Q: You've just read to us from the introduction the view that this piece of paper fragment was received on the 30th of June of 1989?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: Is that the correct date?
A: It is not, I'm afraid. It's a mistake that I made when I wrote the reports. And I think the correct date is the 11th of May 1989. And the error
arises on my part because sometimes items would come and go to the laboratory several times. They would be booked in and out several times.
Q: I wonder if we can just look at that and see, perhaps, an example that will explain what you are meaning. Would you look for me at Production No. 1497; we'll see it on the screen. Page 61. Thank you.
And do you see there a piece of paper which you would recognise as an examination note prepared by
[3031]
your colleague Dr. Hayes?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And do we see that it deals with the piece of paper that we've just been speaking about?
A: That's correct, yes, sir. It deals with PK/689.
Ambrosia said:
[PK/689 is a photo of a piece of the front page of the RT-SF16 manual, you can see this in the photo CL linked in an above post]
Q: Yes. And the examination bears the date 16th May 1989?
A: That's correct, sir, yes.
Ambrosia said:
16th May 1989 is the day after Hayes claimed examination of the grey shirt containing MST-13 fragment(PI/995), this is from page 57 of Hayes report, which is the first page in the report after the renumbered, "inserted" section dealing with PI/995. This evidence is being given late on Day 18, 2 days after Hayes testimony, which is presumably still fresh in the minds of the judges at this time
Q: Now, I am interested in looking at the information above the printed word "Examination." Do we see that the first information is "Received at RARDE (Superintendent Henderson)"?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And then there's a date given?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: Is it the 11th of May 1989?
A: That's correct, sir, yes.
Q: Then underneath that, it says: "Passed to DC Jordan on same date for non-destructive" -- is that "fingerprints"?
A: "Fingerprints," I think that says.
Q: Do you know who DC Jordan is?
A: There were, in fact, DC Jordan both in the metropolitan police, who I suspect that's who that
[3032]
is. And there happens to also, I think, to be one in the Lockerbie team. But I suspect that this one is the one from Scotland Yard, because Scotland Yard were tasked to do the fingerprints for the Lockerbie inquiry.
Q: I see. And was it common to give items to other agencies for inquiries to be carried out?
A: Was it common, did you say?
Q: Yes.
A: Not common, no. It happened in a number of occasions. But I wouldn't say it was common, as such. It didn't certainly happen to all of them.
Q: And when it did happen, were records kept?
A: That's correct, yes, sir.
Q: I see. In order for this item to be examined for the presence of fingerprints by DC Jordan, where would it go?
A: It would go to the fingerprint laboratory in Lambeth in London.
Q: And that's therefore out of the control of RARDE, is it?
A: That's correct, sir.
Q: And do we see that the following line says: "Returned to RARDE on 16/5/89"?
[3033]
A: That's correct, yes, sir.
Q: And that's the same date as at the top of Dr. Hayes' examination note?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And then there is another piece of information on the next line, still above the printed word "examination." Can you read what that says?
A: Yes, sir, I think I can.
Q: What does it say?
A: I think it says: "Passed to DC Jordan on 16/5/89 for chemical treatment after photography."
Ambrosia said:
There are corroborating records owing to this testing being referred to here that establish that PK/689 exists as part of the evidence 16th May 1989
Q: I see. And what sort of chemical treatment would that be a reference to?
A: I suspect that, presumably, their initial fingerprint examination could not be done properly without some kind of more invasive chemical fingerprint treatment. I suspect that's probably what it was.
Q: And in order for an examination of the sort described there to occur, where would the fragment go?
A: That would again go to the Lambeth laboratory.
Q: I see.
A: The Lambeth fingerprint laboratory.
[3034]
Q: And for each of these passings of the production from RARDE to DC Jordan and back again, would a record be kept?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And do you know whether or not the fragment PK/689 was passed to DC Jordan or anyone else for any other examination after the one that we've just looked at?
A: Without consulting the records, I don't know. I know that we -- it came and went several times. But I would have to consult the records, I'm afraid.
Q: I see. And how then -- now that we've seen that the item could move in and out of RARDE on a number of occasions for a number of reasons, and that there would be a record kept of the date, both of its arrival and its departure, how can you help us to understand why the date 30th June is given on page 107?
A: Well, I'm afraid that when I logged the whole list of comings and goings of items down when I wrote this report, I must have put my ruler across on
the wrong line for this. I didn't, obviously, go back to the beginning of when we first received it. I must have inadvertently picked a date when it did certainly come back after some treatment of some description on
[3035]
the 30th of June '89. But the truth is that we had received it before that. That wasn't the first time we received it.