"Humiliating" the Arabs? And if so... so what?

a_unique_person said:


Once again, the false dichotomy. How many times do I have to say I don't care for Saddam, but for the process that should be followed. 1,000,000 more times?
We'll have to keep defending that view against anti-Americans...no one said that freedom was cheap, did they?
 
Zero said:
If you were a kitten, I'd trade you for a puppy...and then I would drown the puppy.

But if the "shoe was on the other foot"? Wouldn't the puppy be protected by the Geneva Convnetions and entitled to trial? Whatever happened to the golden rule, Zero?

I see the appeal of your arguments... strawmen can be fun!

Your idea of "objectivity" is laughably clear. By all means keep digging.
 
Zero said:
We'll have to keep defending that view against anti-Americans...no one said that freedom was cheap, did they?


All this proves is that both you and AUP can't be bothered to actually read the article you both keep referencing. Freedom isn't cheap, but willful ignorance is priceless.
 
Jocko said:


But if the "shoe was on the other foot"? Wouldn't the puppy be protected by the Geneva Convnetions and entitled to trial? Whatever happened to the golden rule, Zero?

I see the appeal of your arguments... strawmen can be fun!

Your idea of "objectivity" is laughably clear. By all means keep digging.
You missed the whole'if you were a kitten'...I hold a different standard for non-human animals...if you were a human I would try to teach you why you were so horribly wrong in your viewpoints.
 
Jocko said:



All this proves is that both you and AUP can't be bothered to actually read the article you both keep referencing. Freedom isn't cheap, but willful ignorance is priceless.
Again, a pathetic attempt, can't you do better? You have a hard time with the rule of law and human rights...
 
Zero said:
Again, a pathetic attempt, can't you do better? You have a hard time with the rule of law and human rights...

Yes, my pathetic attempts to enlighten you with the very sources you casually throw around.

I corrected your error about whether or not Saddam was a POW, citing the man who speaks for the US military. Then I supplied you with the full wording of article 4 of the Geneva Conventions.

And each time, I get the same rote response: Is that all ya got?

Yes, Zero, that's all I got. It's also all the UN has got, the US has got, and the "rule of law" (outside planet Zero, that is) has got. Since you choose to ignore where your position errs on pretty much every conceivable point, I guess there's nothing more I can do.

There's certainly something pathetic about the whole thing. You're right about that much, at least.
 
Jocko said:
Uh, well here's one. Saddam is not a POW and therefore not protected by the Geneva Conventions. Everyone knows that.
Do we?

Rumsfeld, Monday:

He continued: “He (Saddam) is being accorded the protections of a prisoner of war and his treatment will be governed by the Geneva Convention.”
http://www.breakingnews.ie/2003/12/15/story125698.html

Rumsfeld, Wednesday:

Rumsfeld said Saddam is "being accorded the protection of a POW but he's not being legally described as one at this stage."
http://www.montereyherald.com/mld/m...69.htm?template=contentModules/printstory.jsp

Jocko, you seem to be more sure then even Rumsfeld (not that he is an ubiased expert on the field). Are you really sure 'everyone knows' that he's not a POW - or that he is not protected by the Geneva Convention?

Further, since Rumsfeld repeatedly says Saddam is being protected as if he was a prisoner of war, the following should apply to the situation:

U.S. Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld said that under the Geneva Conventions, it's illegal for prisoners to be videotaped and subjected to "public curiosity."
:confused:
 
Jocko said:


Yes, my pathetic attempts to enlighten you with the very sources you casually throw around.

I corrected your error about whether or not Saddam was a POW, citing the man who speaks for the US military. Then I supplied you with the full wording of article 4 of the Geneva Conventions.

And each time, I get the same rote response: Is that all ya got?

Yes, Zero, that's all I got. It's also all the UN has got, the US has got, and the "rule of law" (outside planet Zero, that is) has got. Since you choose to ignore where your position errs on pretty much every conceivable point, I guess there's nothing more I can do.

There's certainly something pathetic about the whole thing. You're right about that much, at least.
All you have is nothing. Well, no, you have a hatred for the rule of law when it conflicts with your biases.

Thanks, Bjorn, good post...I wonder how Jocko deals with it.
 
Bjorn said:
Do we?

Rumsfeld, Monday:

http://www.breakingnews.ie/2003/12/15/story125698.html

Rumsfeld, Wednesday:

http://www.montereyherald.com/mld/m...69.htm?template=contentModules/printstory.jsp

Jocko, you seem to be more sure then even Rumsfeld (not that he is an ubiased expert on the field). Are you really sure 'everyone knows' that he's not a POW - or that he is not protected by the Geneva Convention?

Further, since Rumsfeld repeatedly says Saddam is being protected as if he was a prisoner of war, the following should apply to the situation:

:confused:

Understood. But the distinction... the RULE OF LAW, as Zero would pout, is that he does not qualify as a POW. If we are treating him as such, it is voluntarily and not due to Geneva requirements.

Rumsfeld may not fit your profile of "objective," but the fact remains that he is the voice of the administration in these matters. Objectively, the Geneva Conventions do not protect enemy leaders. That only supports my position.

It also bears mentioning that the tapes were made and aired before the statement, and before this unofficial POW status was conferred. Just because we are treating him as a POW doesn't make him a POW acccording to the "RULE OF LAW (TM)."

For instance, one can't help treating Zero like a petulant child; that doesn't make him a toddler.
 
Jocko said:


Understood. But the distinction... the RULE OF LAW, as Zero would pout, is that he does not qualify as a POW. If we are treating him as such, it is voluntarily and not due to Geneva requirements.

Rumsfeld may not fit your profile of "objective," but the fact remains that he is the voice of the administration in these matters. Objectively, the Geneva Conventions do not protect enemy leaders. That only supports my position.

It also bears mentioning that the tapes were made and aired before the statement, and before this unofficial POW status was conferred. Just because we are treating him as a POW doesn't make him a POW acccording to the "RULE OF LAW (TM)."

For instance, one can't help treating Zero like a petulant child; that doesn't make him a toddler.
Funny, treating you as an ignorant punk seems to fit perfectly...:p

You don't find anything odd about the slip-sliding standards, and the double standards?
 
Jocko said:


Uh, well here's one. Saddam is not a POW and therefore not protected by the Geneva Conventions. Everyone knows that. Any similarity between the rules of the conventions and the treatment he's getting reflects well on US treatment of the murderous bastard, not ill.

It doesn't take much to see the difference between the POW tapes and Saddam's treatment. Was he shown with marks from fresh beatings? Was he forced to read a statement at gunpoint? Is he being denied medical care?

Did they videotape his slow decapitation with a knife, ala Daniel Pearl, and release it to friendly media outlets as a warning to the infidels? Your allegations are quite whacked, Zero. Again, this is all moot because the SOB ain't a POW. Period.

Jeez, they showed him getting checked for lice. If that's so bloody sensitive, then boo-freakin-hoo for them.

There would hardly be one person here who wouldn't have been horrified at what happened to Daniel Pearl. Then again, many Muslims/Arabs would be too. For what purpose are you comparing the treatment of Saddam by a supposedely civilised country with that inflicted on Pearl by terrorists picking on a reporter?
 
a_unique_person said:


There would hardly be one person here who wouldn't have been horrified at what happened to Daniel Pearl. Then again, many Muslims/Arabs would be too. For what purpose are you comparing the treatment of Saddam by a supposedely civilised country with that inflicted on Pearl by terrorists picking on a reporter?
This is that same moral relativism that seems to afflict the right-wingers these days, that attitude of "so long as we are not as bad as the worst case scenario, our behavior is acceptable."
 
a_unique_person said:


Haven't you heard, the conservatives don't believe in moral relativism.

Which conservatives? I'm guessing by your comment you meant each and everyon single one of them. But damn if that don't leave you even more open to a legit counter to your claim. so I challange you to name all the conservatives that do not believe in mora realativism, and then admit your moronic error when one tells you that they do and that you are wrong.

I'm really getting as sick of seeing this sort of weak assed ◊◊◊◊ pass for a legitimate post as I am of those from the other side of the political spectrum making morons like you think they speak for all.

Frankly, your inability to see things as they are and comment on them, as opposed to seeing things how you wish they would be and commenting against others that disagree with your fantasy, isa starting to bore the hell out of me.
 
The media has been full of conservative articles since 9/11 from opionionmeisters about how "moral relativism" is the scourge of our times. Now when it suits, it is time to roll it out. Not following proper procedures is OK in the case of Saddam. It is the US that constantly claims the moral high ground.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person:
Now when it suits, it is time to roll it out. Not following proper procedures is OK in the case of Saddam. It is the US that constantly claims the moral high ground.

What proper procedures haven't or aren't been followed?
 
Jocko said:


Understood. But the distinction... the RULE OF LAW, as Zero would pout, is that he does not qualify as a POW. If we are treating him as such, it is voluntarily and not due to Geneva requirements.

Rumsfeld may not fit your profile of "objective," but the fact remains that he is the voice of the administration in these matters. Objectively, the Geneva Conventions do not protect enemy leaders. That only supports my position.

It also bears mentioning that the tapes were made and aired before the statement, and before this unofficial POW status was conferred. Just because we are treating him as a POW doesn't make him a POW acccording to the "RULE OF LAW (TM)."

For instance, one can't help treating Zero like a petulant child; that doesn't make him a toddler.

Dubya has never declared the war to be over. He has only declared the major part of the conflict to be over. The war is still on.
 
a_unique_person said:


Dubya has never declared the war to be over. He has only declared the major part of the conflict to be over. The war is still on.

Irrelevant. The point is that Saddam is, ipso facto, not a POW. The fact that the authorities have conferred POW-like treatment, and are calling him such for lack of a better term, does not change the fact that he is not a POW, whether the W in question continues or not.

He ought to be thanking his lucky stars that we're being nicer than we have to be, which is why criticisms ring so hollow. As an enemy head of state, we could string him up wherever and whenever we pleased... and before you jump on the superiority horse, rest assured we won't and wouldn't. Anyone with a working mind would know that.
 
Jocko said:


Irrelevant. The point is that Saddam is, ipso facto, not a POW. The fact that the authorities have conferred POW-like treatment, and are calling him such for lack of a better term, does not change the fact that he is not a POW, whether the W in question continues or not.

He ought to be thanking his lucky stars that we're being nicer than we have to be, which is why criticisms ring so hollow. As an enemy head of state, we could string him up wherever and whenever we pleased... and before you jump on the superiority horse, rest assured we won't and wouldn't. Anyone with a working mind would know that.
What drives you to post this sort of thing? This isn't the Old West, where you gather up a posse, catch the bad guy and 'string him up'.
 
Zero said:
What drives you to post this sort of thing? This isn't the Old West, where you gather up a posse, catch the bad guy and 'string him up'.

No, you ignoramus. it's Article 4 of the Geneva Conventions, which I posted and you obviously ignored. Or is the Geneva Conventions now considered jungle law by you?

Get a grip. I should be asking you what drives you to post such errant nonsense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom