Identification of the Toshiba radio from PA103

But then we have several statements that the five small pieces were all from a single page. Except that seems close to impossible to me.

Can you locate the actual quotes? I'm going to bed. I have a tennis match to watch at 8 o'clock in the morning!

Certainly, I've got a little more of a run at it now.
day 20 3099-
"The five fragments are all of approximately the same size, 20 millimetres by 15 millimetres, and outline shape as if generated by a single high speed fragment passing through a paper booklet. Four of the sheets bear printed black lettering on both surfaces whilst the fifth sheet is devoid of any printing on either surface."
"The two sides of all five fragments are shown in photographs 274 and 275. The sequence of the order of the layering of these sheets was in the order of (1) to (5) as depicted in these two photographs. A detailed comparison of the printed characters on sides A and B of the four printed sheets demonstrates a perfect sequential match with the back-to-back areas of pages 3 to 10 (inclusive) of the control sample of the Toshiba RT-SF16 owner's manual (item PT/1)."

Six sheets total for the booklet (three folded and stapled) and twelve sides so this sound like every page but the front or back cover. Other cover present as blank sheet? Seems unsure which.

And you get one guess what that fragment was that tore em out! Do Libyan manual bits surviving get more plausible if they're rushed off by bits of Libyan timer that survived? Can they include anything in this mix that's not Libyan?
 
Six sheets total for the booklet (three folded and stapled) and twelve sides so this sound like every page but the front or back cover. Other cover present as blank sheet? Seems unsure which.

And you get one guess what that fragment was that tore em out! Do Libyan manual bits surviving get more plausible if they're rushed off by bits of Libyan timer that survived? Can they include anything in this mix that's not Libyan?


This makes better sense than some of the other versions I've read.

Actually, a lot of these manuals are many-folded blocks of paper made from a single large sheet with instructions in several languages. But it sounds as if this one wasn't like that, and six pages (probably three pages folded and stapled) is probably what they're describing.

So, the front cover flies free and more or less unpunctured, to be picked up in Northumberland, while the remaining five sheets are subjected to multiple punched-out holes caused by small hard objects being propelled against the manual. (I think it's the back cover that's blank.)

Does this sound likely to you?

It's only possible if the manual has been packed with the front cover open, which isn't all that likely to start with. And even if that had been the case, the chances of that sheet of paper surviving make the proverbial snowball in hell look like a good bet.

However, I don't think it was the timer fragment that was supposed to have preserved the bit in the shirt collar - I seem to remember they were in separate holes in the cloth - according to Hayes, that is.

Actually, I'm still wondering what the intact comparison manuals looked like for this radio - there's supposed to be a photo somewhere but I don't understand the court numbering reference system used in a lot of the posts. All the references to "same page" make me wonder if it might indeed have been one of these many-folded one-sheet things. Which would make the detaching of the front cover even more implausible.

Rolfe.
 
extracts of Feradays testimony Day 18 about the identification of the Toshiba radio:

Allen Feraday Trial evidence said:
(reformatted, numers in [brackets] are the original page numbers from where this transcript was copied, all emphasis is mine)

[Feraday is reading from production 181, this is the report by RARDE prepared by Feraday from his own notes and those of Hayes (who by the time this report was written had left RARDE), which both men signed off on.]


A "Consequently a visit was made to the Toshiba UK headquarters at Camberley, Surrey on the 2nd of February 1989 in an attempt to identify the Lockerbie fragments. Full cooperation was received from the Toshiba Company in supplying the service data sheets for all of their present and past portable radios and cassette players. After a search of over 130 different data sheets, the particular small diamond-shaped tracking pattern noted upon one of the

[3024]

Lockerbie circuit board fragments was tentatively identified as originating from a Toshiba brand portable radio/cassette player, model number RT-8016. A detailed examination of an unserviceable RT-8016 radio provided by the Toshiba Company that same day, the 2nd of February 1989, confirmed this similarity.
"Subsequently a visit was made to the headquarters of the Toshiba company in Japan, between 23rd of April 1989 and the 1st of May 1989, where it was learned that similar circuit boards to that noted in the model RT-8016 were in fact installed into seven different models of portable radio/cassette players manufactured by the Toshiba Company or assembled by their subsidiaries or agents. These seven models were all of a similar external appearance with only some minor cosmetic, voltage, and/or wavelength differences. These seven models were identified as follows:

"A, RT-8016, manufactured in Japan.
"B, RT-8026, manufactured in Japan.
"C, RT-SF16 BomBeat manufactured in Japan.
"D, RT-SF26, manufactured in Japan.
"E, RT-SF12(R), "Sugar," manufactured in Japan.
"F, ARS-8016 "Daewoo" assembled in South

[3025]

Korea.
"G, RT-SF16 Videocon Hi-Beat assembled in India.

"Subsequently, control samples of each of these different models were obtained, with the exception of the models RT-8026 and RT-SF26, which were stated to be out of production and unobtainable. Both of these two absent models were different from the
other five models in that they possessed a graphics equaliser panel mounted upon the front of the set and employed an additional graphics equaliser circuit board internally. The master negatives of this separate graphics equaliser circuit board panel were subsequently obtained from the Toshiba headquarters in Japan."

Q: Can we stop there just for a second, again, Mr. Feraday. Do we understand from what you've read to us that your first view on the matter was that the fragment AG/145 might have come from a printed circuit board such as would be found in a Toshiba radio/cassette player, model number RT-8016?

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Q: You made further inquiries and learned that similar circuit boards were included in a number of models, which included the RT-8016?

[3026]

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Q: Now, as far as you understood matters at that stage, was the circuit board used in the models you've read to us also used in the model such as you saw in West Germany?

A: It was not so, no.

Q: I see. Would you look for me at Label 330, please. And can you tell me what you have in front of you now, Mr. Feraday?

A: It is the box and a cassette radio, model RT-F453D, made by Toshiba.

Q: Now, that model, RT-453D, is that the same type as you saw in West Germany?

A: It is, sir, yes.

Q: And therefore the same as we saw in the photographs a moment ago?

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Q: Does it also have a name within its title?

A: Yes, it has the name "BomBeat" in its title.

Q: I see. And do we see that both on the box and on the player itself?

A: We do indeed. It's under the top

[3027]

left-hand side, where it says "Toshiba" on the radio, and it's also on the front of the box.

Q: How is that spelt, please, Mr. Feraday?

A: It's B-O-M-B-E-A-T.

Q: I see. And you would see that on the radio/cassette player that you had the opportunity of examining in West Germany?

A: That's correct, yes, sir.

Q: And from what you've just told us, in reading your report, one of the models which contained a similar printed circuit board to the model RT-8016 also contained the word "BomBeat" in its title?

A: That's correct, sir, yes, the one that I've marked "C," RT-SF16.

Q: But should we be clear in understanding that the RT-SF16 BomBeat has a different printed circuit board in it from the RT-F453?

A: That's correct. It has the circuit board in the -- RT-SF16 BomBeat, the one that I saw in Japan, it has a circuit board that is similar to the Lockerbie fragment.

Q: Yes.

A: It also has two speakers, not one speaker.

Q: So there is a visual difference as well?

[3028]

A: It physically looks similar to the 8016.

Q: So visually, there are differences between the two which share the common name "BomBeat"?

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Last week of April 1989, 5 months prior to the MST-13 fragment surfacing, a visit to Toshiba in Japan narrows down the radio type used to a maximum of 7 possibles.

Invstigators looked at Khreesats bomb with the icecube timer recovered by the initial Autumn Leaves raid, they note it's radio was called "BomBeat".

One radio the RT-SF16 was also called "BomBeat" although a different style.

Feraday evidence said:
Q: Can we move on to page 107 of your report, where you left off.

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And you are beginning there, I think, to give us an explanation about some explosively damaged paper fragments. And again this is still by way of
introduction.

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Could you read that passage to us.

A: Yes, sir.
"On the 30th of June 1989, some explosively damaged paper fragments, which bore indications that they originated from the "owner's instruction manual" for a "Toshiba RT-SF16" radio/cassette player, were received at this laboratory, thus conclusively establishing which of the seven models of the Toshiba radio had been employed in the Lockerbie bomb.
Consequently the Toshiba model RT-SF16 radio/cassette

[3029]

player has been used as the control sample for comparison purposes with the recovered Lockerbie fragments as detailed below. It has been noted that
each control sample of Toshiba radio was packed inside a cardboard transit box complete with a black plastics electrical mains lead. Although many fragments of both charred cardboard and burnt soft plastics have been recovered from the Lockerbie debris, none of these fragments can be conclusively established to have originated from a Toshiba radio or its packing."

30th June the manual fragments point to the "BomBeat" model. Only this is a mistake.

Feraday evidence said:
Q: You've just read to us from the introduction the view that this piece of paper fragment was received on the 30th of June of 1989?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Is that the correct date?

A: It is not, I'm afraid. It's a mistake that I made when I wrote the reports. And I think the correct date is the 11th of May 1989. And the error
arises on my part because sometimes items would come and go to the laboratory several times. They would be booked in and out several times.

Q: I wonder if we can just look at that and see, perhaps, an example that will explain what you are meaning. Would you look for me at Production No. 1497; we'll see it on the screen. Page 61. Thank you.
And do you see there a piece of paper which you would recognise as an examination note prepared by

[3031]

your colleague Dr. Hayes?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And do we see that it deals with the piece of paper that we've just been speaking about?

A: That's correct, yes, sir. It deals with PK/689.

Ambrosia said:
[PK/689 is a photo of a piece of the front page of the RT-SF16 manual, you can see this in the photo CL linked in an above post]

Q: Yes. And the examination bears the date 16th May 1989?

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Ambrosia said:
16th May 1989 is the day after Hayes claimed examination of the grey shirt containing MST-13 fragment(PI/995), this is from page 57 of Hayes report, which is the first page in the report after the renumbered, "inserted" section dealing with PI/995. This evidence is being given late on Day 18, 2 days after Hayes testimony, which is presumably still fresh in the minds of the judges at this time

Q: Now, I am interested in looking at the information above the printed word "Examination." Do we see that the first information is "Received at RARDE (Superintendent Henderson)"?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And then there's a date given?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Is it the 11th of May 1989?

A: That's correct, sir, yes.

Q: Then underneath that, it says: "Passed to DC Jordan on same date for non-destructive" -- is that "fingerprints"?

A: "Fingerprints," I think that says.

Q: Do you know who DC Jordan is?

A: There were, in fact, DC Jordan both in the metropolitan police, who I suspect that's who that

[3032]

is. And there happens to also, I think, to be one in the Lockerbie team. But I suspect that this one is the one from Scotland Yard, because Scotland Yard were tasked to do the fingerprints for the Lockerbie inquiry.

Q: I see. And was it common to give items to other agencies for inquiries to be carried out?

A: Was it common, did you say?

Q: Yes.

A: Not common, no. It happened in a number of occasions. But I wouldn't say it was common, as such. It didn't certainly happen to all of them.

Q: And when it did happen, were records kept?

A: That's correct, yes, sir.

Q: I see. In order for this item to be examined for the presence of fingerprints by DC Jordan, where would it go?

A: It would go to the fingerprint laboratory in Lambeth in London.

Q: And that's therefore out of the control of RARDE, is it?

A: That's correct, sir.

Q: And do we see that the following line says: "Returned to RARDE on 16/5/89"?

[3033]

A: That's correct, yes, sir.

Q: And that's the same date as at the top of Dr. Hayes' examination note?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And then there is another piece of information on the next line, still above the printed word "examination." Can you read what that says?

A: Yes, sir, I think I can.

Q: What does it say?

A: I think it says: "Passed to DC Jordan on 16/5/89 for chemical treatment after photography."

Ambrosia said:
There are corroborating records owing to this testing being referred to here that establish that PK/689 exists as part of the evidence 16th May 1989

Q: I see. And what sort of chemical treatment would that be a reference to?

A: I suspect that, presumably, their initial fingerprint examination could not be done properly without some kind of more invasive chemical fingerprint treatment. I suspect that's probably what it was.

Q: And in order for an examination of the sort described there to occur, where would the fragment go?

A: That would again go to the Lambeth laboratory.

Q: I see.

A: The Lambeth fingerprint laboratory.

[3034]

Q: And for each of these passings of the production from RARDE to DC Jordan and back again, would a record be kept?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And do you know whether or not the fragment PK/689 was passed to DC Jordan or anyone else for any other examination after the one that we've just looked at?

A: Without consulting the records, I don't know. I know that we -- it came and went several times. But I would have to consult the records, I'm afraid.

Q: I see. And how then -- now that we've seen that the item could move in and out of RARDE on a number of occasions for a number of reasons, and that there would be a record kept of the date, both of its arrival and its departure, how can you help us to understand why the date 30th June is given on page 107?

A: Well, I'm afraid that when I logged the whole list of comings and goings of items down when I wrote this report, I must have put my ruler across on
the wrong line for this. I didn't, obviously, go back to the beginning of when we first received it. I must have inadvertently picked a date when it did certainly come back after some treatment of some description on

[3035]

the 30th of June '89. But the truth is that we had received it before that. That wasn't the first time we received it.
 
couple of things that jump out at me here:

i) People are creatures of habit. If we accept that the RTF-16 radio was the correct model, like the Khreesat bomb, it was named "BomBeat" Is it more likely that the same terrorist group will use a similar MO when they carry out attacks, and so the name "BomBeat" in the radios description points to the same perpetrators? Or is it more likely that the name is yet another coincidence, perhaps pointing to nothing more than the fact that terrorists share a twisted sense of wordplay.

ii) The *crucial* piece of manual PK/689 just happens to be examined on the day after the most crucial piece of evidence in the entire case is also examined by the same examiner?!

15th May, apparently, Hayes discovers the MST-13 fragment - the next day he examines PK/689, thats a hell of a 2 days, yet another coincidence? They're stacking up.

Finally of PK/689 on the 16th Hayes notes state that it was photographed. If this item was photographed, then PI/995 ought to have been as well, where are those photos?
 
Feraday Trail evidence Day 20 said:
Ambrosia said:
No evidence was given day 19, as difficulties in translation were being resolved

A "Many fragments originating from the owner's manual of a Toshiba RT-SF16 radio/cassette recorder have been recovered. These fragments, which are detailed below, are damaged consistent with their close involvement in a powerful explosion. They have been identified by a detailed comparison with the control sample of the owner's manual PT/1 (PR/111) which was removed from the box containing the sample
Toshiba RT-SF16 radio/cassette recorder (PR/105). The

[3094]

original positions of the fragments upon each page clearly indicate that the manual was not folded at the moment of explosion, apart from at its original stapled centre fold."

Q: And do you then begin to describe for us an item designated as PK/689?

A: That is correct, sir. Yes.

Q: Can we look at photograph 266, please. And could you perhaps read on, Mr. Feraday.

A: "When originally received at this laboratory, this item was apparently an irregularly
shaped single fragment of paper, shown in photograph 266, which measured approximately 135 millimetres by 125 millimetres. Detailed examination revealed the
fragment to consist of two overlaid sheets lightly adhering together, having the same irregular shape. On the upper surface of the two sheets, shown in photograph 267, were depicted (a) the legend" ... Hiba ... O cassette recorder ... SF16 ... BomBeat SF16"; and (b) apparent sets of operating instructions printed in several languages."

Q: Can we pause there for a moment, Mr. Feraday. Did your conclusion regarding the manual, that it was not folded, apart from its original stapled centre fold, cause you to come to any assessment


[3095]

regarding the manual?

A: Only, as I say, the manual, in my opinion, was not folded and that it appeared that a fragment had been blown out of -- during the explosion and had cut its way completely through the manual.

Q: What way would the manual have been folded if new?

A: It would have just been folded down the middle where the staple is, but not otherwise folded.

Q: Does that mean it would, if new, have been folded in the same way as you deduced this manual to have been folded?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Did the writing on this fragment assist you in identifying which model the fragments of printed circuit board had come from?

A: Yes, sir. It very much did.

Q: What view did you arrive at?

A: I came to the view that as the fragments and the paper fragments -- the fragments of circuit board and the paper fragments were both explosively damaged, that in all probability the fragments of circuit board originated from a BomBeat SF16.

Q: Thank you. Did you then go on to carry out a comparison of the information printed on both

[3096]

sides of the two sheets that we see in this photograph?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Do we see the results in photographs 269 to 272?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Could we see photographs 269 and 270, please. Do we see photograph 269 to the left, Mr. Feraday?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And do we see there that you have compared the fragment with the control sample owner's manual?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And where did that portion of the fragment correspond to?

A: It corresponded more or less to the centre of page 1 of the manual.

Q: Is that the outer cover?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: Thank you. And on page 2 -- photograph 270, do we see the other side of that
fragment?

A: That is correct, sir. That's the same fragment, just literally turned over.

[3097]

Q: And where did it correspond to on the control sample?

A: From the -- again, more or less the centre position of page 2, which is the rear of the front cover.

Q: Thank you. And have you drawn in red on the control sample the area which corresponds to the fragment?

A: As best as I could, sir, yes.

Q: Could we now see photographs 271 and 272. Is the fragment shown in these photographs the second of the two overlaid sheets?

A: Yes, sir.

Q: And do we see that the fragment corresponded with a portion of page 4 of the control sample?

A: One side of it -- of the fragment compared with page 3; and the other side of it, the
rear side of it, compared with page 4.

Q: Yes. And these are the pages following on from those that we looked at in the preceding photographs?

A: That is correct, sir. Yes.

Q: Could you return to your report and read

[3098]

to us what you described after drawing our attention to these photographs.

A: From, "on the lower surfaces"; is that it, sir? Page 112?

Q: Yes. From where you referred to the photographs 269 to 272, please.

A: Okay.

"A detailed comparison of the information printed on both sides of the two sheets, shown in the four photographs, 269 to 272, showed a perfect match in sequence and information detail with the corresponding areas of pages 1 to 4 of the Toshiba SF16 owner's manual (PT/1). These sheets appeared to have been violently impacted and disrupted and bore localised areas of blackening and scorching consistent with their
close explosives involvement."

So the Horton fragment (PK/689) is a large piece of the centre of the manual 135mm by 125mm, it's received by RARDE 11th May 1989, a piece Horton describes as about 8" by 8" (200mm square), it's photo'd 16th May before destructive testing. Horton ID's "Label 24" as what she found, but much more damaged than the condition she found it in. PK/689 is described in Ferdays reports as being a fragment punched out of the centre of the page. Feradays report describes a complete control manual as being:

Feraday Trial evidence said:
The manual consists of a white paper booklet measuring 26 centimetres by 19 centimetres and incorporating three complete sheets of paper which are folded and stapled together in the centre to produce a booklet of twelve sides of paper.

Horton describes finding almost an intact page, 8" by 8"(20.3cm x 20.3cm) her dimensions match the size of an intact page.

If Mrs Horton is right and she found a whole page of manual which was actually the first 2 pages,(1,2,3 & 4) then the fragments from PI/995 which are

Feraday Evidence said:
a perfect sequential match with the back-to-back areas of pages 3 to 10 (inclusive) of the control sample of the Toshiba RT-SF16 owner's manual (item PT/1)."

can't possibly be from the same manual.
 
A couple of quick points.

The Slalom shirt collar was examined on 12th May, not 15th (you may be mixing this up with 15th September, the date of the Feraday/Williamson memo). 12th May was a Friday, so the manual examination you refer to above was done the following Tuesday. Still a helluva few days. I'm still not convinced anything actually happened on these days though.

Khreesat's electronics stash. I don't put too much emphasis on this "BomBeat" thing. Khreesat was using a variety of electronics items for his bomb-making. There were a hi-fi tuner and a couple of VDUs as well as the radio-cassete player that was recovered. (Sorry, I don't know where to find the list of stuff right now, but it is available.) He didn't have a production run of identical IEDs.

I believe Abu Talb, at Camp Zeist, said he would never have used a stereo player because there wasn't enough room inside the casing to get enough explosive in. But do we actually believe a word Abu Talb says? And if the Lockerbie evidence is at all to be believed (which may be a bit of an "if"), then it self-evidently was possible to get enough explosive into a stereo player.

It seems to me that Khreesat was using an assortment of electronics products, so just about anything might have turned up in an incident. It's just this whole tenuous trail of a particular Toshiba model sold almost exclusively to Libya (to match the particular timer model sold exclusively to Libya) that is held to be so significant as far as the indictment goes.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
That extract from the evidence absolutely clarifies the structure of the manual - it really was a stapled booklet, not a folded wad. Stuff the centimetres, let's get this straight in inches.
  • Complete manual (control sample) 10½ x 7¾ inches. That's bigger than I had thought, not much smaller than an A4 page.
  • Mrs. Horton's estimate of what she found was about 8 x 8 inches, "almost intact, just a bit tatty round the edges".
  • That find, when examined at RARDE before any destructive testing, is recorded as 5½ x 5 inches.
Difficult to know how much to trust Mrs. Horton's memory - memory can play strange tricks, and it's noticeable she seems to be describing a find that was roughly square. Nevertheless, her description seems closer to an almost-intact page than to the large fragment blown out of the centre that Feraday describes. In particular, she says she remembers the word "Toshiba" on the find, but the word is partially obscured in the evidential fragment.

It's now clear that the piece of manual alleged to have been found by Mrs. Horton wasn't just one sheet but two, the first two of the six. Supposedly punched out of the middle of the manual by the explosion, presumably by something about 5 or 6 inches square being slammed into it. I'm guessing a chunk of the plastic casing of the radio, a circuit board from inside it, or maybe the tape transport if that was still in it. Presumably all 6 pages were punched out, but the other four became detached and were not recovered.

I totally don't buy it. That should have been incinerated.

Then we have the other much smaller fragments that were found in items of clothing. I find these a bit easier to swallow as regards actual survival. However, at least one of these finds was five sheets thick, thus implying that at least one of the two Horton pages was also represented in that compacted wad.

We can only account for that by assuming the area in question belonged to a part of the manual outwith the 5½ x 5 inch Horton fragment. So, one very big fragment, of which two leaves are recovered in a legible condition, and at least four much smaller fragments from elsewhere in the manual, compacted so that most of the leaves remained stuck together, heavily explosion-damaged.

All surviving and identifiable, having been right up close and personal with 450g of Semtex when it blew up.

Oh come on. Do they think the judges came up the Clyde on a banana boat? Apparently so. :nope:

Rolfe.
 
A couple of quick points.

The Slalom shirt collar was examined on 12th May, not 15th (you may be mixing this up with 15th September, the date of the Feraday/Williamson memo). 12th May was a Friday, so the manual examination you refer to above was done the following Tuesday.

I'm conflating dates on re-numbered pages actually. Yes my mistake.

12th May (Friday) Hayes examines PI/995, notes for this examination is pg 51.

15th May (Monday) pages 52-56 are about a different examination of evidence, these pages were previously numbered 51-55 and were renumbered for reasons never explained.

16th May (Tuesday) Hayes examines PK/689.

evidence number PI/991 is detailed on pg 49 of Hayes notes, dated 15th May 1989.

evidence number PT/30 was noted on page 90 of Hayes notes, 8th June 1989, and is both dated later than PT/35 and has a lower evidence number.
 
I totally don't buy it. That should have been incinerated.

Then we have the other much smaller fragments that were found in items of clothing. I find these a bit easier to swallow as regards actual survival. However, at least one of these finds was five sheets thick, thus implying that at least one of the two Horton pages was also represented in that compacted wad.

We can only account for that by assuming the area in question belonged to a part of the manual outwith the 5½ x 5 inch Horton fragment. So, one very big fragment, of which two leaves are recovered in a legible condition, and at least four much smaller fragments from elsewhere in the manual, compacted so that most of the leaves remained stuck together, heavily explosion-damaged.

I don't have a problem with bits of manual surviving an explosion. If you lookat pictures of impacts on 9/11 we see paper raining down into the streets. A passport survived enough to be identified later. Granted those were low pressure cooler deflagrations rather than explosions, but who knows what random things might well survive.

When Feraday goes through all this at the trial he has a series of photographs pointing out exactly where each fragment came from, one wonders if Mrs Hortons memory is accurate whether the prosecution needed to cut bits of PK/689 off in order to account for these other much smaller scraps of manual found in the babygro and the Yorkie trousers etc.

Another point I thought about was this. We know that the radio itself could not be identified were it not for the manual. The innards of the radio could have come from 7 possible sources. How much of the manual is the same for each of those 7 radios? Do Toshiba write a whole new manual for each one? Do they just print alternative covers and keep the body of the manual the same? Was it ever established that the manual as found could *only* have come from this particular model, if say we discount PK/689 as possibly coming from a n other radio in someone elses luggage?

Was enough of the manual recovered in the tiny fragments that are almost certainly in the IED case, blasted into bits of clothing to positively ID it as a RTF-16 and *only* an RTF-16 manual?
 
I don't have a problem with bits of manual surviving an explosion. If you lookat pictures of impacts on 9/11 we see paper raining down into the streets. A passport survived enough to be identified later. Granted those were low pressure cooler deflagrations rather than explosions, but who knows what random things might well survive.


I don't see "9/11" as being comparable. Of course bits of paper were raining down. A couple of planes crashed into a couple of office blocks full of filing cabinets and desks covered in clutter and so on. The planes themselves were intact until they hit the buildings, and the fires were started by the engiges and fuel tanks - the fuselages themselves (where the passport and other paper would have been) didn't necessarily explode as such.

I don't doubt Mrs. Horton's description of what she saw in the Northumberland countryside after Lockerbie either. That included Christmas cards raining down. The actual explosion only damaged a relatively small number of suitcases, a couple of baggage containers and the outer skin of the aircraft. Paper in suitcases that came apart as the plane came apart, and paper in the cabin, would have blown all over the place.

I'm not even discounting the possibility that the small, compacted fragments might have survived, blasted into cloth as described. But once you start telling me that a 5" x 5" piece of two pages survived from the close vicinity of that explosion, blowing free in the wind, I baulk. We don't know of any paper on 9/11 that was so close to an explosion and survived, still legible. Oh wait, there weren't any explosives involved on 9/11.

When Feraday goes through all this at the trial he has a series of photographs pointing out exactly where each fragment came from, one wonders if Mrs Hortons memory is accurate whether the prosecution needed to cut bits of PK/689 off in order to account for these other much smaller scraps of manual found in the babygro and the Yorkie trousers etc.


I haven't seen the photographs, but I'm sure they were plausible to a degree. I'm assuming the four smaller fragments were from parts of the manual elsewhere than the Horton fragment.

I don't believe that what Mrs. Horton found was ever within inches of 450g of Semtex when it exploded. So I don't think it's a question of cutting anything off what she found, I think it's a question of tailoring a fragment of that manual (I imagine the police could have had as many copies as they wanted from Toshiba) so that it contained enough information to identify the exact model of radio (you know, this one model fortuitously sold only to Libya), and yet allowed for the other scraps still to have come from the same item.

Mrs. Horton picked up quite a few bits and pieces and handed them in to the police in a carrier bag. Obviously these included some sort of piece of paper that could plausibly be represented as that large fragment, ten years on, to a lady who probably hadn't looked at it all that closely at the time and certainly hadn't kept a copy. I think it could be that simple.

Another point I thought about was this. We know that the radio itself could not be identified were it not for the manual. The innards of the radio could have come from 7 possible sources. How much of the manual is the same for each of those 7 radios? Do Toshiba write a whole new manual for each one? Do they just print alternative covers and keep the body of the manual the same? Was it ever established that the manual as found could *only* have come from this particular model, if say we discount PK/689 as possibly coming from a n other radio in someone elses luggage?

Was enough of the manual recovered in the tiny fragments that are almost certainly in the IED case, blasted into bits of clothing to positively ID it as a RTF-16 and *only* an RTF-16 manual?


I had exactly the same thoughts, but I'm now wondering whether it actually matters. If the large Horton fragment was fabricated, then why bother sticking to the real fragments for the rest of the finds? Assuming there were any scraps of manual recovered from cloth actually picked up in Scotland in the first place. We're already very suspicious that PI995 is a plant, and that seems to contain the biggest of the scraps as well as the timer fragment. I don't know whether we have enough on the other scraps to assess whether they might also have been slipped in retrospectively late in 1989, but if they were that small, I wouldn't be surprised.

I very much doubt that these tiny scraps could identify the manual as coming from one particular model. As you say, these things tend to be a bit repetitve. Their presence within the Maltese clothing does however associate the manual definitely with the bomb suitcase, rather than having it originate from elsewhere in the plane. But we can hardly get a 5x5 chunk saying "... hiba ... o cassette recorder ... SF16 ... BomBeat SF16" into a shirt collar. So we really need that bigger piece to turn up separately - not so clearly associated with the explosion as it stands, but able to be tied in with the rest once you have the template of the sample manual.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
It occurs to me that the model of radio, in just the same way as the MST-13, doesn't in any way rule out Khreesat even if all this singularly implausible evidence is entirely genuine. We know Khreesat used a variety of electronics items for his bombs. We only have Abu Talb's word for it that the group never used a stereo radio-cassette recorder, and in the immortal words of Mandy Rice-Davis, "he would say that, wouldn't he?"

The thing the investigators loved about this radio, just as they loved the same thing about the MST-13, was that it was supplied to Libya. Well, the PFLP-GC people were Arab. They travelled around in the Middle East. One of the Lockerbie commentators places Jibril in Libya itself at the relevant time. No great reason they couldn't have picked up one of these radios, really. Just as there's no great reason they couldn't have got hold of an MST-13 from Libya to "make the medicine better, stronger".

It's just that the radio identification depends on the manual, and the survival of the manual, much more so than the survival of the MST-13 fragment, really does seem extremely implausible.

I suppose I'm having my cake and eating it here. If we decide that the manual and the timer fragment were planted, then we really are in the territory of dirty work at the crossroads, full-blown conspiracy and all. But on the other hand if we decide these items are really and honestly kosher, then I still think this was Khreesat's work anyway. It was just really, really convenient he utilised two vital components for his IED that it just so happened were closely traceable to Libya.

But look at what was in that IED.
  • A bronze Samsonite hardshell suitcase. The one thing we don't have any trace on, according to the official theory.
  • Some clothes, which the bomber(s) conveniently bought brand new in a small shop only a couple of weeks before the explosion, so they could be traced there. (And it was a place where Megrahi and other Libyans were known to hang out.)
  • A Toshiba radio-cassette recorder of a model apparently wholly or overwhelmingly supplied as a batch to Libya, identified because the bombers generously packed the manual in the suitcase with it, in such a way that it wasn't instantly incinerated in the explosion.
  • An MST-13 timer, again a very limited edition model, supplied exclusively to Libya. Again the one little corner of the main circuit board that survived was luckily just about the only fragment distinctive enough to be identifiable.
If all of that is for real, then there's still no especial reason it couldn't have been Jibril's group, as I said. But if you wanted to aggregate as much circumstantial evidence as possible pointing to Libya, could you have done a better job on purpose?

I think the manual is more likely to be a plant than the timer fragment, based on survivability (or not) of the explosion. I do so wish Wyatt had considered that aspect in his tests. And if the manual is a plant, then it follows pretty closely that the probability of the timer fragment also being a plant is very high.

Rolfe.
 
Another vague thought. Feraday originally thought the radio was white. There were white pieces of plastic recorded. Then he changed his mind. The bits of plastic in PI995 were black.

I wonder where the other bits of black plastic were that helped change his mind? I wonder which of the seven possible models of radio was available in white, and where they were sold?

Rolfe.
 
Another vague thought. Feraday originally thought the radio was white. There were white pieces of plastic recorded. Then he changed his mind. The bits of plastic in PI995 were black.

I wonder where the other bits of black plastic were that helped change his mind? I wonder which of the seven possible models of radio was available in white, and where they were sold?

Rolfe.

The SF 8016 was white, but otherwise looks like the same exact model. You re-posted the pics in post 3. That was the original lead with the Toshiba corp, and Feraday did report white plastics in Feb 89 IIRC as showing clearly a definitely white radio. I don't know yet what this was supposed to mean.

Then it was black, and I haven't yet seen how these two leads were ever reconciled. And it was also clearly the SF16, which is black and as we've seen indicates Libyan guilt, softly. By May 16 (says the papers) that info was available without the long process that it took to ID PT/35(b) and its links to Libya.

DeBraeckeleer has a good article on this issue. Bobby Ingram's story is sounding more relevant all the time, eh?

I think one issue we'll want to get at here is the collection of AG/145. Its bits were consistent with either model, and it was found with (including?) white plastic, found not in Maltese clothes but in the info plate from container AVE4041. So one wonders if the actual bomb was a white 8016? But I hear there are peculiarities about that too, like the deflection angle required for projectiles to have gotten in there. It may have been one plant job replaced with another, for all I know at his point. Sorry to be so vague, but I don't even remember where quite I saw that. But I will run across it again and the question is worth looking at.

Rolfe said:
I think the manual is more likely to be a plant than the timer fragment, based on survivability (or not) of the explosion. I do so wish Wyatt had considered that aspect in his tests. And if the manual is a plant, then it follows pretty closely that the probability of the timer fragment also being a plant is very high.

I do agree with this. I'm still attached to the little suite of timer arguments I've come up with, but this stuff might have to take precedence.
 
The SF 8016 was white, but otherwise looks like the same exact model. You re-posted the pics in post 3. That was the original lead with the Toshiba corp, and Feraday did report white plastics in Feb 89 IIRC as showing clearly a definitely white radio. I don't know yet what this was supposed to mean.

Feradays testimony (reading from his own report) specifically states
Feraday said:
Although many fragments of both charred cardboard and burnt soft plastics have been recovered from the Lockerbie debris, none of these fragments can be conclusively established to have originated from a Toshiba radio or its packing

How convenient.

I used to have a Toshiba casette radio very similar to the one used in the Lockerbie bomb. I also used to enjoy taking electronic stuff apart for no good reason when I was younger. There is a bunch of black plastic used in the internal construction of those radios regardless of the colour of the outside casing.

You can see this in the photo of the Toshiba radio taken apart, internal constuction contains black plastics.

DeBraeckeleer has a good article on this issue.

The letter he quotes has Feraday satisfied that the radio was an 8026 type with white case entirely, it's the manual fragments that make him change his mind and those weren't examined till May as we have already noted.
 
The letter he quotes has Feraday satisfied that the radio was an 8026 type with white case entirely, it's the manual fragments that make him change his mind and those weren't examined till May as we have already noted.


And were they even examined in May?

One of the things I've been trying to get a feel for is the time period of the switch in the investigation from honest assessment of the evidence as it came up, to trying to make it point a certain way.

I was about to post, assuming that happened, because I still entertain the possibility that no evidence was fabricated, and what actually happened was cumulative misinterpretation and misdirection until they were all baying after Libya and Megrahi with blinkers on. However, I stopped mid-sentence, because I think the details of the Horton fragment are close to convincing me that that had to have been fabricated.

I started looking at the timer fragment, because that's the one everybody gets excited about, and the thing people make documentaries about and so on. Mrs. Horton is a bit of a throwaway line in the only documentary she appears in, and the significance of what she's supposed to have found isn't really explored. But really, it's the alleged survival of that 5-inch square piece of paper, and its almost equally strong trail back to Libya, that's turning out to be the killer point for me.

Of course, we don't have the same provenance difficulties with the Horton fragment as with the timer fragment. Mrs. Horton found something, she remembers doing that, and she handed it in. Switching that something for a rather similar but on the other hand altogether different piece of paper isn't much of a problem. So we don't have re-numbered pages and altered labels to get excited about. We just have a piece of paper that's supposed to have survived an explosion that Wyatt couldn't even get a fibreglass circuit board to survive.

Right.

So when, really, did the point come when fabricated evidence was being introduced into the investigation? I don't think it was May, because so much of the timer fragment evidence suggests its May provenance was retrospective. That, to me, suggests that other fabricated evidence that seems to come up in May was retrospectively introduced too. I haven't seen any suggestion that the paper fragment was described on an interpolated page, but I don't think that's important. It's surprising that Hayes messed it up once, you wouldn't expect him to leave trails all over the place.

I appreciate your point about the Lambeth laboratory and the fingerprint testing, and you could be right about that. However, all the photography seems to have happened at RARDE (and we're getting a feel for their standards of photographic provenance), and I merely wonder whether in September or later (the point when I still think the fabrications were introduced), it was clear that a different piece of paper could be substituted without anyone at the Met being able (or willing, probably) to prove anything different.

I was leaning to a point later in 1989 for the introduction of fabrications, however your information about Hayes's employment history tends to nudge it all to an earlier date. I'm thinking that indeed the 15th September memo may represent activity surrounding the introduction of whatever fabrications were created - I suggest the entirety of PI995, the substitution of the RTF-16 manual pages for whatever Mrs. Horton found, and the addition of a few tiny scraps of manual to three other evidence bags.

(I still don't know what to make of the Gauci clothes, at all, so I'll continue to assume the bulk of these were not planted. It's hard to imagine how they could have been, as far as I can see.)

The fact that they were already messing with the evidence examined in mid-May (the genuine Horton fragment) could explain why the same time period was chosen to insert the de novo PI995 item. However, while the Horton fragment could be accommodated simply by substituting a new page for whatever Hayes wrote at the time, it was necessary to make room for an entire new page to describe PI995.

So, I still think this could fit a late summer 1989 decision to take active steps to implicate Libya rather than Iran, with the fabicated evidence being insinuated into the investigation, with retrospective provenance, in September. Or do you think the Lambeth involvement in June is enough to knock this idea on the head?

Bearing in mind that the Met itself doesn't eactly have a reputation for the fearless and singleminded pursuit of truth in all its forms.

Rolfe.
 
Just quickly coming back to Mrs Horton's testimony, and I meant to raise this when I forsted posted it, is the sheer lack of interest or inquiry made by Megrahi's defense team.

(my bold and emphasis)

Zeist Transcripts said:
16 Q Right. I wonder if you would look,

17 please, at Label 24. You'll see there is a bag which

18 contains items there. Do you recognise anything?

19 A Well, not in its present state. I'm

20 sure when I handed it in, it was in one piece.

21 Q Yes.

22 A Yes.

23 Q Perhaps -- I wonder if it could be put

24 on the document imager, to see if we can see it. You

25 can see within the police plastic bag, I think as


966

1 you've described, more than one piece of a document.

2 And you can at least see writing on it?

3 A Yes.

4 Q Do I understand you to say that when you

5 handed it in, it was in one piece?

6 A It was in one piece, sir. I am

7 practically sure of that, yes.

8 Q But apart from that, you recognise the

9 item?

10 A Yes. Uh-huh.

<snip>

17 Q Thank you very much.

18 LORD SUTHERLAND: Mr. Taylor.

19 MR. TAYLOR: If Your Lordship could give me

20 one moment, please.

21 My Lord, I have no questions for the witness.


22 Thank you.

23 LORD SUTHERLAND: Mr. Macleod.

24 MR. MACLEOD: I have no questions, My Lord.

What the hell were they thinking exactly?! An absolutely crucial point of evidence, and critical to the assertion by the prosecution that this evidence was from Toshiba used to conceal the bomb, and the precise model that, once again, points inescapably to Libya and thus their defendant!

A witness makes claims of tampering of her discovery in open court, and they have "no questions for the witness"??

Utterly bizarre.
 
Hans Kochler is extremely critical of Megrahi's defence team in his report. There were manipulations there, of course. Someone left the team in protest over inteference by Libyan "advisors", and after that things are said to have gone downhill.

I've got a few thoughts about it all.

First, there was undoubtedly a lot of interference by Libyan lawyers, and I'm not convinced their objective was to get acquittals. It was all a fairly cosy arrangement; throw these two - or one of them at least - to the lions, pay up a few billion dollars, and then you get to play in the international community again. What would actually have happened to all that if Megrahi had also been acquitted?

The other point as regards the Libyans is, I rather think they were extremely keen to avoid anything significant about what Megrahi was really doing on and around 21st December 1988, and indeed about his work in general, coming out in court. He was in Malta, travelling on a "coded" diplomatic passport. Not an illegal false passport, a legal passport with a false name, issued to him because he was an intelligence officer. One way to counter charges that he was there to smuggle a bomb on board KM180 would have been to explain, with evidence, what he was really doing. But they very definitely didn't go there. My impression was they'd rather let him be convicted than let that come out in court.

Then again, the defence advocates and solicitors had one hell of a job. The prosecution had all the resources of the police at their disposal, to sift through the mountains of evidence and construct a case out of it all. The defence legal team have to to all the countering themselves - they have to be their own detectives, if you like. (This is why the Rumpole books are such fun - Rumpole is a barrister, but he's having to do the detective work to establish his clients' innocence, with both the police and the prosecution ranged against him.)

But what defence advocates tend to do at that point, is to fall back on forcing the prosecution to prove their case. The defence doesn't have to prove what did happen, it just has to cast reasonable doubt on the prosecution version. Given the mountains of evidence and the complexities of this case, I think they fixed on a certain number of areas where they thought the prosecution case was vulnerable. Giaka, obviously, and they scored a spectacular victory with that one. (They may have thought they'd won when he was thrown out.) The Erac printout, where the defence advocate spent a couple of days trying to show that tray 8849 could have been a number of other things and didn't necessarily come off KM180. The timer fragment, with it's glaring problems of provenance. Gauci's identification. The Bedford suitcase (they weren't told about the Heathrow break-in of course, or they could have made more of that).

I think they genuinely tried on these points, but they were only human, and they missed other tricks. The Horton pages being one of them. It's easy to concentrate on the timer and overlook the importance of the manual, as we've seen.

I also think there's a big leap between casting doubt on provenance, and trying to show alternative non-incriminating explanations for the evidence, and outright accusations of fabrication on the part of the investigating authorities. We see the defence skirt this when they cast doubt on the provenance of the timer fragment, but they never throw propriety to the winds and go all-out to prove it was a deliberate fabrication. If they'd challenged the Horton fragment as it should have been challenged, they'd more or less have been forced to do that, and I suspect that's a bridge too far for many lawyers, especially in a high-profile political and international case like this, with the CIA sitting at the elbows of the prosecution.

Rolfe.
 
However, I stopped mid-sentence, because I think the details of the Horton fragment are close to convincing me that that had to have been fabricated.

But really, it's the alleged survival of that 5-inch square piece of paper, and its almost equally strong trail back to Libya, that's turning out to be the killer point for me.

We just have a piece of paper that's supposed to have survived an explosion that Wyatt couldn't even get a fibreglass circuit board to survive.

The point I was trying to make earlier with the comparison to 9/11, is that what you are saying about the 5x5 piece of manual being unable to survive the explosion, is the same argument from incredulity that we hear truthers giving over say the passport of one of the hijackers.

I appreciate that we are talking here about a papr manual that was packed inside a case in which 400+g of high explosives detonated, and that no explosives detonated at ground zero, so the physics are very very different.

FWIW I don't think it's possible the cover piece could have survived either, but I am not an explosives expert, I know almost nothing about explosives.

My point is that Hayes & Feraday are both scientists, neither of them baulked at the idea that a fragile paper fragment could have survived the explosion. There were explosives guys at the AAIB, there have been any number of people since then looking through the evidence, and no-one with any explosives training has stated that a paper manual could not have survived, or was highly unlikely to have done. The defense team at the original trial and at the appeal do not seem to have made that argument.

I'd guess that the reason the timer board should not have survived was it was in the radio and the manual was outside and might have been shielded from some of the forces involved in the explosion by the case of the radio as it was being blown apart.

I think that if we are talking about when evidence was planted/tampered with/fabricated to point at Libya then we are talking about dates between May and September 1989.

If we assume that PK/689 was a plant, it might well have been done to point to Khreesat, both radios called "Bombeat", PFLP-GC based in Libya, that kind of angle.
 
The point I was trying to make earlier with the comparison to 9/11, is that what you are saying about the 5x5 piece of manual being unable to survive the explosion, is the same argument from incredulity that we hear truthers giving over say the passport of one of the hijackers.

I appreciate that we are talking here about a papr manual that was packed inside a case in which 400+g of high explosives detonated, and that no explosives detonated at ground zero, so the physics are very very different.

FWIW I don't think it's possible the cover piece could have survived either, but I am not an explosives expert, I know almost nothing about explosives.

My point is that Hayes & Feraday are both scientists, neither of them baulked at the idea that a fragile paper fragment could have survived the explosion. There were explosives guys at the AAIB, there have been any number of people since then looking through the evidence, and no-one with any explosives training has stated that a paper manual could not have survived, or was highly unlikely to have done. The defense team at the original trial and at the appeal do not seem to have made that argument.

I'd guess that the reason the timer board should not have survived was it was in the radio and the manual was outside and might have been shielded from some of the forces involved in the explosion by the case of the radio as it was being blown apart.

I think that if we are talking about when evidence was planted/tampered with/fabricated to point at Libya then we are talking about dates between May and September 1989.

If we assume that PK/689 was a plant, it might well have been done to point to Khreesat, both radios called "Bombeat", PFLP-GC based in Libya, that kind of angle.

I completely appreciate what your saying, but it wasn't an entire page that was presented as evidence. It was, as Mrs Horton stated, "well, not in it's present state", when presented to her at Zeist by the prosecution.

The scraps extracted by Feraday, that being the compacted pieces found in the collar, is just about plausible at a stretch, but an entire intact page as Mrs Horton described, is a stretch too far, and no doubt would raise questions from other Scientific observers. However, Mrs Horton's adamant discovery of an entire page is simply glossed over and presumably put down to her jaded and confused memory, 11 years after the fact. The prosecution presented a badly scortched and frayed piece of manual (which no one has really questioned), and the judges simply accepted this was Mrs Hortons find (with some testing done) and just enough was legible to point towards Libya, thus Megrahi.

Then my question is, if we're speculating that the manual was indeed a plant to help direct the judges, why take your plot outwith the confines of those intimately involved in the examining pieces? Do we require a corroborating source, and one outwith the primary investigators, or indeed better still, a member of the public who found something very similar many years ago could provide this corroboration?
 
Last edited:
Then my question is, if we're speculating that the manual was indeed a plant to help direct the judges, why take your plot outwith the confines of those intimately involved in the examining pieces? Do we require a corroborating source, and one outwith the primary investigators, or indeed better still, a member of the public who found something very similar many years ago could provide this corroboration?

I am not sure what you mean here.

I believe that investigators framed Libya in general and Megrahi/Fhimah in particular for the bombing of 103 for politically motivated reasons. I also believe that any conspiracy involved here will have had to have been a simple one involving as few people as possible.

Other trial evidence that's pertinent to Mrs Horton.

Trial evidence Day 6 pg967 said:
EXAMINATION IN CHIEF BY MR. CAMPBELL:

Q: Mr. Walton, what is your full name?

A: Brian George Walton.

Q: And are you a retired police constable?

A: That's correct.

[...]

Q: Do you recall the night in which the Pan Am 103 aircraft crashed?

A: Yes, I do.

Q: In the period thereafter, did members of the public bring items of debris to the police station at Alnwick?

A: That's correct. Or we went out to various locations and collected debris.

Q: In some cases would people contact you and advise you that there was an item to be collected?

A: That's correct, yes.

Q: And on other occasions did members of the public attend at the police office with material?

A: That's correct, yes.

Q: Would you look, please, at Label 24. Is that an item which has a police label attached to it?

A: That's correct, yes.

Q: Of which force is the police label?

A: Lothian and Borders.

Q: Do you recognise the item that's attached?

A: From my recollection, it's a handbook,

[969]

pieces of an instruction handbook.

Q: Do you remember that item being handed in to you?

A: Yes, I do.

Q: Was it a lady who handed it in to you?

A: That's correct, yes.

Q: Mrs. Horton?

A: That's correct.

Q: And when you looked at the item, what struck you about it?

A: It had tiny bits of singeing on some of the edges of the pieces. At that time, obviously -- it was either the day after or the following day, either
the Thursday or the Friday; at that time it didn't have significance from -- that it obviously might have now, with hindsight knowledge. But at that time, I mean, it was just -- to me, it was debris possibly from the aircraft.

Q: And do I take it from that answer that it was handed in to you within one or two days after the --

A: I can't remember offhand whether it was the Thursday or the Friday. So that would be the 22nd or the 23rd.

Q: And what did you do with it?

[970]

A: Together with other pieces that Mrs. Horton handed to me, I bagged the stuff individually. Again, I can't remember now the full list, but there was this item, which I would place in a bag very -- I don't know if that's the original bag, but in a bag marked "Northumbria Police" --

Q: Is that bag marked "Northumbria Police"?

A: Right.

Q: Right. What did you do with the items once you'd bagged them, and with that item in particular?

A: They were registered in the property register at Alnwick police station. The property was put -- kept in the store there and eventually went to
the incident room at Hexham police station, where they were collating everything from Northumbria area.

Q: Thank you.

Thats the corroborating evidence from a police officer with 20 years experience. He says that PK689 was what Mrs Horton handed in. That it was singed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom