Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

You know the reports aren't right and you don't want a new investigation by authorities. You say average citizens should provide a complete explanation. That is unethical. Why are you being unethical?

Why do you feel the need to be this dishonest?

I except some errors in the reports. I argue they don't effect the conclusions in any significant manner.

I don't and have never claimed the average citizen should provide an alternative explanation. I say, you as a representative of a group that has lobbied and raised money to do so should present (and support) an alternative theory. You have failed to do so and seem unwilling to even attempt it.

How am I "unethical"? I'm not making claims, you are.
 
Last edited:
Why do you feel the need to be this dishonest?

I except some errors in the reports. I argue they don't effect the conclusions in any significant manner.

I don't and have never claimed the average citizen should provide an alternative explanation. I say, you as a representative of a group that has lobbied and raised money to do so should present (and support) an alternative theory. You have failed to do so and seem unwilling to even attempt it.

How am I "unethical"? I'm not making claims, you are.

On the outside chance that you just don't know enough, and aren't exactly being unethical in a knowing sense, I'll put it another way.

How can the lack of an explanation for column 79 losing enough lateral support to buckle not affect the NIST conclusions? You admit that Nordenson has an error in his analysis which affects this situation. Do you not understand the implication is that column 79 would not lose lateral support?

You do need to be told that it is unethical to ask anyone other than the authorities to provide a sound explanation for the crime.
 
Last edited:
Maybe you just don't know enough, and aren't exactly being unethical in a knowing sense, so I'll put it another way.

How can the lack of an explanation for column 79 losing enough lateral support to buckle not affect the NIST conclusions? You admit that Nordenson has an error in his analysis which affects this situation. Do you not understand the implication is that column 79 would not lose lateral support?

You do need to be told that it is still unethical to ask anyone other than the authorities to provide a sound explanation.
I do. I don't see where they effect the general consensus that fire and damage combined with time caused the collapse.


You make a claim that this had to be controlled demolition at two separate levels. The penthouse collapse was a separate event followed by a multi-story explosive event. I ask you to support that assertion with a coherent theory. You refuse. Why?
 
I do. I don't see where they effect the general consensus that fire and damage combined with time caused the collapse.


You make a claim that this had to be controlled demolition at two separate levels. The penthouse collapse was a separate event followed by a multi-story explosive event. I ask you to support that assertion with a coherent theory. You refuse. Why?

You admit the reports have errors which undermine the whole NIST hypothesis because they show column 79 would not have lost enough lateral support to buckle.

If you excuse that it is fair to say you are an unethical person.
 
Last edited:
You admit the reports have errors which undermine the whole NIST hypothesis because they show column 79 would not have lost enough lateral support to buckle.

If you excuse that it is fair to say you are an unethical person.
You are the one that claim they are serious. I don't think they effect the overall conclusion that fire and damage over time caused the collapse.

Why can't you even present a coherant theory for what we all know you believe? Do you not want people to look at it and critique it to the same level you do the "official" reports?

From my seat it looks like you're not that secure with your belief.
 
You do need to be told that it is unethical to ask anyone other than the authorities to provide a sound explanation for the crime.

On what basis are you calling my ethics? I'm a poster on a forum that has made no claims. I don't try to support my opinion using any professional affiliation or status. You on the other hand..........................
 
When we take our car in for an oil change, should we ask them to skip checking the other fluid levels because the warning lights are not on?


Should taxpayers pay for weekly inspections inside every building in the United States for explosives?
 
Other than AE911Truth asking for donations, what, if any, other basis do you have for saying these things?

Do you think we have been told the whole truth about 911 and if not do you support a new investigation?

We certainly have not been told the truth by you, using a furnace experiment, instead of a dynamic fire environment, shame Tony, I read your entire link.
I fully understand why it is wrong.
 
You admit the reports have errors which undermine the whole NIST hypothesis because they show column 79 would not have lost enough lateral support to buckle.


Let's hear it once again from an explosives expert.


Brent Blanchard Interview

Undicisettembre: What do you think about World Trade Center 7? Was its collapse a controlled demolition, in your opinion?

Brent Blanchard: No. Absolutely not. I know people who were on the site and they told me first hand they knew the building was about to collapse. And even if I didn't know those people you can look at the way the North Tower collapsed and how all the debris that fell to the north directly into WTC7 shearing huge chunks of building 7 on the South side, which is not the side that everyone watches on the YouTube videos. On the south side there was extensive damage all the way down. The entire load bearing mechanism is weakened when a towering structure more than twice the size of the subject structure literally falls on top of it.

http://undicisettembre.blogspot.com/2014/10/an-interview-with-explosive-expert.html
 
Do you think we have been told the whole truth about 911 and if not do you support a new investigation?


Well, take a look at this video.


Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kSq663m0G8


Fires raged out of control for hours where the collapse of WTC 7 began, and yet, no secondary explosions from explosives were observed or heard, which goes to show just how absurd and ridicules the conspiracy CD theory really is.
 
Well, take a look at this video.


Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kSq663m0G8


Fires raged out of control for hours where the collapse of WTC 7 began, and yet, no secondary explosions from explosives were observed or heard, which goes to show just how absurd and ridicules the conspiracy CD theory really is.

We know that already, get with the conversation the point is Tony used a link to a furnace test,
On materials not in a composite construction.
The experimenter then used an FEA to predict results of an assembly, he did not do an accurate assembly test in a real fire, with real component assemblies.
That negates Tony's point for obvious reasons.
 
You are the one that claim they are serious. I don't think they effect the overall conclusion that fire and damage over time caused the collapse.

Why can't you even present a coherant theory for what we all know you believe? Do you not want people to look at it and critique it to the same level you do the "official" reports?

From my seat it looks like you're not that secure with your belief.

Let's see what the experts have to say on the ceiling tile issue.http://www.fireengineering.com/arti...ents/the-ol-professor/suspended-ceilings.html
 
The welds are 3/8" fillets on both sides of the 14 inch deep x 2 inch thick support plate (under the seat to the column) and the top of the seat to the outside of the column flange.

The weld material is E70.

See Frankel Steel drawing #9114.

The force required to shear the seat at room temperature, per Nordenson, is 632,000 lbs. and my calculation shows the same. If you disagree show your work.

The strength of the weld would be 22,000 psi per inch of weld, at room temperature.
Using Monrue's equation for a pinned beam, the welds fracture at 125,000 pounds or, around 3200 pounds dropped twelve feet in an eccentric strike do to applied leverage.
 
We know that already, get with the conversation the point is Tony used a link to a furnace test,
On materials not in a composite construction.

I wanted to make that point once again, very clear to Tony. However, Tony will find a way to explain away the furnance test, which would be another example of the way he does business.
I see where he is going, you explain the details, he rejects those details simply because the details do not point to the use of explosives.

If you say it, he rejects it, but it is difficult for him to reject visual, audio evidence and physical evidence. That is the way he plays the game.

.
 
Last edited:
On the outside chance that you just don't know enough, and aren't exactly being unethical in a knowing sense, I'll put it another way.

How can the lack of an explanation for column 79 losing enough lateral support to buckle not affect the NIST conclusions? You admit that Nordenson has an error in his analysis which affects this situation. Do you not understand the implication is that column 79 would not lose lateral support?

You do need to be told that it is unethical to ask anyone other than the authorities to provide a sound explanation for the crime.

The Nordenson error had nothing to do with ARUP's beam walk-off analysis. You should do some serious introspection and really try to answer why you can't bring yourself to come to be honest about that. Are you conflating the two in order to lie to your fellow travelers, or is the lying only for your own benefit?

Moreover, WAI explicitly corrected Nordenson's error (their report was, in fact, a direct response to Nordenson et al's and they cited that error specifically and noted they corrected for it--everything you claim you want to see) and WAI still found a collapsing floor lead to run away collapse. Instead of being happy that a professional engineering firm has done exactly what you claim you want them to, you instead hand wave their analysis away based on the fact that you think the temperatures their simulation generated in the collapse initiating floor were too high. Of course, you making that claim is merely your preconceived bias projected forward as you make it based on an an intentional misapplication of the NIST temperature model (taking it to be some sort of theoretical hottest case scenario, which you know it is not) and without being able to say that (1) the temperature profile used by WAI was incorrect or (2) that the temperature profile used by WAI actual significantly altered their runaway collapse analysis.
 
Last edited:
The Nordenson error had nothing to do with ARUP's beam walk-off analysis. You should do some serious introspection and really try to answer why you can't bring yourself to come to be honest about that. Are you conflating the two in order to lie to your fellow travelers, or is the lying only for your own benefit?

Moreover, WAI explicitly corrected Nordenson's error (their report was, in fact, a direct response to Nordenson et al's and they cited that error specifically and noted they corrected for it--everything you claim you want to see) and WAI still found a collapsing floor lead to run away collapse. Instead of being happy that a professional engineering firm has done exactly what you claim you want them to, you instead hand wave their analysis away based on the fact that you think the temperatures their simulation generated in the collapse initiating floor were too high. Of course, you making that claim is merely your preconceived bias projected forward as you make it based on an an intentional misapplication of the NIST temperature model (taking it to be some sort of theoretical hottest case scenario, which you know it is not) and without being able to say that (1) the temperature profile used by WAI was incorrect or (2) that the temperature profile used by WAI actual significantly altered their runaway collapse analysis.

WAI does not provide their analysis showing the amplification, just like NIST didn't. I also don't see where they corrected Nordenson's use of a point load for the falling beam and girder assembly.

I can say that none of the three: NIST, Nordenson (ARUP), or WAI can break through the next floor down with floor sections falling through one story onto the next floor down, especially with hot beams, and regardless of heated beams below.

There is simply not enough load amplification in a fall through one floor with the amount of deflection the beams would have.

If I hadn't already, let me make it clear that it doesn't matter if WAI had the beams at 859 Degrees C to get them to fall, their falling floor section can't break through the next one down. There is no chance that all of the steel involved on both floors of WAI's analysis would be above 800 degrees C.

This is critical to the collapse hypothesis of all three, as they need the floor cascade to remove lateral support from columns. Without it they have no collapse.

I think all three analyses are bovine skedaddle.

You can keep trying to salvage Weidlinger, but you will need to show me their amplification analysis and where they correct Nordenson's use of a point load. I can't find either.
 
Last edited:
There is simply not enough load amplification in a fall through one floor with the amount of deflection the beams would have.

What percentage of the floor (load) and beams leading into the falling beam do you account for?

Obviously the beam would not be alone in the real world.
 
What percentage of the floor (load) and beams leading into the falling beam do you account for?

Obviously the beam would not be alone in the real world.

You should know DGM, my friend I died today burned up alive, I snuck in low to within 5 feet of a huge burning stump pile, and well the Radiation from the pile not the directly hot rising gases burned me alive.:rolleyes:

So much for Tony's most of the heat comes from radiation BS.

I even have video of the super heated stump pile, although I have not uploaded it yet.;)
 
You should know DGM, my friend I died today burned up alive, I snuck in low to within 5 feet of a huge burning stump pile, and well the Radiation from the pile not the directly hot rising gases burned me alive.:rolleyes:

So much for Tony's most of the heat comes from radiation BS.

I even have video of the super heated stump pile, although I have not uploaded it yet.;)
It's almost like he's never heard of flash over. Firefighter ventilate a building so the fire can burn and not fester into a concentration of super heated gas.

I always rolled my eyes well "truther" talked about "oxygen starved" fires. Most of the times that's the worst thing you can do for a fire.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom