I'm back on Mrs. Horton's recognition again. Yes, I agree about the brand recognition of Toshiba all right. However, the only letters that can be read look like IIBA. Indeed, if someone gave you that piece and said, what do you think the full manufacturer's name is, you wouldn't have much trouble coming up with the right answer. But that's not what happened.
Deccy and Geoff Horton are out in the Glebe field opposite their house one cold December morning, essentially litter-picking. It's not a single hugely important item she's seen and decided to preserve, they responded to an appeal for members of the public to go out and gather up all the stuff that had landed in that particular area. (This didn't have the importance of the identified debris trails in Scotland, where everything was done officially with two witnesses, this was just the light stuff that blew over to Northumberland.) They handed in two carrier bags full of stuff. This was just one of the bits that "went into the bag".
It's slightly surprising she would remember any particular piece under these circumstances. However, it seems she does. Here's what she says about it.
Camp Zeist said:
Q I would like to ask you about one item 23 in particular. Do you remember coming upon a document of some sort that made reference to a radio cassette player?
A Yes, I do.
Q Can you describe what that item was like?
A Well, from what I remember, it was possibly about -- I know I'm supposed to say it. About that kind of size, you know, about possibly eight by eight, or something like that, inches.
Q Could you see writing on it?
A I could see writing, because I remarked to my husband, "This appears to be from a cassette player," or something like that. I do remember it was something electrical.
Q And did you hand that item in to the police?
A Yes, that went into the bag as well.
Q Right. I wonder if you would look, please, at Label 24. You'll see there is a bag which contains items there. Do you recognise anything?
A Well, not in its present state. I'm sure when I handed it in, it was in one piece.
Q Perhaps -- I wonder if it could be put on the document imager, to see if we can see it. You can see within the police plastic bag, I think as you've described, more than one piece of a document. And you can at least see writing on it?
A Yes.
Q Do I understand you to say that when you handed it in, it was in one piece?
A It was in one piece, sir. I am practically sure of that, yes.
Q But apart from that, you recognise the item?
A Yes. Uh-huh.
Now let's look at what she is supposed to be describing.
First, the word "Toshiba" doesn't leap out from this. You'd have to work it out. But then Mrs. Horton doesn't say she saw the word Toshiba at all. "I do remember it was something electrical," is all she actually says.
My first thought is that this scrap is only about 5" by 3", and badly torn - almost all the way through in a couple of places. I imagine it would have been wet as well, after lying out in the field all night. I think a piece of paper like that would be memorable mostly for the care you'd have to take when picking it up, not to get it even more badly torn, or even have it disintegrate in your hand.
As Geni says, the tears don't look like forensic damage at all. And there is a photograph of the item before it was sent to the Met for forensic testing - if that showed something significantly different, something Mrs. Horton was going to look at and say, oh yes, that's what it looked like, why not produce that?
Look at the bolded part. "I know I'm supposed to say it." This is a coached witness. Hardly a surprise, all witnesses are coached to some extent. Somebody (in this case the prosecution team, as she was a prosecution witness) has to determine what the witness knows and what they intend to say in court. They've asked her to say the item she found was about the size of what's in the plastic bag. She does say, about that kind of size, then she says, about 8" by 8". What's in the bag is a fair bit smaller than that. It seems to me she's remembering picking up something larger, but dutifully agreeing it was "that kind of size". She's remembering picking up a sheet of paper virtually intact, not something in tatters and almost torn through in two places.
I think what strikes me about this is that is she looked at it closely enough at the time to see that it was "something electrical", and possibly to have read the words "cassette recorder", surely she would also have remembered the almost disintegrated state of the thing. And yet she doesn't. She's trying to tell the truth, but at the same time she knows there are certain things she's "supposed" to say.
This really does give me the impression of a witness who remembers seeing something quite different, but who is dutifully trying to identify the item shown to her. Does she even remember seeing the words "cassette recorder" originally, or has she acquired that from looking at the court exhibit or a photo of it during an interview? From looking at this, we can't even say the original item picked up was from a Toshiba. Just "something electrical".
How dangerous would it have been to make a fairly radical substitution like this? I think not at all. Suppose Mrs. Horton was approached about finding this item, and said, "Oh no, I remember what I picked up, it said 'Panasonic' on it. This definitely isn't that." Well, bugger. But it was worth a try. Sorry, madam, there must have been some mix-up, apologies for troubling you. And Mrs. Horton doesn't get that nice trip to Utrecht.
If she'd said she didn't remember the item at all, but of course it might have been one of the things she put in that bag that morning, they could still have used it. That was probably the most likely outcome, I think, and possibly why Geoff wasn't called. But as it was, she was prepared (or suggestible and helpful enough) to give an identification. Except she didn't.
There's just so much wrong with this.
Rolfe.