it, switching that piece of paper was a very easy way to introduce that evidence. It totally eliminates the need to manufacture provenance, and introduces a witness attesting to its early discovery who is quite clearly not conspiring in anything.

Rolfe.

That's pretty much my thinking on this unscathed page found by Mrs Horton.

The item shown to Mrs Horton at Zeist contained just enough wording to be recognised by Mrs Horton as a 'Toshiba', just as she had discovered, but also just enough wording that it could be determined that this particular model was of that predominantly used by Libya. This corroboration from a member of the public as a witness to something that she discovered, despite her somewhat perplexed view of what she was shown, proved a legitimate indicator of Libya's and Megrahi's guilt, while it also simply reinforced Feraday's 'fragment' of timer discovery, and it's connection to Libya and Megrahi.

I have no qualms in accepting the fact that Mrs Horton may well have discovered debris in her garden on 22 December, including a page of a Toshiba manual. The possibility that some passenger(s) on 103 may well have had one of their own contained in their luggage, or indeed as an intended Christmas present, which then broke free during the disintergration of the aircraft, allowing a portion of manual to scatter in the wind, landing in Mrs Horton's garden along with Christmas cards and other debris, I can accept as capable of happening.

However, personally I don't think that the manual discovered by Mrs Horton was in close proximity to the bomb, (if a fragment surviving the explosion is "unbelievable", then a sheet of paper surviving is completely preposterous) and I don't believe the portion presented to her at Zeist was infact the the page she found outside her home. What I believe she was shown at Zeist was a manipulated sheet from a manual which would point away from a completely innocent model of Toshiba carried by a paasenger on 103 (and, as a bonus, points away from Khreesat too!), and more pertinently, would point once again towards Libya and thus Megrahi.

Aside from Feraday's initial assertion that it was a white Toshiba, given the pieces found in the frame of container AVE4041, Feraday himself had stated that the compacted pieces of the manual he had extracted from the Slalom shirt collar, together with the tiny bits of black plastic that he had identified (PI995), he could not determine the exact model of Toshiba recorder. However, the portion shown to Mrs Horton (who's memory 11 years after her discovery could be faded) conveniently revealed just enough information for Feraday, and the Zeist judges, to conclude it was a model, RT-SF16, which led inescapably towards Libya.

She herself remarked "well, not in it's present state" when asked to identify the evidence presented to her at Zeist, but allowing for the apparent testing done on the page resulting in it's damaged state (and that of being near an 'explosion'), the judges simply accepted that Mrs Horton's find emanated from the explosive device itself was therefore plausible.
 
Last edited:
Some thoughts on the "almost exclusively Libyan" origin for the RTSF-16 black radio.

Trial Evidence Day 35 said:
[Yoshihiro Miura, employee of Toshiba, Japan]
[EXAMINATION IN CHIEF BY MR. CAMPBELL:]
Q: And if we go towards the right-hand side of the page and look at the two columns under 88/10 to 89/3, that's to say October '88 to March '89. Do we see there the figure of 29,700 such radio/cassette players?

A Yes.

Q And does that, then, include the 20,000 that you've told us about that were shipped in October, together with a further 9,700?

A Yes, that is correct.

Q And do we see in the next column the percentage of worldwide sales of each of the supplies

[5418]

in that period?

A Yes.

Q And do we see that in that six-month period that 75.94 per cent of the supplies of this particular type of radio/cassette went to Libya?

A Yes.

Campbell then talks with Takuya Honda, also an employee of Toshiba, Japan. He states that a Libyan company were involved in the purchase of Radios from Toshiba, he went to the office dealing with this deal in July 1988, at which point the deal was all but rubber stamped. Libyan company was called "Electric General Company". The deal was rubber stamped in November 1988 and as part of it 20,000 radios were delivered.

76% isn't "almost exclusive" in my book, and we are only talking about it being at 76% of global sales for October 1988 to March 1989.

Yoshihiro Miura is NOT asked at the trial where the other 24% of these radios were sold to, or anything about sales figures for periods prior to October 1988, we don't know when this model was first produced. There are approximately 10000 of these radios in circulation elsewhere in the world between October 1988 and March 1989.

The sales records were available to both sides in full, but I can't see anywhere in the trial evidence that these are discussed apart from these two witnesses.

Even if the radio was "exclusively Libyan" they were sold to a Libyan company for general sale in Libya, and the prime suspects the PFLP-GC were based in Libya at this time anyway.
 
I agree that the percentage ordered by Libya does not equate to 'exclusively' Libyan, but it is enough to allow the court to make the inference that there was a high probability, especially when taken in conjuction with the MST timer, that this conclusive identification of it being the RT-SF16 model points yet another finger towards Megrahi.

I think any of the focus on the PLFP was primarily around the cell based in Frankfurt (with passing references made to Syria, Beruit and the activities of Talb in Sweden and Denmark) and this was obscured or waved away given the quite obviously multi-asset status of Khreesat, his release from German custody, and who may be complicit in the destruction of 103 if any indication it was actually his device that was used.

Yes, the PFLP were using Toshiba's as uncovered in Frankfurt, but a different kind from what was 'discovered' by Feraday, and despite their activities in Libya, it was thus Megrahi the Libyan, from the country whom he worked as a devious agent for, had made a mass order on the Bombeat RT16's, therefore he was quite clearly the culprit.
 
I wonder how positively the small scraps of paper could be identified with their supposed locations in the intact manual?

I've been trying to figure out how this might have transpired. My first thought was, was there ever any evidence of a manual in the recovered debris? It's always possible all the scraps were planted retrospectively. But on the other hand, I'm not sure introducing a paper manual de novo is all that likely a move on the part of any conspirator. If you want to make the radio the right model, more likely you "find" another, more unique part.

On the other hand, if you already have some scraps that are too small to make sense of, the idea of "finding" a bigger part of the manual might be something that occurs to you more easily. Particularly if you've already got Mrs. Horton's page, which turned out to be a red herring unfortunately, but wouldn't it have been awfully handy if it had been the thing we were looking for.... Then once you've got that, it's not too hard to find plausible places the tiny scraps might fit in?

I would suspect these guys were investigating Toshiba radios, trying to figure out what the thing was, and in the course of these investigations discovered this particular model, which was one of the list of possibles from the original scrap of circuit board, had this particular connection to Libya. And it sort of went from there.

Does anyone want to defend the possibility that the pages exhibited in court as the Horton find could possibly have been inside the bomb suitcase and survived?

Rolfe.
 
I suppose this is the best spot we have to discuss explosives amounts.

I've seen little specificity about this in official reports and such. On the Internet, the amount 312 grams Semtex H is most widely cited, but with no origin I can see except "Trail of the Octopus," citing the bomb seized from Khreesat and Dalkamouni.

I've seen 350 and 400 pop up, and especially 450. I think Buncrana posted this somewhere else about a Dr. Peel:
The witness told the specially-convened Scottish court sitting at Camp Zeist in The Netherlands that he had used an analytical model, devised by himself, in addition to Government software to calculate the ''stand-off'' distance and weight of the device. A 450-gramme bomb was responsible for the blast which resulted in the New York-bound Boeing 747 plummeting from the skies above Lockerbie..... The stand-off distance was 24 inches from the skin of the fuselage, he concluded. His calculations were backed up by a number of tests, including experiments with computer modelling. ...

There were also forensics tests that are said to confirm "RARDE's initial assessment that the bomb had contained about 400 grammes of Semtex high explosive - less than a 2lb. bag of sugar." This is from Leppard's "Trail of Terror," 1991, which is a weird book I now own. :) That's the Indian Head tests by Ferraday and Thurman (Harry Bell was there too). Interestingly, Leppard cites the actual findings as
...the explosive charge used to bring down the plane was 'in all probability' about 454 to 680 grammes or 1 to 1 1/2 pounds of Semtex.
That's really the most specific number I've seen yet. Is it just Thurman, explosions and adrenaline, Anglo-American comraderie and booze pumping their numbers up? Or is this good science? Can that much even fit inside a RT-SF16? It seems so - the third test carried out by an FAA guy present, used 680 grams it says, and the IEDs were all built by Ferraday in the identically-built RT-8016. [p 135-147]

Anyway, why are the majority of sources so vague about the suspected amount? Was there an uncomfortably wide zone between 'strong enough to pierce the fuselage' and 'weak enough to allow timer chunks and whole pages of a paper manual to survive'?
 
Bump. Gave PK/689 a slot in my new 12-card set.
Card_10_PK689.jpg
 
:)

I'd forgotten all about this thread! It's the dodgiest thing allegedly surfacing in this case, that's for sure.

Rolfe.
 
Just so we have it clear, here is the forensic explosives Lab photograph showing a control sample of the Toshiba instruction manual and the blast damaged fragment of an instruction manual for a RT-SF16 stereo radio cassette recorder.

This blast damaged fragment is supposedly the piece the Horton's 'found' in their garden the day after 103 came down. However, at the Zeist trial Mrs Horton disputed this badly damaged portion that was presented to her, claiming the page she found was 'almost intact'.

[URL=http://img541.imageshack.us/i/toshibamanaulcomv000179.jpg/][/URL]
 
Yay! Buncrana's back!

Rolfe.

Oh I've been dipping in and out reading the threads occasionally Rolfe, just that recently I had some major computer problems and what with work during the day and Uni at night, I've been struggling to offer anything worthwhile that would further our discussions.

Still, yourself and CL have continued being busy little bees on the subject..:)
 
Just so we have it clear, here is the forensic explosives Lab photograph showing a control sample of the Toshiba instruction manual and the blast damaged fragment of an instruction manual for a RT-SF16 stereo radio cassette recorder.

This blast damaged fragment is supposedly the piece the Horton's 'found' in their garden the day after 103 came down. However, at the Zeist trial Mrs Horton disputed this badly damaged portion that was presented to her, claiming the page she found was 'almost intact'.

[URL="http://img541.imageshack.us/i/toshibamanaulcomv000179.jpg/"][URL]http://img541.imageshack.us/img541/5346/toshibamanaulcomv000179.th.jpg[/URL][/URL]


I'm always suspicious of memories like that, because it's so easy to be mistaken. Twelve years had passed. However, that fragment doesn't look much like "almost intact" to me, and it's not easy to see how you could have picked that up and managed to retain a memory that it was almost intact.

I'm trying to imagine how that could possibly have survived the blast. I think I recall someone suggesting that it might have been the tape transport of the radio that preserved it. The theory was that the manual was lying flat against the side of the radio, in the box (and apparently at a bit of an angle by the look of that positioning). The Semtex was on the other side of the tape transport from the manual, and when it exploded it propelled the tape transport out at the forward edge of the blast, together with anything that was behind it - including that part of the manual, and presumably the corresponding part of the box, and the suitcase, and I suppose the baggage container wall and even the skin of the plane? There is a lonely detached piece of baggage container wall supposed to have been found from the centre of the explosion-damaged part. Is that supposed to represent the same phenonemon, I wonder?

Overall, I have extreme difficulty believing in this as a likely scenario. It's paper, dammit, and even sandwiched between the tape transport and the suitcase/container wall, how could it have survived that blast? Also, the tape transport was never found. If it had survived the blast at all intact, as it would have done according to that scenario, it should have been picked up. It's heavy enough to have gone relatively straight down, and not been blown into and over the forests with the light paper and cloth.

However, am I being too doubting?

Rolfe.
 
The RT-SF16 had to have its bulky tape mechanism removed to fit the explosives, so that can't work out. In skimming testimony quite a bit I've seen no mention of spindles, motors, tape heads, etc. anywhere. Splinter of speaker magnet comes up one, but the hard and heavy mechanics, no.

I second a hurrah for Buncrana's brief return. You should make sure to make a cameo appearance once in a while, even if just to say "yeah, cool." Tat's an interesting image you have. Where the heck did you get it?

It again illustrates an odd point I still don't get. Note the top image, intact cover, is labeled PT/1. Now, PT is a prefix usually meaning evidence removed from another previously-logged piece of evidence. PT/35 from inside PI/911 for example. Within a category, the numbers are usually sequential relative to find time.

But here, the first number in that category goes to a control sample intact RT-Sf16 manual they acquired. And the second item in the category, PT/2, is a crumpled piece of the same manual, removed from the slalom shirt collar PI/911. At the same time PT/35 was discovered there.

How does that make sense?

There was a switch at some point to the PT/system - previously they'd used initials (like TSH/ for Dr Hayes). Must have switched over immediately after introducing the category as for radio manual control samples, then by PT/2 it means recovered evidence and just so happens to start with recovered manual?

Anyway, I'm also working up a piece about the actual radio debris, sewing together a few points I've made in this thread and some other observations, that paints a pretty compelling picture of Mr. Feraday overseeing the planting of AG/145 et al. I didn't mean to see this happening as well, but it seems pretty likely. Should be good, but I can use a critique to correct any delusions.
 
If only Megrahi's defence team had been alert to the significance of Mrs Horton's testimony of dispution of the manual fragment presented and it's very pertinent close relation to Hayes/Feraday's assertion that this trail of 'radio-bomb' led directly to Libya and thereby their client.

Could Mrs Horton's testimony and memory of the discovery have been corroborated by her husband? Did he remember, as his wife did, that the page of manual they recovered was "almost intact"?

I'm no lawyer, but when such critical evidence is presented to the court and is now unrecognisable to the witness, could it be argued that it is inadmissible or should not carry as much weight in the judges conclusions?

Take the page, albeit severely damaged, and it's clear pointer to a particular model of radio out of the equation and evidence 'found', then all we have is the timer fragment. The timer that was sold by a Swiss company that was headed by someone clearly not credible and indeed it was becoming incresingly evident that these timers may well have ended up in many different hands and not 'exclusively' Libya.

Take that page out of the aggregate evidence gathered by Feraday and Hayes, and we have no distinct model of radio, further confounding Feraday's confusing and contradictory initial conclusions on the model and colour of radio used to house the bomb.

I'm absolutely dumfounded at the lack of even a cursory cross questioning by Megrahi's team of Mrs Horton about her recollection about the exact state of the page when found in her garden, and it's likelyhood of survival in such a state after being in such close proximity to an explosion which resulted in such obvious and stark damage to items composed of more durability.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, I look forward to this.

My problem is that the Toshiba circuit board fragment was apparently found by a policeman very early in the search. I could well imagine Tom Thurman being in a position to plant such a thing, but I completely baulk at him wanting to do that as early as January 1989. Unless you're suggesting a later substitution? When was that photo taken anyway?

Also, if you want to direct attention away from the PFLP-GC, why would you choose to introduce evidence of the presence of a Toshiba BomBeat radio-cassette player at all? Even if it wasn't the exact same model as Khreesat was playing with.

Numerological games with these evidential identifiers seldom end well in my experience.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom