"Humiliating" the Arabs? And if so... so what?

Lothian said:
I agree he had to be shown. Why could they not have just shown a picture of him. Why did they show pictures of him having a swab taken? While I don’t agree such a picture humiliates the Arab race, it humiliates Saddam and does nothing to convince any of the terrorists that they will be fairly treated by the US forces

A still photo would have left room open that it wasn't Saddam. You can only get a feeling about what someone really looks like by motion pictures.

And he was receiving a medical exam. The guy looked like crap, he needed one. Did you notice they were also checking his hair for lice/fleas?

edited to add: I did not see any footage of Saddam having his mouth swabbed. I did see footage of a tongue depressor and asking him to go, "Ahhhhhh.")

This beats a picture of someone getting kicked in the face with their hands tied behind their back, doesn't it?

I think it is already well known in the Arab world from the Gulf War in 1991 how we treat our enemies, which is very well.
 
Luke T. said:


A still photo would have left room open that it wasn't Saddam. You can only get a feeling about what someone really looks like by motion pictures.

And he was receiving a medical exam. The guy looked like crap, he needed one. Did you notice they were also checking his hair for lice/fleas?

(edited to add: I did not see any footage of Saddam having his mouth swabbed. I did see footage of a tongue depressor and asking him to go, "Ahhhhhh.")

This beats a picture of someone getting kicked in the face with their hands tied behind their back, doesn't it?

I think it is already well known in the Arab world from the Gulf War in 1991 how we treat our enemies, which is very well.
 
"I wish it was a Hollywood movie, the wishful thinking of an American director," said Palestinian Salah Ahmed. "The scene of him being examined by American doctors was the most painful since his statues were destroyed."


:dl:


You poor thing. I’m sure some of your brethren will blow-up a bus full of Jews in a few days, that should make you feel better.
 
It's just another talking point they came up with. Democrats want Arabs to feel humiliated, so the only way to solve that problem will be to replace our military with the united nations.
 
I wonder if there was talk around France in 1781 about how much the North Americans must have resented French intervention in the United States...

"Those poor Anglo-Americans. They must have felt humiliated seeing reports of Lord Cornwallis' surrender. I suppose we will see Tory acts of terror rise in revenge on us, and we deserve it coming to us, too. We are just asking for it."
 
If Saddam's cowardly surrender brought shame to the Arab world, then this shame has one source and one source only: Saddam. I don't see how his hypocracy and lack of spine could it any way reflect badly on the US or the West.
 
DanishDynamite said:
If Saddam's cowardly surrender brought shame to the Arab world, then this shame has one source and one source only: Saddam. I don't see how his hypocracy and lack of spine could it any way reflect badly on the US or the West.

And don't forget he was captured with a pistol, he could easily have made sure no one ever saw him alive. If not by killing himself by shooting at the solders, a hand grenade in that little hole would made quite a mess.

Also he had something like 750,000 million, on him, if he really was so worried about his appearance he could easily have afforded a little Queer Eye for the Tyrant Guy.
 
Saddam's Arrest Brings Humiliation Debate

CAIRO, Egypt (AP) - Was he an Arab hero or a dictator? This is the question being debated in newspapers in the Middle East and by Arab intellectuals faced with the image of a bearded, bedraggled Saddam Hussein in the hands of American captors.

Many are asking, too, if Saddam's downfall was a humiliation to the entire Arab world, not just to the ousted Iraqi leader. Others say that with Saddam's capture, it's time to drop any expectation that a great hero will unite the Arab world.

``A new humiliation to Arabs'' was the headline on a column this week by Abdel Bari Atwan, editor of the London-based Arabic daily Al-Quds Al-Arabi.

``It was a shock for us, and a humiliation to millions of Arabs who saw the TV shots of the Iraqi president being subjected to the humiliating medical checkup. We hoped that he would have fought until the end, and fallen as a martyr like his two sons and grandson or chose Hitler's end,'' Atwan wrote, referring to the Nazi leader's suicide.

But Atwan was quick to find excuses for Saddam's succumbing to U.S. forces without a shot being fired after he was found in a spider-hole near his hometown of Tikrit.

``We only heard the American version of the story. Maybe they drugged him because if Saddam wanted to surrender this way, he would have ... accepted the many offers to leave power,'' Atwan wrote.

Instead, he added, Saddam had chosen ``to stand up to American arrogance.''

Apparently, many Arabs shared Atwan's view of Saddam's arrest on Saturday as a collective humiliation - and an intentional one.

In a telephone poll, the popular Arab satellite channel Al-Jazeera asked viewers if showing Saddam being probed by U.S. military doctors was meant to humiliate Arabs. Al-Jazeera said that of the 1,500 people who called in, 97 percent said it was.
 
Lothian said:

I think the point being made was to win hearts and minds of the rebels you don’t sink to the level of the Saddam Regime rather you show yourselves to be above it.

I resent any suggestion that we sunk to the level of the Saddam regime. The comparison is odious.
 
I think people who are claiming Arab humiliation areb't interpreting the videos correctly.

Saddam wasn't subjected to humiliation. He was humiliated. It was the state he was in when he was captured.

It was uncomfortable for me to watch, and I'm sure it was uncomfortable for others. People are transferring that discomfort and blaming the US for releasing those videos.

Not very rational, in my opinion.
 
Tony said:

Why? Out of curiosity.

I just get a squeamish reaction from seeing anyone in a humiliated state. Like I'm looking at an episode of someone's embarassing personal life.

It's just an empathetic emotional response.
 
Lothian said:
I agree he had to be shown. Why could they not have just shown a picture of him. Why did they show pictures of him having a swab taken? While I don’t agree such a picture humiliates the Arab race, it humiliates Saddam and does nothing to convince any of the terrorists that they will be fairly treated by the US forces

I think showing a picture of him with a swab in his mouth is a pretty minor humiliation, if it is at all. If this "humiliation" inspires more resistance and causes more problems, then I'd suggest that the degree of cultural sensitivity needed to avoid that is unatainable.

But if for the sake of argument we agree that the picture of him with a swab in his mouth was a humiliation, then you still have to answer the question: which is better for peace in Iraq? Wouldn't showing Saddam with the full dignity he had before the invasion be even more inspiring to Iraqi resistance?
 
specious_reasons said:


I just get a squeamish reaction from seeing anyone in a humiliated state. Like I'm looking at an episode of someone's embarassing personal life.

It's just an empathetic emotional response.

Here's a possible remedy the next time you feel that way about Saddam: Take a deap breath and slowly start counting to 60,000... the number of people he's reported to have ordered murdered in Bagdad alone.
 
shuize said:

Here's a possible remedy the next time you feel that way about Saddam: Take a deap breath and slowly start counting to 60,000... the number of people he's reported to have ordered murdered in Bagdad alone.

In no way am I sympathetic to Saddam. I hope you didn't infer that from my post.
 
The only Arabs that were really humiliated outside of Iraq for Saddam's capture were the silly Palestinians. Syrians did not like him. Not even Gadaffi liked him Iranians despised him. So did followers of al-Qaeda Saddam was just a phony muslim in their eyes. So IMHO al-Qaeda operatives would be rubbing their hands with glee with his capture. It is exactly what they wanted to Americans to do.
However Gihadi operatives like al-Qauda and JI would not willingly send their militia into Iraq while Saddam was in power because it would alienate the Palestinians, which is their principle front for their war against Israel. Now the Americans are in Iraq instead there are now millions of willing Gihadi volunteers to take them on as long as the Americans are an occupation force there just like the Mujahiddeen did to when they took on the mighty USSR in Afghanistan.


CDR
 
Lothian said:
The BBC suggested that the Americans were treating him as a POW. As such the pictures showing him having his saliva swabbed was an example of the behaviour they objected to when the Iraqis displayed their POWs.

I think the point being made was to win hearts and minds of the rebels you don’t sink to the level of the Saddam Regime rather you show yourselves to be above it.

I dare say that the American higher command felt that by humiliating Saddam the people currently ambushing them and the civilians in Iraq would feel more inclined to give themselves up.

Ditto, Lotian. The humiliation of the Germans after WWI was one of the main reasons for WWII. Hitler gave them back their pride, (for as long as it lasted, at least). The Marshall Plan was put into place when it becam apparent that the shattered pride of Germany had to be restored after WWII, (and also to ensure that East Germany didn't do any better than West, which may well have been the case without the aid that was provided).

Humiliation is one of the rituals that the Palestinians are subject to. Look at the resentment that has been built and sustained from that treatment. In the short term, it may appear to be a good tactic, it makes people cringe and shy away. In the long term, it builds resentment and a desire for revenge.

Don't underestimate the power of feelings. We are animals first, and higher thinkers second.

Saddam was a tyrant of the worst kind, but by indulging in petty acts of humiliation, the Americans are just showing how petty they are.
 
specious_reasons said:


In no way am I sympathetic to Saddam. I hope you didn't infer that from my post.

Once again, people have to defend themselves against the false dilemma. One can be in favour of proper behaviour, and not in favour of the person who is receiving it. Similar to the way many see capital punishment as barbaric. All you are doing is saying that you are not going to descend to their level of behaviour.
 
American said:
It's just another talking point they came up with. Democrats want Arabs to feel humiliated, so the only way to solve that problem will be to replace our military with the united nations.



thats right; to facilitate the rise of the anti-Christ


by the way this is my favourite math sentence

600 + 60 + 6 = 666
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom