Identification of the Toshiba radio from PA103

Well paper fragments have been known to survive explosions. A 12:1 glide ratio is basicaly imposible (there are paper planes than can do it but they have some very well done folding) but wind could do it. On the other hand poor chain of custody and there are alturnative explanations.

Oh and the damage isn't consistent with any form of forensic analysis I've run across. Taking samples would result in straight cuts and damage through say soaking in in some kind of solvent would likely have removed most of the ink as well.
 
There's no debate that light articles were able to make it to Morpeth and beyond - there was a 90mph westerly gale blowing that evening, and there was a substantial amount of such debris from the plane strewn around. Mrs. Horton spoke of finding Christmas cards and things like that the following morning.

Centimetres from a Semtex explosion, in the middle of little hard shards of debris, then blown 60 miles and landing in a field, leaving just the part of the page legible to make that vital identification.

Mrs. Horton says she remembers an entire page, larger than that (and there's no evidence that the fingerprint testing reduced it in size significantly - it was photographed before testing anyway). She also remembers the word "Toshiba", but all you can read on the exhibit is "IBA" - even the H is partly missing. Memory can be strange, but it's hard to see the exhibit as being something she might have described in those terms. It's a scrap, not intact, and you can't read "Toshiba" on it. It's badly torn, which would have been difficult to avoid noticing if you were picking it up off the grass.

But even accepting all that, it's the sheer survival of the thing I can't get my brain round, especially when there are explosives experts expressing disbelief that fibreglass circuit board fragments could have survived the same thing.

Rolfe
 
Last edited:
Oh and the damage isn't consistent with any form of forensic analysis I've run across. Taking samples would result in straight cuts and damage through say soaking in in some kind of solvent would likely have removed most of the ink as well.


Yes, that had occurred to me as well. The timer fragment was cut forensically, and this is well described, and the cuts are very straight and deliberate.

Rolfe.
 
Doesn't have to to it for very long since it would get blown clear fairly quickly. White paint is enough to stop the initial flash damage of a nuclear weapon at a range of a few tens of meters (the following shockwave less so).

Yeah, but one inch is one inch. Anyway, even if you're right, and may well be, the facts of PT/30 as reported by Dr. Hayes suggest the terrorists just put the main board back in backwards. It would obviously make the radio not work.

Or is there a plausible fluke there, with the board fragmenting and turning enough that the opposite side take the main hit, protecting the bombward side with some hyperkinetic ninja-flip?

I dunno. Went ahead and elaborated on the PT/30-35 disconnect (connect?) Sept. 14/15 thing:
http://lockerbiedivide.blogspot.com/2010/06/feradays-forensic-follies-section-sixty.html
I'll brush it up later. I'll be slow to follow for the weekend and next week, with a lot going on, so y'all run on ahead if it suits ya.
 
To quibble a bit with Rolfe, branding on the Toshiba scale makes it so that "HIBA" would likely be remembered as Toshiba.

Otherwise we're on the same page of course. Fact is, this PK/689 could not have been near any such bomb and be in half this shape, it's in worse shape even than she recalls, there's no good forensic explanation for that, so... it's clearly just torn a bit from the strain of trying to bridge two sets of needs. Needs to be mostly intact and say/suggest Toshiba, and needs to have been right next to the friggin bomb.

I mean really, Rolfe, could you have done any better after making such a ridiculous decision?
:D

These things are becoming the rule, not exception, aren't they?
 
I'm back on Mrs. Horton's recognition again. Yes, I agree about the brand recognition of Toshiba all right. However, the only letters that can be read look like IIBA. Indeed, if someone gave you that piece and said, what do you think the full manufacturer's name is, you wouldn't have much trouble coming up with the right answer. But that's not what happened.

Deccy and Geoff Horton are out in the Glebe field opposite their house one cold December morning, essentially litter-picking. It's not a single hugely important item she's seen and decided to preserve, they responded to an appeal for members of the public to go out and gather up all the stuff that had landed in that particular area. (This didn't have the importance of the identified debris trails in Scotland, where everything was done officially with two witnesses, this was just the light stuff that blew over to Northumberland.) They handed in two carrier bags full of stuff. This was just one of the bits that "went into the bag".

It's slightly surprising she would remember any particular piece under these circumstances. However, it seems she does. Here's what she says about it.

Camp Zeist said:
Q I would like to ask you about one item 23 in particular. Do you remember coming upon a document of some sort that made reference to a radio cassette player?
A Yes, I do.
Q Can you describe what that item was like?
A Well, from what I remember, it was possibly about -- I know I'm supposed to say it. About that kind of size, you know, about possibly eight by eight, or something like that, inches.
Q Could you see writing on it?
A I could see writing, because I remarked to my husband, "This appears to be from a cassette player," or something like that. I do remember it was something electrical.
Q And did you hand that item in to the police?
A Yes, that went into the bag as well.
Q Right. I wonder if you would look, please, at Label 24. You'll see there is a bag which contains items there. Do you recognise anything?
A Well, not in its present state. I'm sure when I handed it in, it was in one piece.
Q Perhaps -- I wonder if it could be put on the document imager, to see if we can see it. You can see within the police plastic bag, I think as you've described, more than one piece of a document. And you can at least see writing on it?
A Yes.
Q Do I understand you to say that when you handed it in, it was in one piece?
A It was in one piece, sir. I am practically sure of that, yes.
Q But apart from that, you recognise the item?
A Yes. Uh-huh.


Now let's look at what she is supposed to be describing.

689.jpg


First, the word "Toshiba" doesn't leap out from this. You'd have to work it out. But then Mrs. Horton doesn't say she saw the word Toshiba at all. "I do remember it was something electrical," is all she actually says.

My first thought is that this scrap is only about 5" by 3", and badly torn - almost all the way through in a couple of places. I imagine it would have been wet as well, after lying out in the field all night. I think a piece of paper like that would be memorable mostly for the care you'd have to take when picking it up, not to get it even more badly torn, or even have it disintegrate in your hand.

As Geni says, the tears don't look like forensic damage at all. And there is a photograph of the item before it was sent to the Met for forensic testing - if that showed something significantly different, something Mrs. Horton was going to look at and say, oh yes, that's what it looked like, why not produce that?

Look at the bolded part. "I know I'm supposed to say it." This is a coached witness. Hardly a surprise, all witnesses are coached to some extent. Somebody (in this case the prosecution team, as she was a prosecution witness) has to determine what the witness knows and what they intend to say in court. They've asked her to say the item she found was about the size of what's in the plastic bag. She does say, about that kind of size, then she says, about 8" by 8". What's in the bag is a fair bit smaller than that. It seems to me she's remembering picking up something larger, but dutifully agreeing it was "that kind of size". She's remembering picking up a sheet of paper virtually intact, not something in tatters and almost torn through in two places.

I think what strikes me about this is that is she looked at it closely enough at the time to see that it was "something electrical", and possibly to have read the words "cassette recorder", surely she would also have remembered the almost disintegrated state of the thing. And yet she doesn't. She's trying to tell the truth, but at the same time she knows there are certain things she's "supposed" to say.

This really does give me the impression of a witness who remembers seeing something quite different, but who is dutifully trying to identify the item shown to her. Does she even remember seeing the words "cassette recorder" originally, or has she acquired that from looking at the court exhibit or a photo of it during an interview? From looking at this, we can't even say the original item picked up was from a Toshiba. Just "something electrical".

How dangerous would it have been to make a fairly radical substitution like this? I think not at all. Suppose Mrs. Horton was approached about finding this item, and said, "Oh no, I remember what I picked up, it said 'Panasonic' on it. This definitely isn't that." Well, bugger. But it was worth a try. Sorry, madam, there must have been some mix-up, apologies for troubling you. And Mrs. Horton doesn't get that nice trip to Utrecht.

If she'd said she didn't remember the item at all, but of course it might have been one of the things she put in that bag that morning, they could still have used it. That was probably the most likely outcome, I think, and possibly why Geoff wasn't called. But as it was, she was prepared (or suggestible and helpful enough) to give an identification. Except she didn't.

There's just so much wrong with this.

Rolfe.
 
I think it's really quite astounding how brief, almost incidental, Mrs Horton's testimony at Zeist was. And yet given the gravity of her statement inadvertently confirming the precise model of Toshiba with her 'evidence found', it's almost seemingly inconsequential (even to Megrahi's legal team!), until Feraday and the judges concluded Mrs Horton's find was part of the actual bomb device.

Although, when first reading through Mrs Horton's testimony, I had interpreted "I know I'm supposed to say it..", as her simply her correcting the fact she was probably beginning to gesture with her hands the size and shape of the item she had found. Realising she had already been told that for the record of transcript, and normal procedure in court, a witness should in all circumstances verbalise their testimony as best possible.

In the interview she gave the the Sunday Sun, she stated,
“We were finding Christmas cards written by the bairns on board, letters, personal effects, things like that. Quite harrowing.”

Decky said she found part of a radio cassette manual with the word Toshiba clearly visible. [...]

She said: “It was in one piece when I found it but in the bag there were several pieces and the name Toshiba was only just discernable by then.

“When I found the piece of paper it was more or less intact, a bit tatty round the edges, but it definitely had Toshiba written across it.”

Police said the paper was damaged following a battery of forensic tests.

Horton Article

Now, I'm really not sure if Mrs Horton is simply embellishing her story, or perhaps her memory has become fertile to influence given the high profile nature of the case. But, it would beg the question, why would she? Does she, as she almost didn't at Zeist, now fully realise the significance of her discovery in adding yet another damning connection in the whole prosecution's case against Megrahi?

Was her recollection of the word Toshiba influenced by her involvement in a programme, "The Conspiracy Files", or is it simply that her time on the stand at Zeist was so incredibly brief, she never really had an opportunity (notably by any cross examination) to give a fuller explanation for her discovery and it's critical and crucial part in the bomb device and pinpointing a specific model of radio?
 
Last edited:
I think it's really quite astounding how brief, almost incidental, Mrs Horton's testimony at Zeist was. And yet given the gravity of her statement inadvertently confirming the precise model of Toshiba with her 'evidence found', it's almost seemingly inconsequential (even to Megrahi's legal team!), until Feraday and the judges concluded Mrs Horton's find was part of the actual bomb device.


I understand that most of the testimony at Camp Zeist was mind-numbingly boring, hours and hours of policemen saying, yes, I found this in that field, m'lud. As if any of them would have remembered most of it without the labels saying so. There was so much of this at the beginning the world's media packed up and went home.

I suspect this was going to be just one more of these routine confirmaitons of something found, and possibly nobody really noticed that she hadn't in fact identified it until later. The prosecutor sounds a bit like someone trying to get a child to say the right answer, and when it comes, then everybody is satisfied.

I'm not sure if she gave evidence at the FAI or not. If this was the first time, and there was no hint beforehand that she was going to be unsure, then possibly nobody was prepared for it. Mr. Taylor seems to have had a lot of defence prepared, and detailed submisisons ready on the Heathrow ingestion, all the things tray 8849 might have been, and Gauci's identification. He may have let Mrs. Horton go because he wasn't expecting it, and it wasn't part of the pre-prepared plan.

Although, when first reading through Mrs Horton's testimony, I had interpreted "I know I'm supposed to say it..", as her simply her correcting the fact she was probably beginning to gesture with her hands the size and shape of the item she had found. Realising she had already been told that for the record of transcript, and normal procedure in court, a witness should in all circumstances verbalise their testimony as best possible.


I hadn't thought of that, I think you're right. I withdraw that suggestion.

In the interview she gave the the Sunday Sun, she stated,

Horton Article

Now, I'm really not sure if Mrs Horton is simply embellishing her story, or perhaps her memory has become fertile to influence given the high profile nature of the case. But, it would beg the question, why would she? Does she, as she almost didn't at Zeist, now fully realise the significance of her discovery in adding yet another damning connection in the whole prosecution's case against Megrahi?

Was her recollection of the word Toshiba influenced by her involvement in a programme, "The Conspiracy Files", or is it simply that her time on the stand at Zeist was so incredibly brief, she never really had an opportunity (notably by any cross examination) to give a fuller explanation for her discovery and it's critical and crucial part in the bomb device and pinpointing a specific model of radio?


Hmm, I see where that comes in. That Conspiracy Files programme. I'll need to look again at the footage - it's likely the Sun was only paraphrasing what she said in the BBC programme, we're not talking quality journalism and they're quite capable of making up an interview from a preview of the broadcast material.

If she saw the word "Toshiba" plainly, then it's surprising she didn't say that in the witness box. Just "something electrical". I wonder if she saw the part-word at the trial, and then assumed she must have seen the whole word if she'd originally seen a more intact version?

It's hard to tell, but what really strikes me is how difficult it would be to pick something that tattered up from the grass and "remember" picking up an intact page. And if the fingerprint treatment had really damaged it so much, why not show the court the pre-treatment photograph for the avoidance of doubt?

It's all very unclear, and all we can really say is that she didn't identify the piece of paper and we can't exclude some sort of substitution. The sequence of events prior to its emerging in the pile of debris at RARDE is pretty suspicious.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Good catch, Buncrana. A suspicious eye like mine was agreeing with Rolfe, but it does seem a small point to coach someone on.

I've honestly not even looked close at the Horton end of the story. Rolfe, what day transcript is that from?

"Toshiba" could be a memory she picked up between 2000 and 2008 rather that back in 88. I imagine it wouldn't even pop out as a good place to plant the SF-16 manual cover if it didn't say Toshiba to begin with. Not if it had a clear and memorable other brand name anyway. Too risky.

caustic
 
Good catch, Buncrana. A suspicious eye like mine was agreeing with Rolfe, but it does seem a small point to coach someone on.

I've honestly not even looked close at the Horton end of the story. Rolfe, what day transcript is that from?

"Toshiba" could be a memory she picked up between 2000 and 2008 rather that back in 88. I imagine it wouldn't even pop out as a good place to plant the SF-16 manual cover if it didn't say Toshiba to begin with. Not if it had a clear and memorable other brand name anyway. Too risky.

caustic

It's Day 06, pp962 for Mrs Horton's 5mins on the stand mate.

There's more in-depth questioning of meaningless witnesses who took a flight from Malta to Frankfurt on the 21st, and ending their journey there, than there was examination of Mrs Horton's miracle find of the actual bomb's radio manual!

As Rolfe pointed out, the thing about her discovery and testimony in court is, knowing the 'damage sustained' by chemical testing, why was the page not shown in it's original form to the witness, as it would have been when discovered?

Why on earth not was an image, as was shown to her of PK689, not also shown of the page before it had been subjected to testing, which had quite obviously resulted in it bearing no semblance in appearance as to her find in 1988?

+It's the page of a manual Mrs Horton, and it is the one you found. Just confirm that for us. Thanks. Bye.+
 
It's Day 06, pp962 for Mrs Horton's 5mins on the stand mate.

There's more in-depth questioning of meaningless witnesses who took a flight from Malta to Frankfurt on the 21st, and ending their journey there, than there was examination of Mrs Horton's miracle find of the actual bomb's radio manual!

As Rolfe pointed out, the thing about her discovery and testimony in court is, knowing the 'damage sustained' by chemical testing, why was the page not shown in it's original form to the witness, as it would have been when discovered?

Why on earth not was an image, as was shown to her of PK689, not also shown of the page before it had been subjected to testing, which had quite obviously resulted in it bearing no semblance in appearance as to her find in 1988?

+It's the page of a manual Mrs Horton, and it is the one you found. Just confirm that for us. Thanks. Bye.+

Exactly. That happened a bit with Scotcop Gilchrist too. He starts answering "no" to some of the "yes yes yes" questions, and it gets awkward for a while.

She's left guessing if this might be the same paper with some later damage, and not shown pre-test photo that would better elicit the "yes." Unless that IS the pre-test photo. Which I'm pretty sure it is.

I was wondering if the bit about it being in two pieces could actually refer to the fact PK/689 was two sheets pressed together in that shape, later separated. But I think she's referring in general to the state of the main sheet.
 
+It's the page of a manual Mrs Horton, and it is the one you found. Just confirm that for us. Thanks. Bye.+


Basically, yes. That was it.

Remember, the cop to whom she handed it in also gave evidence, and he said it looked like that. They can't both be right, one of them has to be mistaken or even both.

The problem with this is the way that evidence was collected. The stuff collected close to the crash site was recorded as to who found it and where it was found, and individually bagged. Even so, stuff slipped through the net, witness Bpbby Ingram being asked to sign things off retrospectively a couple of years later.

This was just locals asked to go out and bring in what they could find. The Hortons filled two plastic bags with what was basically litter. Some of it probably was litter. Maybe Mrs. Horton remembered that item, and made some remark to her husband about it as she says - but how many things did she pick up? Very hard to be sure about any one of them, years later.

It could even be that she's remembering some other item in the bag, and didn't notice the Toshiba scrap at all - the whole thing could be complete cross purposes. It could be that that would have been the default line if she'd been too insistent that it didn't look the same.

As far as the policeman is concerned, I find it hard to believe he had any memory at all of what was brought in. He didn't pick the stuff up off the grass, he just took in the carrier bags - and not just the Hortons', almost certainly plenty more from the other Northumberland helpers. How could he remember every scrap? How could he know which scrap he was supposed to remember? No, he was simply told, that was one of the things in one of the bags Mrs. Horton gave you, will you identify it in court? What's he going to say? One piece of litter looks much like another piece of litter?

All we know is, rightly or wrongly, she didn't identlfy it, and was apparently never shown the photograph of the pre-fingerprinting item for comparison. On its own that would mean little, but put it together with all the rest of the weirdness, and it starts to look very peculiar.

Rolfe.
 
Exactly. That happened a bit with Scotcop Gilchrist too. He starts answering "no" to some of the "yes yes yes" questions, and it gets awkward for a while.


Yes. I suspect him of having dutifully signed-off that evidence bag, and probably a few more, retroactively, with no real idea whether he found the item in it or not. Just to keep the paperwork right, you know. Then he has to go on oath and swear he found it where and when it says. Worrying, but doable. Then someone notices the label has been altered....

But hey, what could be wrong, can't be anything significant, kthnksbye, next witness please.

She's left guessing if this might be the same paper with some later damage, and not shown pre-test photo that would better elicit the "yes." Unless that IS the pre-test photo. Which I'm pretty sure it is.


No, she wasn't shown a photo, she was shown the actual piece of paper I believe. In a plastic bag. Wy not show the pre-test photo as well? That's why they take these pictures, so that they can say to the witness, well this is what it looked like, and we have secure chain-of-custody to show this is the same item. Didn't happen.

I was wondering if the bit about it being in two pieces could actually refer to the fact PK/689 was two sheets pressed together in that shape, later separated. But I think she's referring in general to the state of the main sheet.


Well, there were supposed to be two sheets, but that single page is almost torn through in at least two places. That's why I think you'd remember picking it up like that. It would almost certainly be wet, and it would be hard to stop it tearing right through. You'd practically have to take it home carefully and dry it flat.

So if she picked up a relatively undamaged portion, why no photo? And if it was relatively undamaged at that point, why did the policeman say it was the same item and looked the same? (OK, I know, he would have identified a chunk of the following day's newspaper if he'd been told to.)

You can't prove any shenanigans, but it sure looks suspicious.

Rolfe.
 
Just a bit about the colors and mounting of those PCBs:

The brown color of the component side is totally consistent with the phenolic-paper boards commonly used in consumer products. I've been seeing that same color since I took apart transistor radios as a kid back in the '60s. Open up a typical Tascam mixer and you'll see the very same stuff. Go to a Radio Shack (or RS) store and you will find perfboards made for hobbyist circuit construction made out of the same stuff, some of which will have PC pads on one side and some of which will be bare on both sides.

The green "lacquer" on the solder side is called "solder mask" It's printed onto the foil side ( I believe by a silkscreen process) after the board has been etched and drilled/punched. It's purpose is to cover the copper traces except at the pads where component leads or other wires are to be soldered to a trace. The reason it's used is that mass-produced PCBs are almost always machine-soldered, and passing a board with no mask through a wave soldering machine would result in solder adhering to every bit of exposed copper foil, which is likely, depending on the spacing between adjacent traces, to cause short circuits ("solder bridges"), which would necessitate hand-reworking (expensive!). A double-sided board (one which has copper traces on both sides) will often have solder mask on both the component and solder sides; a single-sided board will have it only on the solder side.

I don't see anything odd about the way the boards are shown mounted in the radio cabinet. It's quite common to see boards mounted with the component sides pointing towards the inside of an enclosure; having the flat soldder side towards the enclosure wall makes it possible to mount the board with a minimal clearance between it and the wall, which in turn makes it easy to mold mounting points right into the plastic cabinet. A board hanging upside-down from the top side of an enclosure is nothing unusual.

Now, I'm not a manufacturing engineer, I'm just a tech who has spent many years staring at the innards of many different kinds of electronic equipment, and what I see in those photos does not strike me as being in any way anomalous for a piece of cheap consumer junk.
 
I don't see anything odd about the way the boards are shown mounted in the radio cabinet. It's quite common to see boards mounted with the component sides pointing towards the inside of an enclosure; having the flat soldder side towards the enclosure wall makes it possible to mount the board with a minimal clearance between it and the wall, which in turn makes it easy to mold mounting points right into the plastic cabinet. A board hanging upside-down from the top side of an enclosure is nothing unusual.

Now, I'm not a manufacturing engineer, I'm just a tech who has spent many years staring at the innards of many different kinds of electronic equipment, and what I see in those photos does not strike me as being in any way anomalous for a piece of cheap consumer junk.

Thanks a lot for the background info, and just adding another voice. It's busy production, but with a small cast. Loovely to have some extras on occasion. Do you think this board is made of the same material ("phenolic paper")? If so, how durable is that compared to, say, 9-layer fiberglass?

And it seems you misunderstood what I meant by backwards. How it's shown looks right, and the screw holes are probably designed so it has to sit about flush with the case - so no room to properly install it backwards unless the component side was basically scraped clean. In itself it's a silly thought, but I'm struggling with how hayes describes PT/30:

"This is a fragment of a SRBP printed circuit board which has been intimately involved in an explosion. It is shown in photograph 262 before its removal from an item of explosion-damaged luggage (item PK/2128, Section 4.2.14) and in close-up in photograph 263.
The fragment is irregularly shaped wit overall dimensions of approximately 4 millimetres by 3 millimetres. It has been partially delaminated by the blast and, hence, does not possess the expected green lacquer and/or solder tracking upon its rear face as this has been ripped completely away. The upper face of the fragment bears part of the white painted characters C32 and a depiction of an electrical resistor. The information detail and spatial configuration of these markings were found to correspond precisely with one specific area located on the Toshiba control circuit board DC/1477 (f 1)". [3091-92]

It seems, this evidence, implies that the terrorists put the board in backwards. I admit, it's a little confusing. But it would explain the non-discolored component sides and intact markings.

What do you make of that?
 
The short form. What CL is saying is that the side of the circuit board which was undamaged was actually the side closest to the Semtex in that mock-up picture. The other side was the damaged side. So did the terrorists put the circuit boards back in upside down while they were constructing the bomb, or what?

I can't see any reason for the circuit boards to have been taken out in the first place, and if you're going to take them out, why put them back in, especially in a way that would mean they were still non-operational (i.e. the radio wouldn't work).

Rolfe.
 
Some amazing screen grabs from Al Jazeera English's new video.

AG/145 fragments, separated and partly cleaned.
AG-145_AlJazeera.jpg

I can't get the image of the smaller fragment in situ against the board to upload yet. But here's the backside of the larger one against the green side.
AG-145-B.jpg

As we can see, neither side shows any sign of blast damage (extreme heat, for example). But where on the board are these fragments from? The middle, just one inch from the Semtex? Or the ends a couple inches away? There's an image that clears that up, and they showed it. I compared it to the assembled IED mock-up, indicated areas circled.
Toshiba_Board_comp_ag145pt30.jpg

PT/30, for anyone needing a reminder, is the fragment discussed here:
http://lockerbiedivide.blogspot.com/2010/06/feradays-forensic-follies-section-sixty.html
Strange twists and turns for that bit.

ETA: Another oddity is both AG/145 at PT/30 would go about the same direction, you'd expect by that - if one goes down, one goes down and to the left pretty much.

Officially PT/30 wound up wedged into the outer frame segment (IIRC) of the blue softshell on the container floor, just beneath the bomb bag - if so, why would AG/145 wind up blasted into a fold of the data plate, on the outside of the container, halfway up its side, two feet or more above the bomb bag?

Is that "non-Newtonian?"
 
Last edited:
I have some sympathy with Feraday's comment that he'd long ago given up trying to figure out where any particular fragment was going to end up in an explosion. However, the survival of a fragment with sufficient printing on it to allow the radio to be identified is looking more and more improbable to me.

Non-newtonian or not, I'm coming round to the idea that Thurman simply planted that chip for Claiden to find. The timing is improbably early, but it's not impossible. If the US spooks already knew about Libya having taken delivery of a large order of a single radio model, and there was an immediate imperative to direct the inquiry away from Syria/Iran with Libya chosen as the handy fall-guy, slipping that in on spec might have seemed worth a shot.

Rolfe.
 
I have some sympathy with Feraday's comment that he'd long ago given up trying to figure out where any particular fragment was going to end up in an explosion.

He would say that, wouldn't he? I'm not really a scientist (but then, neither is he), but I think things should go, IN the explosion, along the general direction of the blast wave - outward in all directions. You'll have deflection, earlier and later stops, and so on. And after the fact you've got wind, rain, wild animals, whatever, that can mess things up. But in any single explosion, I don't think you should have major u-turns, or things from the same board two inches apart flying in opposite directions.

So, not to labor the point, I rather suspect either AG/145 or PT/30 or both were planted in the spot found, depending which way any real bomb was actually facing. But then for many reasons I think all of them were planted anyway.

Non-newtonian or not, I'm coming round to the idea that Thurman simply planted that chip for Claiden to find. The timing is improbably early, but it's not impossible. If the US spooks already knew about Libya having taken delivery of a large order of a single radio model, and there was an immediate imperative to direct the inquiry away from Syria/Iran with Libya chosen as the handy fall-guy, slipping that in on spec might have seemed worth a shot.

Right on. IF the radio was planted, we can deduce that intel knew of the Libyan link prior to that, so not too long after the purchase. The "Bombeat" part might have recommended it.

It suggests an early and tentative start - it's vague enough to pull back from if need be, but also capable of adding to any further Libyan implications. And of course these came in ... in fact the anomalous white plastic found with AG/145 I think fits this - an added spacer, an apparent different model, but left just an inch away and ready to turn, on the "discovery" of that manual cover and suddenly a bunch of black plastic.

Anyway, here is the remaining radio pic, the smaller of the two largest pieces of AG/145. Again, facing the Semtex, one inch away, and reportedly found blasted into the data plate halfway up the container's side:
AG-145_AlJazeera_C.jpg


Looking again at the board, and considering there capacitors and (??), I can see a case for these shielding small patches of board. I can also see a case for those melting and vaporizing the board instead. This is more a problem for PT/30, as AG/145 seem to be from right around the big thing (??), which looks more solid. BUT ... these are the labeled parts ("L106" etc) - are the shielded parts underneath that labeled, or only the visible (vulnerable) parts? Anyone want to weigh in on that? I think he could have picked more plausible stretched of the board to plant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom