"Humiliating" the Arabs? And if so... so what?

Mycroft said:


Do be sure to remove the beam from your own eye before you point to the splinter in someone else's. ;)

Would you like to point out some strawmen for men, or facts I have not backed up or qualified where appropriate. Skeptic is the King of Strawmen, just look at his latest topics for some excellent examples.
 
Jocko said:


Which will no doubt have a major impact on all those "fair and reasoned" people who worship him.

The trial will be for the civilized people of the world; showing Saddam for the beaten, pliant coward he is was for the minority who choose not to vest their judgment in the justice system.

Who says you can't have your cake and eat it too?

You can't. Either you follow the rule of law, or you don't.
 
Jocko said:


And that's what you call facts, huh? Theories sprinkled with invective references to 9/11? May you never serve on my jury.

The B-52 is a bomber, not a bomb. I've never heard it called a WMD and your naming it as such sounds suspiciously like another "fact" that won't bear scrutiny. And I have no idea what your comparison to the NVC arsenal has to do with anything; is this another utopian application of fairness, where everyone should use rocks and spears? Explain, please.

I think we can quite easily say that B52s were used to kill as many people as Saddam and his WMD. If the cap fits.
 
a_unique_person said:


Not so much lies, as blatant logical fallacies, his favourite being the strawman.
How many logical fallacies equal a lie?

Let's be very specific to this thread, shall we? Here's how America feels about videotape of our captured troops:


U.S. Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld said that under the Geneva Conventions, it's illegal for prisoners to be videotaped and subjected to "public curiosity." He called on the world's media outlets not to broadcast the video.
Link

Talk about your double standard, huh?

Or this one
The first convention cited by the Defense Department is Article 13 of Geneva Convention III which states that POWs must at all times be "protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity."
POWs should be protected from 'insult', which surely would include humiliation, right?
 
a_unique_person said:


You can't. Either you follow the rule of law, or you don't.

Hypocrite. I'll worry about the moral absolutism of "following the rule of law" (though you significantly failed to mention a law, so far as I saw) when the rest of the world does.

The law takes many forms. Speaking in the native's tongue helps to make yourself understood, even if people back home don't understand a word.
 
a_unique_person said:


I think we can quite easily say that B52s were used to kill as many people as Saddam and his WMD. If the cap fits.

"We" can say no such thing, since "we" haven't provided any backup, even when pressed on "our" ridiculous claims.

Furthermore, even if it were true, that doesn't make a B-52 a WMD any more than polio, drunk driving or domestic violence is, if "we" are simply going by body count.

If this is how "we" choose to define "our" terms (i.e., however we feel like it without regard to what they actually mean), then "we" have nothing else to discuss.

As you say, the cap certainly fits.
 
Jocko said:


Hypocrite. I'll worry about the moral absolutism of "following the rule of law" (though you significantly failed to mention a law, so far as I saw) when the rest of the world does.

The law takes many forms. Speaking in the native's tongue helps to make yourself understood, even if people back home don't understand a word.
Wait...you just said that, so long as their are contries that break the law, it is alright for America to act in a criminal manner? Did you REALLY just say that?!?

OK, I'm gonna start robbing banks, and I'll worry about the law when every single person in the world stops breaking the law. That makes as much sense as what you posted. PLEASE explain it to me how that works.
 
Zero said:
How many logical fallacies equal a lie?

POWs should be protected from 'insult', which surely would include humiliation, right?

Uh, well here's one. Saddam is not a POW and therefore not protected by the Geneva Conventions. Everyone knows that. Any similarity between the rules of the conventions and the treatment he's getting reflects well on US treatment of the murderous bastard, not ill.

It doesn't take much to see the difference between the POW tapes and Saddam's treatment. Was he shown with marks from fresh beatings? Was he forced to read a statement at gunpoint? Is he being denied medical care?

Did they videotape his slow decapitation with a knife, ala Daniel Pearl, and release it to friendly media outlets as a warning to the infidels? Your allegations are quite whacked, Zero. Again, this is all moot because the SOB ain't a POW. Period.

Jeez, they showed him getting checked for lice. If that's so bloody sensitive, then boo-freakin-hoo for them.
 
Jocko said:


Uh, well here's one. Saddam is not a POW and therefore not protected by the Geneva Conventions. Everyone knows that. Any similarity between the rules of the conventions and the treatment he's getting reflects well on US treatment of the murderous bastard, not ill.

It doesn't take much to see the difference between the POW tapes and Saddam's treatment. Was he shown with marks from fresh beatings? Was he forced to read a statement at gunpoint? Is he being denied medical care?

Did they videotape his slow decapitation with a knife, ala Daniel Pearl, and release it to friendly media outlets as a warning to the infidels? Your allegations are quite whacked, Zero. Again, this is all moot because the SOB ain't a POW. Period.

Jeez, they showed him getting checked for lice. If that's so bloody sensitive, then boo-freakin-hoo for them.
Is it a war? Is he a prisoner?

Or is the real issue your lack of objectivity?
 
Zero said:
Wait...you just said that, so long as their are contries that break the law, it is alright for America to act in a criminal manner? Did you REALLY just say that?!?

OK, I'm gonna start robbing banks, and I'll worry about the law when every single person in the world stops breaking the law. That makes as much sense as what you posted. PLEASE explain it to me how that works.

No, you silly little man. The point was that AUP was going on about how a fair, open trial will sway militant islam's opinion. I was merely pointing out how naive that is.

Again, the trial is for us. The "humiliation" is for them. Everybody gets the message.

Well, apparently ALMOST everyone.
 
Zero said:
Is it a war? Is he a prisoner?

Or is the real issue your lack of objectivity?

Enemy leaders are not POWs. Haven't you been listening to any news over the last week or so?

I imagine you must be pretty busted up over how Mussolini got treated as well. Get over yourself, Zero, he's not a POW. But thank heaven Saddam has caring, compassionate people like you and AUP in his corner.
 
And just to make you very, very happy, Zero, I did the research you couldn't be bothered to do. Took all of 30 seconds.

United States Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld says the issue of Saddam's future will be determined in consultations with US coalition partners.

But he stopped short of saying the ousted leader, who has been eluding US troops for nine months, will be granted formal prisoner of war status.

"We have said thus far is that we are according him the privileges and rights of a prisoner of war," he said. "But we're not yet defining him as such."

Source: ABC News

Objective enough for you? Kee-rist.
 
Jocko said:


Enemy leaders are not POWs. Haven't you been listening to any news over the last week or so?

I imagine you must be pretty busted up over how Mussolini got treated as well. Get over yourself, Zero, he's not a POW. But thank heaven Saddam has caring, compassionate people like you and AUP in his corner.

You are a hypocrit. Plain and simple, because you expect one standard for out captured troops, and another for the prisoners of the U.S. Plus, you fall into that same logical fallacy as so many others, in that you see any disagreement as being support for the enemy. Saddam Hussein should be treated with the rights afforded by the Geneva Convention, given a fair trial, and then pretty obviously convicted and put to death (or sentenced to life in prison, depending on the site of his trial)

Your attack on me is pathetic. Try again, and this time try engaging your brain.
 
Jocko said:
And just to make you very, very happy, Zero, I did the research you couldn't be bothered to do. Took all of 30 seconds.



Source: ABC News

Objective enough for you? Kee-rist.
Jeez, citing Rummy isn't objective at all!! Of course, this is an administration which has arbitrarily ignored the rule of law since seizing power.
 
Zero said:
Jeez, citing Rummy isn't objective at all!! Of course, this is an administration which has arbitrarily ignored the rule of law since seizing power.

You're amazing. The one man qualified to speak for the US military on the matter, and you whine about objectivity. You ought to put aside the propagnada pamphlets and pick up a friggin' newspaper once in a while.

Since I'm amused by your temper-tantrum tailspin, let me drop this ugly baby in your lap and see if it coos:

Article 4 of the Geneva Convnetions, regarding the classification and treatment of POWs

Article 4

A. Prisoners of war, in the sense of the present Convention, are persons belonging to one of the following categories, who have fallen into the power of the enemy:

1. Members of the armed forces of a Party to the conflict as well as members of militias or volunteer corps forming part of such armed forces.

2. Members of other militias and members of other volunteer corps, including those of organized resistance movements, belonging to a Party to the conflict and operating in or outside their own territory, even if this territory is occupied, provided that such militias or volunteer corps, including such organized resistance movements, fulfil the following conditions:

(a) That of being commanded by a person responsible for his subordinates;

(b) That of having a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance;

(c) That of carrying arms openly;

(d) That of conducting their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war.

3. Members of regular armed forces who profess allegiance to a government or an authority not recognized by the Detaining Power.

4. Persons who accompany the armed forces without actually being members thereof, such as civilian members of military aircraft crews, war correspondents, supply contractors, members of labour units or of services responsible for the welfare of the armed forces, provided that they have received authorization from the armed forces which they accompany, who shall provide them for that purpose with an identity card similar to the annexed model.

5. Members of crews, including masters, pilots and apprentices, of the merchant marine and the crews of civil aircraft of the Parties to the conflict, who do not benefit by more favourable treatment under any other provisions of international law.

6. Inhabitants of a non-occupied territory, who on the approach of the enemy spontaneously take up arms to resist the invading forces, without having had time to form themselves into regular armed units, provided they carry arms openly and respect the laws and customs of war.

B. The following shall likewise be treated as prisoners of war under the present Convention:

1. Persons belonging, or having belonged, to the armed forces of the occupied country, if the occupying Power considers it necessary by reason of such allegiance to intern them, even though it has originally liberated them while hostilities were going on outside the territory it occupies, in particular where such persons have made an unsuccessful attempt to rejoin the armed forces to which they belong and which are engaged in combat, or where they fail to comply with a summons made to them with a view to internment.

2. The persons belonging to one of the categories enumerated in the present Article, who have been received by neutral or non-belligerent Powers on their territory and whom these Powers are required to intern under international law, without prejudice to any more favourable treatment which these Powers may choose to give and with the exception of Articles 8, 10, 15, 30, fifth paragraph, 58-67, 92, 126 and, where diplomatic relations exist between the Parties to the conflict and the neutral or non-belligerent Power concerned, those Articles concerning the Protecting Power. Where such diplomatic relations exist, the Parties to a conflict on whom these persons depend shall be allowed to perform towards them the functions of a Protecting Power as provided in the present Convention, without prejudice to the functions which these Parties normally exercise in conformity with diplomatic and consular usage and treaties.

C. This Article shall in no way affect the status of medical personnel and chaplains as provided for in Article 33 of the present Convention.


See, you'd think you had a case under number 2 until you get to the four qualifiers beneath. Other than that, Saddam don't qualify, and if he's privileged enough to enjoy POW treatment, even de facto POW status, it's out of the pure generosity of good ol' Uncle Sam.

Now, next time you question someone's objectivity, consider your own.
 
Zero said:



Your attack on me is pathetic. Try again, and this time try engaging your brain.

I like you. You're funny. If you were a kitten I'd adopt you.
 
Jocko said:


You're amazing. The one man qualified to speak for the US military on the matter, and you whine about objectivity. You ought to put aside the propagnada pamphlets and pick up a friggin' newspaper once in a while.

Since I'm amused by your temper-tantrum tailspin, let me drop this ugly baby in your lap and see if it coos:

Article 4 of the Geneva Convnetions, regarding the classification and treatment of POWs




See, you'd think you had a case under number 2 until you get to the four qualifiers beneath. Other than that, Saddam don't qualify, and if he's privileged enough to enjoy POW treatment, even de facto POW status, it's out of the pure generosity of good ol' Uncle Sam.

Now, next time you question someone's objectivity, consider your own.
On the other hand, Saddam's constant military garb, and the conventions of our own laws, would place the leader of a foreign nation as being 'commander in chief' of the military, which is certainly more appropriate under Iraq's dictatorship than in U.S. law.

Just as importantly, would you wish Bush to be treated with respect if he were captured by a foreign government? The 'golden rule' thing should apply, don't you think? As I posted on another thread earlier tonight, a good test of objectivity is to reverse roles, and see how you would feel if the shoe was on the other foot.
 
Jocko said:


I like you. You're funny. If you were a kitten I'd adopt you.
If you were a kitten, I'd trade you for a puppy...and then I would drown the puppy.
 
Jocko said:


Enemy leaders are not POWs. Haven't you been listening to any news over the last week or so?

I imagine you must be pretty busted up over how Mussolini got treated as well. Get over yourself, Zero, he's not a POW. But thank heaven Saddam has caring, compassionate people like you and AUP in his corner.

Once again, the false dichotomy. How many times do I have to say I don't care for Saddam, but for the process that should be followed. 1,000,000 more times?
 
Zero said:
On the other hand, Saddam's constant military garb, and the conventions of our own laws, would place the leader of a foreign nation as being 'commander in chief' of the military, which is certainly more appropriate under Iraq's dictatorship than in U.S. law.

Oh, so you have seen him in a uniform. That makes him a soldier. Gotcha. I saw C. Everett Koop in a uniform once. And Madonna wore one in that video.

Moral of the story: clothes don't always make the man. Read article 4 and you'll see how silly you're being.

Just as importantly, would you wish Bush to be treated with respect if he were captured by a foreign government? The 'golden rule' thing should apply, don't you think? As I posted on another thread earlier tonight, a good test of objectivity is to reverse roles, and see how you would feel if the shoe was on the other foot.

The golden rule has nothing to do with the Geneva Conventions, and I think I've done enough research for you for one night. You can try to substantiate your own strawmen if you wish, but if I were you, I'd get a hobby or something.

Go tell Kofi Annan about the golden rule. I'm sure he'll quote line and verse in the UN charter dealing with it. Sorry, Zero, this goes beyond your schoolyard concept of "fairness."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom