"Humiliating" the Arabs? And if so... so what?

Now, I don't have a problem with the images of Saddam after being captured.

But, think about this for a second. Many people in the middle east admire Saddam Hussein. Yes, as appalling as that may be, there are folks in that part of the world who think he is a matyr and a hero.
So, obviously they are going to be disturbed by the images. Would any of you be disturbed if you saw similar images of George Bush being examined and prodded by the enemy? Of course you would.
So, don't be so shocked and appalled that some people in the middle east are expressing their disgust. Can you really expect anything less?
Yes, we all know that Hussein is a ruthless, murderous dictator, but not everyone agress with us.

Again, this is not me advocating their point of view. Like I said, I don't have a problem with the images being shown.
But if you idealists out there really think that the whole world is going to share your opinion on the Saddam video then you're being pretty damn naive.
 
Basically, this is yet another case of Skeptic lying. At first I thought he was honest and wrong, but now I just think he's being intentionally dishonest. What he's posted is not what he says it is, as usual. People are saying that the videotapes of Saddam that are being shown are intentionally humiliating(not to mention being in violation of POW laws), not that bringing down the regime is humiliating. As usual, Skeptic reads into things what he wants to, and then attacks a strawman.

Maybe he's trying to get a job at Fox News?
 
Ed said:

I resent any suggestion that we sunk to the level of the Saddam regime. The comparison is odious.
Ed,

I am not equating the Saddam Regime with that of Bush nor am I supporting Saddam or his actions.

I believe that for the current killings to stop the Americans need to win the hearts and minds (to quote Bush) of the terrorists. Whether you understand it or not a lot of people in the world dislike the actions of the American nation. You have a simple choice either change their opinion or put up with the consequences i.e. fight a war on terror.

I think that showing Saddam having a medical exam was a deliberate choice. Yes they needed to show him, yes it needed to be a video, no it did not need to be him having a medical. If an American POW was shown having a medical I think we would have some Americans (and certainly the Government) criticising the Iraqis. I feel that it sends the wrong message out displaying arrogance. It says that the standards Americans expect to be treated with themselves do not apply when they treat others.
 
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Ed

I resent any suggestion that we sunk to the level of the Saddam regime. The comparison is odious.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, lets go through the checklist.

1. Using WMD to kill your enemies, check.
2. Killing millions in an invasion, check.
3. Subverting the democratic process, check.
4. Having no sense of shame about it all, check.

I can only go on the facts.
 
Wow, AUP, every time I think you've said the stupidest thing, you keep on talking.

a_unique_person said:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Ed

I resent any suggestion that we sunk to the level of the Saddam regime. The comparison is odious.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, lets go through the checklist.

1. Using WMD to kill your enemies, check.

Ah yes, that old cannard. We used the first anly only nuclear weapons to ever be used in war. Almost 60 years ago. This statement is meaningless: the situations aren't comparable, nobody had ever used (or even possesed) them before, and our present viewpoint on nuclear weapons has changed significantly.


2. Killing millions in an invasion, check.

Which millions, exactly, are you refering to? World war 1 or 2? Or are you claiming we killed millions of Iraqis? And is the fact that people were killed the only relevant factor, or does, perhaps, do the reasons matter (ie, Japan attacked us, Kuwait never attacked Iraq, etc.)? Seems to me like the reasons never matter to you. Maybe we should go lose some wars, I guess that might balance things out for you.


3. Subverting the democratic process, check.

Saddam never subverted the democratic process. He never HAD a democractic process. Duh.


4. Having no sense of shame about it all, check.

Ha! What a meaningless statement. Is this one of your "facts"?


I can only go on the facts.

If you ever do that, it would be a first.
 
Ziggurat said:
Wow, AUP, every time I think you've said the stupidest thing, you keep on talking.



Ah yes, that old cannard. We used the first anly only nuclear weapons to ever be used in war. Almost 60 years ago. This statement is meaningless: the situations aren't comparable, nobody had ever used (or even possesed) them before, and our present viewpoint on nuclear weapons has changed significantly.


Are you saying the US didn't use WMD on it's enemies?



Which millions, exactly, are you refering to? World war 1 or 2? Or are you claiming we killed millions of Iraqis? And is the fact that people were killed the only relevant factor, or does, perhaps, do the reasons matter (ie, Japan attacked us, Kuwait never attacked Iraq, etc.)? Seems to me like the reasons never matter to you. Maybe we should go lose some wars, I guess that might balance things out for you.


Vietnam might be a good start.



Saddam never subverted the democratic process. He never HAD a democractic process. Duh.


No, there was a democratic process, and it was subverted.



Ha! What a meaningless statement. Is this one of your "facts"?

 
Originally posted by a_unique_person
Are you saying the US didn't use WMD on it's enemies?

Which enemies, exactly? (and yes, I mean besides Japan). Since you're on a Vietnam kick, maybe you mean agent orange. I don't think that counts, though it is nasty stuff.


Vietnam might be a good start.

Are you talking total casualties, or kills for US forces alone? Got a good source for casualty breakdown?

Oh, and as to the other implication you make that's not exactly a "fact": we're not the same today as we were during the Vietnam war. But then, maybe you think that Saddam changed his ways, saw the error in being a homicidal tyrant, and decided to pursue a path of peace.
 
a_unique_person said:


No, there was a democratic process, and it was subverted.


Pure curiosity. What was the democratic process? Not that silly vote before the war surely.
 
Mycroft said:


For someone who's just registered this month...
What can I say, Skeptic lies alot...or has he just been lying alot this month?
 
Zero said:
What can I say, Skeptic lies alot...or has he just been lying alot this month?

He doesn't lie at all. If he did, this wouldn't be an example of it. Pointing out that humiliating an enemy is a side-effect of defeating him is expressing an opinion, and even if you disagree with that opinion does not make it a lie.

Just as I'm not lying when I suggest that your history here is probably longer than your registration suggests. Even if my opinion is wrong, it is not a lie.
 
Luke T. said:
A still photo would have left room open that it wasn't Saddam. You can only get a feeling about what someone really looks like by motion pictures.
Did you see moving dinosaurs in Jurassic Park? I'm not saying that it wasn't Saddam, but even motion pictures CAN be contrived, no?
 
Mycroft said:


He doesn't lie at all. If he did, this wouldn't be an example of it. Pointing out that humiliating an enemy is a side-effect of defeating him is expressing an opinion, and even if you disagree with that opinion does not make it a lie.

Just as I'm not lying when I suggest that your history here is probably longer than your registration suggests. Even if my opinion is wrong, it is not a lie.
Actually, your opinion is wrong...but that's cool. Having an opinion 6that is wrong is one thing; basing your opinion on intentionally misreading things to suit your near-religious political beliefs is lying.
 
a_unique_person said:
Vietnam might be a good start.

A bit more than 50K Americans died in the Vietnam War. Although at the time we all had a good puke over the "kill ratios," I doubt they were 40 or more, which is what you'd need for "millions."
 
epepke said:


A bit more than 50K Americans died in the Vietnam War. Although at the time we all had a good puke over the "kill ratios," I doubt they were 40 or more, which is what you'd need for "millions."

Civilian losses were huge, and cannot be pinned down due to the nature of Vietnamese society. I have read estimates from 5 million to 1 million total. The "million" part is what Americans find hard to grasp. Also, fact that they didn't work in suits in a big tower in a city with video cameras everywhere. Compare "thousands" to "Millions".

Don't forget that the US used B52s, another WMD, to carry out carpet bombing of Hanoi and rural areas. The Viet Cong had no helicopters, bombers, fighter planes, navy, endless supplies of ammunition, heavy artillery, endless supplies of arms, heavy machine guns, etc.
 
Mycroft said:


He doesn't lie at all. If he did, this wouldn't be an example of it. Pointing out that humiliating an enemy is a side-effect of defeating him is expressing an opinion, and even if you disagree with that opinion does not make it a lie.

Just as I'm not lying when I suggest that your history here is probably longer than your registration suggests. Even if my opinion is wrong, it is not a lie.

Not so much lies, as blatant logical fallacies, his favourite being the strawman.
 
a_unique_person said:
Surely a fair and reasoned trial is the best way to expose Saddam for what he is.

Which will no doubt have a major impact on all those "fair and reasoned" people who worship him.

The trial will be for the civilized people of the world; showing Saddam for the beaten, pliant coward he is was for the minority who choose not to vest their judgment in the justice system.

Who says you can't have your cake and eat it too?
 
a_unique_person said:


Civilian losses were huge, and cannot be pinned down due to the nature of Vietnamese society. I have read estimates from 5 million to 1 million total. The "million" part is what Americans find hard to grasp. Also, fact that they didn't work in suits in a big tower in a city with video cameras everywhere. Compare "thousands" to "Millions".

Don't forget that the US used B52s, another WMD, to carry out carpet bombing of Hanoi and rural areas. The Viet Cong had no helicopters, bombers, fighter planes, navy, endless supplies of ammunition, heavy artillery, endless supplies of arms, heavy machine guns, etc.

And that's what you call facts, huh? Theories sprinkled with invective references to 9/11? May you never serve on my jury.

The B-52 is a bomber, not a bomb. I've never heard it called a WMD and your naming it as such sounds suspiciously like another "fact" that won't bear scrutiny. And I have no idea what your comparison to the NVC arsenal has to do with anything; is this another utopian application of fairness, where everyone should use rocks and spears? Explain, please.
 
a_unique_person said:


Not so much lies, as blatant logical fallacies, his favourite being the strawman.

Do be sure to remove the beam from your own eye before you point to the splinter in someone else's. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom