Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

An assertion of which you have no valid proof, Tony's Ideas, have been proven fallacious, your Ideas are similarly regarded.

Tony didn't realize the by simply changing impact point the energy to fracture a connection changes.

Without knowledge of how and where the girder and floor it supported were loaded, his assertion that the failure of one girder not causing the other to fail is invalid.

His fire science knowledge is non existent, and his conclusions are nonsensical.

I hope others notice that many people here are all talk and no action. They usually just makes claims and provide no calculations or basis for what they say.
 
Last edited:
Simple fact: You don't know how much force was required to destroy the lower floors because you have not done the analysis required to determine how damaged those floors could be. Your assertions are just bovine skedaddle, to borrow a phrase, and you know it.

Unlike you, WAI modeled the whole collapse. You can't point to any error they committed in doing so, so you fall back "well, they didn't show me all their math and they didn't come to the conclusion I wanted [note how your biased mind only objects when both conditions are met], so their report must have been an elaborate attempt to lie under oath."

I have applied elevated temperatures to the floors below. You seem to think there is a lot more to it than that, but aren't sure, so you keep it vague. You may not realize that I can see you lack experience here.

When are you going to show where WAI corrected Nordenson's use of a point load for the falling beam and girder assembly and show me where WAI provides an analysis for the amplification?

Girders and beams just don't fail as easily as these people are trying to say and to break through them requires a significant amplified load. I have already shown that and it was something Nordenson got right.
 
Last edited:
I hope others notice that many people here are all talk and no action. They usually just makes claims and provide no calculations or basis for what they say.
Where have you gotten with your action?

Honestly. What is your opinion on why no engineering organisation or association will give you the time of day.
 
The NIST with all their resources spent over 7 years on the problem, and they still couldn't wouldn't get it right.

Well, truthers with their supposed 2,500 experts, have had fifteen years and they still can't understand the collapses. Hell, 9/11 truth can't even produce a valid scientific paper on the subject.

The NIST report may contain a few inconsequential flaws which don't seem to affect the conclusion, so what?

No truther has ever proved the NIST's conclusion wrong, so until they do, why should we even bother with insane claims such as CD?

Logic and 9/11 truth should have a meeting one day.
 
I hope others notice that many people here are all talk and no action. They usually just makes claims and provide no calculations or basis for what they say.

Oh I think there is a very ancient basis, for the actions of simple leverage acting on a connection. The Idea is centuries old.
http://archimedespalimpsest.org/about/history/archimedes.php

You have made many openly totally fallacious statements Tony and provided absolutely no proof of claim for any that are valid.

Maxwell simply determined an equation that determines how leverage affects the energy applied to a connection by a force on a beam.

A FEA, Tony is just a calculator a computer program that measures potentials, of yours I can only say garbage in BS. Out.

I used your own data and simply did multiple calculations of various impacts only impacts inline with the dirrect load path of the connection of the girder on the Column exhibited the strength you stated Tony.

Your supposed to be an engineering professional, I am not, publish your data that shows how you determined the girder could not fail, in all variances of impact loading.
Not just impact along the line of highest connection strength, dirrect impact where it connects to the Column!
 
Where have you gotten with your action?

Honestly. What is your opinion on why no engineering organisation or association will give you the time of day.

Oh the Hypocrisy, from Him DGM, apparently Tony never studied Maxwell.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Clerk_Maxwell

Any valid researcher truther would be happy to have the mistake pointed out, accept it and move on, but no not our dear Tony.:D

Here is why Maxwell is important, http://research.omicsgroup.org/index.php/Structural_rigidity
 
Last edited:
Well, truthers with their supposed 2,500 experts, have had fifteen years and they still can't understand the collapses. Hell, 9/11 truth can't even produce a valid scientific paper on the subject.

The NIST report may contain a few inconsequential flaws which don't seem to affect the conclusion, so what?

No truther has ever proved the NIST's conclusion wrong, so until they do, why should we even bother with insane claims such as CD?

Logic and 9/11 truth should have a meeting one day.

It doesn't matter if NIST is wrong or not, CD can only be proven By evidence of CD of which there has never been and never will be any.
 
Oh I think there is a very ancient basis, for the actions of simple leverage acting on a connection. The Idea is centuries old.
http://archimedespalimpsest.org/about/history/archimedes.php

You have made many openly totally fallacious statements Tony and provided absolutely no proof of claim for any that are valid.

Maxwell simply determined an equation that determines how leverage affects the energy applied to a connection by a force on a beam.

A FEA, Tony is just a calculator a computer program that measures potentials, of yours I can only say garbage in BS. Out.

I used your own data and simply did multiple calculations of various impacts only impacts inline with the dirrect load path of the connection of the girder on the Column exhibited the strength you stated Tony.

Your supposed to be an engineering professional, I am not, publish your data that shows how you determined the girder could not fail, in all variances of impact loading.
Not just impact along the line of highest connection strength, dirrect impact where it connects to the Column!

My calculations for impact of the falling floor on the one below does involve shear of the girder seat where it connects to the column. I have shown them publicly on the 911 free forum and Metabunk.org. Nobody has been able to refute them after I showed the falling floor would not be able to apply enough load to shear the girder seat.

Can we see your calculations?
 
Last edited:
I have applied elevated temperatures to the floors below. You seem to think there is a lot more to it than that, but aren't sure, so you keep it vague. You may not realize that I can see you lack experience here.

When are you going to show where WAI corrected Nordenson's use of a point load for the falling beam and girder assembly and show me where WAI provides an analysis for the amplification?

Girders and beams just don't fail as easily as these people are trying to say and to break through them requires a significant amplified load. I have already shown that and it was something Nordenson got right.


Apparently, there's a problem with what you say. For an example, explain how floors collapsed within WTC 5, which was due to fire.

FAILURE ANALYSIS OF THE WORLD TRADE CENTER 5 BUILDING

The local collapse of WTC 5 was the first documented case in which a protected steel structure had collapsed entirely due to fire. The symmetrical nature of the local collapse strongly suggests that the failures were due to the uncontrolled fires. This is supported by the observation that the columns in this area remained straight and freestanding and the roof was not penetrated in this region of the building. Therefore, impact damage by debris from WTC 1 or WTC 2 can be ruled out.

Tony said:

My calculations for impact of the falling floor on the one below does involved shear of the girder seat where it connects to the column. I have shown them publicly on the 911 free forum and Metabunk.org. Nobody was able to refute them after I showed the falling floor would not be able to apply enough load to shear the girder seat.

Cont.

This local collapse appeared to have begun at the shear connections where girders were connected to shop fabricated beam stems and column assemblies.

http://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/ETD/Available/etd-042907-214619/unrestricted/LaMalva.pdf
 
Last edited:
No, I did not reach any conclusion before doing the calculations.

Did you ever do these calculations with Chandler?

  1. Force stack up on moment frame of WTC7 through collapse
  2. Error margins on acceleration measurements

How about these all by yourself?
  • Probability of fire being extinguished by dust.
  • Amount of explosives necessary for demolition
  • Decibel levels, frequencies of noise generated by necessary explosives
  • Ditto for Thermite, except include light emission
I'm sure there are more I could ask, and I'm sure others can chime in, knowing your posting history, etc.

Don't expect any more from me though, I freely admit i'm doing this for the lulz. Your cause is dead, no matter what, in my opinion.
 
Did you ever do these calculations with Chandler?

  1. Force stack up on moment frame of WTC7 through collapse
  2. Error margins on acceleration measurements

How about these all by yourself?
  • Probability of fire being extinguished by dust.
  • Amount of explosives necessary for demolition
  • Decibel levels, frequencies of noise generated by necessary explosives
  • Ditto for Thermite, except include light emission
I'm sure there are more I could ask, and I'm sure others can chime in, knowing your posting history, etc.

Don't expect any more from me though, I freely admit i'm doing this for the lulz. Your cause is dead, no matter what, in my opinion.

I have done the calculations necessary to support my conclusions. They are available in papers and occasionally on forum posts I have made over the years.
 
It doesn't matter if NIST is wrong or not, CD can only be proven By evidence of CD of which there has never been and never will be any.
clap.gif
clap.gif

That is the central error of false dichotomy that Tony has been persisting with for many months.

(Tony says)"I have proved that "xyz" is wrong THEREFORE I am right." Where "xyz" is ARUP or Nordenson or....whoever - it matters not.


Utter idiotic nonsense.

I matters not how many explanations Tony proves wrong - if he claims CD he has to prove CD.

Tony is - of course - well aware of that true situation. Which is why he is happy for members to keep arguing for ARUP, Nordenson, whoever....

...as long as they DON'T identify Tony's single fatal error. He has not and cannot prove CD.
 
I hope others notice that many people here are all talk and no action. They usually just makes claims and provide no calculations or basis for what they say.


Personally, I like to post photos and investigative reports involving structural failures of steel frame buildings due to fire so there is no question.
 
Last edited:
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
That is the central error of false dichotomy that Tony has been persisting with for many months.

(Tony says)"I have proved that "xyz" is wrong THEREFORE I am right." Where "xyz" is ARUP or Nordenson or....whoever - it matters not.


Utter idiotic nonsense.

I matters not how many explanations Tony proves wrong - if he claims CD he has to prove CD.

Tony is - of course - well aware of that true situation. Which is why he is happy for members to keep arguing for ARUP, Nordenson, whoever....

...as long as they DON'T identify Tony's single fatal error. He has not and cannot prove CD.
That's it in a nutshell. I don't expect Don Quixote to admit it though.
 
I have done the calculations necessary to support my conclusions. They are available in papers and occasionally on forum posts I have made over the years.

In that case, you should have understood how absurd the CD theory really is.

Have you ever wondered why experts concluded that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7?
 
My calculations for impact of the falling floor on the one below does involved shear of the girder seat where it connects to the column. I have shown them publicly on the 911 free forum and Metabunk.org. Nobody was able to refute them after I showed the falling floor would not be able to apply enough load to shear the girder seat.

Can we see your calculations?

Did you use the Maxwell equations I saw no evidence that you did?

Yes as soon as I can transcribe them into a post able form, using the data you provided and the maxwell equations, I wrote a simple calculating program, simplified the problem to the girder floor, connection and girder on the floor impacted by varing location of impact by just one foot the strength decreased by a factor of ten.

How the girder impacts the floor below determined the energy it exerted on the connection, that is basic engineering Tony.

David B. Benson used the Maxwell equations in the computer program for the Paper he wrote with Greening, that allowed progression though the cold structure faster Though Floor stripping do to beam and girder failures.

The Floor below the girder actually fractures easier when cold, as that is when the welds and bolts are most venerable to sheer, heating the connection actually allows it more ductile deformation before sheer of bolts and welds fail.

In other words heating produces a condition of Ductile failure that negates the potential of shear lag fracture.

Instead your talking of inducing ductile tearout, not Fracture at 872 C Ductile tear out will occur no matter how the Lower floor is impacted.
At that temperature, the steel has lost almost 3/4 of it's strength.

So the floor below the impacted floor, has to be cold, or cooled below 300C for Fracture to occur.

"History
One of the founders of the mathematical theory of structural rigidity was the great physicist James Clerk Maxwell. The late twentieth century saw an efflorescence of the mathematical theory of rigidity, which continues in the twenty-first century.


"[A] theory of the equilibrium and deflections of frameworks subjected to the action of forces ... in cases in which the framework ... is strengthened by additional connecting pieces ... in cases of three dimensions, by the regular method of equations of forces, every point would have three equations to determine its equilibrium, so as to give 3s equations between e unknown quantities, if s be the number of points and e the number of connexions[sic]. There are, however, six equations of equilibrium of the system which must be fulfilled necessarily by the forces, on account of the equality of action and reaction in each piece. Hence if e== 3s-6, the effect of any eternal force will be definite in producing tensions or pressures in the different pieces; but if e>3s-6, these forces will be indeterminate...."[Maxwell 1864]"

The equation I used was Maxwell's equation for a pinned beam.
 
Wow, even the Dust Smothers All the Fire one?

Oh there is a new one, radiation is the main way fires heat steel, not dirrect contact with hot gases.
So yesterday I walked up to five feet near the edge of a huge burning stump pile, and burned completely up do to the Infer red radiation coming of the pile.
Now I am just a burnt courpse posting as a ghost.:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom