"Humiliating" the Arabs? And if so... so what?


Dubya has never declared the war to be over. He has only declared the major part of the conflict to be over. The war is still on.


As far as the Geneva convention is concerned, the war has been over since the Iraqi generals signed the instrument of general surrender in Mosul on April 28. Anybody captured after that is not a POW. It has nothing to do with "W" declaring anything.
 
Skeptic said:

Dubya has never declared the war to be over. He has only declared the major part of the conflict to be over. The war is still on.


As far as the Geneva accord is concerned, the war has been over since the Iraqi generals signed the instrument of general surrender in Mosul on April 28. It has nothing to do with "W" declaring anything.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/2989459.stm

Bush declares victory in Iraq

Cheers greeted Mr Bush's announcement of victory
US President George W Bush has said the US has prevailed in the Battle of Iraq in a speech on the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln.

He explicitly linked the conflict in the Gulf to the 11 September 2001 terror attacks on the United States.

.....

Earlier, Mr Bush's spokesman Ari Fleischer warned that the president's speech would not mark the end of hostilities "from a legal point of view".
 
My point precisely, AUP: W's declerations are not the legal basis for POW status. The instrument of surrender is.
 
AFAIK, although the US has accepted the surrender of those particular forces, it still regards itself as being at war, for legal reasons. Dubya is the leader of the armed forces. He has only ever declared that the major part of the hostilities are over.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/031105/140/ed34w.html

Wednesday November 5, 06:32 PM

Bush: 'We're Still At War With Iraq'
President Bush has admitted Saddam Hussein is alive and the Coalition is still effectively at war with Iraqi rebels.Saddam was "trying to stir up trouble" he said, as the number of American soldiers killed continues to rise.But he vowed the United States would track down the ousted Iraqi president.

"We'll get him, we'll find him," said Mr Bush.

Analysts said Mr Bush's remarks were his clearest acknowledgement to date that Saddam is alive and playing a role in the armed opposition to US forces.

Six months after declaring an end to major combat in Iraq, Mr Bush said: "We are at war."
 
Actually

In Japan we went to great lengths to prevent infringing on cultural taboos when they surrendered. Including having them sign the surrender on an American ship so they wouldn't be dishonored.
 
a_unique_person said:
AFAIK, although the US has accepted the surrender of those particular forces, it still regards itself as being at war, for legal reasons. Dubya is the leader of the armed forces. He has only ever declared that the major part of the hostilities are over.

Is this your basis for saying that the U.S. should not have shown video of a disheveled Saddam getting a swab taken of his mouth?
 
Mycroft said:


Is this your basis for saying that the U.S. should not have shown video of a disheveled Saddam getting a swab taken of his mouth?

The US has a big deal of the publication of dead soldiers, as it contravenes the 'rules' of war. Fair enough, this is not supposed to happen. Similary, you are not allowed to publish demeaning pictures of POWs. Saddam is a POW.

The US is indulging in the fallacy of "Special Pleading".
 
a_unique_person said:


The US has a big deal of the publication of dead soldiers, as it contravenes the 'rules' of war. Fair enough, this is not supposed to happen. Similary, you are not allowed to publish demeaning pictures of POWs. Saddam is a POW.

The US is indulging in the fallacy of "Special Pleading".

The appeal to authority is not a fallicy if the the authority is, indeed, an authority.

Special pleading is not a fallicy if the appeal really is special. Saddam, as leader of that country and the putative cause of remaining unrest is, in fact, "special". That, combined with the experience that the US had with disbelief at the deaths of his sons, certainly makes this a special case. This is so self evident as to begger the imagination. Do you think that he will be tried in a non-special way? Do you think that he is being held in non-special circumstances?
 
I usually call myself a leftie if I choose to label myself politically at all. For what it's worth. But here's my opinion on this issue:

The rules about POWs are there, as far as I'm concerned, to protect the poor bastards who do the fighting. They're just doing what they were told to do, and it's both inhumane and pointless to mistreat them once they've been captured and rendered harmless.

How you treat captured national leaders is a different issue. I'm not saying that "anything goes", but they aren't captured soldiers and so the same rules don't necessarily apply.
 
It is very strange that people are objecting to the videotaping of Saddam Hussein. Why do I have the feeling that if no video of Hussein had been released, these same people would be complaining about that? Conspiracy theories would be flying.
 
Luke T. said:
It is very strange that people are objecting to the videotaping of Saddam Hussein. Why do I have the feeling that if no video of Hussein had been released, these same people would be complaining about that? Conspiracy theories would be flying.

Close. Here's what would really happen:

If the U.S. captures Saddam but is slow in releasing video footage, those people would complain and conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and shows him looking well, people would complain that he's being pampered because he was an American puppet all along. Conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and shows him looking bad, people would complain that he's being bullied and humiliated ... and conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and does not release video footage, conspiracy theories would fly and people would complain.

Oh, I forgot one ... If the U.S. doesn't capture Saddam, conspiracy theories would fly and people would still complain.
 
Originally posted by Ed
The appeal to authority is not a fallicy if the the authority is, indeed, an authority.

Special pleading is not a fallicy if the appeal really is special. Saddam, as leader of that country and the putative cause of remaining unrest is, in fact, "special". That, combined with the experience that the US had with disbelief at the deaths of his sons, certainly makes this a special case. This is so self evident as to begger the imagination. Do you think that he will be tried in a non-special way? Do you think that he is being held in non-special circumstances?

And let's not forget, even if you were to agree it was a violation, it would be a minor violation at best.
 
Luke T. said:
It is very strange that people are objecting to the videotaping of Saddam Hussein. Why do I have the feeling that if no video of Hussein had been released, these same people would be complaining about that? Conspiracy theories would be flying.

A cleaned and processed Saddam. As you say, proof was needed that he is captured and being treated according to law.

All I am saying is that the process is important. It is the processes and institutions of law and democracy that give us our best promise of democratic freedom. Our habits of life. You toss these out for expedient purposes, then that too becomes a pattern of behaviour.
 
shuize said:


Close. Here's what would really happen:

If the U.S. captures Saddam but is slow in releasing video footage, those people would complain and conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and shows him looking well, people would complain that he's being pampered because he was an American puppet all along. Conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and shows him looking bad, people would complain that he's being bullied and humiliated ... and conspiracy theories would fly.

If the U.S. captures Saddam and does not release video footage, conspiracy theories would fly and people would complain.

Oh, I forgot one ... If the U.S. doesn't capture Saddam, conspiracy theories would fly and people would still complain.

You forgot the most important part: the real evil behind the US's behavior would be blamed, of course, on "zionist control" of the USA and "jewish control" of the media.

Wait, that's already happening in the Arab world. Never mind.
 
Skeptic said:


You forgot the most important part: the real evil behind the US's behavior would be blamed, of course, on "zionist control" of the USA and "jewish control" of the media.

Wait, that's already happening in the Arab world. Never mind.

There is plenty of evidence that a clique of Jewish extremists do have a enourmous influence over the US, the "neo-conservatives" have some prominent Zionists. This does no in way constitute a global Jewish conspiracy, but they are an important part of a world power that is running off the rails. Read the thread Cain started with the comments by Chomsky. (He's a Jew, isn't he?) Wolfowitz is not a very moral guy, as his support of the Suharto regime shows.

Your logic means that any actions by Jews that are not moral cannot ever be criticised, because that then constitutes an attack on all Jews, with the next step being sending all Jews off to the death camps. Get real. You are just like the cops who will never criticse another cop, no matter how corrupt they are.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person

There is plenty of evidence that a clique of Jewish extremists do have a enourmous influence over the US, the "neo-conservatives" have some prominent Zionists.

Who? Can you name names?
 
a_unique_person said:


There is plenty of evidence that a clique of Jewish extremists do have a enourmous influence over the US, the "neo-conservatives" have some prominent Zionists.

Oh, here we go. At least you're being open and direct about your antisemitism for once; I suppose that must be called an improvement of sorts. Please take your seat between Huzington in the "Stalin never killed anybody" section and that guy who thinks Oswald wasinnocent.

This does no in way constitute a global Jewish conspiracy, but they are an important part of a world power that is running off the rails.

Can't have it both ways. Which is it?

Read the thread Cain started with the comments by Chomsky. (He's a Jew, isn't he?) Wolfowitz is not a very moral guy, as his support of the Suharto regime shows.

Your logic means that any actions by Jews that are not moral cannot ever be criticised, because that then constitutes an attack on all Jews, with the next step being sending all Jews off to the death camps. Get real. You are just like the cops who will never criticse another cop, no matter how corrupt they are.

I'm Catholic and I happen to think "the jooz" (© Mycroft Productions) are very much the wronged party in the mideast conflict. So explain how I, a non-Zionist, could possibly feel this way? I mean, once your "they're all in on it together" theory is shot to hell, not much remains of your argument, does it?
 
Originally posted by Jocko
I'm Catholic and I happen to think "the jooz" (© Mycroft Productions) are very much the wronged party in the mideast conflict. So explain how I, a non-Zionist, could possibly feel this way? I mean, once your "they're all in on it together" theory is shot to hell, not much remains of your argument, does it?

Lol!

You see having the opinion that Israel got the shaft in the Mideast makes you a Zionist, Jew or not. Now if you happen to work in the media or the government, that makes you a member of the International Zionist Conspiracy, and your very existance becomes proof that the IZC© has undue influence somewhere.

IZC membership is cool. You get an ID card that gets you great discounts at many fine shops and if you maintain your membership in good standing for a few years, you can apply for membership in the Illuminati. Once in that club, your Catholic/Zionist credentials will lead to rapid advancement, and if you can add 32nd degree Mason to your resume, your career is made.
 
Mycroft said:


Lol!

You see having the opinion that Israel got the shaft in the Mideast makes you a Zionist, Jew or not. Now if you happen to work in the media or the government, that makes you a member of the International Zionist Conspiracy, and your very existance becomes proof that the IZC© has undue influence somewhere.

IZC membership is cool. You get an ID card that gets you great discounts at many fine shops and if you maintain your membership in good standing for a few years, you can apply for membership in the Illuminati. Once in that club, your Catholic/Zionist credentials will lead to rapid advancement, and if you can add 32nd degree Mason to your resume, your career is made.

I am not a JOOOOO either but I have a nice corresponding membership. I never pay retail.
 
Mycroft said:


Lol!

You see having the opinion that Israel got the shaft in the Mideast makes you a Zionist, Jew or not. Now if you happen to work in the media or the government, that makes you a member of the International Zionist Conspiracy, and your very existance becomes proof that the IZC© has undue influence somewhere.

IZC membership is cool. You get an ID card that gets you great discounts at many fine shops and if you maintain your membership in good standing for a few years, you can apply for membership in the Illuminati. Once in that club, your Catholic/Zionist credentials will lead to rapid advancement, and if you can add 32nd degree Mason to your resume, your career is made.

I am afraid that feeding off like minded opinion holders is the lowest form of fact validation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom