The piece of evidence that apparently all on its own caused Feraday to change his mind radically about what model of radio had been used in the IED, to one which could be traced to Libya and which appeared to implicate Libya almost as strongly as the MST-13. We're led to believe that this model of radio wasn't something anyone living in, say, Frankfurt or Stockholm or London, could just pop into Curry's and buy. We're led to believe it was such a specifically Libyan model that is pointed inexorably to that country.
<snip>
I don't think the item produced in court was what Gwen Horton found. She herself was very doubtful about it, and I suspect the policeman is just agreeing with what he's been told to agree with, having no clear memory of the item from 11 years ago. So I really, really don't believe that what Gwen Horton picked up was a manual for the Libya-exclusive model, and thus I don't see any real reason to believe it was singed.
I agree with you that she appears to have found a piece of paper with the word Toshiba on it, probably the whole word. Quite possibly part of a manual for a radio or similar item, that was part of an innocent passenger's luggage. Something commonly available in Curry's or Dixon's. I don't see any need for it to have been singed. Mrs. Horton doesn't say she remembers it as being singed. Mr. Walton is, in my opinion, merely describing what he is being shown, rather than clearly remembering the appearance of one of the many pieces of random litter he bagged 11 years previously.
Then, when it appeared politic to make it look as if this atrocity was carried out by someone other than Iran, and IDing the radio as that very identifiable Libyan model seemed like a good way to do it, switching that piece of paper was a very easy way to introduce that evidence. It totally eliminates the need to manufacture provenance, and introduces a witness attesting to its early discovery who is quite clearly not conspiring in anything.
Rolfe.
That's pretty much my thinking on this unscathed page found by Mrs Horton.
The item shown to Mrs Horton at Zeist contained
just enough wording to be recognised by Mrs Horton as a 'Toshiba', just as she had discovered, but also
just enough wording that it could be determined that this particular model was of that predominantly used by Libya. This corroboration from a member of the public as a witness to something that she discovered, despite her somewhat perplexed view of what she was shown, proved a legitimate indicator of Libya's and Megrahi's guilt, while it also simply reinforced Feraday's 'fragment' of timer discovery, and it's connection to Libya and Megrahi.
I have no qualms in accepting the fact that Mrs Horton may well have discovered debris in her garden on 22 December, including a page of a Toshiba manual. The possibility that some passenger(s) on 103 may well have had one of their own contained in their luggage, or indeed as an intended Christmas present, which then broke free during the disintergration of the aircraft, allowing a portion of manual to scatter in the wind, landing in Mrs Horton's garden along with Christmas cards and other debris, I can accept as capable of happening.
However, personally I don't think that the manual discovered by Mrs Horton was in close proximity to the bomb, (if a fragment surviving the explosion is "unbelievable", then a sheet of paper surviving is completely preposterous) and I don't believe the portion presented to her at Zeist was infact the the page she found outside her home. What I believe she was shown at Zeist was a manipulated sheet from a manual which would point away from a completely innocent model of Toshiba carried by a paasenger on 103 (and, as a bonus, points away from Khreesat too!), and more pertinently, would point once again towards Libya and thus Megrahi.
Aside from Feraday's initial assertion that it was a white Toshiba, given the pieces found in the frame of container AVE4041, Feraday himself had stated that the compacted pieces of the manual he had extracted from the Slalom shirt collar, together with the tiny bits of black plastic that he had identified (PI995), he
could not determine the exact model of Toshiba recorder. However, the portion shown to Mrs Horton (who's memory 11 years after her discovery could be faded) conveniently revealed just enough information for Feraday, and the Zeist judges, to conclude it was a model, RT-SF16, which led inescapably towards Libya.
She herself remarked "well, not in it's present state" when asked to identify the evidence presented to her at Zeist, but allowing for the apparent testing done on the page resulting in it's damaged state (and that of being near an 'explosion'), the judges simply accepted that Mrs Horton's find emanated from the explosive device itself was therefore plausible.