Crazy Chainsaw
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2006
- Messages
- 8,339
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
That is the central error of false dichotomy that Tony has been persisting with for many months.
(Tony says)"I have proved that "xyz" is wrong THEREFORE I am right." Where "xyz" is ARUP or Nordenson or....whoever - it matters not.
Utter idiotic nonsense.
I matters not how many explanations Tony proves wrong - if he claims CD he has to prove CD.
Tony is - of course - well aware of that true situation. Which is why he is happy for members to keep arguing for ARUP, Nordenson, whoever....
...as long as they DON'T identify Tony's single fatal error. He has not and cannot prove CD.
I have too say Tony's calculations are right for a limited set of impacts with the lower beam connections at elevated temperatures, however he ignored the mechanical advantage of a cold connection forming a fulcrum and applying leverage on the Connection to force a shear lag fracture. At above 220 C the steel is too soft to form a fulcrum and litterally pry the connection apart.
In Tony's defense this is something anyone could easily have missed the hotter the steel the less likely it is to lever itself out of the connection instead it will ductilly deform.
The formation of a fulcrum at the connection is critical to reducing the energy to induce failure, from induced levered shear.