I experience, therefore I am

It's no language at all, just new age guff.

Let us go thru the Hidden Door, the Portal into the land beyond the event horizon of the formless, the Elysian Fields where the fairies in the foliage play.
 
Let us go thru the Hidden Door, the Portal into the land beyond the event horizon of the formless, the Elysian Fields where the fairies in the foliage play.

How did Maartenn find this Door that is always Hidden? If it's hidden then how does he know that it is there? Who told him?
 
Last edited:
tsig is like the phylosophical zombie. Like this demon of the underworld.
Whenever you try to tell him about your existence, it terrorises its models.

Tsig cannot understand that he is the Universe.
Everything about Tsig is Universe. His inner and outer world is Nature.

So whatever comes in his mind, when he asks questions,
comes from the Universe.

But Tsig cannot understand that the Universe has its own language.
That he needs to decode it.

There are herbes or plants which can slow your mind.
And it's not bad to find ways to slow your mind.
Meditation, relaxation, can help you. You don't need drugs.

When you slow your mind, you can see better what the Universe has to tell you.
And these insights are sometimes very amazing and very powerful.

But you forget them. They are too complex to translate them in words.
Our language is llmited. Our memory can not keep them to write it down.

Before you think about a word to describe what the Universe revealed you,
another amazing insight comes in your mind.

It comes and it goes and you cannot keep it with you. it's powerful.

So, when you think about intuïtion, thoughtexperiments and images of the mind as 'foolish nonsense',
stay in the dark.

These pearls are not for swines.
 
Last edited:
And they were all steeped in mysticism. Maartenn seems to have a rose coloured view of our nasty, short and brutish past.

Waking at dawn, eating mush and following a horse's behind around all day plowing the fields confers mystical wisdom.

I grew up on a farm and attained wisdom at the age of 15 and left.
 
Tsig cannot understand that he is the Universe.


He is?

OK, I'll accept that for the sake of argument, and see where it leads us.

But Tsig cannot understand that the Universe has its own language.
That he needs to decode it.


If Tsig is, as you claim, the universe, that would be his own language. Why would he need to decode it?

There are herbes or plants which can slow your mind.


Are these herbs and plants growing inside Tsig? If not, they don't exist, because you have defined the universe as Tsig.

When you slow your mind, you can see better what the Universe has to tell you.


Why would Tsig need to see what the universe has to tell him? You have already said that Tsig is the universe.
 
Tsig doesn't need to see anything if he doesn't want to.
He is a free human being.

But...

When you found ways to slow your mind for a moment.
You find yourself a deep state of relaxation.
Powerful images with particular feelings reveal themselves to you.
You want to write it down or translate it to words,
But, the following amazing images are suddenly there
And you forgot the previous once.

That's how the Universe reveals things to you.
But, you don't have to write it down or to tell anyone about it.
Most of the time, you forget them.

You can keep this wisdom for yourself if you want to.
 
Last edited:
tsig is like the phylosophical zombie. Like this demon of the underworld.
Whenever you try to tell him about your existence, it terrorises its models.

Tsig cannot understand that he is the Universe.
Everything about Tsig is Universe. His inner and outer world is Nature.

So whatever comes in his mind, when he asks questions,
comes from the Universe.

But Tsig cannot understand that the Universe has its own language.
That he needs to decode it.

There are herbes or plants which can slow your mind.
And it's not bad to find ways to slow your mind.
Meditation, relaxation, can help you. You don't need drugs.

When you slow your mind, you can see better what the Universe has to tell you.
And these insights are sometimes very amazing and very powerful. But you forget them. They are too complex to translate them in words. Our language is llmited. Our memory can not keep them to write it down. Before you think about a word to describe what the Universe revealed you, another amazing insight comes in your mind. It comes and it goes and you cannot keep it with you. it's powerful. So, when you think about intuïtion, thoughtexperiments and images of the mind as 'foolish nonsense',
stay in the dark.

These pearls are not for swines.

Which is another way of saying your mind filled with useless trash you can't use once you wake up again. Or bad art.

It's of course trivially true that the universe is everything, so of course if we hear something we hear the universe. Many before have figured out how to hear it. The trick, of course, is to understand it, and as we see so conspicuously here, that is not the same.
 
When you slow your mind, you can see better what the Universe has to tell you.
And these insights are sometimes very amazing and very powerful.

But you forget them. They are too complex to translate them in words.
Our language is llmited. Our memory can not keep them to write it down.

I know exactly what you mean.

Also, what's the use?
The impression these slowed-down experiences leave in one's mind is slippery. There's no lasting connection.

It's almost as if they were mere illusion. A storm in the brain.

If you can elucidate these profundities in the now, in the noise and velocity of the busy world, then do so. Many have tried; some get close. Musicians mostly.

Perhaps there's vital knowledge to be had there. Sam Harris thinks so and I don't disagree, but it's important to know that it's all material regardless of how weird the experience.
 
When you found ways to slow your mind for a moment.
You find yourself a deep state of relaxation.
Powerful images with particular feelings reveal themselves to you.
You want to write it down or translate it to words,
But, the following amazing images are suddenly there
And you forgot the previous once.

That's how the Universe reveals things to you.

No. Do you really think that all our knowledge of the universe has been revealed by people relaxing? Quite the opposite. Please share some the of the things that you have learned about the universe by relaxing. I'll bet that relativity is not one of them.
 
Last edited:
You have claimed that Tsig is the universe. If this is so, then Tsig can't see anything but Tsig, bacause nothing else exists.

And Tsig is a philosophical zombie at the same time. So the universe must be a philosophical zombie.
 
As part of a volunteer program, I used to teach the basics of ecology to sixth graders. Part of that curriculum was to start with a simple blackboard drawing of some basic components of an ecosystem (the sun, a cloud, a lake, some plants, some animals, the air, the soil), and then draw arrows on it pointing out the interactions and interdependencies. Plants to air, air to plants, animals to soil, the cloud to the lake, and so forth until the picture is a tangle of arrows.

Why am I mentioning this? Because there was a time when that sort of understanding of an ecosystem was "mystical" knowledge of the highest order. In past eras, after a lifetime of observing nature in a holistic way, one might correctly perceive that the processes of the natural world are based on cycles and flows, but this required considerable insight and a leap of faith or two, because many of the specific details were invisible. People didn't know what oxygen was, or nitrogen or carbon, or energy, or genes or evolution. They had to guess at some of the connections. And if they guessed wrong here and there, such as thinking that life energy is something that is drawn in from the air with your breath (a partial truth), or something that flows in currents through the ground, they still had a truer "big picture" than most.

I think mysticism as applied to subjective experience is going the same way. Neuroscience is gradually filling in some of the connections in how our subjective selves work, which is going to sharpen and de-romanticize the understandings derived from everyday reflection and from mystical practices.

In ecology, the mystical view of extant pervasive cycles and flows was in conflict with the prevailing view in which transactions with gods were necessary to complete any given cycle (e.g. the gods must send the rain, or make the crops grow, perhaps in return for worship or sacrifices). Mystics were correspondingly less theistic than most others at the time. Mysticism was thus a path toward atheism, although it was rarely followed that far outside of east Asia.

Mysticism applied to the mind and subjective experience has many parallels there as well. There, the prevailing hypothesis that will be rendered unnecessary as "natural philosophy" fills in the gaps is the "magic-puppet hypothesis," the idea that the subjective self is a supernatural entity that originates outside the material brain and attaches to it or is projected into it, which also implies a supernatural realm where it originates. (And other supernatural entities populating that realm, and rules for returning to that realm after death, and so forth.)

As with the nature-gods hypothesis, though, the magic-puppet hypothesis is not a central tenet of mysticism, but the point that mysticism departs from. When yoked to religion, it doesn't depart very far (so, for instance, "Christian mysticism" results in detailed catalogues of the layers of hell and the species of angels), but more open-minded mysticism can lead to better insight about the nature and origin of the subjective self. For example, mystics were the first to question whether time actually exists as we experience it, and whether our subjective selves are as separate from the surrounding environment as they superficially appear. No doubt cognitive neuroscience will fill in some details and straighten out some wrong guesses, but I predict that just as with ecology, the understanding that ultimately results will be a mysical one -- even if no one calls it that any more.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Surely some mistake there. Who is posting this?


Either we are all Tsig's sockpuppets, or Maartenn100's claim that Tsig is the universe is wrong. The latter involves proposing that entities other than Tsig exist; the former doesn't. What would William of Ockham do?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom