I experience, therefore I am

I haven't understood half of the things in this thread...

I suspect it's because I'm American, and because English doesn't seem to be Maartenn's primary language, and of course because there seems to be a lot of woo and fallacious arguments mixed together. Since other people seem to have some sort of clue of whats going on, I'm going to suspect it's mostly the first one. :P

I feel like we need to start over and go back to the basics here. Like that A=A, and that the purpose of language is communication. And then after a while make our way on to issues like what exactly a deductive argument is, and what arguments are fallacious... No?

Perhaps, but I would not hold my breath waiting for clarity of thought or expression. For teaching to work, one has to acknowledge the need for it.
 
Wow, I feel like bursting into song or something. Inna gadda da vida! We are the world! Giveum all a coke! God, it's God, I see God!


I think it's more like, "This is the dawning of the age of Aquarius, the age of Aquarius, Aquariuuus...!"
 
The one who seeks for it in the visible world will not find it.
Because the fools do not use Theoscience*. All it takes is an anecdote and a sandwich, for crying out loud!

The One Who search for it in the Invisible Nature of this world, It will reveal itself to Him or Her.
^This!

It's so self-evident, you materialistic fools. Use a depsipictor and a steady hand. Or a FLIR camera. (Hisss, material science, hissss.) Hold the FLIR in a spectral chi ball between open palms in prayer position Omega.
(Whatever you do, do not adopt the Gothic form of prayer position Gamma. To do that is to invite choas.)

The Universe has ways to reveal itself, a materialist cannot even imagine...
Yes. Immaterialists have so much so show you all. The snorblarfs nand zink fleemoofs. You will not only not know!


* I joke about a lot but never about Theoscience. It's a totally actual thing.
 
So, there is a Hidden Door in this world.
A dark territory.
An Invisible World wich can only be entered,
when you are this sort of materials.

Otherwise there is no Key to this Door.
To Be or not to be.

You are this Door or you are not.

There is only one Portal to this Kingdom.

It's a World wich cannot be described in material terms only.
We have no words for this area of knowledge.

yet This World exists,
and it is real.

Would you please drop the word salad and explain what the hell it is you mean ?
 
I beiieve that when you can stay focused when you use drugs, the patterns in the 'language of images in your mind' will reveal some fears, some wishes, and hidden feelings you may not have seen.

Or the drug alters your mind and what you experience doesn't mean squat.

I have no math nor material language

Learn some, before you assume that what you don't know doesn't exist.
 
<snip>

Imagine a very sophisticated computer-robot with scanners, scientists and engineers only can dream about.

How is this thing going to discover 'dreams' in Nature on its own? It's a computer wich can generate information and integrate this information is better mathematical models.

By mapping the world on it's own, it can make maps of our nervesystem and brain with mathematical models you only can dream about.
It can scan things in this world, our best tools can't scan.

But it can never discover 'dreaming' in this world.
It will never be able to discover 'consciousness' in this world.
It will never find 'Us' in the material world.

Because it has no language for it and we have no language to explain Us to him. (it)

We are gibberisch to this thing.
And IT will interprete your word 'pane' or 'being sad' as gibberish or foolish nonsense from idiotic inferior bad information gathering systems.


(Sorry if this has been said, I'm still on the first page of this thread: the first few posts following the quoted post above seem to be ignoring this, so I will jump in with this):


I saw a programme on telly a few months ago discussing research into AI, and the efforts are going into "growing" an artificial mind by setting up initial conditions and then allowing the "mind" to learn through interacting with its environment, much like a toddler in a playroom. The robot learns language along with physical action, and it interacts with humans during that process.

As time goes on, the "mind" that is developed through this process builds a world view. Since humans are part of its world view, it will of necessity model the minds of the humans it deals with (thus replicating the most likely route through which humans evolved the intelligence to imagine the thoughts of others), and in this way the AI will learn about emotions.

The main thing I wanted to say is that the programme showed a graph of a "landscape" of different energy states which was a representation of the working of the robot's "brain", and areas where the energy was high were peaks, and there were troughs in between where "energy" (or activity or potential or something) was more sparse. The whole changes dynamically, with feedback, and the peaks get progressively strengthened over time. Now, learning demands an ability to access new states, or to move through new pathways, but as time goes on the pattern of peaks gets increasingly "locked in", causing a loss of ability to be "creative" and to "learn".

This is the crux: What they find is that the "brain" of the computer periodically undergoes a sort of meltdown, a fibrillation of the whole landscape which shakes down the peaks and frees up the connection pathways to refresh! The computer basically has a dream!
 
Indeed, asydhouse: a material description, that's all it can offer us. Good, but not good enough.

Chemicals can poison our minds, so my advice: don't use it, when you don't need it.
But it's been used by sjamanists, priests, monks, boedhists and many people today and in the past for spiritual purposes.

So, for spirtual purposes only. (or relaxation or health) I would say:)

What you see with it has a language of its own: the language of dreams, or parabales and farytales.

Don't look at it with the eye of the materialist, Daffyd or Elisabeth I.

Don't take it literally. That's the danger. Most of the time we cannot grasp it and it comes and goes very fast, before we understand what it wants to reveal to us and before we can make words from it, it's gone.

But it has meaning. It has something to tell you. There are revelations about yourself in it.
Your life, your fears, feelings, wishes, desires, the most important people in your life, and maybe other things we do not yet understand.

This is a part of Nature Our best detector cannot detect. The math cannot describe it,

but only your Inner Eye can witness Its hidden existence.

Priests, sjamanists and the Pythia and others took this language too literally for too long. They looked at it with the same eye to survive in this world. The eye of the materialist. Do not take it literally.
The Inner Eye may not be like the material eye. They have different origines and different functions.

Daffyd and Elisabeth I,

You were right about the Seeing Stones made by Feanor of the Noldor, made by the Elves of Valinor, in the old days of The Lord of the Rings. But the palantir of Orthanc was used by Sauron to poison the mind of Saruman. You must had the hart and the mind to resist it. That's the only analogy I wanted to make. It's an analogy, don't take it literally. Don't interprete it with the eye of the materialist.


Don't get me wrong: science is very useful in Our lives. It can make us survive in the material world. We need it. But, it cannot describe everything wich exists. I was a little bit radical against 'materialism'. But I'm fine with it.

it's a very good tool in this world, but it cannot describe the Most Important thing in this world: You, Daffyd.
That's all. But that's a lot.

None of us is 'a pure materiallist'. When I use this word, I mean: the idealised materialist who does not exist,
without a mind, without experieces and without awareness. Without qualia. A philosophical zombie.

This zombie has only two tools of knowledge: following the math and verifiable evidence.

He cannot discover the Invisible Nature of some material things in this world.
But you can call this zombie a creature of darkness. IT has no eye for You.

You can use its tools and its dark language to survive in this world.
But You do not exist in his world. You are useless for his models. IT does not need your existence. No words for you. Nonsense. You are gibberish to him.

Your Inner Eye sees a world behind his comprehension. It's nonsense for him.
But Our Inner Eye can witness Its existence and its value.



The materialistic tools are limited to describe everything wich exists in this world.
So, every model, constructed with these cold material tools must be wrong or incomplete. We are not part of it.
 
Last edited:
It takes the form of powerful images and feelings, indeed. Of creatures from farytales and old stories.
Did you not know that a few images with a certain emotion can tell us more in one second,
than hundred words can reveal us in five mintues.
Maybe this knowledge is behind your comprehension.
But our forefathers, sjamanists and many other spiritual societies knew that the language of our mind is pictures and feelings.
It's new to you obviously, but it's an old wisdom.
Behind your comprehension, I see.
This wisdom is been lost, and the images were taken to literally. They interpreted it with the eye of the materialist.
The biggest mistake they made.
 
Last edited:
It takes the form of powerful images and feelings, indeed. Of creatures from farytales and old stories.


That isn't a language. It's an hallucination.

This wisdom is been lost...


That's probably why life expectancies are so much greater these days, for example. In the good old days people were wise enough to die young.
 
It takes the form of powerful images and feelings, indeed. Of creatures from farytales and old stories.
Did you not know that a few images with a certain emotion can tell us more in one second,
than hundred words can reveal us in five mintues.
Maybe this knowledge is behind your comprehension.
But our forefathers, sjamanists and many other spiritual societies knew that the language of our mind is pictures and feelings.
It's new to you obviously, but it's an old wisdom.
Behind your comprehension, I see.
This wisdom is been lost, and the images were taken to literally. They interpreted it with the eye of the materialist.

Is that why life expectancy was so short back then? Because they were so wise?
 
So, we all know that when we scan a chemical and electric process in the brain, that the mathematical model we make of this process and the chemical system is not the only thing there is.

There is something else too at the same time.

We know this.
Because we are such materials.
We know that these materials are also consciousness, dreams, awareness, mind...

The only tool we have to discover this part of reality is
being these materials.


It seems you are saying that our sense of self is the "consciousness". You are saying that the phenomenon we call our minds is not simply the chemical processes which give rise to the mind, but the actual "sense" of self we have when we are focussed on ourselves.

I have no problem with that: Our sense of self is an emergent higher-level property of the chemical processes in the brain/body complex we call our bodies. You could characterise our sense of self as an informational entity. At the level of self-reflectivity, we are information.

You are arguing that only an entity that is composed of the same materials as us can "know" what it is to be us. But by your own argument, since our minds are informational objects, and the robot I described in my previous post is also manipulating information in order to grow into the AI it will hopefully become, that AI will be in exactly the same boat as we are: a substrate of physical material which gives rise to an emergent higher-level informational entity.

What's your problem with this? :confused:
 
Last edited:
It seems you are saying that our sense of self is the "consciousness". You are saying that the phenomenon we call our minds is not simply the chemical processes which give rise to the mind, but the actual "sense" of self we have when we are focussed on ourselves.

I have no problem with that: Our sense of self is an emergent higher-level property of the chemical processes in the brain/body complex we call our bodies. You could characterise our sense of self as an informational entity. At the level of self-reflectivity, we are information.

You are arguing that only an entity that is composed of the same materials as us can "know" what it is to be us. But by your own argument, since our minds are informational objects, and the robot I described in my previous post is also manipulating information in order to grow into the AI it will hopefully become, that AI will be in exactly in the same boat as we are: a substrate of physical material which gives rise to an emergent higher-level informational entity.

What's your problem with this? :confused:

He can't have a problem with something that he completely ignores. He has ignored the links showing that his claim about perception and scientific language was wrong.
 
Indeed, asydhouse: a material description, that's all it can offer us. Good, but not good enough.

Chemicals can poison our minds, so my advice: don't use it, when you don't need it.
But it's been used by sjamanists, priests, monks, boedhists and many people today and in the past for spiritual purposes.

So, for spirtual purposes only. (or relaxation or health) I would say:)

What you see with it has a language of its own: the language of dreams, or parabales and farytales.

Don't look at it with the eye of the materialist, Daffyd or Elisabeth I.

Don't take it literally. That's the danger. Most of the time we cannot grasp it and it comes and goes very fast, before we understand what it wants to reveal to us and before we can make words from it, it's gone.

But it has meaning. It has something to tell you. There are revelations about yourself in it.
Your life, your fears, feelings, wishes, desires, the most important people in your life, and maybe other things we do not yet understand.

This is a part of Nature Our best detector cannot detect. The math cannot describe it,

but only your Inner Eye can witness Its hidden existence.

Priests, sjamanists and the Pythia and others took this language too literally for too long. They looked at it with the same eye to survive in this world. The eye of the materialist. Do not take it literally.
The Inner Eye may not be like the material eye. They have different origines and different functions.

Daffyd and Elisabeth I,

You were right about the Seeing Stones made by Feanor of the Noldor, made by the Elves of Valinor, in the old days of The Lord of the Rings. But the palantir of Orthanc was used by Sauron to poison the mind of Saruman. You must had the hart and the mind to resist it. That's the only analogy I wanted to make. It's an analogy, don't take it literally. Don't interprete it with the eye of the materialist.


Don't get me wrong: science is very useful in Our lives. It can make us survive in the material world. We need it. But, it cannot describe everything wich exists. I was a little bit radical against 'materialism'. But I'm fine with it.

it's a very good tool in this world, but it cannot describe the Most Important thing in this world: You, Daffyd.
That's all. But that's a lot.

None of us is 'a pure materiallist'. When I use this word, I mean: the idealised materialist who does not exist,
without a mind, without experieces and without awareness. Without qualia. A philosophical zombie.

This zombie has only two tools of knowledge: following the math and verifiable evidence.

He cannot discover the Invisible Nature of some material things in this world.
But you can call this zombie a creature of darkness. IT has no eye for You.

You can use its tools and its dark language to survive in this world.
But You do not exist in his world. You are useless for his models. IT does not need your existence. No words for you. Nonsense. You are gibberish to him.

Your Inner Eye sees a world behind his comprehension. It's nonsense for him.
But Our Inner Eye can witness Its existence and its value.



The materialistic tools are limited to describe everything wich exists in this world.So, every model, constructed with these cold material tools must be wrong or incomplete. We are not part of it.

I'll take everything that exists and you can have the rest.
 
It takes the form of powerful images and feelings, indeed. Of creatures from farytales and old stories.
Did you not know that a few images with a certain emotion can tell us more in one second,
than hundred words can reveal us in five mintues.

Yes, that is a brain process. What is mystical about it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom